User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > USA AAA Leagues > USA AAA #2 > Good Luck to Spicewood and any other Longhorn Fans
Page:
 
thunderdoozer
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by tomcollins
Originally posted by thunderdoozer

Ohio State should have won that game.

Whoever called cover zero when the Bucks were up five with 30 seconds to go should be fired.

Then tied to a horse and dragged through the Grand Canyon.



It was cover 1 IIRC (There was a SS, no FS). If Cosby doesn't make the adjustment and Russell gets the INT, everyone would be saying how genius it was to get pressure on him. It was a ballsy call that was made worse by how Russell read the route wrong, but not as awful as you might think. Getting a sack or INT there ends the game.


7 in the box, 4 men in man coverage, no one in zone.

You can watch the play here: http://espn.go.com/ncf/recap?gameId=290050251&confId=80

Someone should be out on the street for that call.
Last edited Jan 7, 2009 12:26:33
 
NWWarrior
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by thunderdoozer
Originally posted by tomcollins

Originally posted by thunderdoozer


Ohio State should have won that game.

Whoever called cover zero when the Bucks were up five with 30 seconds to go should be fired.

Then tied to a horse and dragged through the Grand Canyon.



It was cover 1 IIRC (There was a SS, no FS). If Cosby doesn't make the adjustment and Russell gets the INT, everyone would be saying how genius it was to get pressure on him. It was a ballsy call that was made worse by how Russell read the route wrong, but not as awful as you might think. Getting a sack or INT there ends the game.


7 in the box, 4 men in man coverage, no one in zone.

You can watch the play here: http://espn.go.com/ncf/recap?gameId=290050251&confId=80

Someone should be out on the street for that call.


It was a horrible call in that situation...that LB standing ther in Limbo was embarrassing...either blitz him or have him drop back at least 10 yards into coverage...Luckily I hate both teams so no stress either way to me....
Also, just puts another horrible light on how stupid the BCS is, 4 teams will be saying they are number one when this season concludes.
Last edited Jan 7, 2009 14:28:00
 
thunderdoozer
offline
Link
 
USC is clearly not in the coversation for champion. USC's schedule, with teams like Virginia, Arizona State, Washington State, Washington, Stanford, and Notre Dame, isn't any tougher than Utah's. And Utah went undefeated.

Texas is not in the running because they didn't even win their own conference. Although, someone explain to me why Oklahoma went to the Big 12 championship over them...

Utah is a legitimate choice for champion. They've beaten 4 currently-ranked teams (4, 11, 17, 24) if you go by the polls rather than the back-assward BCS. And they are unbeaten.

The winner of the game tomorrow is a legitimate choice for champion. It will be Oklahoma's 7TH GAME against a ranked opponent this season and Florida's 6TH! Anyone who faces that many ranked teams and comes away with only one loss is a candidate for the championship.

I'd like to see a Championship game AFTER the bowls. This season, it should be Utah vs. Oklahoma/Florida.
Last edited Jan 7, 2009 17:38:16
 
tomcollins
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by thunderdoozer
USC is clearly not in the coversation for champion. USC's schedule, with teams like Virginia, Arizona State, Washington State, Washington, Stanford, and Notre Dame, isn't any tougher than Utah's. And Utah went undefeated.

You are missing all the easy teams on Utah's schedule- teams they struggled to beat, like Air Force, New Mexico, and Michigan. USC played a Pac-10 schedule, which means every week you need to worry about losing (except against the two Washingtons). Utah had a gimme a lot more often. They have had a great season, and done more than most non-BCS teams did, but their schedule was considerably easier to go undefeated with than USCs.
Originally posted by thunderdoozer

Texas is not in the running because they didn't even win their own conference. Although, someone explain to me why Oklahoma went to the Big 12 championship over them...

Because it was a 3 way tie, not a 2-way tie. Oklahoma was easily more deserving than Texas, who was more deserving than Texas Tech.

Originally posted by thunderdoozer

Utah is a legitimate choice for champion. They've beaten 4 currently-ranked teams (4, 11, 17, 24) if you go by the polls rather than the back-assward BCS. And they are unbeaten.

