User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Oceania AAA Leagues > Oceania AAA #2 > Oceania AA MVP/Pro Bowl Race Season 2
Page:
 
TheKingOfVa
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by PlayinHarder
Originally posted by Rage Kinard

The season is young, he's just throwing names out there. Maybe rather than just complaining you should list some others worthy of being considered.


Amen to that!!!!!

Good job TheKingOfVa, thanks for the hard work you put into this. It's fun to read.



Thanks I'll adjust the list through out the year then we can get a committee in to vote on the real pro bowl teams.

 
brOUsterman
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by TheKingOfVa
Originally posted by lecanadien17

I like how the league leader in interceptions isn't a pro bowler. I realize that he doesn't have that many tackles or PD, but thats because no one ever throws at him.


Lecanadien the list isn't perfect and this isn't the final version, Plus I think it's two other Darwin CB's on the team. And your right I overlooked him but no need to throw a hissy fit just post his name team and stats like that TE did earlier.


Thanks Rage, like I said your more than welcome to post players you think should be on there. Every single good player isn't going to make the team.

Brousterman that comment wasn't need, there aren't any dumb decisions on the D side of the ball. I took a lot of time to compile that list and it's a shame people like you make people not want to do anything for the league. If you have a player you think should be on the list than submit their name and stats.


Myabe your right. Also it had nothign to do with any of they players you picked as it was the comment im not going to pick teams that dnt have good records cause there defense is out on the field to much and stats are padded.

I do apprciate you taking the time no doubt. Im defending players like on my defense, and other defensive units that are in the lower half, should atleast be considered, which i dont know if any are right now, no matter what the situation is.
 
TheKingOfVa
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by brOUsterman
Originally posted by TheKingOfVa

Originally posted by lecanadien17


I like how the league leader in interceptions isn't a pro bowler. I realize that he doesn't have that many tackles or PD, but thats because no one ever throws at him.


Lecanadien the list isn't perfect and this isn't the final version, Plus I think it's two other Darwin CB's on the team. And your right I overlooked him but no need to throw a hissy fit just post his name team and stats like that TE did earlier.


Thanks Rage, like I said your more than welcome to post players you think should be on there. Every single good player isn't going to make the team.

Brousterman that comment wasn't need, there aren't any dumb decisions on the D side of the ball. I took a lot of time to compile that list and it's a shame people like you make people not want to do anything for the league. If you have a player you think should be on the list than submit their name and stats.


Myabe your right. Also it had nothign to do with any of they players you picked as it was the comment im not going to pick teams that dnt have good records cause there defense is out on the field to much and stats are padded.

I do apprciate you taking the time no doubt. Im defending players like on my defense, and other defensive units that are in the lower half, should atleast be considered, which i dont know if any are right now, no matter what the situation is.




They are still considered a guy with a 1-7 made the defense team. But just like real life the pro bowl teams are made up from mostly the best teams. Just like on defense the elite units (almost the whole NY Giants D-line made the team)guys usually make it.
 
cruscott35
offline
Link
 
Are HB's blocking for other HB's??? Why are there no FBs? Jackson James on Aukland should be there.
 
TheKingOfVa
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by cruscott35
Are HB's blocking for other HB's??? Why are there no FBs? Jackson James on Aukland should be there.


Good point sorry about that. I'll compile a fb list over the next few days and update.
 
ernierenm
offline
Link
 
I can say you picked my guy the 2-7 team and he didn't have any padded stats most of his big games were in the close games we lost. look at the scores and last game he only played 22 plays and got 2 tackles.
 
lecanadien17
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by TheKingOfVa
Originally posted by lecanadien17

I like how the league leader in interceptions isn't a pro bowler. I realize that he doesn't have that many tackles or PD, but thats because no one ever throws at him.


Lecanadien the list isn't perfect and this isn't the final version, Plus I think it's two other Darwin CB's on the team. And your right I overlooked him but no need to throw a hissy fit just post his name team and stats like that TE did earlier.



I wasn't throwing a hissy fit, I think you did a great job and thanks for putting the effort in. You did list the corner on my team that typically wins the defensive game MVP from me in Karls Myth, I was just pointing out that the league leader in interceptions typically is a pro bowler. I would've said that for anyone even if they weren't me or on my team. But again, thanks for doing this, it was a cool read.
 
Forest21
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by cruscott35
Are HB's blocking for other HB's??? Why are there no FBs? Jackson James on Aukland should be there.


Oceania AA MVP/Pro Bowl Race Season 2

There's no Jackson James on the Auckland Old Gold & All Blacks
 
Newcastle
offline
Link
 
Nice to see Slim Walker up there...and grats to my fellow Dline man - Remoh. Interesting selection process. I think some stats are padded...if you look carefully and some arent. I think a more objective viewpoint and who would be the mvp in various positions can best be ascertained at the end of the season when everyone has been able to rumble with everyone else. But interesting list so far, and thanks to the O.P. for taking the time to put it together.

ps. i dont mean to sound snide or bitchy, simply noting is all.
Last edited May 14, 2008 16:09:10
 
Ironhead
offline
Link
 
I have to side with the guys saying the teams with poor records still have some quality efforts being put out by their players. I mean, 1000 yards rushing by a guy on team with an O-line ravaged by an ownership change or poor blocking is as impressive (maybe even more so) as a guy running for 1700 on a good team.
 
sxewesley
offline
Link
 
I agree with you Ironhead and Newcastle. However, What King was specifically talking about was defense I think.

Good teams pad offensive stats and bad teams pad defensive stats, it does need to be taken into consideration because the differences can be astounding.

One team has had 938 plays on offense 104.2 per game, another has had 671 or 74 plays per game. That is a HUGE difference.

Or one team has had 912 plays on D, 101 per game and another team has had 690 for 76 plays per game.

The better your team is as a whole, the more it helps your individual offensive stats and hurts your individual defensive stats.

Couple that with positions like CB where the better you are the less stats you have and we need to use a little judgment is all. I am not trying to make a huge deal out of this, it is something we should be aware of though.
 
Ironhead
offline
Link
 
Understood, and I'm not trying to argue with anyone here; just saying that I'd like to see everyone get some consideration and not have the people suffering through a rough season feel they aren't appreciated. Let's face it, the league wouldn't be much fun if the losing teams weren't still trying. Those upsets are what make the game so great and they're forged by the hard work of the guys struggling for recognition. I now surrender the soap box back to the forum
 
sxewesley
offline
Link
 
I totally agree with you. Sorry if I didn't make myself clear. I was trying to say that good offensive production from players on lower ranked teams should be given special consideration, because it is much harder for them with less plays.
 
cruscott35
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by cruscott35
Are HB's blocking for other HB's??? Why are there no FBs? Jackson James on Aukland should be there.


Didn't realize this wasn't the pro bowl for my league, disregard, I don't care if you guys have fullbacks or not.
 
wrkarl
offline
Link
 
Thank you for including Karls Myth in your Pro bowl listings
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.