User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Suggestions > Suggestion to slow down gutting and killing teams
Page:
 
Viscount
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by jackriley
Originally posted by Viscount


Serious question: If someone on your team only owned 1 player who was a backup and since that was their first player he wasn't built very well. After playing GLB for a bit he finds out how much better his player could've been, so he asks you if his player could be released so that he can retire him, start again and to try build him much better after learning fom his original mistakes, would you release him?


Would I? Well if he's a back up, sure. I'd have 0 problem with that honestly. If it were a vital starter, the only thing i'd probably provide is a shorter contract, to give the team more time to release him.

But.. my question is.. what's that have to do with what i said and what's that have to do with Owners gutting Teams and then selling them to buy new ones.

I know you're not suggesting that everyone that guts teams, does so because all the players on the team 'inquire' for a release because they don't like their builds.


The backup part is referring to the losing teams that are at the bottom of the league not really bringing any competitiveness to the other teams.

So if a bad built player is allowed to retire and start over, why shouldn't an owner with a bad team be allowed to start over as well?

Instead of gutting a team mid season, would you rather owners only sell their team at the end of the season after going like 0-16?
Last edited Jan 10, 2009 22:23:58
 
Diamonddog
offline
Link
 
Viscount, I am saying that if you can't handle not winning every season, then maybe you shouldn't own a team.

An agent creates many players, when he does something with that player, it is 1 50th of the team.

When an owner determines that he can't go 16-0 and quits, that effects 50 players.

that is all I am saying.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by Viscount
Originally posted by bigpimpin123

Isn't there a waiting list? My suggestion would be that new potential team owners can be placed in front of previous owners.


This already happens.


I disagree with the main suggestion in this thread. There are many other reasons why owners sell their teams during the season, such as real life time constraints and then a month later find that they do have time to run a team.

The admins won't have the time to evaluate why each owner sold his or her team, so this suggestion would be punishing everyone who sells a team not just the people who deserve it.

Also, losing an entire season isn't exactly a fun GLB experience. Although an owner may be abandoning a team, they're also giving the players the opportunity to go to a better team.

Coaches who lose lot's of games in NFL get fired and eventually move to another team, why can't owners do that here?

Also, for the record, my team got promoted and and now we're losing most of our games but I won't be selling my team.



+1
This man speaks truth
 
PatsFan94
offline
Link
 
Yup I hate it when a team can't compete as well perfect example http://goallineblitz.com/game/team.pl?season=5&team_id=1576 season 5 in USA BBB #10, promoted to USA A #5. In season 6 they finished with no playoffs 9-6-1 so the gutted.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by Diamonddog
I think you shouldn't be able to own a team for a full season, after you abandon a team in the previous season.

Too many owners run teams that do quite well, and then get promoted, and then are not headed for another 13-3 season, so they give up the team 3 or 4 games in, and start a new one the following season.

Maybe if they had to sit out the next season as an owner, they might not be so eager to just throw the team on the trash heap.

(can't wait to see what kind of trolls this brings out of the woodwork)


the thing that I think people are having a problem with is selling back teams at all, if this was limited to midseason sellbacks I think it would be great, although selling back a team does suck from a competitive balance standpoint but sellbacks that are done after the season is over are way less detrimental to your league because then that team can be removed and sent down without any real penalty to the league. just mu .02
 
Diamonddog
offline
Link
 
driftinggrifter, you are one of two people that the only 20 seconds I will spend on you is to say that I will ignore you.

 
Knick
Sknickers
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Diamonddog
driftinggrifter, you are one of two people that the only 20 seconds I will spend on you is to say that I will ignore you.



ITT:E-Vengence
 
Diamonddog
offline
Link
 
Jared, I agree with you.
Let those willing to take over gutted teams some kind of chemistry grace period so they can rebuild after the quitters have left. You are correct.

let those that dont quit when the going gets tough have half a chance.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by driftinggrifter
Originally posted by Viscount

Originally posted by bigpimpin123


Isn't there a waiting list? My suggestion would be that new potential team owners can be placed in front of previous owners.


