the reason OT's are finally stopping DE's, is because Bort tweaked how the OT's drop into pass protection... creating more of a true pocket... Also, if, and it's a huge IF, it's because OT's are finally working on speed and agility to the point that they finally bridged the gap, OT's only had 2 main attributes to worry about before. Blocking, and Strength. LB's and S's still have to worry about the pass.
kenmoody
offline
offline
Originally posted by NWWarrior
Originally posted by grooveskipinc
Someone who has dumped all of their points into a couple abilities to take advantage of game mechanics is just trying to pwn LOLdot football. It's the same in any online game - balance never happens because people are more concerned with winning teh interweb and pwning n00bs than actually playing the game.
Linebackers and secondary positions have to dump points into numerous places to be viable, but in doing so you are completely vulnerable to power backs. Until defenses have the option of situational coverage (if offensive player A is in, defensive player 1 is covering him) offenses built around taking advantage of silly game mechanics will always have the advantage.
You shouldn't have to have your safeties and linebackers have 80+ str and 70+ tackling in order to stop a powerback 1 on 1. They still need to be able to cover WR's, TE's, and elusive HB's. 190 lb corners tackle 240 lb TE's and FB's all the time, they take out the legs.
You the man Groove...
agreed
Originally posted by grooveskipinc
Someone who has dumped all of their points into a couple abilities to take advantage of game mechanics is just trying to pwn LOLdot football. It's the same in any online game - balance never happens because people are more concerned with winning teh interweb and pwning n00bs than actually playing the game.
Linebackers and secondary positions have to dump points into numerous places to be viable, but in doing so you are completely vulnerable to power backs. Until defenses have the option of situational coverage (if offensive player A is in, defensive player 1 is covering him) offenses built around taking advantage of silly game mechanics will always have the advantage.
You shouldn't have to have your safeties and linebackers have 80+ str and 70+ tackling in order to stop a powerback 1 on 1. They still need to be able to cover WR's, TE's, and elusive HB's. 190 lb corners tackle 240 lb TE's and FB's all the time, they take out the legs.
You the man Groove...
agreed
Spirer
offline
offline
Originally posted by grooveskipinc
Someone who has dumped all of their points into a couple abilities to take advantage of game mechanics is just trying to pwn LOLdot football. It's the same in any online game - balance never happens because people are more concerned with winning teh interweb and pwning n00bs than actually playing the game.
Linebackers and secondary positions have to dump points into numerous places to be viable, but in doing so you are completely vulnerable to power backs. Until defenses have the option of situational coverage (if offensive player A is in, defensive player 1 is covering him) offenses built around taking advantage of silly game mechanics will always have the advantage.
You shouldn't have to have your safeties and linebackers have 80+ str and 70+ tackling in order to stop a powerback 1 on 1. They still need to be able to cover WR's, TE's, and elusive HB's. 190 lb corners tackle 240 lb TE's and FB's all the time, they take out the legs.
Totally agree. Not to mention that if you were to "translate" a GLB powerback build to real life, you would get a body-builder or a weightlifter, rather than a football player
Someone who has dumped all of their points into a couple abilities to take advantage of game mechanics is just trying to pwn LOLdot football. It's the same in any online game - balance never happens because people are more concerned with winning teh interweb and pwning n00bs than actually playing the game.
Linebackers and secondary positions have to dump points into numerous places to be viable, but in doing so you are completely vulnerable to power backs. Until defenses have the option of situational coverage (if offensive player A is in, defensive player 1 is covering him) offenses built around taking advantage of silly game mechanics will always have the advantage.
You shouldn't have to have your safeties and linebackers have 80+ str and 70+ tackling in order to stop a powerback 1 on 1. They still need to be able to cover WR's, TE's, and elusive HB's. 190 lb corners tackle 240 lb TE's and FB's all the time, they take out the legs.
