User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Oceania A Leagues > Oceania A #2 > League Defensive MVP Voting
Page:
 
barracus79
offline
Link
 
5- Funky Windpasser - DE- West Island Rage
6-Graham Whitfield - DT - Oakland Suppressors
5- Cy 'Spine Crusher' Simpson - DT- Rockdale Raging Ramathorns
4- Sofa King We Todd Did - DE - WBH Avengers
5-Will Sackyu - DE - Charlotte Big Dawgs
6- Jaxson Grimm - CB - WBH Avengers +1
4- Xavier Wade - CB - Oakland Suppressors
0- El Pollo Loco - CB - West Island Rage
13- China Man - CB - Toledo Red Rockets -1
 
M.R. Champs
offline
Link
 
Because I don't like the guy...

5- Funky Windpasser - DE- West Island Rage
6-Graham Whitfield - DT - Oakland Suppressors
5- Cy 'Spine Crusher' Simpson - DT- Rockdale Raging Ramathorns
4- Sofa King We Todd Did - DE - WBH Avengers
5-Will Sackyu - DE - Charlotte Big Dawgs
5- Jaxson Grimm - CB - WBH Avengers -1
4- Xavier Wade - CB - Oakland Suppressors
0- El Pollo Loco - CB - West Island Rage
14- China Man - CB - Toledo Red Rockets +1
 
mrasfine89
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by barracus79
I challenge anyone from Toledo to explain why China deserves any MVP mention over Jaxson. I'll even put the 2 categories at the top that China beat Jaxson:

Tackles
China Man - 40
Jaxson Grimm - 38

Forced Fumbles
China Man - 1
Jaxson Grimm - 0

Missed Tackles
Jaxson Grimm - 0
China Man - 3

Pass Deflections
Jaxson Grimm - 129
China Man - 126

Interceptions
Jaxson Grimm - 19
China Man - 7

Interception TDs
Jaxson Grimm - 14
China Man - 1


Contrary to popular belief, it is the Most Valuable Player, not the Player With The Best Stats award. Even the stats are subjective though. Theoretically, you played 16 teams worse than you, we played 13. And don't forget about China Man's 1,800 return yards and 9 TDs (special teams, I know, but still player stats). The fact of the matter is that we all think that our players are the best and most valuable and unfortunately, a voting system like this proves little but which team has more voting agents.
 
barracus79
offline
Link
 
lmao. so by this logic, the team that went 0-16 should have the MVPs because every team they played was better than them? wow.

you should consider the POSSIBILITY that the reason we went 16-0 might be due to the fact that we had VALUABLE PLAYERS.

furthermore, china man's special teams stats have as much to do with the defensive MVP award as the price of eggs in mexico.


bottom line, i don't understand how you can evaluate value without using stats, which also includes team records, especially in a simulation game. stats are not subjective. you made the tackle or you didn't. you intercepted the ball more than someone else, or you didn't.
 
Chiefshb
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by barracus79
we had VALUABLE PLAYERS.


and steriods

Originally posted by
furthermore, china man's special teams stats have as much to do with the defensive MVP award as the price of eggs in mexico.


436 pesos i believe. this is for a half dozen.



Last edited Apr 3, 2009 11:47:53
 
SAGA45
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by M.R. Champs
Because I don't like the guy...


The honesty is appreciated and the hate welcomed. Thank you

 
Mr.Cracker
offline
Link
 
5- Funky Windpasser - DE- West Island Rage
6-Graham Whitfield - DT - Oakland Suppressors
5- Cy 'Spine Crusher' Simpson - DT- Rockdale Raging Ramathorns
4- Sofa King We Todd Did - DE - WBH Avengers
5-Will Sackyu - DE - Charlotte Big Dawgs
4- Jaxson Grimm - CB - WBH Avengers -1
4- Xavier Wade - CB - Oakland Suppressors
0- El Pollo Loco - CB - West Island Rage
15- China Man - CB - Toledo Red Rockets +1
 
gwelch
offline
Link
 
I know the system is flawed, but we just don't have the participation to do it right.

If we did, I would have done a tradtional MVP and asked for nominations, etc.

As it was, I picked playoff teams and the leaders on those teams to get the list. The voting was a quick way to pick a winner without getting into a lot of discussion (although, I always like the arguments on "Why my player should be MVP").

I guess you can call it the Oceania A method of MVP voting. Flawed, but fun to do.
 
gwelch
offline
Link
 
New day, so I can vote again.

