User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > USA AAA Leagues > USA AAA #2 > Week 13 Predictions by WiSeIVIaN
Page:
 
thunderdoozer
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by islander1
Originally posted by thunderdoozer

Originally posted by WiSeIVIaN


The Nighthawks on the other hand have fell from greatness, and are a disgusting 0-5 against winning teams this season.


1-5. We beat the Slashers.

But, yeah, we suck.


WTF?
http://goallineblitz.com/game/game.pl?game_id=289221


Seriously, our GMs suck.

I don't even have the time to find exploit plays anymore.
 
islander1
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by whodey08
Originally posted by Dustin Diamond

Originally posted by Spirer


One thing that Bort could implement that might make the game better is maybe give defense a bonus to reading a play that keeps getting repeated. Something like a tiny bonus that grows to be significant if they use it a lot.

It would be very easy to do, just create a counter for the plays being called and then apply a VSN bonus to reading play based on the number of times that play has been called.

It would void or make the single play games a lot harder, which would be a good thing. It also does complete sense, since that's what would happen in real life. It is a game and we all want to win, but still...


I don't like it. If you find a hole in another teams defense you should be able to exploit it as many times as you can. this is a video game, not real life football.


They took a poll though and it was overwhelmingly in favor of making the game as realistic as possible. So it should be implemented!! Even though this game is not even close to being realistic when defenses cant stop passes or runs or get sacks or get fumbles or get penalties....lol


This. If you (not you whodey) want a video game, go pick up Madden. This is not a 'video game'.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by islander1
Originally posted by whodey08

Originally posted by Dustin Diamond


Originally posted by Spirer



One thing that Bort could implement that might make the game better is maybe give defense a bonus to reading a play that keeps getting repeated. Something like a tiny bonus that grows to be significant if they use it a lot.

It would be very easy to do, just create a counter for the plays being called and then apply a VSN bonus to reading play based on the number of times that play has been called.

It would void or make the single play games a lot harder, which would be a good thing. It also does complete sense, since that's what would happen in real life. It is a game and we all want to win, but still...


I don't like it. If you find a hole in another teams defense you should be able to exploit it as many times as you can. this is a video game, not real life football.


They took a poll though and it was overwhelmingly in favor of making the game as realistic as possible. So it should be implemented!! Even though this game is not even close to being realistic when defenses cant stop passes or runs or get sacks or get fumbles or get penalties....lol


This. If you (not you whodey) want a video game, go pick up Madden. This is not a 'video game'.


It's a strategy RPG, if you want real football hit the weight room. Like it or not it's a game. Defensive recognition is a cop out. Players with high vision already recognize plays earlier than those with low vision, if you aren't actively scouting, looking for holes in other teams D you aren't doing your due diligence. A team that is willing to throw all of their eggs in one basket should not be punished for gambling. To me it looks like more & more people just want this game to have the higher leveled team win. Strategy is king & that's what makes the game great, you can't go in & change things once the game starts. If you aren't ready to stop something & the other team exploits it great, that's what this game is all about. PLANNING.

 
islander1
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Dustin Diamond
Originally posted by islander1

Originally posted by whodey08


Originally posted by Dustin Diamond



Originally posted by Spirer




One thing that Bort could implement that might make the game better is maybe give defense a bonus to reading a play that keeps getting repeated. Something like a tiny bonus that grows to be significant if they use it a lot.

It would be very easy to do, just create a counter for the plays being called and then apply a VSN bonus to reading play based on the number of times that play has been called.

It would void or make the single play games a lot harder, which would be a good thing. It also does complete sense, since that's what would happen in real life. It is a game and we all want to win, but still...


I don't like it. If you find a hole in another teams defense you should be able to exploit it as many times as you can. this is a video game, not real life football.


They took a poll though and it was overwhelmingly in favor of making the game as realistic as possible. So it should be implemented!! Even though this game is not even close to being realistic when defenses cant stop passes or runs or get sacks or get fumbles or get penalties....lol


This. If you (not you whodey) want a video game, go pick up Madden. This is not a 'video game'.