Totally agree. Not to mention that if you were to "translate" a GLB powerback build to real life, you would get a body-builder or a weightlifter, rather than a football player

gambrinus843
offline
offline
Originally posted by grooveskipinc
Someone who has dumped all of their points into a couple abilities to take advantage of game mechanics is just trying to pwn LOLdot football. It's the same in any online game - balance never happens because people are more concerned with winning teh interweb and pwning n00bs than actually playing the game.
Linebackers and secondary positions have to dump points into numerous places to be viable, but in doing so you are completely vulnerable to power backs. Until defenses have the option of situational coverage (if offensive player A is in, defensive player 1 is covering him) offenses built around taking advantage of silly game mechanics will always have the advantage.
You shouldn't have to have your safeties and linebackers have 80+ str and 70+ tackling in order to stop a powerback 1 on 1. They still need to be able to cover WR's, TE's, and elusive HB's. 190 lb corners tackle 240 lb TE's and FB's all the time, they take out the legs.
The part that bothers me the most is the absolute lack of reality when it comes to actual body type. Yes he has awesome strength and carrying most likely to go along with his power through, but for gods sake he is 6'2 and 195Lb's. If you look at that realistically, that is 6 inches taller and 8 lb's LIGHTER than Barry Sanders. I dont care how much strength you have, at 195lbs you do not bowl over 280LB DE's let alone string together 9 broken tackles on one play. If you want to tell me A jerome Bettis 250LB HB is breaking 30 tackles a game ( still unrealistic) but Ill take it, but a Power back who weighs as much as most CB's?!?!?! Cmon now. I am the GM for the Honolulu Beach Boys and we have very ballanced Builds with good strength and tackling that has not been neglected and Csonka broke 34 tackles on 9 carries against us. This is a team that has multiple championships, and very little player turnover, and to have 34 missed tackles on 9 carries is ridiculous.
Someone who has dumped all of their points into a couple abilities to take advantage of game mechanics is just trying to pwn LOLdot football. It's the same in any online game - balance never happens because people are more concerned with winning teh interweb and pwning n00bs than actually playing the game.
Linebackers and secondary positions have to dump points into numerous places to be viable, but in doing so you are completely vulnerable to power backs. Until defenses have the option of situational coverage (if offensive player A is in, defensive player 1 is covering him) offenses built around taking advantage of silly game mechanics will always have the advantage.
You shouldn't have to have your safeties and linebackers have 80+ str and 70+ tackling in order to stop a powerback 1 on 1. They still need to be able to cover WR's, TE's, and elusive HB's. 190 lb corners tackle 240 lb TE's and FB's all the time, they take out the legs.
The part that bothers me the most is the absolute lack of reality when it comes to actual body type. Yes he has awesome strength and carrying most likely to go along with his power through, but for gods sake he is 6'2 and 195Lb's. If you look at that realistically, that is 6 inches taller and 8 lb's LIGHTER than Barry Sanders. I dont care how much strength you have, at 195lbs you do not bowl over 280LB DE's let alone string together 9 broken tackles on one play. If you want to tell me A jerome Bettis 250LB HB is breaking 30 tackles a game ( still unrealistic) but Ill take it, but a Power back who weighs as much as most CB's?!?!?! Cmon now. I am the GM for the Honolulu Beach Boys and we have very ballanced Builds with good strength and tackling that has not been neglected and Csonka broke 34 tackles on 9 carries against us. This is a team that has multiple championships, and very little player turnover, and to have 34 missed tackles on 9 carries is ridiculous.
islander1
offline
offline
Originally posted by NWWarrior
I admit I grow tired of the best players each season being whoever Bort decides to "Bork" each offseason, At our levels now it is near impossible to redirect builds to keep up with Bort.
just MHO...good luck to all this season
Not just your opinion to be honest. It's a three ring circus every season.