I agree here, they are certainly a valid choice. I wouldn't, but its not anything I'd hold against people. BTW- Alabama won't be #4 in the end. USC will have beaten 2 top 10 teams (maybe even 3), depending on the rankings. It's certainly pretty close, especially with the big wins. However, the 2nd tier teams USC had to face were a little better. 3rd tier teams probably a little worse.
Originally posted by thunderdoozer

The winner of the game tomorrow is a legitimate choice for champion. It will be Oklahoma's 7TH GAME against a ranked opponent this season and Florida's 6TH! Anyone who faces that many ranked teams and comes away with only one loss is a candidate for the championship.

Are you counting the SEC fraud ranked teams that were ranked at the time, but turned out were garbage? Florida's schedule was pretty weak, as Alabama was overrated, Georgia is mediocre, etc.... But they have absolutely crushed everyone in their path, (except Ole Miss, who wasn't bad). If Utah had been beating teams this badly on their schedule, I'd give them an argument.
Originally posted by thunderdoozer

I'd like to see a Championship game AFTER the bowls. This season, it should be Utah vs. Oklahoma/Florida.


No point. Utah would get clown stomped.
 
NWWarrior
offline
Link
 
Forget about schedules and just look at talent and how the teams are playing right now.

On a neutral field, I think USC would be slightly favored over all of those teams...mho
 
Mercutioh
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by thunderdoozer
Originally posted by tomcollins

Originally posted by thunderdoozer


Ohio State should have won that game.

Whoever called cover zero when the Bucks were up five with 30 seconds to go should be fired.

Then tied to a horse and dragged through the Grand Canyon.



It was cover 1 IIRC (There was a SS, no FS). If Cosby doesn't make the adjustment and Russell gets the INT, everyone would be saying how genius it was to get pressure on him. It was a ballsy call that was made worse by how Russell read the route wrong, but not as awful as you might think. Getting a sack or INT there ends the game.


7 in the box, 4 men in man coverage, no one in zone.

You can watch the play here: http://espn.go.com/ncf/recap?gameId=290050251&confId=80

Someone should be out on the street for that call.

amen. it's sad that 3 games versus texas and two are decided by dropped balls. Hamby in the end zone in the first half of game one and Rob rose dropping an INT in the breadbasket. My hat is off to Texas but McCoy has earned himself a place on the hates it hates it forever list.
 
thunderdoozer
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by tomcollins
Originally posted by thunderdoozer

USC is clearly not in the coversation for champion. USC's schedule, with teams like Virginia, Arizona State, Washington State, Washington, Stanford, and Notre Dame, isn't any tougher than Utah's. And Utah went undefeated.

You are missing all the easy teams on Utah's schedule- teams they struggled to beat, like Air Force, New Mexico, and Michigan. USC played a Pac-10 schedule, which means every week you need to worry about losing (except against the two Washingtons). Utah had a gimme a lot more often. They have had a great season, and done more than most non-BCS teams did, but their schedule was considerably easier to go undefeated with than USCs.


According to 5 of the 6 computer rankings in the BCS (these are numerically based, and free from opinion bias), Utah had a stronger season than USC. If it weren't for USC's history of success, they would not be ranked above Utah because of the polls. And, IMHO, what you did in the past should not factor into your ranking this season.

Utah just butt-hurt Alabama, ranked 4. It wasn't even close. I think they could easily run with Florida or Oklahoma, maybe even win.
Last edited Jan 7, 2009 19:44:43
 
islander1
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by thunderdoozer
Originally posted by tomcollins

Originally posted by thunderdoozer


USC is clearly not in the coversation for champion. USC's schedule, with teams like Virginia, Arizona State, Washington State, Washington, Stanford, and Notre Dame, isn't any tougher than Utah's. And Utah went undefeated.

You are missing all the easy teams on Utah's schedule- teams they struggled to beat, like Air Force, New Mexico, and Michigan. USC played a Pac-10 schedule, which means every week you need to worry about losing (except against the two Washingtons). Utah had a gimme a lot more often. They have had a great season, and done more than most non-BCS teams did, but their schedule was considerably easier to go undefeated with than USCs.