5- Funky Windpasser - DE- West Island Rage
7-Graham Whitfield - DT - Oakland Suppressors +1
4- Cy 'Spine Crusher' Simpson - DT- Rockdale Raging Ramathorns -1
4- Sofa King We Todd Did - DE - WBH Avengers
5-Will Sackyu - DE - Charlotte Big Dawgs
4- Jaxson Grimm - CB - WBH Avengers
4- Xavier Wade - CB - Oakland Suppressors
0- El Pollo Loco - CB - West Island Rage
15- China Man - CB - Toledo Red Rockets
 
andrew rolinc
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by barracus79
lmao. so by this logic, the team that went 0-16 should have the MVPs because every team they played was better than them? wow.




Easier opposition = better stats.

Oh, and who won NFL MVP last year?

Peyton Manning

He finished the season 4th in completions, 3rd in completion percentage, 6th in passing yards, 13th in yards per attempt, 5th in passing TD's tied for 12th for most INT's, and had the 5th best QB ranking.

Now it seems like he didn't have the best stats among QB's but he won it anyway. Brees was first in yards, and tied for first in TD's but he didn't win

Last edited Apr 3, 2009 12:40:55
 
andrew rolinc
offline
Link
 

5- Funky Windpasser - DE- West Island Rage
7-Graham Whitfield - DT - Oakland Suppressors
4- Cy 'Spine Crusher' Simpson - DT- Rockdale Raging Ramathorns
3- Sofa King We Todd Did - DE - WBH Avengers -1
5-Will Sackyu - DE - Charlotte Big Dawgs
4- Jaxson Grimm - CB - WBH Avengers
4- Xavier Wade - CB - Oakland Suppressors
0- El Pollo Loco - CB - West Island Rage
16- China Man - CB - Toledo Red Rockets +1
 
mrasfine89
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by barracus79
lmao. so by this logic, the team that went 0-16 should have the MVPs because every team they played was better than them? wow.


That's not my point at all. I was referring to the competition that each team/player plays. For example, Grimm outlevel his average opponent by over 11 levels, while China Man was just under 4 (even adjusting down for CPU opponents). Those 7 levels make a pretty big diffenence difference in the world of GLB. I'm not arguing that China Man's stats are as good as Grimm's. That is obviously not the case.

The best player with the best stats on the best team isn't necessarily the most valuable player in the league. A player is valuable when the team is significantly worse without them. According to your agrument, your team is stacked and full of 'valuable' players.

With that said, I agree with M.R. Champs, and will continute to vote for/defend my players. And if you have a problem with that, either get your agents to vote too or post in this thread: http://goallineblitz.com/game/forum_thread.pl?thread_id=2393995
 
twinswinmh
offline
Link
 
5- Funky Windpasser - DE- West Island Rage
7-Graham Whitfield - DT - Oakland Suppressors
4- Cy 'Spine Crusher' Simpson - DT- Rockdale Raging Ramathorns
3- Sofa King We Todd Did - DE - WBH Avengers
5-Will Sackyu - DE - Charlotte Big Dawgs
5- Jaxson Grimm - CB - WBH Avengers +1
4- Xavier Wade - CB - Oakland Suppressors
0- El Pollo Loco - CB - West Island Rage
15- China Man - CB - Toledo Red Rockets -1

 
ravsrul
offline
Link
 
5- Funky Windpasser - DE- West Island Rage
7-Graham Whitfield - DT - Oakland Suppressors
4- Cy 'Spine Crusher' Simpson - DT- Rockdale Raging Ramathorns
3- Sofa King We Todd Did - DE - WBH Avengers
5-Will Sackyu - DE - Charlotte Big Dawgs
6- Jaxson Grimm - CB - WBH Avengers +1
4- Xavier Wade - CB - Oakland Suppressors
0- El Pollo Loco - CB - West Island Rage
14- China Man - CB - Toledo Red Rockets -1



 
piscapoe
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by barracus79
I challenge anyone from Toledo to explain why China deserves any MVP mention over Jaxson. I'll even put the 2 categories at the top that China beat Jaxson:

Tackles
China Man - 40
Jaxson Grimm - 38

Forced Fumbles
China Man - 1
Jaxson Grimm - 0

Missed Tackles
Jaxson Grimm - 0
China Man - 3

Pass Deflections
Jaxson Grimm - 129
China Man - 126

Interceptions
Jaxson Grimm - 19
China Man - 7

Interception TDs
Jaxson Grimm - 14
China Man - 1



Maybe b/c China Man is playing in his suggested league for his level? Why don't you put your player in his suggested league and see what happens.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.