I admit I grow tired of the best players each season being whoever Bort decides to "Bork" each offseason, At our levels now it is near impossible to redirect builds to keep up with Bort.
just MHO...good luck to all this season
Not just your opinion to be honest. It's a three ring circus every season.
islander1
offline
offline
as far as groove's comments. I only disagree with the tackling. Defenders in general should have considerably more tackling then 'softcapped'. Tackling has been a total afterthought in this game from day 1. My own LB is closing in on 2nd cap tackling and it's kinda goofy that he's a rarity in that sense. Tackling is the fundamental skill of a linebacker, linemen, even safeties.
Everything else, totally agree with groove though
Everything else, totally agree with groove though

Last edited Jan 5, 2009 15:17:02
grooveskipinc
offline
offline
Originally posted by islander1
as far as groove's comments. I only disagree with the tackling. Defenders in general should have considerably more tackling then 'softcapped'. Tackling has been a total afterthought in this game from day 1. My own LB is closing in on 2nd cap tackling and it's kinda goofy that he's a rarity in that sense. Tackling is the fundamental skill of a linebacker, linemen, even safeties.
Everything else, totally agree with groove though
a LB or safety MISSING the tackle is far more likely than a guy having multiple broken tackles. you shouldn't have to max tackling to stop a guy. you should have to max tackling to stop him from gaining the extra 3 yards.
as far as groove's comments. I only disagree with the tackling. Defenders in general should have considerably more tackling then 'softcapped'. Tackling has been a total afterthought in this game from day 1. My own LB is closing in on 2nd cap tackling and it's kinda goofy that he's a rarity in that sense. Tackling is the fundamental skill of a linebacker, linemen, even safeties.
Everything else, totally agree with groove though

a LB or safety MISSING the tackle is far more likely than a guy having multiple broken tackles. you shouldn't have to max tackling to stop a guy. you should have to max tackling to stop him from gaining the extra 3 yards.
Painmaker
offline
offline
Originally posted by grooveskipinc
a LB or safety MISSING the tackle is far more likely than a guy having multiple broken tackles. you shouldn't have to max tackling to stop a guy. you should have to max tackling to stop him from gaining the extra 3 yards.
Yeah, I think at lot of folks could agree with this. Having low tackling should mean you give up a couple of extra yards bringing a guy down, not that you cant do it at all. Giving up an extra two yards every play to a power back would be disastrous enough for a defense -- no need for more than a quarter of the backs in the game to immediately become "unstoppable."
a LB or safety MISSING the tackle is far more likely than a guy having multiple broken tackles. you shouldn't have to max tackling to stop a guy. you should have to max tackling to stop him from gaining the extra 3 yards.
Yeah, I think at lot of folks could agree with this. Having low tackling should mean you give up a couple of extra yards bringing a guy down, not that you cant do it at all. Giving up an extra two yards every play to a power back would be disastrous enough for a defense -- no need for more than a quarter of the backs in the game to immediately become "unstoppable."
baumusc
offline
offline
Originally posted by grooveskipinc
Originally posted by islander1
as far as groove's comments. I only disagree with the tackling. Defenders in general should have considerably more tackling then 'softcapped'. Tackling has been a total afterthought in this game from day 1. My own LB is closing in on 2nd cap tackling and it's kinda goofy that he's a rarity in that sense. Tackling is the fundamental skill of a linebacker, linemen, even safeties.
Everything else, totally agree with groove though
a LB or safety MISSING the tackle is far more likely than a guy having multiple broken tackles. you shouldn't have to max tackling to stop a guy. you should have to max tackling to stop him from gaining the extra 3 yards.
Totally agree.
Originally posted by islander1
as far as groove's comments. I only disagree with the tackling. Defenders in general should have considerably more tackling then 'softcapped'. Tackling has been a total afterthought in this game from day 1. My own LB is closing in on 2nd cap tackling and it's kinda goofy that he's a rarity in that sense. Tackling is the fundamental skill of a linebacker, linemen, even safeties.
Everything else, totally agree with groove though

a LB or safety MISSING the tackle is far more likely than a guy having multiple broken tackles. you shouldn't have to max tackling to stop a guy. you should have to max tackling to stop him from gaining the extra 3 yards.