This already happens.


I disagree with the main suggestion in this thread. There are many other reasons why owners sell their teams during the season, such as real life time constraints and then a month later find that they do have time to run a team.

The admins won't have the time to evaluate why each owner sold his or her team, so this suggestion would be punishing everyone who sells a team not just the people who deserve it.

Also, losing an entire season isn't exactly a fun GLB experience. Although an owner may be abandoning a team, they're also giving the players the opportunity to go to a better team.

Coaches who lose lot's of games in NFL get fired and eventually move to another team, why can't owners do that here?

Also, for the record, my team got promoted and and now we're losing most of our games but I won't be selling my team.



+1
This man speaks truth


No, he doesn't. This is nothing more than a "poor me" excuse for owners who fail at their jobs.

Owners have EVERY RESOURCE someone could need for recruiting. I'm not saying recruiting is easy, but you gotta work hard at it. You have the forums, Market place, trade blocks.

There isn't any real reason someone can't put together a competitive team over a period of time, Unless... In reality, that team is nothing more than a farm team, which personally, I think should be barred from usage but that's another story for another day.

If an owner, with all the resources at his finger tips, sells their team, and i'm basing this version of my opinion, on what someone else said which makes alot of sense.

They should not be allowed to be put back on the waiting list for a minimum of 1 season. WIthout any discussion. They should have to wait a FULL SEASON, personally, with the # of people wanting teams who've never been owners, I think they should have to wait TWO full seasons, before they can attempt to get another team.

But I also think there should be a limit on how many times you can sell your team and get back on the waiting list, after a certain #, I think you should no longer be allowed to purchase a team that isn't a pee wee, at all.

If you LOSE your team, then the length of period should be longer.

So perhaps, if you sell your team, you have to wait 1 season.

If you lose it, you have to wait 2 seasons.

Limit sales to 3 times.

Limit Losses to 1. In other words, 1st time you lose your team, you gotta wait 2 seasons, then you get a second chance at owner ship, but if you lose your team again, that's it.
 
Diamonddog
offline
Link
 
jackriley +1
 
Link
 
Originally posted by jackriley
But I also think there should be a limit on how many times you can sell your team and get back on the waiting list, after a certain #, I think you should no longer be allowed to purchase a team that isn't a pee wee, at all.

If you LOSE your team, then the length of period should be longer.

So perhaps, if you sell your team, you have to wait 1 season.

If you lose it, you have to wait 2 seasons.

Limit sales to 3 times.

Limit Losses to 1. In other words, 1st time you lose your team, you gotta wait 2 seasons, then you get a second chance at owner ship, but if you lose your team again, that's it.


this should be edited into the OP and making clear that your talking about midseason sell backs in your OP would be a good idea
 
Link
 
I also want to make something clear about this topic.

All these owners talking about how "i was promoted and now i can't win"

Believe me, I feel your pain. I'm one of those teams y'all were beating the hell out of for a while and then finally was able to recruit the right people compete. I inherited a gutted team in season 5, and i've had to struggle to the point I am now. I'm not complaining, it goes with the territory, all I'm saying is that ownership is a job, it takes work and effort. If you lose your team its probably because you failed to put forth 1 of those 2, or both things.
 
Viscount
offline
Link
 
jackriley, punishing every person who sells a team is not a solution to the problem of gutting teams.
 
Link
 
I got one this season(gutted team) most high level guys wouldn't sign because they looked at the 1-15 for the season 6 standings and not the chemistry grace period right undreneath it, anyway we are massively underleveled and at a complete disadvantage with a reset stadium, but that isn't going to make me sell my team, I will take my lumps and with all the hardwork, and the good group of agents I've collected we'll be alright in a few seasons
 
Link
 
Originally posted by Viscount
jackriley, punishing every person who sells a team is not a solution to the problem of gutting teams.


yeah actually it is, do some people get punished for no reason yes, but they have to deal with it, because it is for the greater good of everyone
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.