User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Page:
 
SAGA45
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
They're just not making the turn very quickly. The AI definition doesn't have anything that's set to wait for the pitch. It's literally something like:

Move back, move outside, move forward and block.


lol! On that play it looked like: Move back, then right...oops...I guess it's left, move forward, block, I suck.
 
nithos
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by SAGA45
lol! On that play it looked like: Move back, then right...oops...I guess it's left, move forward, block, I suck.

Exactly, the guard gets outside in time, but since there isn't anyone to block with 5 yards, the guard takes off running in a random direction instead of heading downfield to block.
 
SAGA45
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by nithos
Originally posted by SAGA45

lol! On that play it looked like: Move back, then right...oops...I guess it's left, move forward, block, I suck.

Exactly, the guard gets outside in time, but since there isn't anyone to block with 5 yards, the guard takes off running in a random direction instead of heading downfield to block.


http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?pbp_id=2778123

He also hangs out (and oddly looks a little lost) until the HB gets the ball and then starts running outside - quite common no matter what the guard's LvL or how athletic he is. So that's a couple of things that need to be checked out along with the TE collision issues on blitzes.

 
jrg42
offline
Link
 
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?pbp_id=3002295

OK. I put one of my WR's with 40 speed and 27 agility and 24 vision in at RG. Still cannot even get close to the outside and make the block. He is not tired as he only played 13 plays the entire game.

I think just tweaking the AI for down field block pickup is not enough, unless it is intended for G's to have massive amounts of points in 'fast type' skills. If this is the case and in your simulations a higher level player (with the right build) can make it out there 70% of the time, that is great. I agree it should not be easy, but I would have guessed that a level 11 WR could at least get out to the right spot in time to do something.

Need some better AI when they run down the line to avoid their own players from getting in their way.
 
Bort
Admin
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by jrg42
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?pbp_id=3002295

OK. I put one of my WR's with 40 speed and 27 agility and 24 vision in at RG. Still cannot even get close to the outside and make the block. He is not tired as he only played 13 plays the entire game.

I think just tweaking the AI for down field block pickup is not enough, unless it is intended for G's to have massive amounts of points in 'fast type' skills. If this is the case and in your simulations a higher level player (with the right build) can make it out there 70% of the time, that is great. I agree it should not be easy, but I would have guessed that a level 11 WR could at least get out to the right spot in time to do something.

Need some better AI when they run down the line to avoid their own players from getting in their way.


That's not a very good test. The WR gets a huge penalty to his stats for playing at G.
 
SAGA45
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by jrg42
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?pbp_id=3002295

OK. I put one of my WR's with 40 speed and 27 agility and 24 vision in at RG. Still cannot even get close to the outside and make the block. He is not tired as he only played 13 plays the entire game.


Same delay there as well. I know Bort said it's not in the code but it just looks like the guard is waiting for the HB to determine which way the play is going and which direction he needs to lead/pull.
 
whoshotjr
offline
Link
 
I think there was another thread about this, and my Guard almost pulled correctly on one play (can't find the play anymore). He did a nice job of getting outside the Tackle and TE, and started up field. However, there was no one immediately available to block within 5 yards or so he made a sharp turn and went and blocked the DT (who was no threat on the play). As the running back moved downfield, the G gave up on the DT and surged downfield to block an LB...but again the guy he blocked wasn't a real threat as he was well behind the play.

So I think the AI change Bort proposes would help in this case. He probably would have headed downfield to block the safety on the play, and it would have been a much bigger gain.

I would note that my Guard is more of a special teams player, so he has decent speed/agility/vision and is a little light on blocking/stamina & special abilities. However, he does get a few snaps at G on occasion.

 
jrg42
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Originally posted by jrg42

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?pbp_id=3002295

OK. I put one of my WR's with 40 speed and 27 agility and 24 vision in at RG. Still cannot even get close to the outside and make the block. He is not tired as he only played 13 plays the entire game.

I think just tweaking the AI for down field block pickup is not enough, unless it is intended for G's to have massive amounts of points in 'fast type' skills. If this is the case and in your simulations a higher level player (with the right build) can make it out there 70% of the time, that is great. I agree it should not be easy, but I would have guessed that a level 11 WR could at least get out to the right spot in time to do something.

Need some better AI when they run down the line to avoid their own players from getting in their way.


That's not a very good test. The WR gets a huge penalty to his stats for playing at G.


Yeah, hard for me to quantify what the out of position penalty is, but I thought it was worth a shot. I don't have a lv 10+ G with super high agility...yet. It was funny seeing him get pwned by the NT a couple of times, though.

 
jrg42
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by whoshotjr
I think there was another thread about this, and my Guard almost pulled correctly on one play (can't find the play anymore). He did a nice job of getting outside the Tackle and TE, and started up field. However, there was no one immediately available to block within 5 yards or so he made a sharp turn and went and blocked the DT (who was no threat on the play). As the running back moved downfield, the G gave up on the DT and surged downfield to block an LB...but again the guy he blocked wasn't a real threat as he was well behind the play.

So I think the AI change Bort proposes would help in this case. He probably would have headed downfield to block the safety on the play, and it would have been a much bigger gain.

I would note that my Guard is more of a special teams player, so he has decent speed/agility/vision and is a little light on blocking/stamina & special abilities. However, he does get a few snaps at G on occasion.



It definitely can be done under the current code, but the frequency at which it happens seems like less than 1 of every 100 plays. I think I posted that one of my G's pulled and blocked someone at lv 3, but has not been able to duplicate that over the next 3-4 levels despite adding more points to agility and speed.

If it takes higher level players to do it; fine. I'll keep working at it, but throw the lower levels a small bone and make the success rate a tad higher.
 
Bort
Admin
offline
Link
 
The new play definitions are in place, so we'll see what happens in the next couple days worth of games.
 
jrg42
offline
Link
 
Thanks Bort! I really think there are a dozen mini-Borts answering posts and tweaking the code. You guys are really on top of stuff.
 
SAGA45
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
The new play definitions are in place, so we'll see what happens in the next couple days worth of games.


Cool! Looking forward to checking out the plays
 
nithos
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
The new play definitions are in place, so we'll see what happens in the next couple days worth of games.

Great, looking forward to rolling over some CBs in tomorrows game.
 
johnbshin
offline
Link
 
not to be a nit but, the pulling guard in this game is the wrong one :/ the guard is supposed to pull across the center (the LG if your running right for example) so the hole that was just vacated is on the backside of the play not right where the rb is headed :/
 
bigtisme
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by johnbshin
not to be a nit but, the pulling guard in this game is the wrong one :/ the guard is supposed to pull across the center (the LG if your running right for example) so the hole that was just vacated is on the backside of the play not right where the rb is headed :/


lol...not on a pitch play.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.