The nature of this game makes it a problem. In real life the potential difference between players is limited, there are no extremes like STR 8 vs 120, or SPD 8 vs 120, etc.
To use bogus stats like that and then try to build a simulation is very hard indeed, read impossible.
I really love the way the sim is designed, the ability to see plays develop, how players react, etc. However, trying to run a realistic simulation with unrealistic values leads to this "ping-pong" of nerf-buff that will never end.
I bet that if Bort gave all players a base of 50 in each attribute and then allowed you to spend points to raise some and lower some, within certain thresholds, the game would work wonderfully.
Imagine all attributes plotted in a graph, with a line connecting all of them. The area beneath that line should be constant, but it would allow for customization. If raising your STR lowered your SPD and AGI, then it would keep things balanced. Having an older player meant you had more time to customize him, but it would mean new and old could compete anyway...
I'm rumbling off, time to go to the gym, enjoy
To use bogus stats like that and then try to build a simulation is very hard indeed, read impossible.
I really love the way the sim is designed, the ability to see plays develop, how players react, etc. However, trying to run a realistic simulation with unrealistic values leads to this "ping-pong" of nerf-buff that will never end.
I bet that if Bort gave all players a base of 50 in each attribute and then allowed you to spend points to raise some and lower some, within certain thresholds, the game would work wonderfully.
Imagine all attributes plotted in a graph, with a line connecting all of them. The area beneath that line should be constant, but it would allow for customization. If raising your STR lowered your SPD and AGI, then it would keep things balanced. Having an older player meant you had more time to customize him, but it would mean new and old could compete anyway...
I'm rumbling off, time to go to the gym, enjoy






























