User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Goal Line Blitz > Has anybody tried simply demoralizing powerbacks this year?
Page:
 
HydrOshocK
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Blamo
100 speed isn't that hard to hit, IMO. My level 42 is sitting at a nice 99 speed right now. Confidence is hardly something I'd call "vital", but I've still got it at about 48... and have my vision near 60 and agility near 68. Stamina is at 40, too. My strength and tackling are both below where you would like them, but my LB has less missed tackles than yours, so apparently I did something right I've also got 40+ jumping, so I could have probably had my strength and tackling numbers closer to where you'd like them if I had chosen to sacrifice that.


And on newer players, hitting 100 speed won't even be hard IMO. My level 17 should be a little above 100 speed at level 40 even if I never put another point into it, and my level 9 will probably reach that plateau a little later... but he'll probably be sitting close to 75-80 agility. Regardless, I think having two super fast guys on the outside, and one decently fast but strong LB in the middle really covers almost all of your bases. Your outside guys can stop an elusive/speedy back from anywhere he's going to run, they're useful in pass coverage, they're adequate pass rushers, they'll fill holes in the middle and they can run down possession receivers. Meanwhile your MLB should be able to take care of most of the runs in the middle, but still be fast enough to clean up any of your OLBs mistakes. If you have a good SS, you're even better off.


tell you what friend, out of the spirit of competition if you want to send us a friendly challenge we'll see if your LB can stop our HB. He's not a power back so your speed LB should match up well. No planning is required other than that we will run our bread and butter run plays and you try to contain or stop them without scheming anything specific. If you succeed then I'll give you props for doing so and take notes for future build ideas and strategy.
 
HydrOshocK
offline
Link
 
PM me if you're interested....I've gotta crash.

later
 
Link
 
I called my girlfriend a PowerBack, and she demoralized me pretty quickly. For what it's worth.
 
Apallyon
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Brandon Farrell
I called my girlfriend a PowerBack, and she demoralized me pretty quickly. For what it's worth.


LMAO.. now thats funny...

as for the LBs... blah they are worthless I stopped counting how many times the opposing back got MONSTER HIT today... and no result.... just another play.....
 
wallysmith
offline
Link
 
Quoted from the Motivational Speaker thread I posted earlier:

Originally posted by Arles

I have a power back and our punter has Motivational. We do a back rotation so my power guy is on the sidelines half the plays. Last season, my back had 7 fumbles in 400 carries. This season, he's had 0 fumbles in 185 rushes in the same league against almost identical competition. Now, his carrying and cover up is the same, but his strength/power thru is a little higher. But, all the defenders he faces (in the same league as last season) have also leveled and improved their builds.


Arles' powerback in Canada AA3:
http://goallineblitz.com/game/player.pl?player_id=331817
Key stats:
Season 6: 404 carries, 7 fumbles, 119 brtk, 16 games
Season 7: 210 carries, 0 fumbles, 115 brtk, 8 games

Top powerback in my MLB's league (W. Europe AAA3):
http://goallineblitz.com/game/player.pl?player_id=277178
Key stats:
Season 6: 248 caries, 4 fumbles, 115 brtk, 16 games
Season 7: 180 carries, 0 fumbles, 139 brtk, 8 games

Top powerback in random league (Ocea AA1):
http://goallineblitz.com/game/player.pl?player_id=253809
Key stats:
Season 6: 423 carries, 9 fumbles, 197 brtk, 16 games
Season 7: 143 carries, 1 fumble, 128 brtk, 8 games

Top powerback in random A league (E. Europe A1):
http://goallineblitz.com/game/player.pl?player_id=63566
Key stats:
Season 6: 323 carries, 7 fumbles, 122 brtk, 16 games
Season 7: 178 carries, 1 fumble, 40 brtk, 8 games

Top powerback in random pro league (S. America Pro):
http://goallineblitz.com/game/player.pl?player_id=33583
Key stats:
Season 6: 506 carries, 8 fumbles, 246 brtk, 16 games
Season 7: 274 carries, 0 fumbles, 193 brtk, 8 games

Looks like Arles is on to something. There may be several reasons why powerbacks are so powerful this season, but it's quite possible that it's not isolated to the tweaks made to required strength/tackling to take them down. In all of the powerbacks above, there are clear trends: far less fumbles and much higher broken tackles in less games. Since we know that continued morale hits makes ballcarriers more prone to fumbling, and since there looks to be less forced fumbles in general this season, then it would be a reasonable assumption to assume that MORALE is playing a large factor in the rise of the powerback. On top of preventing fumbles, the increased morale is also aiding the powerbacks in making their broken tackle rolls as well.

Motivational Speaker is the only thing I can think of that would help restore or accelerate morale regeneration, especially in the way it's implemented. Even though we don't know any numbers involving morale, we can figure out how often MS fires and who it affects. Plus, every team has the perfect MS: their punter, who has a chance to activate MS roughly 90 times a game with 10 VA points spent in it. This ends up benefiting the offense far more than the defense, since morale hits to the defense are spread throughout all the players, whereas morale hits to the offense are severely focused on the ballcarriers.

The next logical question is: why don't elusive backs get this same boost? This is just a hunch, but I believe that every time a HB is contacted, it's a morale hit, even if they don't go down. Since elusives are easier to take down, they only get the morale hit for the actual tackle, whereas powerbacks get the morale hits for all the attempted (but failed) tackles before the final tackle.

