User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Oceania AAA Leagues > Oceania AAA #1 > Oceania AAA - Season 2 - MVP Candidates
Page:
 
turnit643
offline
Link
 
love the back and forth about the corners ... especially about Amanda since she was just dropped into the conversation as an example of a player that doesn't have the big numbers but is still very valuable to her team. I think we can agree that the numbers don't tell the whole story about corners, but they are eye-catching and guys like McNeeley must be doing something right.

At the end of the season, I think we should ask all of the team owners to submit a list of 5 players from their team to be put on the official ballot as MVP candidates. After the list has been assembled, we hold a vote - each team gets one ballot and makes their selections for the top 3 offensive and defensive players, and you can't vote for guys on your own team. Tally the votes and there we go - Offensive and Defensive MVPs.

What do you guys think?
 
Rudger
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by McGruffHawk
Nobody mentioned Amanda for MVP. That was a tangent of evaluating corners.

Frankly, I don't think any of the corners belong in the discussion when compared to Vin or Nuggett.


I love you guys who completely disregard our guys because they are on a losing team. Yah Ray Lewis and Chris Mcallister suck because the ravens had a bad year.(not realy a ravens fan but its the first example that comes to mind)

BTW who the heck are you talkin about, Vin and Nugget? Rusty Nugget for Offense MVP? If you mean defense players post some supporting stats. Dont just say "noone compares to these guys I like".
 
turnit643
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Rudger
Originally posted by McGruffHawk

Nobody mentioned Amanda for MVP. That was a tangent of evaluating corners.

Frankly, I don't think any of the corners belong in the discussion when compared to Vin or Nuggett.


I love you guys who completely disregard our guys because they are on a losing team. Yah Ray Lewis and Chris Mcallister suck because the ravens had a bad year.(not realy a ravens fan but its the first example that comes to mind)

BTW who the heck are you talkin about, Vin and Nugget? Rusty Nugget for Offense MVP? If you mean defense players post some supporting stats. Dont just say "noone compares to these guys I like".

I think he was referring to RB Vin Numbers and QB Rusty Nuggett who were each mentioned earlier in the thread along with their numbers.
 
Rudger
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by turnit643
love the back and forth about the corners ... especially about Amanda since she was just dropped into the conversation as an example of a player that doesn't have the big numbers but is still very valuable to her team. I think we can agree that the numbers don't tell the whole story about corners, but they are eye-catching and guys like McNeeley must be doing something right.

At the end of the season, I think we should ask all of the team owners to submit a list of 5 players from their team to be put on the official ballot as MVP candidates. After the list has been assembled, we hold a vote - each team gets one ballot and makes their selections for the top 3 offensive and defensive players, and you can't vote for guys on your own team. Tally the votes and there we go - Offensive and Defensive MVPs.

What do you guys think?


Great Idea, prolly going to be a pain in the rear to organise though...

Who all gets a vote? Just the owners of the various AAA teams? Or, Everyone and their brother who feels like signing in taht day?

I think it would work well just being the owners who vote on MVPs, they probably would be atleast a little less biased.
 
turnit643
offline
Link
 
Each owner would receive a ballot by PM that they could share with their team in their team forum before returning it. 32 teams, 32 ballots, 32 votes. Rank the top 3 offensive guys 1 through 3, same with D players (and special teamers too I suppose .) We tally up what gets submitted back. Not too hard, I'd be willing to organize it.
 
Rudger
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by turnit643
Each owner would receive a ballot by PM that they could share with their team in their team forum before returning it. 32 teams, 32 ballots, 32 votes. Rank the top 3 offensive guys 1 through 3, same with D players (and special teamers too I suppose .) We tally up what gets submitted back. Not too hard, I'd be willing to organize it.


hah, sounds almost too easy! Well im all for that idea.

This is for Offense MVP and Defense MVP right? You said and maybe Special Teams MVP? Sounds like a good idea to me. Ill keep checking back here to see if anyone else agrees or if we should go back to the banter
 
lukin83
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by turnit643
love the back and forth about the corners ... especially about Amanda since she was just dropped into the conversation as an example of a player that doesn't have the big numbers but is still very valuable to her team. I think we can agree that the numbers don't tell the whole story about corners, but they are eye-catching and guys like McNeeley must be doing something right.

At the end of the season, I think we should ask all of the team owners to submit a list of 5 players from their team to be put on the official ballot as MVP candidates. After the list has been assembled, we hold a vote - each team gets one ballot and makes their selections for the top 3 offensive and defensive players, and you can't vote for guys on your own team. Tally the votes and there we go - Offensive and Defensive MVPs.

What do you guys think?


I would suggest being able to use one of the three votes on a player from your own team.

I love the idea.


Hell, we could have a Pro Bowl ballot, too.
Last edited May 13, 2008 18:16:35
 
turnit643
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by lukin83

I would suggest being able to use one of the three votes on a player from your own team.

I love the idea.


Hell, we could have a Pro Bowl ballot, too.

Thought about the Pro Bowl ballot thing too, would be a bigger project, but possibly doable.
 
BMoreAbsurd
offline
Link
 
I dunno about a Pro Bowl...but an Oceanic All Pro team...that's doable. We would need to find someone that we can all agree is unbiased to gather the nominees, though...and who would vote? I would think owners and GMs...

Just an idea.
 
lukin83
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by BMoreAbsurd
I dunno about a Pro Bowl...but an Oceanic All Pro team...that's doable. We would need to find someone that we can all agree is unbiased to gather the nominees, though...and who would vote? I would think owners and GMs...

Just an idea.


