User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Page:
 
cptafw163
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by TyrannyVaunt
Originally posted by GMathiasf

Originally posted by TyrannyVaunt


The higher the fame, the better the endorsement should be. Regardless of position. Look Steve Hutchinson is perhaps the best G in the NFL... But I don't see him doing Sony commercials... Instead I see Peyton Manning. A Guard shouldn't have a fame score as high as a QB, HB, WR. Just like a NT shouldn't have a fame score like a dominant LB or Safety.

So make fame based on something like this...

Players Fame = # of snaps + league rank (BBB, A, AA, AAA, Pro) + position trophies + team trophies + position factor.

Position Factor would be weighted by position (QB, HB, WR = 300 flex should be higher weight than other positions).

The higher the fame, the better the endorsement.

Every player gets an endorsement once their fame is 600+. The higher the fame, the better the endorsement deals become.



Why trophies? Those are a terrible measure of performance honestly and are more about beating the crap out of bad teams than anything else. Whichever Conference has more CPUs wins the trophies.


Yes there are issues with gutted teams, and putting up uber numbers because you played against a bunch of gut jobs... But you play 16 games. Typically there are only 1 to 2 CPU's per conference. This season is a little strange given Zeta has 3 and Alpha has zero, but that is an exception of the rule. So yes, trophies should be counted toward your fame number. If you play 14 games against quality opponents, and 2 CPU's... For the most part every team has their work horses who will have a shot to get some padded stats during those two games. So whats the big deal?


The only trophy that means anything is the championship. Everything esle is more on the OC/DC than the player...and if a certain person owns every player on their team and can give all the carries to one HB during a gut job game so he can get 600 yards..without screwing a different agent out of stats.

j/k...but seriously.


don't get your panties in a bunch. Endorsements are just there to satisfy the selfish guys who want this game to have cars and mansions and hooker parties.
 
Lambda
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by GMathiasf
Originally posted by TyrannyVaunt

The higher the fame, the better the endorsement should be. Regardless of position. Look Steve Hutchinson is perhaps the best G in the NFL... But I don't see him doing Sony commercials... Instead I see Peyton Manning. A Guard shouldn't have a fame score as high as a QB, HB, WR. Just like a NT shouldn't have a fame score like a dominant LB or Safety.

So make fame based on something like this...

Players Fame = # of snaps + league rank (BBB, A, AA, AAA, Pro) + position trophies + team trophies + position factor.

Position Factor would be weighted by position (QB, HB, WR = 300 flex should be higher weight than other positions).

The higher the fame, the better the endorsement.

Every player gets an endorsement once their fame is 600+. The higher the fame, the better the endorsement deals become.



Why trophies? Those are a terrible measure of performance honestly and are more about beating the crap out of bad teams than anything else. Whichever Conference has more CPUs wins the trophies.


easy solution: make trophies based on conference
 
GMathiasf
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by TyrannyVaunt
Originally posted by GMathiasf

Originally posted by TyrannyVaunt


The higher the fame, the better the endorsement should be. Regardless of position. Look Steve Hutchinson is perhaps the best G in the NFL... But I don't see him doing Sony commercials... Instead I see Peyton Manning. A Guard shouldn't have a fame score as high as a QB, HB, WR. Just like a NT shouldn't have a fame score like a dominant LB or Safety.

So make fame based on something like this...

Players Fame = # of snaps + league rank (BBB, A, AA, AAA, Pro) + position trophies + team trophies + position factor.

Position Factor would be weighted by position (QB, HB, WR = 300 flex should be higher weight than other positions).

The higher the fame, the better the endorsement.

Every player gets an endorsement once their fame is 600+. The higher the fame, the better the endorsement deals become.



Why trophies? Those are a terrible measure of performance honestly and are more about beating the crap out of bad teams than anything else. Whichever Conference has more CPUs wins the trophies.


Yes there are issues with gutted teams, and putting up uber numbers because you played against a bunch of gut jobs... But you play 16 games. Typically there are only 1 to 2 CPU's per conference. This season is a little strange given Zeta has 3 and Alpha has zero, but that is an exception of the rule. So yes, trophies should be counted toward your fame number. If you play 14 games against quality opponents, and 2 CPU's... For the most part every team has their work horses who will have a shot to get some padded stats during those two games. So whats the big deal?


You have to be kidding me Ty. Usually you're much better than this. The big deal is that in those 2 games, some players get half of their stats or more for the season. This is especially true for sacks from DEs, Pancakes, kick returns/punt return TDs.

Let's just look at week 1 in our League:
San Juan pulled the only CPU team in Alpha so they'll get 4 CPU teams (unless someone else folds) this season. In their first game, their HB ran for nearly 450 yards. So if he does that in his other 3 CPU games, he'll have about 1800 yards in those 4 games. Early money goes on him winning a trophy. San Juan also had a DE with 29 tackles because the CPU team that is still human owned ran the ball more than 70 times. When it comes to sacks, the top 9 players all played CPU teams. The most anyone not playing a CPU team got was 3 while we have 7 players with 7 or more. Pancakes is a huge joke as well. If you don't seriously think that a system that rewards teams for playing shitty teams and padding stats by giving them an actual advantage, then I can't help you.

Taut made a good suggestion to leave out the 4 best games of all players. The bottom line is that Bort is going to change it because it was honestly terrible. No one is defending the way endorsements are done except those who won out ridiculously. Wow, I'm shocked to see the Cartel got 3 and the Pitbulls got a bunch. There's a reason you're defending this terrible system and it's not logic or reason.
 
TyrannyVaunt
offline
Link
 
^^^ In response... I would be all for having trophies count, but having the trophies factored only after tossing out your top 3 or 4 games. That should eliminate 98% of the gut jobs where players stats get inflated and blown up.

And lastly come on GMathiasf... You should give me more credit bro. I am not defending the terrible system. Yes the Cartel did get three, but they were for a K, P and DT. And they were not very good endorsements so Bort can have them back. Its not a big deal.

I like the endorsements, and I have said in this very thread that I believe he should overhaul the system and give them out to everyone. But the endorsements should be very fundamental for low fame players and buffed more and more as you increase your fame.

I think the thing that we have varying opinions on is the way the fame number is calculated, with relation to trophies. If you want to toss out four games, fine... But I still think trophies, both individual and team oriented should be weighted heavily when calculating a fame score.

Brett Favre is famous because of his stats and individual accomplishments. Not because of the one Super Bowl Trophy... More so for what he accomplished as a player. Same should be said for GLB players IMO.


Last edited Feb 27, 2009 14:56:35
 
SoCold
offline
Link
 
we talked it over and we think the endorsements are pretty fair.

 
tautology
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by SoCold
we talked it over and we think the endorsements are pretty fair.



They were very fair to you guys

 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.