User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Suggestions > Repetitive plays: More it's run, more likely the defensive is to stop it.
Page:
 
jdbolick
offline
Link
 
What makes this particularly frustrating is that Bort's excuse for nuking the running game in Season 7 was his complaint that people just ran HB Off Tackle (Strong I) over and over again, but instead of implementing some kind of penalty for repetitive play-calling, instead he trashed elusive RBs, deified power backs, and now we have more repetitive play-calling in the run game than ever before.
 
ryan_grant-25
offline
Link
 
i know in RL that you can adjust to this, but if i find something i can abuse, i am going to take advantage of it, and i expect another team to do the same to me. if this were to happen, it would ruin scouting for the game.
 
DrunkenCowboy
offline
Link
 
What's wrong with running the same play over and over again if a team gives you the same defense?

There are some teams that think it's cool to blitz their LOLBs and SS 100% on 1st down vs an I-formation..I would like the freedom to run this deep pass play to give it to the TE on the same play over and over again without being penalized.

Until there is way more play selection, I say this is a bad idea..
 
Link
 
Originally posted by DrunkenCowboy
What's wrong with running the same play over and over again if a team gives you the same defense?

There are some teams that think it's cool to blitz their LOLBs and SS 100% on 1st down vs an I-formation..I would like the freedom to run this deep pass play to give it to the TE on the same play over and over again without being penalized.

Until there is way more play selection, I say this is a bad idea..


I just played a team that ran the Strong-I Slant play 25+ times in their last 28 or so plays. We were ahead by 21 and they scored 2 TDs driving down the field with the same play over and over again, with only minutes left to play. At times they ran the play 6 or 7 times in a row. Got the ball back. And ran it another 10+ times in a row.

http://goallineblitz.com/game/game.pl?game_id=373754&mode=pbp

The CBs never changed their positioning before the snap as someone mentioned on the first page. Heck, they even bit on a slight fake at the start of every single play that left them 2 or 3 steps behind the WR. Every single time.

You really believe that:
1, the defense should not have picked up on what was coming and adjusted their pre-snap position to stop it?
2, the defense should still have been susceptible to the fake at the beginning of each play? even after the 5th, 10th, 15th and 20th time?
3, there should be no vision bonus to a defense who knows exactly what the offense will do?

I think in such a case, fakes should be completely useless and a defense should get a slight attribute boost due to not needing to read the play before acting on it.
Last edited Mar 14, 2009 16:04:06
 
conanfan
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by DrunkenCowboy
What's wrong with running the same play over and over again if a team gives you the same defense?

There are some teams that think it's cool to blitz their LOLBs and SS 100% on 1st down vs an I-formation..I would like the freedom to run this deep pass play to give it to the TE on the same play over and over again without being penalized.

Until there is way more play selection, I say this is a bad idea..


or the same thing could apply to offense.

Have two or more outputs for a formation and down. If a D runs the same play versus a certain formation all the time, the most effective play gets called more often.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by Rofl
this already happens. Starting positions of players are slightly changed if they see a formation that's used over and over again.


Completely inaccurate statement here.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by Deathblade
Best way to go about this imo is...give defenses bonuses to their rolls.

More likely to break their block, more likely to make tackles, more likely to get a PD or Int, less likely to fail vision checks, less likely to get faked...all that good stuff.

It seems like it would actually get the job done, and it would be more realistic than say, 5% bonus to all attributes or something.

The % modifiers would be dependent on several factors. Obviously, the more that a team runs a play, the higher it will be. I think it should also increase at a rate relative to vision. Higher vision = higher % modifiers per consecutive play, lower vision = lower % modifiers.


+1000
 
Granted86
offline
Link
 
+1 to OP
 
joehan
offline
Link
 
+1 to OP and Deathbaldes idea
 
ryan_grant-25
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by DrunkenCowboy
What's wrong with running the same play over and over again if a team gives you the same defense?

There are some teams that think it's cool to blitz their LOLBs and SS 100% on 1st down vs an I-formation..I would like the freedom to run this deep pass play to give it to the TE on the same play over and over again without being penalized.

Until there is way more play selection, I say this is a bad idea..


exactly, not my problem defenses cant mix it up.
 
aliuking
offline
Link
 
I don't like the idea much at all because it isn't like we have a lot to choose from when it comes to offensive plays, when comparing it to Madden and other football games there are far more choices to choose from when it comes to plays in specific formations. And if an opponent is making it blatantly obvious by only using 2 or 3 plays shouldn't it be easier to gameplan?
 
FarmerJosh
offline
Link
 
You would think it would be easier to gameplan, but i just played a team that basically runs fades with its overleveled receivers and they catch it every time. Normally you would be able to run a cover 2 and play off, or use double coverage, but that just doesn't work. Giving defensive players a boost when they know what's coming would help a lot with cheap things like that. And if the receivers suddenly ran a slant, i would definitely accept a penalty on that, it encourages a more diverse gameplan.
 
mozzart23
offline
Link
 
Boo-

I say give the Offense all they want and it's up to the D-

"In real life" teams know what is coming often times from game film, game situations, and still cannot stop it.

I am a Defensive Orientated person but why should we get a bonus just because it's the same play?

Run the same D, and hope that your guys are in the right spots to cause a turnover or TFL.

No biggy IMO

-Mozz
 
Staz
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by mozzart23
Boo-

I say give the Offense all they want and it's up to the D-

"In real life" teams know what is coming often times from game film, game situations, and still cannot stop it.

I am a Defensive Orientated person but why should we get a bonus just because it's the same play?

Run the same D, and hope that your guys are in the right spots to cause a turnover or TFL.

No biggy IMO

-Mozz


Running a play frequently is different than running it almost every time. If you pull it about 10 times a game, that's often, but not to the point of "saturation"

Now, if the team runs it on 1st, 2nd, 3rd, 1st, 2nd, 1st, then the defense should wise up and start gearing up for that play. Then, if they see the play developing, they're already on it. That's how it goes in real life, and how it should go now.

It's what makes play action and draws effective. In the case of the play action, you've established the run, and the defense is waiting for it. So you fake the handoff, somebody bites, and voila. You've got a play.
 
Link
 
You guys say there arent a lot of plays to call, but you cant make that argument when your only running 1 of them.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.