According to 5 of the 6 computer rankings in the BCS (these are numerically based, and free from opinion bias), Utah had a stronger season than USC. If it weren't for USC's history of success, they would not be ranked above Utah because of the polls. And, IMHO, what you did in the past should not factor into your ranking this season.

Utah just butt-hurt Alabama, ranked 4. It wasn't even close. I think they could easily run with Florida or Oklahoma, maybe even win.


Totally agree
 
tomcollins
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by thunderdoozer
Originally posted by tomcollins

Originally posted by thunderdoozer


USC is clearly not in the coversation for champion. USC's schedule, with teams like Virginia, Arizona State, Washington State, Washington, Stanford, and Notre Dame, isn't any tougher than Utah's. And Utah went undefeated.

You are missing all the easy teams on Utah's schedule- teams they struggled to beat, like Air Force, New Mexico, and Michigan. USC played a Pac-10 schedule, which means every week you need to worry about losing (except against the two Washingtons). Utah had a gimme a lot more often. They have had a great season, and done more than most non-BCS teams did, but their schedule was considerably easier to go undefeated with than USCs.


According to 5 of the 6 computer rankings in the BCS (these are numerically based, and free from opinion bias), Utah had a stronger season than USC. If it weren't for USC's history of success, they would not be ranked above Utah because of the polls. And, IMHO, what you did in the past should not factor into your ranking this season.

Utah just butt-hurt Alabama, ranked 4. It wasn't even close. I think they could easily run with Florida or Oklahoma, maybe even win.


None of the computers account for margin of victory, so they are worthless IMO. Alabama isn't that good of a team, they just had an easy schedule and were overall lucky.
 
NWWarrior
offline
Link
 
So if Utah played USC today on a neutral field, you would be sure Utah would win?

Nothing against utah on my part...I like them wayyyy more than the crummy Florida schools
 
thunderdoozer
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by tomcollins
Alabama isn't that good of a team, they just had an easy schedule and were overall lucky.


No offense, but that's total garbage.

You can't just make up whatever you want about teams. Alabama was ranked #1 at the end of the regular season, and #4 at bowl time. There is no reason whatsoever to consider them less than an elite team.

And margin of victory is worthless. If you beat me by 50 once and I beat you by 1 ten times, who's better? It's all about wins and losses, not who can run the score up.

NW, you know better than to decide a game before it is played. Utah-USC would be a great game, no doubt.
Last edited Jan 7, 2009 20:58:34
 
tomcollins
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by thunderdoozer
Originally posted by tomcollins

Alabama isn't that good of a team, they just had an easy schedule and were overall lucky.


No offense, but that's total garbage.

You can't just make up whatever you want about teams. Alabama was ranked #1 at the end of the regular season, and #4 at bowl time. There is no reason whatsoever to consider them less than an elite team.

And margin of victory is worthless. If you beat me by 50 once and I beat you by 1 ten times, who's better? It's all about wins and losses, not who can run the score up.

NW, you know better than to decide a game before it is played. Utah-USC would be a great game, no doubt.


Alabama was #1 because they hadn't lost, not because they were any good. This is a team that eeked out wins against lowly Kentucky, almost lost to Ole Miss and LSU, etc... If you honestly don't think margin of victory doesn't help decide which team would be favored over another, you are beyond hope. There was plenty of reason, as even Alabama fans I know consider their season to be one where they overachieved. Their schedule was actually easier than Utah's (before they played Florida). Only one team they played was ranked at the end of the season (and had 4 losses), yet Alabama could have easily been 9-3 going into the SEC Championship.

If a team beats you by 50 once, it would be billions to one that you would lose 10 games in a row to that team again (unless one of the teams had half the team injured in some of the games or something absurd like that). If you can beat a team by 50, that data point says you are far far far better than your opponent. Replaying the game would lead to a victory of your opponent of maybe .001% of the time at best. Similarly, if a team wins 10 games in a row against a team by 1 point, the odds that the other team wins by 50 in the next game have to be equally high. I agree that wins and losses are what matters in terms of success, but let's not confuse with how successful a season someone has had with how good their team is. USC - Utah would be a good game if you considered the Rose Bowl a good game (e.g. you liked seeing USC wafflecrush opponents). It would get absolutely out of hand.