Totally agree.
islander1
offline
offline
Originally posted by grooveskipinc
Originally posted by islander1
as far as groove's comments. I only disagree with the tackling. Defenders in general should have considerably more tackling then 'softcapped'. Tackling has been a total afterthought in this game from day 1. My own LB is closing in on 2nd cap tackling and it's kinda goofy that he's a rarity in that sense. Tackling is the fundamental skill of a linebacker, linemen, even safeties.
Everything else, totally agree with groove though
a LB or safety MISSING the tackle is far more likely than a guy having multiple broken tackles. you shouldn't have to max tackling to stop a guy. you should have to max tackling to stop him from gaining the extra 3 yards.
That's where strength comes in, actually. According to Bort. On some level it makes sense to me, but I havent actually played legitimate football, so I can always defer to the more experienced audience.
Originally posted by islander1
as far as groove's comments. I only disagree with the tackling. Defenders in general should have considerably more tackling then 'softcapped'. Tackling has been a total afterthought in this game from day 1. My own LB is closing in on 2nd cap tackling and it's kinda goofy that he's a rarity in that sense. Tackling is the fundamental skill of a linebacker, linemen, even safeties.
Everything else, totally agree with groove though

a LB or safety MISSING the tackle is far more likely than a guy having multiple broken tackles. you shouldn't have to max tackling to stop a guy. you should have to max tackling to stop him from gaining the extra 3 yards.
That's where strength comes in, actually. According to Bort. On some level it makes sense to me, but I havent actually played legitimate football, so I can always defer to the more experienced audience.
Last edited Jan 5, 2009 19:35:27
grooveskipinc
offline
offline
good tackling has a lot to do with vision, in my experience. taking the right angle, taking out legs or leading with your shoulder. you have to know where to tackle and know when to wrap up. should corners miss tackles on scatbacks and wide receivers? yes, they should. should they be unable to tackle a halfback? no. it also doesn't take 2 corners and a safety to bring down halfbacks, no matter how much creatine and hgh they've taken.
my point is this - you cannot gimp your building of a secondary player (I'm including linebackers here as well) just in case you might play a team that is taking advantage of Bort's inability to find positional parity. A halfback that is 220 lbs and 5'10" that has 100 strength should be pretty dang strong, but they're really not stronger than the 6'5" 330 lb defensive tackle with 90 strength.
Bort should start encouraging players to build realistic players instead of making 1 attribute god-mode. Remember Flames' team of 100+ speed players? They killed people until Bort made agility worth something, and then suddenly receivers with 100 speed, 30 agility, 30 stamina, and 30 catching were total crap.
The fix for this and future issues like this (and there will be more if Bort just balances by nerfing) is to have a weighted player build in his calculations. A linebacker that is fast, strong, and agile is worthless if he can't see a hole to fill. Likewise a halfback that is outrageously strong, fast, and has good ball control skills shouldn't be as dominant as they are because they have neglected some of the critical skills of a full time back (vision, confidence, agility). In my opinion a halfback that isn't well rounded with these skills should be timid about getting hit, or not patient enough to see or even cognizant of the opening in the line, or be running into the back of the guard that just pulled for him.
In real football powerbacks are a big threat, but there is a reason they aren't on the field every play. They get pounded on, and they're short yardage backs.
my point is this - you cannot gimp your building of a secondary player (I'm including linebackers here as well) just in case you might play a team that is taking advantage of Bort's inability to find positional parity. A halfback that is 220 lbs and 5'10" that has 100 strength should be pretty dang strong, but they're really not stronger than the 6'5" 330 lb defensive tackle with 90 strength.
Bort should start encouraging players to build realistic players instead of making 1 attribute god-mode. Remember Flames' team of 100+ speed players? They killed people until Bort made agility worth something, and then suddenly receivers with 100 speed, 30 agility, 30 stamina, and 30 catching were total crap.
