User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Suggestions > Endorsements - What I am thinking
Page:
 
TerrellOwns
offline
Link
 
There's nothing "Off-topic" about saying that only a retard would implement endorsements while the sim is completely fucked up.

- Thanks for trying to silence the opposition to this utterly wasteful addition. Just like VAs, this is a band-aid to distract people from the fact that no progress is being made on the sim.
Last edited Feb 26, 2009 20:11:41
 
Adderfist
offline
Link
 
Champ trophy's need to mean less in calculating fame.
 
Bert28
offline
Link
 
I like this idea. Great job Bort!
 
Capaneus
offline
Link
 
Another thing I would throw out is that I'm not convinced of the one endorsement per team/three per game max. Often times, the best players are clustered on one team, and some teams don't have any good players. My instinctive feeling is that it verges on handing out a "participation" trophy. But, given how powerful the items are, I can understand that that might unbalance things too much.
 
MeatBomb
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by tautology
Bort:

Regarding MVPs

The biggest difficulty in determing these sorts of things has to do with palying gutted teams, and the fact some players may face 4 gutted teams while others might face one one (or none).

Does the differential in fame make up for this level of disparity?

For instance-

A level 40 HB can easily pick up 800+ yards and 20 TDs vs a gutted teams. If they play three more gutted teams than an opponent, that is perhaps an 1800 yard and 50 TD "lead" that thye establish against the rest of the league in their primary stat lines.


Solution: In order to prevent this from causing inequities, throw away the 4 best games from each player. That goes a long ways towards making things a bit more even.


I was thinking along those same line when I thought to only use stat caslculations against playoff eligible teams at season's end in determining endorsement calculations. At least then, everyone has the same level of competition to compare to and the instances of stat-padding will be way down.
 
Link
 
I like the idea of special teams MVP's. Give the return men and backups that are on kick coverage teams something to play for. Track total tackles on kickoffs, and pancakes on kick returns, same for punts. Give the guys who are down at the bottom of the depth chart, playing a lot on special teams something to live for.
 
Kopitar11
offline
Link
 
So only "local" endorsements this season if you go through with this idea?(I like it btw)
 
MeatBomb
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Capaneus
Another thing I would throw out is that I'm not convinced of the one endorsement per team/three per game max. Often times, the best players are clustered on one team, and some teams don't have any good players. My instinctive feeling is that it verges on handing out a "participation" trophy. But, given how powerful the items are, I can understand that that might unbalance things too much.


Maybe give a max cap of endorsements per team and also require a fame rating at least above the league mean to be eligible for an endorsement. That would keep slow build teams and teams without any relatively leveled and competitive players from claiming endorsements.
 
Bort
Admin
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by tautology
Bort:

Regarding MVPs

The biggest difficulty in determing these sorts of things has to do with palying gutted teams, and the fact some players may face 4 gutted teams while others might face one one (or none).

Does the differential in fame make up for this level of disparity?

For instance-

A level 40 HB can easily pick up 800+ yards and 20 TDs vs a gutted teams. If they play three more gutted teams than an opponent, that is perhaps an 1800 yard and 50 TD "lead" that thye establish against the rest of the league in their primary stat lines.


Solution: In order to prevent this from causing inequities, throw away the 4 best games from each player. That goes a long ways towards making things a bit more even.


With the right weight balance I think fame could actually work pretty well to filter down the gut job masters.

It is also quite possible to go back through and re-calculate the stats that "count" for the purposes of an MVP calculation. Perhaps we could multiply the stats by a percentage, based on the level difference in the teams or the score differential, etc.
 
DavidD458
offline
Link
 
Hey Bort,

Sounds good. I would definitely give something to the people that got the endorsements currently. 4 BTs seems like a good idea.

As for the limit 3 per team, I think this should be risen. I don't think it'll be a problem of people stacking endorsement players. Raise the limit to 6 just in case. 6 won't change a team, but it also won't restrict anyone from joining a team that they just want to join. I think a limit of 3 is too small.

Also, what about a Super Bowl MVP award (endorsement) for a championship winner? I think it would be a pretty cool idea and give a little extra to a well-deserved championship victory.
 
Bort
Admin
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by MeatBomb
Originally posted by Capaneus

Another thing I would throw out is that I'm not convinced of the one endorsement per team/three per game max. Often times, the best players are clustered on one team, and some teams don't have any good players. My instinctive feeling is that it verges on handing out a "participation" trophy. But, given how powerful the items are, I can understand that that might unbalance things too much.


Maybe give a max cap of endorsements per team and also require a fame rating at least above the league mean to be eligible for an endorsement. That would keep slow build teams and teams without any relatively leveled and competitive players from claiming endorsements.


That's not a bad idea. Or limit it to players who are at least at the league minimum?
 
kretchfoop
offline
Link
 
Keep going with the test servers. The general structure looks solid...but my opinion will be different once it is rolled out. I think special teams is going to be more of a problem than anything. Will kickers get it? Will returners get it? I have a feeling that it will be skewed so that gunners get screwed.
 
Hikariu
offline
Link
 
Does this force teams to go with less depth just to get numbers?
 
Snipeshow
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by DavidD458
Hey Bort,

Sounds good. I would definitely give something to the people that got the endorsements currently. 4 BTs seems like a good idea.

As for the limit 3 per team, I think this should be risen. I don't think it'll be a problem of people stacking endorsement players. Raise the limit to 6 just in case. 6 won't change a team, but it also won't restrict anyone from joining a team that they just want to join. I think a limit of 3 is too small.

Also, what about a Super Bowl MVP award (endorsement) for a championship winner? I think it would be a pretty cool idea and give a little extra to a well-deserved championship victory.


That, or put a cap on each type of endorsement per team?
 
Bort
Admin
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by DavidD458
Also, what about a Super Bowl MVP award (endorsement) for a championship winner? I think it would be a pretty cool idea and give a little extra to a well-deserved championship victory.


That's not bad either. Could be pretty cool. Far less likely to be subjective as well.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.