Do you bet on sports? I'm guessing no, since you would be too broke to play this game if you did.
 
thunderdoozer
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by tomcollins
If you honestly don't think margin of victory doesn't help decide which team would be favored over another, you are beyond hope.


So you agree that Utah is better than USC. You know, since Utah beat Oregon State and USC lost to them

Originally posted by tomcollins
If you can beat a team by 50, that data point says you are far far far better than your opponent. Replaying the game would lead to a victory of your opponent of maybe .001% of the time at best.


What's it like in make-believe stat land? I've always wanted to vacation there...

Wins are what is important, not margin of victory. MOV is next to irrelevant. These are kids out there on the field, 18 to 22 years old. Their lack of maturity can let otherwise evenly matched games get out of hand. Momentum is big in college sports for this reason. They can give up. A few fluke plays can put them way behind. Bad reffing. A million things.

You can't compare scores to determine who is better. It should be determined on the field. This is why the BCS fails miserably and will always fail miserably.
 
baumusc
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by thunderdoozer
Originally posted by tomcollins

Originally posted by thunderdoozer


USC is clearly not in the coversation for champion. USC's schedule, with teams like Virginia, Arizona State, Washington State, Washington, Stanford, and Notre Dame, isn't any tougher than Utah's. And Utah went undefeated.

You are missing all the easy teams on Utah's schedule- teams they struggled to beat, like Air Force, New Mexico, and Michigan. USC played a Pac-10 schedule, which means every week you need to worry about losing (except against the two Washingtons). Utah had a gimme a lot more often. They have had a great season, and done more than most non-BCS teams did, but their schedule was considerably easier to go undefeated with than USCs.


According to 5 of the 6 computer rankings in the BCS (these are numerically based, and free from opinion bias), Utah had a stronger season than USC. If it weren't for USC's history of success, they would not be ranked above Utah because of the polls. And, IMHO, what you did in the past should not factor into your ranking this season.

Utah just butt-hurt Alabama, ranked 4. It wasn't even close. I think they could easily run with Florida or Oklahoma, maybe even win.


USC beat Ohio State (10), Penn State(6), Oregon(15-will be higher after beating Oklahoma State). They also beat Cal and Arizona who both might finish in the top 25 after their bowl wins. Their only loss was to Oregon State (24) who will be ranked higher after beating Pitt. Oregon State also almost handed Utah a loss but lost the game 31-28. USC's schedule was far from easy and they definitely seem to be playing the best football right now. Utah should get the nod for co-national champions though because they are undefeated and beat Alabama in a more convincing fashion than did Florida.
 
baumusc
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by islander1
Originally posted by thunderdoozer

Originally posted by tomcollins


Originally posted by thunderdoozer



USC is clearly not in the coversation for champion. USC's schedule, with teams like Virginia, Arizona State, Washington State, Washington, Stanford, and Notre Dame, isn't any tougher than Utah's. And Utah went undefeated.

You are missing all the easy teams on Utah's schedule- teams they struggled to beat, like Air Force, New Mexico, and Michigan. USC played a Pac-10 schedule, which means every week you need to worry about losing (except against the two Washingtons). Utah had a gimme a lot more often. They have had a great season, and done more than most non-BCS teams did, but their schedule was considerably easier to go undefeated with than USCs.


According to 5 of the 6 computer rankings in the BCS (these are numerically based, and free from opinion bias), Utah had a stronger season than USC. If it weren't for USC's history of success, they would not be ranked above Utah because of the polls. And, IMHO, what you did in the past should not factor into your ranking this season.

Utah just butt-hurt Alabama, ranked 4. It wasn't even close. I think they could easily run with Florida or Oklahoma, maybe even win.


Totally agree


Both Utah and USC could run with Florida or Oklahoma. USC and Utah both dominated their bowl games against the #4 and #6 teams. In a head to head matchup though I think USC would pull it out because of their defense. SC was one tipped TD pass from being undefeated this season.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.