User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Suggestions > ReProgram the Simulation - Redo The Game
Page:
 
ThaOutlaw
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by GG
It took him like no time at all to overhaul the game to incorporate VAs....which was one of the very worst implementations ever. But he did that, he overhauled the game to include that. So he can overhaul the game to remove that, or to re-do it all. Especially because a lot of the stuff he always seems to be interested in is the worst thing for the game, bringing in only more and more layers of disparity to pile on top of existing disparities.

It's like any idea of parity he is literally totally against implementing.


I liked the VA's abilities, that's a good implementation to me.

Football isn't all about parity, it's about putting together a good team. You find players that bring parity.

What I have a problem with is the sim.

Football is about changing tactics to fit your players, you find a team that you know has weaknesses but will have strengths as well.

Football isn't about bringing parity, it's about using what you've got to exploit your opponents weaknesses. Right now the sim is too...wacky...to allow us to know really how to use strengths besides to be an exploiter.
 
TheInfinity
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by mandyross
Originally posted by TheInfinity

Originally posted by mandyross


Are you a programmer?


I dabble, but not on the level of this game. I'm also not Bort. But from my understanding he is extremely skilled at what he does and that's what I'm basing the time frame off of.

Say 42 Days, 6 weeks. So minus 12 days for weekends. That's 28 days. 8 Hour work day makes it 224 work hours. And that's if he takes Saturday and Sunday as personal days, which he doesn't have to do but I assume he is human and needs/likes rest.


It seems an awful tight schedule to me. And a huge risk of his current base of customers.

Although I do totally agree with your individual points as to which changes should be good.


Well he wouldn't be stopping the game to do this. It'd be done on a separate computer (like all of his updates are) while the game continues to run. He'd basically stop making things for us and start working on the Season 8 Overhaul. So, there wouldn't be a mass quitting of the game during down time.

And it is a bit of a tight schedule, 8 hours a day of programming can be hell, but considering this is the job he chose to work to make his living, 40 hours a week is reasonable. I don't expect 50-70 hours a week, but hey, if it means the difference between patch-work fix after patch-work fix and a new shiny coherent solid system.. then maybe he'll have to pull those hours on a couple weeks.
 
Nixx
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by GG
It took him like no time at all to overhaul the game to incorporate VAs...


How do you know that? The 'prestige attributes' thread was started on August 26th, and VAs came out on December 27th. So up to 4 months is 'no time at all'?

Of course I'm not saying he spent 4 months working on just VAs, that's as ridiculous as saying he spent 'no time at all' on them.
 
GG
offline
Link
 
JDaniels...

Disparity in real football is one thing, but parity (or working more towards parity) in a computer game with paying customers is a totally different thing, and needs to be the centerpiece of any programming towards the game. Otherwise you just see more and more people throw their hands up and walk away.

And VAs is the worst idea ever. I was opposed to it from the beginning and expressed my complaints, some agreed, most didnt. But VAs are bad because they just further create more gap between teams formally closer together. So for instance, a level 40 team vs a level 38 team, mightve been like 24-10 but is now 40-3 because of how CERTAIN cookie-cutter VAs and SAs and adv EQT, that you compile WITH a certain cookie-cutter "extreme" build method will yield massively great results. So everyone HAS TO build the same way to stay competitive. ANd many dont, and there are thousands of leagues of teams that have differences in builds, small SP differences, and small VA differences, but all compiled together has made playing the game itself impossible to enjoy now.

You: 1) trim your playbook down to those choice 5 plays, 2) use the same exact defensive AI settings (namely SS/RLB blitz, cover 1, all man, 335, etc), 3) build players EXACTLY "this" way, and thats the game. Nothing outside of all that can or will work, in fact, it wont even create any competitiveness. Pointless to run weakside plays. Pointless to NOT hold back your FB/RB to pass protect, pointless to use zone, pointless to build players either a little or a lot differently etc.
Last edited Jan 11, 2009 23:51:47
 
GG
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Nixx
Originally posted by GG

It took him like no time at all to overhaul the game to incorporate VAs...


How do you know that? The 'prestige attributes' thread was started on August 26th, and VAs came out on December 27th. So up to 4 months is 'no time at all'?

Of course I'm not saying he spent 4 months working on just VAs, that's as ridiculous as saying he spent 'no time at all' on them.


The idea of VAs came up between end of season 5/beginning of season 6. Bort didnt start COLLATING the VA idea until season 6 had started. Between season 6 and season 7 is about 40 days. It took Bort less than an actual month of programming to incorporate it INTO the code.
Last edited Jan 11, 2009 23:55:22
 
ThaOutlaw
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by GG
JDaniels...