It's a strategy RPG, if you want real football hit the weight room. Like it or not it's a game. Defensive recognition is a cop out. Players with high vision already recognize plays earlier than those with low vision, if you aren't actively scouting, looking for holes in other teams D you aren't doing your due diligence. A team that is willing to throw all of their eggs in one basket should not be punished for gambling. To me it looks like more & more people just want this game to have the higher leveled team win. Strategy is king & that's what makes the game great, you can't go in & change things once the game starts. If you aren't ready to stop something & the other team exploits it great, that's what this game is all about. PLANNING.



Take a look at the performance of NY-CA's defense. Don't, for a minute, pretend to think I don't know what the fuck I am doing defensively.

There is no strategy in running the same play over and over again, nor is there anything resembling realism. You want strategy? Learn how to integrate more plays over the course of the game then just one or two runs.

All I want is a more realistic sim. That's what the vast majority of people voted for.

PS: There is strategy in actual football as well. As well as adjustments during the game

Go back to running the same play 50 times on Madden.
 
panther17
offline
Link
 
Savedbythebell is actually on the Royals. Not the team that has been doing it.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by islander1
Originally posted by Dustin Diamond

Originally posted by islander1


Originally posted by whodey08



Originally posted by Dustin Diamond




Originally posted by Spirer





One thing that Bort could implement that might make the game better is maybe give defense a bonus to reading a play that keeps getting repeated. Something like a tiny bonus that grows to be significant if they use it a lot.

It would be very easy to do, just create a counter for the plays being called and then apply a VSN bonus to reading play based on the number of times that play has been called.

It would void or make the single play games a lot harder, which would be a good thing. It also does complete sense, since that's what would happen in real life. It is a game and we all want to win, but still...


I don't like it. If you find a hole in another teams defense you should be able to exploit it as many times as you can. this is a video game, not real life football.


They took a poll though and it was overwhelmingly in favor of making the game as realistic as possible. So it should be implemented!! Even though this game is not even close to being realistic when defenses cant stop passes or runs or get sacks or get fumbles or get penalties....lol


This. If you (not you whodey) want a video game, go pick up Madden. This is not a 'video game'.


It's a strategy RPG, if you want real football hit the weight room. Like it or not it's a game. Defensive recognition is a cop out. Players with high vision already recognize plays earlier than those with low vision, if you aren't actively scouting, looking for holes in other teams D you aren't doing your due diligence. A team that is willing to throw all of their eggs in one basket should not be punished for gambling. To me it looks like more & more people just want this game to have the higher leveled team win. Strategy is king & that's what makes the game great, you can't go in & change things once the game starts. If you aren't ready to stop something & the other team exploits it great, that's what this game is all about. PLANNING.



Take a look at the performance of NY-CA's defense. Don't, for a minute, pretend to think I don't know what the fuck I am doing defensively.

There is no strategy in running the same play over and over again, nor is there anything resembling realism. You want strategy? Learn how to integrate more plays over the course of the game then just one or two runs.

All I want is a more realistic sim. That's what the vast majority of people voted for.

PS: There is strategy in actual football as well. As well as adjustments during the game

Go back to running the same play 50 times on Madden.


Look, I don't do it with my offense or in Madden, which BTW I haven't played since NFL 2K5 came out so stop with the Madden BS. I don't give a shit about your defense either. All I am saying is that there are plenty of ways to play the game. The HHW have risen to be one of the top teams in GLB just by running it down other teams throats, I played against them when they were in BBB in season 2, guess what, their offense hasn't changed a lot. Should they be punished because they do something better than anyone else? The whole point of this game is to set your tactics, then await the roll of the dice, it's Dungeons & Dragons on a football field. I just don't think there should be diminishing returns for taking advantage of a weakness, that said, the strategy can completely backfire, isn't that punishment enough?
 
Reggie Smash
offline
Link
 
Good debate. Bort does already have a feature where the defense adjusts to what you're doing - it's called "Basic AI" and you can set the adjustment percentage yourself. But if you want to take matters into your own hands, then you risk getting played by teams that run one or two plays all game long. That's just the state of the game.

