does Bort even know the amount of days that it takes to be necro
Forum > Goal Line Blitz > how old is a necro thread
sjmay
offline
offline
Originally posted by Dub J
I do agree that there does need to be more clarity on what constitutes a thread too old to be bumped. I have looked and haven't really seen anything concrete on this, tbh.
Common sense isn't clarification enough?
How many players have been banned for replying and or contributing to a thread that is on the 3rd page??
vs.
How many players have been banned for adding a +1 to threads over 4+ months old??
I do agree that there does need to be more clarity on what constitutes a thread too old to be bumped. I have looked and haven't really seen anything concrete on this, tbh.
Common sense isn't clarification enough?
How many players have been banned for replying and or contributing to a thread that is on the 3rd page??
vs.
How many players have been banned for adding a +1 to threads over 4+ months old??
Malachorn
offline
offline
Originally posted by haleykrl
does Bort even know the amount of days that it takes to be necro
No. He doesn't really even know the forum rules, tbh.
Heck, that's not even "his side" of the business.
DigitalDaggers has control of that side and Pallow is directly under him, so far as I know.
does Bort even know the amount of days that it takes to be necro
No. He doesn't really even know the forum rules, tbh.
Heck, that's not even "his side" of the business.
DigitalDaggers has control of that side and Pallow is directly under him, so far as I know.
Dub J
offline
offline
Originally posted by sjmay
Originally posted by Dub J
I do agree that there does need to be more clarity on what constitutes a thread too old to be bumped. I have looked and haven't really seen anything concrete on this, tbh.
Common sense isn't clarification enough?
How many players have been banned for replying and or contributing to a thread that is on the 3rd page??
vs.
How many players have been banned for adding a +1 to threads over 4+ months old??
I understand that posters shouldn't add anything that isn't constructive to an old post (like adding +1), that is reasonable. I was just commenting on having it worded to where we could have a definite time frame to mark a post as old.
Originally posted by Dub J
I do agree that there does need to be more clarity on what constitutes a thread too old to be bumped. I have looked and haven't really seen anything concrete on this, tbh.
Common sense isn't clarification enough?
How many players have been banned for replying and or contributing to a thread that is on the 3rd page??
vs.
How many players have been banned for adding a +1 to threads over 4+ months old??
I understand that posters shouldn't add anything that isn't constructive to an old post (like adding +1), that is reasonable. I was just commenting on having it worded to where we could have a definite time frame to mark a post as old.
Malachorn
offline
offline
Originally posted by sjmay
Originally posted by Dub J
I do agree that there does need to be more clarity on what constitutes a thread too old to be bumped. I have looked and haven't really seen anything concrete on this, tbh.
Common sense isn't clarification enough?
When we are talking about laws?
No. No, it is not. That implies that the judge, jury, and executioner is going to be completely fair and unbiased.
The rules have to be well-defined and clear not only for the posters, but also for the "forum janitor" mods.
TBF, it's kinda hard to expect the mods to do a great job when they're encouraged to do whatever they want.
...and inconsistency breeds contempt here.
Originally posted by Dub J
I do agree that there does need to be more clarity on what constitutes a thread too old to be bumped. I have looked and haven't really seen anything concrete on this, tbh.
Common sense isn't clarification enough?
When we are talking about laws?
No. No, it is not. That implies that the judge, jury, and executioner is going to be completely fair and unbiased.
The rules have to be well-defined and clear not only for the posters, but also for the "forum janitor" mods.
TBF, it's kinda hard to expect the mods to do a great job when they're encouraged to do whatever they want.
...and inconsistency breeds contempt here.
sjmay
offline
offline
Originally posted by Dub J
Originally posted by sjmay
Originally posted by Dub J
I do agree that there does need to be more clarity on what constitutes a thread too old to be bumped. I have looked and haven't really seen anything concrete on this, tbh.
Common sense isn't clarification enough?
How many players have been banned for replying and or contributing to a thread that is on the 3rd page??
vs.
How many players have been banned for adding a +1 to threads over 4+ months old??
I understand that posters shouldn't add anything that isn't constructive to an old post (like adding +1), that is reasonable. I was just commenting on having it worded to where we could have a definite time frame to mark a post as old.
I can see that, but I can also see how old threads might become relevant and you would want them to be resuscitated and continue the discussion.
Originally posted by sjmay
Originally posted by Dub J
I do agree that there does need to be more clarity on what constitutes a thread too old to be bumped. I have looked and haven't really seen anything concrete on this, tbh.
Common sense isn't clarification enough?
How many players have been banned for replying and or contributing to a thread that is on the 3rd page??
vs.
How many players have been banned for adding a +1 to threads over 4+ months old??
I understand that posters shouldn't add anything that isn't constructive to an old post (like adding +1), that is reasonable. I was just commenting on having it worded to where we could have a definite time frame to mark a post as old.
I can see that, but I can also see how old threads might become relevant and you would want them to be resuscitated and continue the discussion.
Jeff Van Gundy
offline
offline
Originally posted by Ubasstards
Failthread
Yeah, I figured that was the smartest thing I could say, but you already said it. Well thought out and intelligent post.
Failthread
Yeah, I figured that was the smartest thing I could say, but you already said it. Well thought out and intelligent post.
Ubasstards
offline
offline
Originally posted by sandman11
Originally posted by Ubasstards
Failthread
Yeah, I figured that was the smartest thing I could say, but you already said it. Well thought out and intelligent post.
thx
Originally posted by Ubasstards
Failthread
Yeah, I figured that was the smartest thing I could say, but you already said it. Well thought out and intelligent post.
thx
haleykrl DTD
offline
offline
what the fuck, this thread is a legit question, i didnt ask why, i know why, i have him on IM, i asked what the freakin time frame in the rules was for a necro bump,
Last edited Mar 9, 2009 23:57:13
Originally posted by forum rules
Do not create threads asking why other users were suspended or banned. That information is private between the administation of the site and the user who was suspended.
Do not create threads asking why other users were suspended or banned. That information is private between the administation of the site and the user who was suspended.
You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.






