Disparity in real football is one thing, but parity (or working more towards parity) in a computer game with paying customers is a totally different thing, and needs to be the centerpiece of any programming towards the game. Otherwise you just see more and more people throw their hands up and walk away.

(Not worried about Va's)

You: 1) trim your playbook down to those choice 5 plays, 2) use the same exact defensive AI settings (namely SS/RLB blitz, cover 1, all man, 335, etc), 3) build players EXACTLY "this" way, and thats the game. Nothing outside of all that can or will work, in fact, it wont even create any competitiveness. Pointless to run weakside plays. Pointless to NOT hold back your FB/RB to pass protect, pointless to use zone, pointless to build players either a little or a lot differently etc.


People want this game to be like real life. Therefore GLB=Disparity. That's ok. I think most people should own a team imo, that's the only way you get the full experience of GLB. That is another discussion, also some people shouldn't be allowed to own a team..

I agree that there is no reason to build players differently, and no reason to actually plan and scout anymore. I think that all could be fixed with a re-build of the sim. Not an extreme parity fixer.

 
GG
offline
Link
 

And...VAs were brought in PURELY to appease some whining vet alpha agents who were "bored that i dont have stuff to do". Without thinking about the consequences of what VAs will/has done to the game. Or disregarding those consequences. Purely to appease some whiners and there was that "oooh, RPG element" to it. But VAs is like every other superficial thing implemented just a fast-food item. People already are bored of it. Just one more BS thing to have to click to add and then you forget about it. And another annoyance in the game, rather than something actually FUN and interactive.
 
GG
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by JDaniels127

I agree that there is no reason to build players differently, and no reason to actually plan and scout anymore. I think that all could be fixed with a re-build of the sim. Not an extreme parity fixer.



Thats the point I was making. That an overhaul is needed because there's too much BS and band-aids and disparity in the game. Not fun anymore. Games are more and more pointless. Building, and differences, and tactical differences. All gone. Just more and more cookie-cutter. Ie, an overhaul is needed. Total re-think of it all.

 
ThaOutlaw
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by GG
Originally posted by JDaniels127


I agree that there is no reason to build players differently, and no reason to actually plan and scout anymore. I think that all could be fixed with a re-build of the sim. Not an extreme parity fixer.



Thats the point I was making. That an overhaul is needed because there's too much BS and band-aids and disparity in the game. Not fun anymore. Games are more and more pointless. Building, and differences, and tactical differences. All gone. Just more and more cookie-cutter. Ie, an overhaul is needed. Total re-think of it all.



Nail, Meet Hammer.

I think a lot of people feel the same way. Too much bubble gum and shoe string holding this thing together. It's time to go in and rebuild the engine here.

The question is, will they? I wish they would..

Something tells me that I shouldn't hold my breath.
 
GG
offline
Link
 
I aint holding my breath either.
Cant say how long I will hold out either.


 
ThaOutlaw
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by GG
I aint holding my breath either.
Cant say how long I will hold out either.




Neither can I.

I really would like to see this game succeed, but some drastic measure are going to have to be taken I believe.
 
bigcurt43
offline
Link
 
and the doom and gloom of GLB has begun once again from GG and Jdaniels. thanks for bringing me down guys
 
ThaOutlaw
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by bigcurt43
and the doom and gloom of GLB has begun once again from GG and Jdaniels. thanks for bringing me down guys


I'm sorry sometimes GLB does that to me. It has such promise, I just hope it pans out.

Sometimes it frustrates me when what I can see for GLB isn't coming to be.

I think it's gonna get there though I really do.
 
GG
offline
Link
 
Really, is there even any valid debate on that from anyone? That an overhaul is not needed? It'd be ludicrous for anyone to say "no".

This game has reached a cul-de-sac. It was headed this way, and things implemented that veered it away from being more expansive and based on parity and individualization of characters and tactics, veered away down the fork instead towards disparity-driven cookie-cutter cabin fever. All the pleas ignored, ridiculed. Where it is right now in this developer-attitude of "no overhaul" has no growth, no evolution of the current game. It's can only get worse and worse or more and more what it already is.

Only way out of that is by overhauling it.
 
ThaOutlaw
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by GG
Really, is there even any valid debate on that from anyone? That an overhaul is not needed? It'd be ludicrous for anyone to say "no".

This game has reached a cul-de-sac. It was headed this way, and things implemented that veered it away from being more expansive and based on parity and individualization of characters and tactics, veered away down the fork instead towards disparity-driven cookie-cutter cabin fever. All the pleas ignored, ridiculed. Where it is right now in this developer-attitude of "no overhaul" has no growth, no evolution of the current game. It's can only get worse and worse or more and more what it already is.

Only way out of that is by overhauling it.


Agreed again, stop it or you are gonna scare me
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.