I'm on board with this, I think it would add the actual realism "everyone" has been looking for since season one
Forum > Suggestions > Player Results Affected by Size
Staz
offline
offline
Originally posted by Diamonddog
Yeah, I sort of agree, but you have to have something that allows a 320 lb D-lineman to knock the stuffing out of a quick player when he does get ahold of him...
Strength, blocking. If you're pumping points into speed/agility, chances are your strength is going to be much lower than the player who focuses purely on that. This is the reason a "high speed/agility" defensive line isn't seen very often in football. Strong OLs just take them out of the game. Now, more speed/agility is needed on the OL when you're a predominantly passing offense (a la Texas Tech) or a finesse team (a la Indianapolis Colts). Strength will be more important the next few seasons, and this would help encourage that.
Originally posted by Skoll Wolfrun
Or Bort just went with his gut & allow people putting 100 Speed on an O-lineman to believe they have 100 Speed and not the actual 80 (or whatever) Cap he set.
Chances are he wouldn't pull something like that. It'd take more coding to add 'per player' caps than it would be to just add weight into overall "every position" calculations during the sims
Yeah, I sort of agree, but you have to have something that allows a 320 lb D-lineman to knock the stuffing out of a quick player when he does get ahold of him...
Strength, blocking. If you're pumping points into speed/agility, chances are your strength is going to be much lower than the player who focuses purely on that. This is the reason a "high speed/agility" defensive line isn't seen very often in football. Strong OLs just take them out of the game. Now, more speed/agility is needed on the OL when you're a predominantly passing offense (a la Texas Tech) or a finesse team (a la Indianapolis Colts). Strength will be more important the next few seasons, and this would help encourage that.
Originally posted by Skoll Wolfrun
Or Bort just went with his gut & allow people putting 100 Speed on an O-lineman to believe they have 100 Speed and not the actual 80 (or whatever) Cap he set.
Chances are he wouldn't pull something like that. It'd take more coding to add 'per player' caps than it would be to just add weight into overall "every position" calculations during the sims
ThaOutlaw
offline
offline
Originally posted by jared
I'm on board with this, I think it would add the actual realism "everyone" has been looking for since season one
Eh if it's not one thing it's another, I'm a firm believer that 100 speed should be a 100 speed....just needs to be harder to obtain.
I'm on board with this, I think it would add the actual realism "everyone" has been looking for since season one
Eh if it's not one thing it's another, I'm a firm believer that 100 speed should be a 100 speed....just needs to be harder to obtain.
happylittletrees
offline
offline
I agree with you, and this would be a way of achieving it, it all depends on how you look at it. is it really that different from having position based attribute caps? not really this just acts in a more 'natural' way
Staz
offline
offline
And much easier to code. Plus, a 280lb OT should be faster and more mobile than a 350lb OT 

Last edited Jan 30, 2009 22:17:59
dmfa41
offline
offline
Originally posted by Staz
I believe Bort has already knocked down the "caps" for different positions. That, and I think just adding weight into an equation would be a lot more simple, and universal, than singling out positions.
This is true. He has stated (quote available in the "Character Depth" thread in Epic Suggestions, I [i[think) that he prefers an absolute adjustment of the statistic, e.g. +/- 3, as opposed to changing soft-caps. I would move that it be based on a multiple of the value's distance from the mean of all weights, e.g. if μ = 240 and σ = 20, then all players between 220-260 would receive no adjustment, those 200-220 and 260-280 would receive slightly greater. It could also be done in an absolute fashion instead of creating discrete classes.
I believe Bort has already knocked down the "caps" for different positions. That, and I think just adding weight into an equation would be a lot more simple, and universal, than singling out positions.
This is true. He has stated (quote available in the "Character Depth" thread in Epic Suggestions, I [i[think) that he prefers an absolute adjustment of the statistic, e.g. +/- 3, as opposed to changing soft-caps. I would move that it be based on a multiple of the value's distance from the mean of all weights, e.g. if μ = 240 and σ = 20, then all players between 220-260 would receive no adjustment, those 200-220 and 260-280 would receive slightly greater. It could also be done in an absolute fashion instead of creating discrete classes.
Loganrobert85
offline
offline
i'm going to have to agree... the linebackers who can catch up to WR's is pretty ridiculous no matter how many levels they have up on the guy...
dmfa41
offline
offline
Suggestion: Penalty/bonus = 2 * ( w - μ ) / σ where w = weight, μ = the mean of all weights, σ = standard deviation
Last edited Jan 31, 2009 12:35:35
You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.





























