User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Suggestions > A way to allow for users to have some say over height at creation, while adding dynamic weight change and doing away with the "Reroll" method of generating starting attributes
Page:
 
HeadlesssKES
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by drifter
Originally posted by HeadlesssKES

Originally posted by drifter


Originally posted by HeadlesssKES



Just real quick..

I like the basic concept. The way of going about it may have to change, though.

First and foremost, you do NOT get more points by becoming shorter. Getting shorter still loses you one point per inch, or whatever.
Reason being is that the shorter you are, the lower your center of gravity.... basically, a PB WANTS to be short. A C may want to be short as well to help push... all run blockers wants to be short...

Anyway, if this were to be implemented, of course the current roll max would have to be used.. there needs to be a ceiling, IMO. Maybe make it 20 for all attributes, all positions?



While being shorter has some advantages at the positions you list, it also has disadvantages. A shorter Center will never be as heavy as a taller one can be. The same goes for a HB - a power back will not be as heavy if he is shorter; a speedback who is shorter will be even lighter as his stamina is likely to exceed his stamina by quite a bit, making him even easier to tackle.

Also, if you were to make it so that lighter players took a bigger stamina hit when tackled by heavier players (another good idea), there would be additional reasons to not be short and light.

I thought of a flat attribute max, but there is so much variation in the current max rolls that I thought it best just to leave those in place.


Height and weight shouldn't be computed linearally, vs each other, as you seem to mention.

Shorter doesn't mean weaker.. and muscle weighs so much. You can have short/stocky, short/strong, etc... a 5'10 C with 100 STR should weigh more than a 6'3 C with 80 STR (just an example, something along these lines though).

So you make a PB... 5'5, 20 STR... keep pumping str to 90 eventually, why shouldn't he weigh around 240, 250?



I never suggest that shorter means weaker. Where is that coming from? Height has no correlation to strength in my suggestion.

First off, a 5'5 receiver is impossible in the table I put up (based on actual NFL data). Min Height if 5'6 for a HB. If that HB had a 2:1 ratio, with 90 strength and 45 stamina, he would weigh 237.6 lbs maximum.

Again those weight numbers come from actual NFL data. If you have a problem with reality not being realistic enough, you probably have other issues.


I didn't look at the table... that may have helped, but the gist of my argument remains the same.

I wasn't arguing for strength vs height, but you said a shorter person could never be as heavy as a taller person.

I brought strength into that because muscle weighs more than fat and everything, so it's conceivable that a shorter, stronger person would be heavier than a taller, less strong person. That is all i was getting at.... however, as you DID use real NFL heights and weights, I'm assuming you put them into a spreadsheet of some sort and drew the whole "correct line" graph.. and went on that

Or something a lot more sophisticated, but with the same basic idea... so I guess my argument has no merit
 
drifter
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by HeadlesssKES
Originally posted by drifter

Originally posted by HeadlesssKES


Originally posted by drifter



Originally posted by HeadlesssKES




Just real quick..

I like the basic concept. The way of going about it may have to change, though.

First and foremost, you do NOT get more points by becoming shorter. Getting shorter still loses you one point per inch, or whatever.
Reason being is that the shorter you are, the lower your center of gravity.... basically, a PB WANTS to be short. A C may want to be short as well to help push... all run blockers wants to be short...

Anyway, if this were to be implemented, of course the current roll max would have to be used.. there needs to be a ceiling, IMO. Maybe make it 20 for all attributes, all positions?



While being shorter has some advantages at the positions you list, it also has disadvantages. A shorter Center will never be as heavy as a taller one can be. The same goes for a HB - a power back will not be as heavy if he is shorter; a speedback who is shorter will be even lighter as his stamina is likely to exceed his stamina by quite a bit, making him even easier to tackle.

Also, if you were to make it so that lighter players took a bigger stamina hit when tackled by heavier players (another good idea), there would be additional reasons to not be short and light.

I thought of a flat attribute max, but there is so much variation in the current max rolls that I thought it best just to leave those in place.


Height and weight shouldn't be computed linearally, vs each other, as you seem to mention.

Shorter doesn't mean weaker.. and muscle weighs so much. You can have short/stocky, short/strong, etc... a 5'10 C with 100 STR should weigh more than a 6'3 C with 80 STR (just an example, something along these lines though).

So you make a PB... 5'5, 20 STR... keep pumping str to 90 eventually, why shouldn't he weigh around 240, 250?



I never suggest that shorter means weaker. Where is that coming from? Height has no correlation to strength in my suggestion.

First off, a 5'5 receiver is impossible in the table I put up (based on actual NFL data). Min Height if 5'6 for a HB. If that HB had a 2:1 ratio, with 90 strength and 45 stamina, he would weigh 237.6 lbs maximum.

