User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Suggestions > CPU-owned teams should not be allowed to make the playoffs
Page:
 
Apple Dapple
offline
Link
 
If the CPU team is better, it should make the playoffs.
 
Apple Dapple
offline
Link
 
I fail, I didn't read the whole suggestion, sorry.

I see your concern. But I don't know how to discern that in the game. Like, if a CPU team is a CPU team and wins like that, they should make the playoffs. But if a playoff-team guts... how do you disqualify them?
 
Apple Dapple
offline
Link
 
All that's happening is people are arguing "Too bad, deal with it" and "No, this should happen" but no one is explaining how.

I understand the problem, what's the solution? It isn't simply making no CPU team playoff-eligible.
 
Nephyte
offline
Link
 
I see it as a bandaid fix, for a non-problem.
 
Fezmid
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by GLBuser4
With that many wins, why did the owner sell the team?


The owner alleges that she was pissed off because the kicker missed an extra point, so cut the players and sold the team. Of course if that were true, why didn't the kicker retire....?

As for how to handle it... I find it hard to believe that there'd be a case where a total CPU team would be able to make the top-8 in a division (except for the leagues that are all CPU). So a check could be made after week 16 -- if all CPU, bump the team down and bump the next team up. It wouldn't be hard to do and I still think it'd be the right thing to do.

And let me reiterate -- my team is in the playoffs already, and the quitting owner actually helped my playoff spot. I'm looking at this from a fairness point of view.
 
Fezmid
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Nephyte
I see it as a bandaid fix, for a non-problem.


Why don't you see it as a problem?

Shouldn't this also mean that the now-CPU owned team should stay in the same division, since they finished the season in the playoffs? That won't happen though - Bort is going to relegate them down, I'm sure. But using the logic in this thread, that shouldn't happen -- they made the playoffs, they should be around next year and the new owner will suffer, just like a current human owner is going to suffer at not making the playoffs because of the CPU team.
 
ryan_grant-25
offline
Link
 
just read the OP, not the other posts, but i agree, a CPU team shouldnt be able to make the playoffs, especially a team that has only CPU players, its basically just giving a team a free pass.... just slide everyones seed up 1 until the CPU team is in the bottom imo.
 
n:iceman:16
offline
Link
 
If your team didn't suck it would make the playoffs. -1
 
Fezmid
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Iceman16
If your team didn't suck it would make the playoffs. -1


It's amazing how poor reading comprehension is in this world nowadays.

I'll use caps so you can understand:

MY TEAM IS ALREADY IN THE PLAYOFFS REGARDLESS OF WHETHER THE ALL-CPU TEAM GETS IN OR NOT!!!!
 
Link
 
Wait!

You have yet to prove it is a problem or unrealistic.

1. Can bad teams get into the playoffs in real life? YES
2. Can an injury or a head case or an illegal gun in the pocket screw up a playoff bound team? Yes

As I see it, your arguements are:

1 - It is bad business. I disagree. Feeling that Bort or any Admin can change the standings is bad business. Knowing that the rules you began the season with are the rules you play with thru the season is good business.

2 - It may give a team a powder puff 1st round game. I would stress the may. I would also suggest that pulling in another team that didn't make the top 8 can have several unintended consequences. What if the 9th team is a QB run team that the #1 seed can't stop that play. The #1 team would be upset, because now it seems their playoff run is skuttled by a stupid, arbitrary rule. They did enough to get the #1 seed & they get the #8 team. Those are the rules.

3 - The #9 team earned a spot. I don't really think you are making this point & I hope if you are you reconsider the foolishness of it.

Your arguements that this is a problem are NOT VALID. Therefore a FIX is not necessary.

Finally, I would suggest that you think the owner is an idiot and you want some way to punish them...but you won't really get at them by changing the rules.