The fix for this and future issues like this (and there will be more if Bort just balances by nerfing) is to have a weighted player build in his calculations. A linebacker that is fast, strong, and agile is worthless if he can't see a hole to fill. Likewise a halfback that is outrageously strong, fast, and has good ball control skills shouldn't be as dominant as they are because they have neglected some of the critical skills of a full time back (vision, confidence, agility). In my opinion a halfback that isn't well rounded with these skills should be timid about getting hit, or not patient enough to see or even cognizant of the opening in the line, or be running into the back of the guard that just pulled for him.
In real football powerbacks are a big threat, but there is a reason they aren't on the field every play. They get pounded on, and they're short yardage backs.
Spiked
offline
offline
Originally posted by grooveskipinc
good tackling has a lot to do with vision, in my experience. taking the right angle, taking out legs or leading with your shoulder. you have to know where to tackle and know when to wrap up. should corners miss tackles on scatbacks and wide receivers? yes, they should. should they be unable to tackle a halfback? no. it also doesn't take 2 corners and a safety to bring down halfbacks, no matter how much creatine and hgh they've taken.
my point is this - you cannot gimp your building of a secondary player (I'm including linebackers here as well) just in case you might play a team that is taking advantage of Bort's inability to find positional parity. A halfback that is 220 lbs and 5'10" that has 100 strength should be pretty dang strong, but they're really not stronger than the 6'5" 330 lb defensive tackle with 90 strength.
Bort should start encouraging players to build realistic players instead of making 1 attribute god-mode. Remember Flames' team of 100+ speed players? They killed people until Bort made agility worth something, and then suddenly receivers with 100 speed, 30 agility, 30 stamina, and 30 catching were total crap.
The fix for this and future issues like this (and there will be more if Bort just balances by nerfing) is to have a weighted player build in his calculations. A linebacker that is fast, strong, and agile is worthless if he can't see a hole to fill. Likewise a halfback that is outrageously strong, fast, and has good ball control skills shouldn't be as dominant as they are because they have neglected some of the critical skills of a full time back (vision, confidence, agility). In my opinion a halfback that isn't well rounded with these skills should be timid about getting hit, or not patient enough to see or even cognizant of the opening in the line, or be running into the back of the guard that just pulled for him.
In real football powerbacks are a big threat, but there is a reason they aren't on the field every play. They get pounded on, and they're short yardage backs.
+1 again ... Groove sir ... your on a roll.
good tackling has a lot to do with vision, in my experience. taking the right angle, taking out legs or leading with your shoulder. you have to know where to tackle and know when to wrap up. should corners miss tackles on scatbacks and wide receivers? yes, they should. should they be unable to tackle a halfback? no. it also doesn't take 2 corners and a safety to bring down halfbacks, no matter how much creatine and hgh they've taken.
my point is this - you cannot gimp your building of a secondary player (I'm including linebackers here as well) just in case you might play a team that is taking advantage of Bort's inability to find positional parity. A halfback that is 220 lbs and 5'10" that has 100 strength should be pretty dang strong, but they're really not stronger than the 6'5" 330 lb defensive tackle with 90 strength.
Bort should start encouraging players to build realistic players instead of making 1 attribute god-mode. Remember Flames' team of 100+ speed players? They killed people until Bort made agility worth something, and then suddenly receivers with 100 speed, 30 agility, 30 stamina, and 30 catching were total crap.
The fix for this and future issues like this (and there will be more if Bort just balances by nerfing) is to have a weighted player build in his calculations. A linebacker that is fast, strong, and agile is worthless if he can't see a hole to fill. Likewise a halfback that is outrageously strong, fast, and has good ball control skills shouldn't be as dominant as they are because they have neglected some of the critical skills of a full time back (vision, confidence, agility). In my opinion a halfback that isn't well rounded with these skills should be timid about getting hit, or not patient enough to see or even cognizant of the opening in the line, or be running into the back of the guard that just pulled for him.
In real football powerbacks are a big threat, but there is a reason they aren't on the field every play. They get pounded on, and they're short yardage backs.
