User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Suggestions > Solution to Test Server Issue - Please do not Delete/Lock - Serious Idea
Page:
 
Keiichi
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Deathblade
Originally posted by Keiichi

Secondlife does. Just saying.


I tried that game for a bit.

It is actually quite interesting.


There are aspects that are interesting. But I lost interest a coupe years ago.

 
mantis7
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by eve999

Major game companies ? Name me one who is publicly traded. And beyond it, there is no need to let people on the test server because the whole thing can be run by the CPU.


I just named two major ones, scroll up
 
James1985
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by mantis7
Originally posted by James1985

Originally posted by mantis7


Originally posted by eve999




I work in IT for a a living. I can tell you NO company of any respectability lets customers run rampant in it's test systems. The whole purpose of a test system to test things before the customers see it.


There are major game companies that let users (all users btw, not just some) use the test servers....
You are wrong on this issue.


Not 1 company in the World lets 100% of there Users run free on test servers. not 1


City of heroes (NC soft)

Sony (planetside)

To name 2 off the top of my head


So you are telling me EVERY single player that has played planetside is running free on its test server? If not then like I said. No Major game company is dumb enough to open its Test server to the public.
 
Deathblade
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by mantis7
I think tehre is deathbklade, seriously, this is a suggestion to end the issue..It is not discussing whether there is or is not a testing server or whether there should or should not be one, it is a suggestion to make it fair.


There has been suggestions thrown out...especially your suggestion. It has been discussed to death in those threads.
 
dmfa41
offline
Link
 
To second Deathblade's sentiment, we lock threads which break rules. You're not breaking any rules here, Mantis.

That being said, if there are superfluous threads about the issue in this forum (essentially any other beyond this one) they'd be classified as duplicates and be locked.

As far as the thread's main idea goes, I was ambivalent before and still am.
 
James1985
offline
Link
 
GLB does not want Cookie Cutter builds.

he opens his test servers to everyone and now we find out Exactly what each stat should be at each level. Explain to me how that is fun?
 
mantis7
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by James1985

So you are telling me EVERY single player that has played planetside is running free on its test server? If not then like I said. No Major game company is dumb enough to open its Test server to the public.


You asked for names of major companies that allowed all users access to test servers,, I gave you two.

Planetside (MMOFPS) run by SONY (who last I checked is pretty major)

And City Of Heroes/City of Villains (NCsoft) is MMORPG that is major...

And someone mentioned Secondlife, which is also MAJOR.

Both games allow a user to enter the test server at any time...Yes.
Last edited Feb 15, 2009 18:35:42
 
mantis7
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by James1985
GLB does not want Cookie Cutter builds.

he opens his test servers to everyone and now we find out Exactly what each stat should be at each level. Explain to me how that is fun?


Explain to me how letting a few people know the best builds (cookie cutter as you call it) and then having pay competetions where these same people play against the 'regular' users without this knowledge..

You are admitting that this inside info would be used...

Do you not see the beauty of my solution? Everyone would would have acccess to this info, therefore no one would have an unfair advantage...If there was one cookie cutter build, my idea would expose it, and Bort could change it so that it wasn't like that!
 
mantis7
offline
Link
 
You see, allowing only a few people to use the test servers does not prevent cookie cutter builds, it only encourages peopel to find them and use them....on the rest of the non-testers.....unfair advantage...

Having test servers available to all will expose these loopholes faster, and more fairly, and we can put a stop to the cookie cutter that everyone (including me) doesnt want to see.

That is the beauty of this idea..
 
eve999
offline
Link
 

I can't confirm or deny if those companies let customers on test servers. I only know that it is stupid to do so.

And actually what I said earlier was true. There is no reason for people to be on the test servers because it can all be run via CPU teams/players. The developers of this site can set up whatever test scenarios they like and then have it run through the CPU. There isn't any reason for anyone to be on those servers.

And I will stop replying to this thread since the mod asked the discussion to be taken elsewhere.
 
James1985
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by mantis7
Originally posted by James1985

GLB does not want Cookie Cutter builds.

he opens his test servers to everyone and now we find out Exactly what each stat should be at each level. Explain to me how that is fun?


Explain to me how letting a few people know the best builds (cookie cutter as you call it) and then having pay competetions where these same people play against the 'regular' users without this knowledge..

You are admitting that this inside info would be used...

Do you not see the beauty of my solution? Everyone would would have acccess to this info, therefore no one would have an unfair advantage...If there was one cookie cutter build, my idea would expose it, and Bort could change it so that it wasn't like that!


You dont get what i am saying

The "Testers" dont get any special knowledge. There builds are just like mine and yours.

One Mod I know was accused of being a tester....her is his SS...For his level I would like to know what is so Special about him.http://goallineblitz.com/game/player.pl?player_id=26755

No you cant. There are even things about the build you can say need to be "Fixed"

This SS has no advatage what so ever over any other SS his level.
 
mantis7
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by eve999

I can't confirm or deny if those companies let customers on test servers. I only know that it is stupid to do so.


Well i can confirm it on CoX, and Sony/Planetside....

If it is stupid in your opinion then obviously I and Sony and NcSoft as well as many others disagree with you.

You haven't said why it is stupid, you havent given one good reason.
 
mantis7
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by James1985
You dont get what i am saying

The "Testers" dont get any special knowledge. There builds are just like mine and yours.


Then why not allow everyone access to testing?

You cannot have it both ways, James..

You cant say it will lead to cookie cutter builds one minute , and then claim there is no knowledge gained from it...

Your argument defies common sense and logic..

If (as you now claim) you gain nothing from being on a test server, then my idea should be allowed....Let everyone use the test servers, because it wouldnt change anything...right?
 
eve999
offline
Link
 

You can PM and I will explain software development to you.
 
mantis7
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by eve999

You can PM and I will explain software development to you.


No thanks, we are having a public debate...I came out with facts that proved you to be wrong...If you would like to continue debating this topic, we can do it here...
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.