Though I guess Bort could put an extra something into the advanced AI programming thing... like a subset where it says "if play X comprises more than Y% of the playcalls out of formation Z, then change the defensive playcall to A" (sorry, ran out of consecutive variables). But that'd probably be making this game way too complicated for the average "hey this game's getting way too complicated" GLBer, so I doubt the idea would ever get off the ground.
Last edited Jan 27, 2009 21:39:57
 
stonecold
offline
Link
 
oops
Last edited Jan 27, 2009 22:12:54
 
stonecold
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Dustin Diamond
Originally posted by islander1

Originally posted by Dustin Diamond


Originally posted by islander1



Originally posted by whodey08




Originally posted by Dustin Diamond




Originally posted by Spirer






One thing that Bort could implement that might make the game better is maybe give defense a bonus to reading a play that keeps getting repeated. Something like a tiny bonus that grows to be significant if they use it a lot.

It would be very easy to do, just create a counter for the plays being called and then apply a VSN bonus to reading play based on the number of times that play has been called.

It would void or make the single play games a lot harder, which would be a good thing. It also does complete sense, since that's what would happen in real life. It is a game and we all want to win, but still...


I don't like it. If you find a hole in another teams defense you should be able to exploit it as many times as you can. this is a video game, not real life football.


They took a poll though and it was overwhelmingly in favor of making the game as realistic as possible. So it should be implemented!! Even though this game is not even close to being realistic when defenses cant stop passes or runs or get sacks or get fumbles or get penalties....lol


This. If you (not you whodey) want a video game, go pick up Madden. This is not a 'video game'.


It's a strategy RPG, if you want real football hit the weight room. Like it or not it's a game. Defensive recognition is a cop out. Players with high vision already recognize plays earlier than those with low vision, if you aren't actively scouting, looking for holes in other teams D you aren't doing your due diligence. A team that is willing to throw all of their eggs in one basket should not be punished for gambling. To me it looks like more & more people just want this game to have the higher leveled team win. Strategy is king & that's what makes the game great, you can't go in & change things once the game starts. If you aren't ready to stop something & the other team exploits it great, that's what this game is all about. PLANNING.



Take a look at the performance of NY-CA's defense. Don't, for a minute, pretend to think I don't know what the fuck I am doing defensively.

There is no strategy in running the same play over and over again, nor is there anything resembling realism. You want strategy? Learn how to integrate more plays over the course of the game then just one or two runs.

All I want is a more realistic sim. That's what the vast majority of people voted for.

PS: There is strategy in actual football as well. As well as adjustments during the game

Go back to running the same play 50 times on Madden.


Look, I don't do it with my offense or in Madden, which BTW I haven't played since NFL 2K5 came out so stop with the Madden BS. I don't give a shit about your defense either. All I am saying is that there are plenty of ways to play the game. The HHW have risen to be one of the top teams in GLB just by running it down other teams throats, I played against them when they were in BBB in season 2, guess what, their offense hasn't changed a lot. Should they be punished because they do something better than anyone else? The whole point of this game is to set your tactics, then await the roll of the dice, it's Dungeons & Dragons on a football field. I just don't think there should be diminishing returns for taking advantage of a weakness, that said, the strategy can completely backfire, isn't that punishment enough?



I do it on NCAA football...Option right, option left. Heck, the Wolverines won the championship 5 years in a row, must be working.
 
Spirer
offline
Link
 
Teams with decent DCs will change their defense every game to match what they believe are the strengths of the opponents offense. This has to do with players and depth charts, plays they use a lot, etc.

Now imagine this: I test a few plays in scrimmages and select 10 plays that I think work well for my team. Then I create 10 different game plans where I use 1 single play, regardless of what is happening. Before each game I go to my 10 offense plans, remove the ones that won't be suited against this team and then decide randomly which one I'll use.

This means that your opponents have no idea what play you are going to call and no way to adjust their defense accordingly. So the game becomes a shot in the dark for BOTH teams. If you are lucky their defense will be subpar against your play and you will run the same play to exhaustion with good chances of a win. If you are unlucky you might be going against a defensive setting that is good against the play and you will likely lose the game.

