User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Goal Line Blitz > Why "nerfs" and "berfs" are a bad idea (this is long, if you have ADD don't read it)
Page:
 
mgse
offline
Link
 
good post
 
rj414
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bukowski
Originally posted by rj414

Originally posted by Bukowski


My team is SA Pro, has a group of WRs that are very balanced, built to withstand any nerf that could possibly come down.

But it doesn't seem to matter, we create separation on quick, short slant patters, only to have the QB throw the ball to where the WR is, instead of where he's going to be, and no EQ alteration can seemingly fix the problem.

I thought Bort was supposed to fix the QB leading WRs thing? It's actually more broken than it ever was before.


tbqh I don't think it's working as intended


I hope not.

But I haven't seen any official word to suggest it. I haven't even heard the testers make mention of it.

Honestly, this is what happens when things are manipulated to make the final stat-line look "realistic", while not actually fixing the root of the problem.

It's the same thing with DEs. The passing game would have never had to have been nerfed, if DEs could actually get pressure of QBs again, while also making hurries worth a bit more, in creating a bad pass. But instead, the entire passing game got nerfed, when that really wasn't the problem to begin with.


The underlying issues with the passing game - the things that Bort has tried to address by changing the way the builds work, are the pass protection and the mechanics of a throw. The mechanics were not a problem until this season, really, but the pass protection logic has always been one. The problem I can see from Bort's point of view are that these are very difficult things to fix - and the community is not patient enough to give him the time to do it. So instead he takes a shortcut - nerfs.
 
ElvisTCB
offline
Link
 
you forgot powerbacks

oh wait, your team has one

nm
 
panther17
offline
Link
 
It amazes me people are bitching about the size of the OP post. Either read it and give your opinion or back out of the thread and move on if your lazy.


RJ, good read as usual.
 
rj414
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by elvistcb
you forgot powerbacks

oh wait, your team has one

nm


I mentioned them briefly, but I wasn't trying to point out specifically what's overpowered and whats not as much as the fact that overpowering any one thing to manipulate stats is not the path Bort should be taking. I am in complete agreement with you that powerbacks are too strong, as well.
 
Bukowski
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by rj414
Originally posted by Bukowski

Originally posted by rj414


Originally posted by Bukowski



My team is SA Pro, has a group of WRs that are very balanced, built to withstand any nerf that could possibly come down.

But it doesn't seem to matter, we create separation on quick, short slant patters, only to have the QB throw the ball to where the WR is, instead of where he's going to be, and no EQ alteration can seemingly fix the problem.

I thought Bort was supposed to fix the QB leading WRs thing? It's actually more broken than it ever was before.


tbqh I don't think it's working as intended


I hope not.

But I haven't seen any official word to suggest it. I haven't even heard the testers make mention of it.

Honestly, this is what happens when things are manipulated to make the final stat-line look "realistic", while not actually fixing the root of the problem.

It's the same thing with DEs. The passing game would have never had to have been nerfed, if DEs could actually get pressure of QBs again, while also making hurries worth a bit more, in creating a bad pass. But instead, the entire passing game got nerfed, when that really wasn't the problem to begin with.


The underlying issues with the passing game - the things that Bort has tried to address by changing the way the builds work, are the pass protection and the mechanics of a throw. The mechanics were not a problem until this season, really, but the pass protection logic has always been one. The problem I can see from Bort's point of view are that these are very difficult things to fix - and the community is not patient enough to give him the time to do it. So instead he takes a shortcut - nerfs.


But every time he does a quick fix, something else ends up broken because of it. He should realize this by now.

The entire SIM is nothing but patchwork at this time, nothing is stable whatsoever.

He needs to stop adding all of these little trinkets, and actually fix what needs to be fixed. The same things have been broken for a long time, while he's wasting time with endorsements and fame - which we really didn't need. I would much rather have a functioning SIM, than these silly little endorsements.
 
PaqMarq11
makes sense
offline
Link
 
i agree.

and for the record i started a thread like this to defend the defensive side of the ball against whiners for the offense who whined about pass completions being down this season. surprise surprise a mod locked it and said that bort has not even tested it yet.

but we all know this is how it starts. some whining here and there by people within the clique then viola! sim has changed OVERNIGHT.

will this get locked? will bort see this and not give in to whiners?

before anyone says i'm biased let me state that i have a QB and a TE. i OC too. so no biases here. defense has caught up with the offense a little bit (except power-backs).
 
rj414
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bukowski

But every time he does a quick fix, something else ends up broken because of it. He should realize this by now.

The entire SIM is nothing but patchwork at this time, nothing is stable whatsoever.