+1 again ... Groove sir ... your on a roll.
NWWarrior
offline
offline
Originally posted by Spiked
+1 again ... Groove sir ... your on a roll.
He is isn't he
+1 again ... Groove sir ... your on a roll.
He is isn't he

grooveskipinc
offline
offline
Originally posted by Spiked
Originally posted by grooveskipinc
good tackling has a lot to do with vision, in my experience. taking the right angle, taking out legs or leading with your shoulder. you have to know where to tackle and know when to wrap up. should corners miss tackles on scatbacks and wide receivers? yes, they should. should they be unable to tackle a halfback? no. it also doesn't take 2 corners and a safety to bring down halfbacks, no matter how much creatine and hgh they've taken.
my point is this - you cannot gimp your building of a secondary player (I'm including linebackers here as well) just in case you might play a team that is taking advantage of Bort's inability to find positional parity. A halfback that is 220 lbs and 5'10" that has 100 strength should be pretty dang strong, but they're really not stronger than the 6'5" 330 lb defensive tackle with 90 strength.
Bort should start encouraging players to build realistic players instead of making 1 attribute god-mode. Remember Flames' team of 100+ speed players? They killed people until Bort made agility worth something, and then suddenly receivers with 100 speed, 30 agility, 30 stamina, and 30 catching were total crap.
The fix for this and future issues like this (and there will be more if Bort just balances by nerfing) is to have a weighted player build in his calculations. A linebacker that is fast, strong, and agile is worthless if he can't see a hole to fill. Likewise a halfback that is outrageously strong, fast, and has good ball control skills shouldn't be as dominant as they are because they have neglected some of the critical skills of a full time back (vision, confidence, agility). In my opinion a halfback that isn't well rounded with these skills should be timid about getting hit, or not patient enough to see or even cognizant of the opening in the line, or be running into the back of the guard that just pulled for him.
In real football powerbacks are a big threat, but there is a reason they aren't on the field every play. They get pounded on, and they're short yardage backs.
+1 again ... Groove sir ... your on a roll.
NWWarrior only hires geniuses...didnt you know that?
Originally posted by grooveskipinc
good tackling has a lot to do with vision, in my experience. taking the right angle, taking out legs or leading with your shoulder. you have to know where to tackle and know when to wrap up. should corners miss tackles on scatbacks and wide receivers? yes, they should. should they be unable to tackle a halfback? no. it also doesn't take 2 corners and a safety to bring down halfbacks, no matter how much creatine and hgh they've taken.
my point is this - you cannot gimp your building of a secondary player (I'm including linebackers here as well) just in case you might play a team that is taking advantage of Bort's inability to find positional parity. A halfback that is 220 lbs and 5'10" that has 100 strength should be pretty dang strong, but they're really not stronger than the 6'5" 330 lb defensive tackle with 90 strength.
Bort should start encouraging players to build realistic players instead of making 1 attribute god-mode. Remember Flames' team of 100+ speed players? They killed people until Bort made agility worth something, and then suddenly receivers with 100 speed, 30 agility, 30 stamina, and 30 catching were total crap.
The fix for this and future issues like this (and there will be more if Bort just balances by nerfing) is to have a weighted player build in his calculations. A linebacker that is fast, strong, and agile is worthless if he can't see a hole to fill. Likewise a halfback that is outrageously strong, fast, and has good ball control skills shouldn't be as dominant as they are because they have neglected some of the critical skills of a full time back (vision, confidence, agility). In my opinion a halfback that isn't well rounded with these skills should be timid about getting hit, or not patient enough to see or even cognizant of the opening in the line, or be running into the back of the guard that just pulled for him.
In real football powerbacks are a big threat, but there is a reason they aren't on the field every play. They get pounded on, and they're short yardage backs.
+1 again ... Groove sir ... your on a roll.
NWWarrior only hires geniuses...didnt you know that?
You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.




