JUST GET OVER IT <-- All caps so you can comprehend.
Last edited Jan 31, 2009 22:36:48
 
elfuego51
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Skoll Wolfrun
Originally posted by elfuego51

I agree that 100% gutted teams, no owner, no GM get disqualified. Any sign of human participation allows playoff contention.


Aren't the Lions CPU run yet?


Yeah and we don't make the playoffs. See everyone? This rule exists in real life and, since Bort is going to start moving the game towards realism, should be implemented............

As for the Lions crack, I'm just glad the new guy's getting promoted from a coordinator position. How could they seriously expect a D-Line coach to be able to coach a whole team, especially when his D-Line sucks more than anything on the team?

We're hopeful and hurting.
 
Fezmid
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Monster of the Midway
Wait!
Your arguements that this is a problem are NOT VALID. Therefore a FIX is not necessary..

I'm sorry -- I didn't realize you were the supreme ruler of all knowledge and that nobody should ever have a thought that isn't in line with yours because if they do, they're obviously NOT VALID.

Idiot.
 
Fezmid
offline
Link
 
Ok, after getting over what a moronic post you made, I'll address your actual "points."

Originally posted by
1. Can bad teams get into the playoffs in real life? YES
2. Can an injury or a head case or an illegal gun in the pocket screw up a playoff bound team? Yes

Ok, we're not talking about a "bad team" getting into the playoffs. We're talking about a good team disbanding at the last second. This isn't about CPU control, good team/bad team -- in essence, the franchise FOLDED. There's NOBODY running the ship. There's nobody playing the games. Yet they're going to get into the playoffs anyway?

I have no idea what you're talking about with a gun in the pocket. Like I said - we're not talking about one team not getting in. We're talking about a team that no longer has a single player, coach, or owner. They folded - and in real life, if a team folded, they obviously wouldn't be "in the playoffs."

Originally posted by
1 - It is bad business. I disagree. Feeling that Bort or any Admin can change the standings is bad business. Knowing that the rules you began the season with are the rules you play with thru the season is good business.

Again, using your logic then this gutted/sold team should NOT be relegated at the end of the season, right? The rules are that the top team goes up, the bottom team goes down. But WAIT! Bort changed that rule. Just like this one should be changed. Maybe not this season (I think it should....), but it should at least be thought about by the admins in the offseason.

Originally posted by
2 - It may give a team a powder puff 1st round game. I would stress the may. I would also suggest that pulling in another team that didn't make the top 8 can have several unintended consequences. What if the 9th team is a QB run team that the #1 seed can't stop that play. The #1 team would be upset, because now it seems their playoff run is skuttled by a stupid, arbitrary rule. They did enough to get the #1 seed & they get the #8 team. Those are the rules.

You've failed to prove why you think this would be an "arbitrary" rule. How is it different than the relegation rule? If they were good enough to get into the playoffs, then a new owner should put up with being in the division next season, right?

I also laughed when you said, "stress the may." Yeah, a CPU team is going to beat a playoff team. Whatever, dude.

Originally posted by
I hope if you are you reconsider the foolishness of it.

And this is the most offensive part and why I called you an idiot. Are you incapable of discussing your points (HA!) without thinking you are the be-all, end-all of righteousness? Again, I say: Idiot.

This isn't entirely related, but does go to the heart of the "arbitrary" comment you made:
http://news.cincinnati.com/article/20090131/BIZ01/901310335/1001/Biz

Why did the government change the IRA rules? It's very arbitrary, right? The rule was that you HAD to take an IRA withdrawl at 70.5 years of age -- but wait, that'd be kinda dumb to require it right now due to the economy, so the rule was changed.
Last edited Feb 1, 2009 07:08:51
 
Outlaw Dogs
offline
Link
 
I would be embarrassed to make the playoffs solely based on a CPU not being able to make the playoffs.
 
Guppy, Inc
offline
Link
 
no team should be handed a playoff spot that they did not earn. The big issue here is that a good team was allowed to go bellyup after the start of the season.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.