User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Page:
 
sckbleh
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by jeffpap
i know in cpl they took it out of their playbooks in the semi's, some leagues are going basic AI only...



So you mean that they were sensible enough that they made an AGREEMENT before the game, publicly, to not use the play? In which case all the criticism would be justified?

WAY smarter to just ASSUME there's some unspoken percentage of strong-I slam that no team should go beyond, and that everyone else has magically determined the exact same threshhold without discussing it. Yeah, right.


 
sckbleh
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by clarkdaddy07
If you aint cheating... you aint trying! lol

I've got several players that were on several different championship teams. I'm 0-3 in games going into the championship games and that's because 3 out of 3 times, we've been Strong I Slammed. Sure, you can all use it, sure it can be stopped with the perfect game plan, but if you've played the game legit all season, how is it bad game planning on our part to assume you will play legit in the playoffs.

If bad game planning is assuming you won't cheat... then sign me up as a bad game planner. Winning a fake trophy in a fake football league just doesn't mean THAT much to me... maybe some of you "need" that championship more than I do.

Good luck who ever we're playing in the Championship game.

We piss excellence and shit gold.... kick ass and take names... you're just another name on our list and another notch on our belt!


Cheating involves breaking rules. That's a strong word you're throwing around for breaking an unwritten, undiscussed rule that still remains unspecified by everyone here.

A few questions for all the whiners:
1) At what point does it become 'cheating' or 'dishonorable' to run the strong I slam? What percentage of plays?
2) What percentage of plays did Valhalla run the Strong I slam in our game against ARR?

If anyone even knows the answer to #2 I bet it's only a couple of you. Just jumping on the whine-wagon.

 
Michael J Fox
offline
Link
 
Good luck in the championship game Valhalla.

Chile will be ready to go medieval on your ass.
 
clarkdaddy07
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by sckbleh
Originally posted by clarkdaddy07

If you aint cheating... you aint trying! lol

I've got several players that were on several different championship teams. I'm 0-3 in games going into the championship games and that's because 3 out of 3 times, we've been Strong I Slammed. Sure, you can all use it, sure it can be stopped with the perfect game plan, but if you've played the game legit all season, how is it bad game planning on our part to assume you will play legit in the playoffs.

If bad game planning is assuming you won't cheat... then sign me up as a bad game planner. Winning a fake trophy in a fake football league just doesn't mean THAT much to me... maybe some of you "need" that championship more than I do.

Good luck who ever we're playing in the Championship game.

We piss excellence and shit gold.... kick ass and take names... you're just another name on our list and another notch on our belt!


Cheating involves breaking rules. That's a strong word you're throwing around for breaking an unwritten, undiscussed rule that still remains unspecified by everyone here.

A few questions for all the whiners:
1) At what point does it become 'cheating' or 'dishonorable' to run the strong I slam? What percentage of plays?
2) What percentage of plays did Valhalla run the Strong I slam in our game against ARR?

If anyone even knows the answer to #2 I bet it's only a couple of you. Just jumping on the whine-wagon.



LOL, I'm not sure what's worse.... cheating... or trying to validate cheating.

Hey man, do what you want. What ever helps you sleep at night. But if you can win a championship knowing that you cheated your way to the title.... you're a bigger piece of crap that I am... and at the end of the day, that's all that matters to me!
Last edited Apr 3, 2009 13:27:22
 
clarkdaddy07
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by sckbleh
Originally posted by clarkdaddy07

If you aint cheating... you aint trying! lol

I've got several players that were on several different championship teams. I'm 0-3 in games going into the championship games and that's because 3 out of 3 times, we've been Strong I Slammed. Sure, you can all use it, sure it can be stopped with the perfect game plan, but if you've played the game legit all season, how is it bad game planning on our part to assume you will play legit in the playoffs.

If bad game planning is assuming you won't cheat... then sign me up as a bad game planner. Winning a fake trophy in a fake football league just doesn't mean THAT much to me... maybe some of you "need" that championship more than I do.

Good luck who ever we're playing in the Championship game.

We piss excellence and shit gold.... kick ass and take names... you're just another name on our list and another notch on our belt!


Cheating involves breaking rules. That's a strong word you're throwing around for breaking an unwritten, undiscussed rule that still remains unspecified by everyone here.

A few questions for all the whiners:
1) At what point does it become 'cheating' or 'dishonorable' to run the strong I slam? What percentage of plays?
2) What percentage of plays did Valhalla run the Strong I slam in our game against ARR?

If anyone even knows the answer to #2 I bet it's only a couple of you. Just jumping on the whine-wagon.



You know, it's not illegal or cheating to push a retard down, but some of us know we shouldn't do it.... guess you need to be told right from wrong. It's like the bible says about fucking your sister...DON'T!
Last edited Apr 3, 2009 10:16:44
 
luxembourgh
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by clarkdaddy07
It's like the bible says about fucking your sister...DON'T!


