User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Page:
 
Spirer
offline
Link
 
The nature of this game makes it a problem. In real life the potential difference between players is limited, there are no extremes like STR 8 vs 120, or SPD 8 vs 120, etc.

To use bogus stats like that and then try to build a simulation is very hard indeed, read impossible.

I really love the way the sim is designed, the ability to see plays develop, how players react, etc. However, trying to run a realistic simulation with unrealistic values leads to this "ping-pong" of nerf-buff that will never end.

I bet that if Bort gave all players a base of 50 in each attribute and then allowed you to spend points to raise some and lower some, within certain thresholds, the game would work wonderfully.

Imagine all attributes plotted in a graph, with a line connecting all of them. The area beneath that line should be constant, but it would allow for customization. If raising your STR lowered your SPD and AGI, then it would keep things balanced. Having an older player meant you had more time to customize him, but it would mean new and old could compete anyway...

I'm rumbling off, time to go to the gym, enjoy
 
enoch101
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by SkersAllTheWay

HIB - 74 rushes and 2 passes (97% run)
SDFL - 63 rushes and 12 passes (84% run)
Waller - 66 rushes and 15 passes (81% run)


For the season we have 31 passes per game/34 rushes per game (imagine our average before your game, much more weighted towards the pass). Watching Omaha game film is what led me to run so much in that instance. But we are probably a dinosaur with our balanced attack given the way the sim is working.
Last edited Mar 11, 2009 05:31:13
 
thunderdoozer
offline
Link
 
The problem is not the pass game, imo.

It's frustrating, yes, but it's realistic. QBs make bad throws, WRs drop open passes, etc., but with tinkering, completion percentages are between 55% and 70% and YPG between even teams is 150-350.

It's almost perfect.


The problem is the rushing game, and Bort has already shown us that he doesn't think it's a big deal. Not only did he not fix it this last offseason, but he made power back SAs stronger.

I'm not convinced that Bort "HAS" to fix anything.
 
Night Dragon
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Spirer
The nature of this game makes it a problem. In real life the potential difference between players is limited,
I bet that if Bort gave all players a base of 50 in each attribute and then allowed you to spend points to raise some and lower some, within certain thresholds, the game would work wonderfully.


I agree with your post 100% and I am glad you said it better than I could. It is impossible to achieve NFL type stats in GLB's current state. There are just too many radical builds to make it possible. This was my biggest gripe when Bort made that poll so long ago. It was a good idea in theory, but impossible to implement in the games current state.

I really like your idea about giving everyone a base of 50. That would force players to have similar builds and thus achieve more realism. Sadly, it will take away from peoples ability to create a player they felt was unique. Interesting idea none the less.
 
GreyFoxTBC
offline
Link
 
Well I know I've chimed in over on the BUGS forum (there has been a powerback discussion going for weeks).
So far I haven't seen a single post from Bort even touching the subject. I am the O.C. for 2 teams and he definitly
made an adjustment to the passing game this off-season. I also think he tweaked strength, which made for the huge
jump in pancakes this year and seems to have made the power back even more outrageous. The real problem with the
power back is that they don't tired out. Sorry but power running takes a ton of energy and it really beats up the body.
Anyone remember Christian Okoye? What a huge physical specimen and a monster runner. How many years did
he play every game? How many years did he even play? There is NO, I repeat, NO penalty for breaking 2 or 3 tackles
every run and doing it 45 to 60 times every game. Fine, don't adjust power backs, but through them in the same energy
use category as the special teams guys. 1 or 2 runs, you need to rest for a few plays.
 
thunderdoozer
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by thunderdoozer


The problem is the rushing game, and Bort has already shown us that he doesn't think it's a big deal. Not only did he not fix it this last offseason, but he made power back SAs stronger.

I'm not convinced that Bort "HAS" to fix anything.


Bort's big "solution" to the power back is a slight tweak to dragging players.

*shoots self in head with gun*
 
islander1
offline
Link
 
pretty much.