Again those weight numbers come from actual NFL data. If you have a problem with reality not being realistic enough, you probably have other issues.


I didn't look at the table... that may have helped, but the gist of my argument remains the same.

I wasn't arguing for strength vs height, but you said a shorter person could never be as heavy as a taller person.

I brought strength into that because muscle weighs more than fat and everything, so it's conceivable that a shorter, stronger person would be heavier than a taller, less strong person. That is all i was getting at.... however, as you DID use real NFL heights and weights, I'm assuming you put them into a spreadsheet of some sort and drew the whole "correct line" graph.. and went on that

Or something a lot more sophisticated, but with the same basic idea... so I guess my argument has no merit


The max Weight to height ratio found in the "2" column on Table B (2 meaning that Strength is twice stamina) is based on the max ratio found in the NFL for a player at that position. In the case of HBs there is not a single HB on an NFL roster that weighs more than 3.6 * his height in inches.

So, while it is conceivable that someone shorter could be heavier, it is not currently the case in the NFL.
 
greengoose
offline
Link
 
Hmmmm.

Barry Sanders, 5'8 208 lbs
Kevin Smith, 6'1" 211 lbs

Smith may be 3 lbs heavier, but there is nobody that would argue the point that Barry was the stronger back - all 5'8" of him. Define stronger, because Barry had tree trunk legs. Barry was faster as well.
Last edited Apr 16, 2009 10:00:28
 
drifter
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by greengoose
Hmmmm.

Barry Sanders, 5'8 208 lbs
Kevin Smith, 6'1" 211 lbs

Smith may be 3 lbs heavier, but there is nobody that would argue the point that Barry was the stronger back - all 5'8" of him. Define stronger, because Barry had tree trunk legs. Barry was faster as well.


What your missing from the equation if you want to talk apples to apples, is stamina. Of course, stamina is harder to quantify even more than strength.

Let's play with those two on the table and make some conjectures though:

Sanders 68", 208lbs = 3.059 his height in inches. This would put him at the 1.1:1 mark on the chart. We'll assume his stamina was about average and call it 45. This would mean that his strength was right about 50. I'd say that's about right, no? As you pointed out, the guy had giant legs.

Kevin Smith, is 73" and 211 lbs. This puts him at 2.89 * his height in inches or at about 1:1.3 on the chart, indicating that his stamina is above his strength. If his stamina is, again, average at 45, this would make his strength around 34 or 35. Since we know comparatively little about Smith compared to Sanders, it's tougher to say if this is accurate. However, you can find in his combine scouting report from before he was drafted, this tidbit: "Lanky frame that appears better suited to the wide receiver position than running back. ... Thin, long limbs." This would indicate a lower strength individual, no? It's certainly not a way anyone would ever think to describe Sanders.

Based on that, I have no problem saying Sanders was the stronger back and that the system holds up pretty well in this case.

Last edited Apr 16, 2009 10:50:25
 
Link
 
Originally posted by Momara94
-1
height isnt really a factor so all non WR and CBs will be as short as possible to start off w/ awesome rolls


Donnie, you are out of your element
 
drifter
offline
Link
 
Bump again
 
Domer
offline
Link
 
Excellent idea IMO. This is the direction this game needs to go. I think the height/weight system needs a little refining, I wouldn't tie it directly to SP, instead perhaps just put a moving max/minimum on certain attributes for being taller or shorter, heavier or lighter. For example.

Start with your average height by position. If you want to be taller at WR, then mayber you CAP your intial speed amount at 17, where as a shorter WR might be able to add the intial speed amount up to 24. Something along thoes lines.

Domer
 
TuNice
offline
Link
 
Drifter once again comes with another amazing, well thought out and explained suggestion.
 
kevbk6222
offline
Link
 
another thing that should be addressed that relates to this is the ability to gain/lose weight in a type of training option. this should have been added when they put in a VA with a weight prerequisite.
 
drifter
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by kevbk6222
another thing that should be addressed that relates to this is the ability to gain/lose weight in a type of training option. this should have been added when they put in a VA with a weight prerequisite.


This is already covered. If you want to gain weight, you increase your ratio of strength to stamina. If you want to lose weight, you increase your ratio of stamina to strength.
 
G.O.D Turner
offline
Link
 
Liked it a couple days ago when I first read it, still like it...bump
 
MxPx3oh!3fan
offline
Link
 
Damn, drifter, you always come through. Let's just make a thread for drifter Epic Suggestions.
 
G.O.D Turner
offline
Link
 
Most of his are why they made that subforum anyway haha
 
drifter
offline
Link
 
Bump because this is the only suggestion to date on a way to handle height and weight in a realistic way
 
kretchfoop
offline
Link
 
Another gem from drifter. This would entirely change the face of the game...for the better. I love it.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.