And no, I haven't submitted what I proposed here as a suggestion. If one of you wants to do it, go ahead, I'll vote on it
 
kurieg
offline
Link
 
IMO -
Islander's wrong in that nobody should be picked on for using what works in a game. Everyone should be playing to win the game as it is - not as how some people envision it should be. Let the argument on that move to the Suggestion forum imo.

Dustin's wrong - GLB should have more strategic depth and be less rewarding to one-trick ponies. Fuck them.



Most of the supposed one trick pony teams really aren't, though. They generally have at least one or two other outlets to relieve pressure on their main play(s).
Last edited Jan 28, 2009 10:12:42
 
islander1
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Reggie Smash
Good debate. Bort does already have a feature where the defense adjusts to what you're doing - it's called "Basic AI" and you can set the adjustment percentage yourself. But if you want to take matters into your own hands, then you risk getting played by teams that run one or two plays all game long. That's just the state of the game.

Though I guess Bort could put an extra something into the advanced AI programming thing... like a subset where it says "if play X comprises more than Y% of the playcalls out of formation Z, then change the defensive playcall to A" (sorry, ran out of consecutive variables). But that'd probably be making this game way too complicated for the average "hey this game's getting way too complicated" GLBer, so I doubt the idea would ever get off the ground.


The problem with auto adjust is it doesn't affect the reaction time towards a play - it completely screws up your base defense(AI) with alterations in the formation itself and then looks to see if that helps.

Moreover, auto adjust isn't formation base driven, it's simply 'overall'. If it were formation driven it'd be a touch more useful.

Kurieg - I will never support or intentionally use a GLB exploit to 'win'. Much less run the same play repeatedly game in and out.
Last edited Jan 28, 2009 12:58:10
 
kurieg
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by islander1
Kurieg - I will never support or intentionally use a GLB exploit to 'win'. Much less run the same play repeatedly game in and out.


It's not an exploit. You don't define what is and is not an exploit in this game. Bort does.
 
WiSeIVIaN
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by kurieg
Originally posted by islander1

Kurieg - I will never support or intentionally use a GLB exploit to 'win'. Much less run the same play repeatedly game in and out.


It's not an exploit. You don't define what is and is not an exploit in this game. Bort does.


That is incorrect. We all have our own opinions of what is or is not an exploit. Just because bort hasn't fixed something yet, doesn't mean that there isn't an exploit that should be fixed, nor does it mean that people can not frown upon others exploiting things that they define as exploits.

For instance, its not against the rules for an owner to sign 150 players then start CPU guys over all of them, while trapping them in their contracts and not reading their PMs. Just because Bort has not gotten around to make a rule to change in coding to prevent this, does not mean that said owner is not out of line. As such, the only viable reaction of the community is to look down on said action to discourage it as much as possible, in the interests of the game.

The "evil" owner isn't breaking the rules, nor is the team that uses a very limited number of plays far too often. But both are exercising actions which are outside the spirit of the game and which most people would agree are bad for GLB, whether it be the owner exploiting how much control owners are given and the lack of player rights in GLB, or the team exploiting the relatively simple sim engine that doesn't allow players to see that a play which was ran 45 times straight will be ran a 46th time. Both actions are exploits, regardless of whether they are possible in GLB...
 
23yrwej
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Mofo
Originally posted by Spirer

One thing that Bort could implement that might make the game better is maybe give defense a bonus to reading a play that keeps getting repeated. Something like a tiny bonus that grows to be significant if they use it a lot.

It would be very easy to do, just create a counter for the plays being called and then apply a VSN bonus to reading play based on the number of times that play has been called.

It would void or make the single play games a lot harder, which would be a good thing. It also does complete sense, since that's what would happen in real life. It is a game and we all want to win, but still...


Did you put this in suggestions yet? I like it


Don't bother. I suggested this 2 times last season. I suggested it a 2nd time because the first time it was locked for people flaming. The 2nd time, no one disagreed with it at all, tons of people said epic it. The mods did nothing.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.