He needs to stop adding all of these little trinkets, and actually fix what needs to be fixed. The same things have been broken for a long time, while he's wasting time with endorsements and fame - which we really didn't need. I would much rather have a functioning SIM, than these silly little endorsements.


This is 100% correct. By adding Vet skills and AE and things that make player building even more complicated before he's got the fundamental sim functioning properly, Bort is just making things even more complex for him and harder to fix.

 
Ubasstards
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bukowski

But every time he does a quick fix, something else ends up broken because of it. He should realize this by now.

The entire SIM is nothing but patchwork at this time, nothing is stable whatsoever.

He needs to stop adding all of these little trinkets, and actually fix what needs to be fixed. The same things have been broken for a long time, while he's wasting time with endorsements and fame - which we really didn't need. I would much rather have a functioning SIM, than these silly little endorsements.


First he should work on the most important things in the game:
1) Color Dots
2) MVP Endorsements
3) GLB background color
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
30) Powerbacks unstoppable
31) D-Line sucks
32) The sim
34) passing sucks
Last edited Mar 5, 2009 12:18:43
 
Bones Brigade
offline
Link
 
A well thought out and well written arguement, for those with the patience to read it.

I agree completely with your assessment of GLB, Bort's attempts to fix problems and your offered solutions.

I know it has been stated before, but I would really rather not see any NEW features (Def. Play Creator, for example) for season 9 and I would greatly prefer to see some core SIM issues fixed:

1) O line blocking assignments, vision pickups of blitzes and general pathing of blockers

Which would then allow DEs and DTs to get 'un-nerfed' because O linemen\FBs\TEs\HBs would actually be interacting logically

2) QB - WR pass logic, target\route interaction. IF vision checks for WRs to see the 'final destination' of the pass is required, then it makes sense to also require that check for DBs. TBH - most DBs have much higher vision than WRs already, so for well built DBs, this would be a non-issue\non-nerf anyways.


 
Bukowski
offline
Link
 
All this ends up being, is Bort giving in to the people that refuse to figure out how to build a player.

Every season, it seems that he's giving these people (the majority) a new beacon of hope, to where they can close the gap a little bit with the elite players. I mean, it's pretty obvious that the majority of people on this game are casual players, while most still haven't figured out how to build proper players, as everyone can see whenever they look through the marketplace. But instead of making to where these players get dominated, as they should, every season he takes away from whatever position was dominating them.

This is bullshit, we need to hold people accountable for what they do in this game. If they build piss-poor players, then they should get dominated.

This isn't a 3rd grade dodge-ball game, this is supposed to be competitive where the best man wins.

The SIM needs to be fixed, and now.
 
kr0n
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by elvistcb
you forgot powerbacks

oh wait, your team has one

nm


such a damn crybaby

when AREN'T you crying about something?
 
rj414
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bones Brigade
A well thought out and well written arguement, for those with the patience to read it.

I agree completely with your assessment of GLB, Bort's attempts to fix problems and your offered solutions.

I know it has been stated before, but I would really rather not see any NEW features (Def. Play Creator, for example) for season 9 and I would greatly prefer to see some core SIM issues fixed:

1) O line blocking assignments, vision pickups of blitzes and general pathing of blockers

Which would then allow DEs and DTs to get 'un-nerfed' because O linemen\FBs\TEs\HBs would actually be interacting logically

2) QB - WR pass logic, target\route interaction. IF vision checks for WRs to see the 'final destination' of the pass is required, then it makes sense to also require that check for DBs. TBH - most DBs have much higher vision than WRs already, so for well built DBs, this would be a non-issue\non-nerf anyways.




For those of you who wanted bullets - Bones has done them perfectly for me - read this if you want the argument made more succinctly. Editing to add to the original post.
 
PaqMarq11
makes sense
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Ubasstards
Originally posted by Bukowski


But every time he does a quick fix, something else ends up broken because of it. He should realize this by now.

The entire SIM is nothing but patchwork at this time, nothing is stable whatsoever.

He needs to stop adding all of these little trinkets, and actually fix what needs to be fixed. The same things have been broken for a long time, while he's wasting time with endorsements and fame - which we really didn't need. I would much rather have a functioning SIM, than these silly little endorsements.


First he should work on the most important things in the game:
1) Color Dots
2) MVP Endorsements
3) GLB background color
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
30) Powerbacks unstoppable
31) D-Line sucks
32) The sim
34) passing sucks


this is just about right except for the last one.
 
rj414
offline
Link
 
Actually, color dots he can do first - those are just kickass :o

But yeah, I think fixing the sim should be his next priority, before adding little nuances like the ones he's been adding.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.