If this is all true, then Motivational Speaker definitely needs to get nerfed. Someone suggested in another forum that maybe it should be limited to the player with the lowest morale and about 3-8 other random players; this sounds like a great idea. In a sim sense, it would be the motivational speaker trying to pump up the low morale player, plus all the other players sitting next to him on the bench but not EVERYONE on the sideline. Also, it should be reduced to activate maybe every other or every third play; this would in effect be the punter watching the game himself, instead of always giving pep talks.
 
Blamo
offline
Link
 
If this is the case, we need to make some sort of prerequisite for it that K/P would have a hard time reaching, or otherwise nerf it. I can understand RB broken tackles being attributed to all the RB VAs they got on top of spending a year getting stronger as opposed to defenses primarily getting tackles... but the fumbles are what are really sticking out to me right now, and I think morale is probably the most likely factor.

If Bort stumbles upon this thread, it'd be GREAT if he could run some tests with and without motivational speaker to see how much of an effect it might be having on powerbacks... because that would be a really easy fix to a ton of the whining that we've exhibited this season.

Hell, while we're at it... I'd like to see if teams without motivational speaker catch less deflected passes and allow more sacks to DEs. After all, for a long time Bort DID say that confidence was the most underrated attribute, and we do know that confidence is directly tied to morale... So it would make sense that a bunch of these things could be tied to all offensive players having near 100 morale at all times, right?
Last edited Jan 18, 2009 05:25:48
 
hambone77us
offline
Link
 
i tried mooning one of the backs before to take away thier confidence will it didnt work and if anything should have it should have been that so i dont think you can demorilize them .
 
wallysmith
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Blamo
If this is the case, we need to make some sort of prerequisite for it that K/P would have a hard time reaching, or otherwise nerf it.


I'm not sure if this will be entirely feasible, because then it would mean another potential VA point reset since many K/P that had it before will not be able to access it now (and would be unbalanced if they kept it, leaving younger K/P screaming "imbalance!").

I think just limiting the number of times it fires and the number of players it affects should be a solid workaround with how it is now. It would still be a skill that every team needs to invest in, but it won't be quite as unbalancing.

Also, another thing that makes MS so unbalancing... Pretty much all of the other VA's modify or enhance some other function that is already programmed into the game, except for MS. In GLB, this is the only skill that improves morale on a team-wide basis.

 
Marvel
offline
Link
 
I think demoralizing really helps my LB it seems when i hit them with 2 Monster Tackles it seems like the RB isn't as good anymore in the game till he's sub-ed out. Because RB's dont have high Confidence well some don't.


-Marvel
 
Hukton Vioxx
offline
Link
 
Tried it and failed completely.
 
Arles
offline
Link
 
Yeah, and to backup WallySmith's point, our punter on the AA team with my powerback has close to 10 Motivational speaker.
 
fbjiii
offline
Link
 
When thinking about the vast changes this season its hard to ignore VP's. Clearly, strength was an undervalued stat the last few seasons and now powerbacks are .. err back.

I wonder if the real problem is the complete speed approach taken by most defenses the last few seasons. I wonder what % of LB's have used all of their VP in quick or track star. If its an incredibly high percent it would seem a simple answer why the balance has swung so much to powerbacks. Every LB out there and even most safeties are built to pursue and take down elusive backs.
 
Marvel
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by fbjiii
When thinking about the vast changes this season its hard to ignore VP's. Clearly, strength was an undervalued stat the last few seasons and now powerbacks are .. err back.

I wonder if the real problem is the complete speed approach taken by most defenses the last few seasons. I wonder what % of LB's have used all of their VP in quick or track star. If its an incredibly high percent it would seem a simple answer why the balance has swung so much to powerbacks. Every LB out there and even most safeties are built to pursue and take down elusive backs.


This is True To Many GLB LB's try to be CB for some reason i saw one LB's build that was a perfect example.........

He Had 33 strength, 62 Speed, 51 Agility, and 37 Tackling. Lvl 24

I was disgusted.
 
Arles
offline
Link
 
One major problem is that no one has a clue on what causes fumbles. I have a 9 monster hit, 60 strength, 55 tackling (with VAs in power tackling) LB who has had 0 forced fumbles last season. Then, we had a OLB with 90ish speed, 50ish strength, 50ish tackling and 3 monster hit force 7! last season.

This season it doesn't matter as we have yet to force a fumble in 8 games. Heck, we've only fumbled twice ourselves (and don't have huge carrying/cover up values).
 
nixa37
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Marvel
Originally posted by fbjiii

When thinking about the vast changes this season its hard to ignore VP's. Clearly, strength was an undervalued stat the last few seasons and now powerbacks are .. err back.

I wonder if the real problem is the complete speed approach taken by most defenses the last few seasons. I wonder what % of LB's have used all of their VP in quick or track star. If its an incredibly high percent it would seem a simple answer why the balance has swung so much to powerbacks. Every LB out there and even most safeties are built to pursue and take down elusive backs.


This is True To Many GLB LB's try to be CB for some reason i saw one LB's build that was a perfect example.........

He Had 33 strength, 62 Speed, 51 Agility, and 37 Tackling. Lvl 24

I was disgusted.


Huh? That's really not all that bad. Level 24 is still pretty low and he should be around 50 in both tackling and strength by level 29 if he knows what he's doing. Clearly he's not a candidate to be a run stuffing MLB, but to call that build disgusting strikes be as a bit ignorant.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.