But she is sooooo hot, oh wait, thats my Niece...?!?
 
clarkdaddy07
offline
Link
 
It doesn't say anything about a niece... I'm thinking niece's are ok! lol
 
jdogg317
offline
Link
 
Not to defend my upcoming opposition, but Valhalla didn't really use the 100% hb slam "cheat code" the way others are exploiting it. I do think they raise a good question: How much is TOO much? I might be reeeeaallly stupid for admitting this, but I was unaware of the advantage or glitch or cheat or whatever it is until about 7 days ago. I rarely go on the glb forum because it is a sack of shit...unless Phantom is posting funny stuff it...but stumbled on it since.
Now that I know it is there, should I pull that play out of my playbook completely? I now know it is a game advantage and not a Handsome Rob advantage, as I assumed. So am I cheating too?
What it boils down to for me is that you can rip on Alloy or Bleh or Valhalla, but the gang in glb like Bort knew this was an issue weeks ago. They had plenty of time to nerf it before the playoffs.
Doesn't make it right. It just is what it is.
 
MeauxJeaux
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by jdogg317

What it boils down to for me is that you can rip on Alloy or Bleh or Valhalla, but the gang in glb like Bort knew this was an issue weeks ago. They had plenty of time to nerf it before the playoffs.
Doesn't make it right. It just is what it is.


That's true. The whole GLB community is ripping itself up over something that should never have happened. It should have been fixed long ago and should have been a non-issue, especially for the playoffs. My apologies for piling on.

 
Ravenwood
offline
Link
 
Good points all around.

Our team in Canada AA got eliminated in round 1 by a really good team. They ran the Strong I Slam 'only' 26 times, but it was enough to seal the deal, and we went down 22-20.

It really bothered me at the time because that play was clearly a big part of their offensive game plan. (Every third play was the Slam.) Since then, it's clear that many teams have made it their entire game plan, so by comparison, the team we lost to was relatively innocent.

But it still kind of sucks, knowing that an acknowledged exploit was allowed by Bort and co. to remain a part of the game, and in this case, might very well have made the difference in the game.

At the end of the day, I think it's up to each agent to decide for themselves 'how much is too much'.
 
jdogg317
offline
Link
 
Oh, and to all you guys, it is really easy for me to say "it is what it is" because no one did it to US. So I totally understand why you'd be angry. I know I would too.
I think what sucks, to me anyway, is that Bort could have called a time out in week 14 or 15 and issued a statement that said "We are nerfing HB Slam for the playoffs, so be ready." Hell...he could have pulled the play altogether, you know? Letting it ride, knowing it is broken, just grinds my gears.
 
Ravenwood
offline
Link
 
I've been campaigning for them to pull the play from the playbook since Sunday.

The most popular argument against it: "That would be unfair to all the teams who've based their offense on it." Figure that one out.

Bort really fucked this one up. He made the problem even worse by launching that poll - A full two-thirds of all respondents have said they'd prefer an acknowledged exploit be fixed whenever, yet still the exploit remains in full force.

Of course, Bort hasn't been anywhere to be found for two days now. So much for the "We value your feedback" bullshit, eh?
Last edited Apr 3, 2009 13:55:14
 
sckbleh
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Ravenwood
I've been campaigning for them to pull the play from the playbook since Sunday.

The most popular argument against it: "That would be unfair to all the teams who've based their offense on it." Figure that one out.

Bort really fucked this one up. He made the problem even worse by launching that poll - A full two-thirds of all respondents have said they'd prefer an acknowledged exploit be fixed whenever, yet still the exploit remains in full force.

Of course, Bort hasn't been anywhere to be found for two days now. So much for the "We value your feedback" bullshit, eh?


I would have been amongst the happiest folks if he'd pulled the play for the playoffs.

And I've been on the other side of this one on another team, too.

Last edited Apr 3, 2009 14:27:53
 
Michael J Fox
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Ravenwood
I've been campaigning for them to pull the play from the playbook since Sunday.

The most popular argument against it: "That would be unfair to all the teams who've based their offense on it." Figure that one out.

Bort really fucked this one up. He made the problem even worse by launching that poll - A full two-thirds of all respondents have said they'd prefer an acknowledged exploit be fixed whenever, yet still the exploit remains in full force.

Of course, Bort hasn't been anywhere to be found for two days now. So much for the "We value your feedback" bullshit, eh?


In fairness, Bort has proven repeatedly that: 1) he isn't very good at customer service, 2) he has difficulty with logic, 3) he fixes nerfs by creating new nerfs.
 
w_alloy
offline
Link
 
Like I mentioned I've been gone so I haven't been able to participate in this thread, but I fully support Sckbleh and RandomBeast.

Also if Chile wants to agree to completely take the slam out of our game plans for the final I'm all for it.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.