I think you have to limit it to just owner voting. Some teams have more GMs than others, so it wouldn't be fair since not everyone is going to be unbiased.
 
lukin83
offline
Link
 
Also, as far as a Pro Bowl Ballot, why not have each owner submit a list of 1 QB, 1 HB, 1 FB, 2 WR, 1 TE, 2 OT, 2 G, 1 C, 2 DE, 2 DT, 3 LB, 2 CB, 1 FS, 1 SS, 1 K, 1 P, 1 KR/PR, 1 special teamer, and one write-in.

Once we have a ballot put together, we can have the owners vote. Final roster would consist of 3 QB, 3 HB, 1 FB, 5 WR, 3 TE, 4 OT, 4 G, 2 C, 4 DE, 4 DT, 6 LB, 5 CB, 2 FS, 2 SS, 1 K, 1 P, 1 ST, and the write-in. We would have separate Alpha and Zeta teams with only owners from each conference voting on their own team.

I'd be willing to head something like this up. Not sure when we should start collecting players for the ballot though. After Week 12 maybe?
Last edited May 14, 2008 06:30:26
 
Eon724
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by nhazelett
BTW turnit thanks for showing McNeeley some love for MVP though, I couldn't have done it without the opposite corner on my team, Rage Bloodpike. If he wasn't completely shutting down his side, the QB wouldn't ever throw it my way.


Thanks Haz. Hope you resign with the Bulls. Couldn't think of anyone I'd rather play opposite of.

We need a good system to evaluate what a good corner is. DB's are hard to do that with because of all the un-tracked stats such as times passed on or TD's given up or which tackles were from run plays or pass plays etc.

I love the thought of an All Pro/Pro Bowl team and voting for it. It's a great idea.

And...
Originally posted by Rudger
I love you guys who completely disregard our guys because they are on a losing team. Yah Ray Lewis and Chris Mcallister suck because the ravens had a bad year.(not realy a ravens fan but its the first example that comes to mind)

QFT Quoted for Truth
 
TtD
offline
Link
 
Not disregarding him, hes obviously a solid stopper, i'm saying the D is weak in front of him because hes had to make that many tackles. It's similar to a FS getting tackles, it only happens when the line or the corners mess up so the sign of a good D is a decent FS with no work. You've got a good D, but only cause you've got a good set of backs and safeties cleaning up for you. I'd also make the arguement that as a starting CB, if your D-line and LB are good enough, even runs won't come down your side. Last game for example my lad had four plays in the entire game go anywhere near him, one pass made for 9.5yds where their WR made a good catch under pressure, in the first minute, a PD for my lad next play on a similar route, then nothing down the same side until a 4th quarter hail mary our FS and SS were also under and a jumped route PD on another CBs WR almost last play of the game. Surely that indicates two things, our D-line is on top of the game and keeping the chances down, and the CB is being avoided.

I'd also question INT as a valid stat, sure it's pretty but it says more about the CBs play style and the QBs skills hes dealing with, is even harder to calculate than everything else about the corners.

From watching our games i'd probably have at least one of our LB and one of our DE in the MVP ballot, they've just been awesome all season and it's really kept us in games to have them flying at opponent QBs.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by lukin83
Also, as far as a Pro Bowl Ballot, why not have each owner submit a list of 1 QB, 1 HB, 1 FB, 2 WR, 1 TE, 2 OT, 2 G, 1 C, 2 DE, 2 DT, 3 LB, 2 CB, 1 FS, 1 SS, 1 K, 1 P, 1 KR/PR, 1 special teamer, and one write-in.

Once we have a ballot put together, we can have the owners vote. Final roster would consist of 3 QB, 3 HB, 1 FB, 5 WR, 3 TE, 4 OT, 4 G, 2 C, 4 DE, 4 DT, 6 LB, 5 CB, 2 FS, 2 SS, 1 K, 1 P, 1 ST, and the write-in. We would have separate Alpha and Zeta teams with only owners from each conference voting on their own team.

I'd be willing to head something like this up. Not sure when we should start collecting players for the ballot though. After Week 12 maybe?


That would be cool to do...You should start it up Lukin..(after WK 12 that is)

 
Rudger
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by TtD

I'd also question INT as a valid stat, sure it's pretty but it says more about the CBs play style and the QBs skills hes dealing with, is even harder to calculate than everything else about the corners.


We are all in the same league here so to some degree we are all dealing with the same QBs. As a Defense Coordinator I can tell you I LOVE to see INTs, that gets my guys off the field.

Also if INTs arent an indication, maybe leading the league in passes defended is?
Mcneeley 36 PD (1st)


Originally posted by lukin83
Also, as far as a Pro Bowl Ballot, why not have each owner submit a list of 1 QB, 1 HB, 1 FB, 2 WR, 1 TE, 2 OT, 2 G, 1 C, 2 DE, 2 DT, 3 LB, 2 CB, 1 FS, 1 SS, 1 K, 1 P, 1 KR/PR, 1 special teamer, and one write-in.

Once we have a ballot put together, we can have the owners vote. Final roster would consist of 3 QB, 3 HB, 1 FB, 5 WR, 3 TE, 4 OT, 4 G, 2 C, 4 DE, 4 DT, 6 LB, 5 CB, 2 FS, 2 SS, 1 K, 1 P, 1 ST, and the write-in. We would have separate Alpha and Zeta teams with only owners from each conference voting on their own team.

I'd be willing to head something like this up. Not sure when we should start collecting players for the ballot though. After Week 12 maybe?


I like this idea, obviously its not a supported one though. So you will need some sort of fantasy football formula to evaluate how each team does.... This idea almost needs a seperate thread.

I still think owners should vote for Offense MVP & Defense MVP.
Last edited May 14, 2008 09:53:11
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.