Bort's standard rule of thumb: Nerf defenses more.
 
rj414
offline
Link
 
I think in the end the changes will give us more balance on offense, but they won't do the defense any favors. Passing is going to become much easier and the nerf of powerbacks is really a nonentity - they needed to be curtailed more - guys like csonka with 12 speed should not be able to simply walk into the endzone from 70 yards out, bottom line. Powerbacks are not designed to be homerun hitters - they are supposed to get consistent, tough yardage. Backs that break a ton of tackles but also score a lot of tds in real life have a balance of speed and power, and that is not really being observed by GLB at the moment and hasn't been since season 6.
 
Spirer
offline
Link
 
Bort and the people posting in the bug forums regarding powerbacks always forget that defensive players need to be much more versatile than offensive players.

If you are facing a team with a Powerback and a fast elusive back (not working now) that is a reciever of Shotgun HB pass, then there is no way you can cater for both scenarios with your MLB.

As it stands he is usually beat in both scenarios, too slow/agile to follow the quick HB and cover the pass, and also unable to effectively stop the powerback rush.

Like I said in previous threads, offense just needs to go extremes and "break" the game, while defense has to try and be balanced and cater for evertyhing.

A powerback needs super strength, high speed and carrying, good agility and little else.
An elusive back/reciever needs super speed and agility, decent carrying and a few bits more.

There no way in this game that a MLB can be built to work well against these 2 extremes. To make matters worse offense players just don't seem to tire so they don't even need much stamina.
 
islander1
offline
Link
 
Spirer - always been my contention.

"If you are facing a team with a Powerback and a fast elusive back (not working now) that is a reciever of Shotgun HB pass, then there is no way you can cater for both scenarios with your MLB.

As it stands he is usually beat in both scenarios, too slow/agile to follow the quick HB and cover the pass, and also unable to effectively stop the powerback rush."

We hear the same crap from opponent's offenses. Build your players better. My ass!

Defense always has been, and will always continue to be in this game, am uphill battle. The best schemes and players in the game can, at best, reliably hold opponents to maybe 17-20 points a game given a balanced league. Sucks pretty hard but it's the game we play.
 
kenmoody
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by islander1
Spirer - always been my contention.

"If you are facing a team with a Powerback and a fast elusive back (not working now) that is a reciever of Shotgun HB pass, then there is no way you can cater for both scenarios with your MLB.

As it stands he is usually beat in both scenarios, too slow/agile to follow the quick HB and cover the pass, and also unable to effectively stop the powerback rush."

We hear the same crap from opponent's offenses. Build your players better. My ass!

Defense always has been, and will always continue to be in this game, am uphill battle. The best schemes and players in the game can, at best, reliably hold opponents to maybe 17-20 points a game given a balanced league. Sucks pretty hard but it's the game we play.


What we need is the ability to dictate players be played in specific situations, based on who they are facing. I mean, I get the coding implications in this. But ultimately, that would be the most realistic and effective fix to the 'breaking the system' scenario.
 
kurieg
offline
Link
 
I've always been annoyed I can't leave my better coverage LBs in on long situations, and the bigger maulers in on others.

 
islander1
offline
Link
 
Well the most practical? solution is complete custom assignments of players for every play.
Of course, this also requires having 2 full sets of linebackers, probably 2 differently built SS's, and maybe different specced LDE's and DT's for given scenarios.

How will everyone still get the minimum needed PT? It's hard enough now, as it is.

Not to mention it makes AI's even more complicated/time consuming then before, which is not what we really want, do we? It's not like we're getting paid to do this.
 
kenmoody
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by islander1
Well the most practical? solution is complete custom assignments of players for every play.
Of course, this also requires having 2 full sets of linebackers, probably 2 differently built SS's, and maybe different specced LDE's and DT's for given scenarios.

How will everyone still get the minimum needed PT? It's hard enough now, as it is.

Not to mention it makes AI's even more complicated/time consuming then before, which is not what we really want, do we? It's not like we're getting paid to do this.


But that is most like the same situation RL football teams make, right? I know it makes it much more involved, but to a certain extent you can define those packages once, at the start of the season, and just tweak them throughout the season. Yes, more work. But right now, even with what we have, that work and time-commitment level is whats separating the top from the bottom.

Anyway, this has all been discussed before and will all be discussed again. (to flip a BSG line)
 
thunderdoozer
offline
Link
 
At the very minimum, let us choose our own packages.

Have a depth chart for each defensive formation.

 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.