User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Suggestions > Promotion/Demotion at the end of the off-season and the problems associated with it - need ideas
Page:
 
Warhawk
Moderator
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Mightyhalo
Stop trying to do realignment/promotions by region only especially if they are going to be moved down and get rid of team swaps.

Someone who wants to move down shouldn't have any choice where they are moved to and I hope you don't allow team swaps again unless it's only for a few extreme cases.





Uh, problem: The good team that moves up would have to switch regions too as a result, and that sure as hell wouldn't fly.
 
GG
offline
Link
 
Dont allow teams to recruit until AFTER promotions/relegations occur? Ie, a "pre-season" period as such where all market activity can start occuring. Not STRAIGHT AFTER playoffs end (ie OFF-season).
Last edited Dec 18, 2008 05:21:31
 
Link
 
Originally posted by Warhawk
Originally posted by Mightyhalo

Stop trying to do realignment/promotions by region only especially if they are going to be moved down and get rid of team swaps.

Someone who wants to move down shouldn't have any choice where they are moved to and I hope you don't allow team swaps again unless it's only for a few extreme cases.



Uh, problem: The good team that moves up would have to switch regions too as a result, and that sure as hell wouldn't fly.


I didn't even understand what he's trying to get at. All promotions/relegations have to stay within the same region to work.

Also, there isn't a problem with doing team swaps either, as long as there's a reason. Why keep a team starting over in a higher league? It wouldn't fix the problem at hand.
 
Mightyhalo
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Warhawk
Originally posted by Mightyhalo

Stop trying to do realignment/promotions by region only especially if they are going to be moved down and get rid of team swaps.

Someone who wants to move down shouldn't have any choice where they are moved to and I hope you don't allow team swaps again unless it's only for a few extreme cases.





Uh, problem: The good team that moves up would have to switch regions too as a result, and that sure as hell wouldn't fly.


Ignoring regions on promotions and demotions would be the best thing for the game and if done right the leagues would be better off across the board.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by GG
Dont allow teams to recruit until AFTER promotions/relegations occur? Ie, a "pre-season" period as such where all market activity can start occuring. Not STRAIGHT AFTER playoffs end (ie OFF-season).


This could work.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by Mightyhalo
Originally posted by Warhawk

Originally posted by Mightyhalo


Stop trying to do realignment/promotions by region only especially if they are going to be moved down and get rid of team swaps.

Someone who wants to move down shouldn't have any choice where they are moved to and I hope you don't allow team swaps again unless it's only for a few extreme cases.



Uh, problem: The good team that moves up would have to switch regions too as a result, and that sure as hell wouldn't fly.


Ignoring regions on promotions and demotions would be the best thing for the game and if done right the leagues would be better off across the board.


Explain what you're getting at better? Because to me, this makes no sense at all. Any African team will not match up with 90% of the teams in the same league ranking. (ex. African AAA teams are probably averaging around level 35, where as the rest of the AAA leagues are averaging lvl 40. You idea would create more lopsided leagues than there already is.
 
Mightyhalo
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by SteelCity Mafia
Originally posted by Warhawk

Originally posted by Mightyhalo


Stop trying to do realignment/promotions by region only especially if they are going to be moved down and get rid of team swaps.

Someone who wants to move down shouldn't have any choice where they are moved to and I hope you don't allow team swaps again unless it's only for a few extreme cases.



Uh, problem: The good team that moves up would have to switch regions too as a result, and that sure as hell wouldn't fly.


I didn't even understand what he's trying to get at. All promotions/relegations have to stay within the same region to work.

Also, there isn't a problem with doing team swaps either, as long as there's a reason. Why keep a team starting over in a higher league? It wouldn't fix the problem at hand.


You had an example on your post. You know you are rebuilding, and want to move to the bottom in a USA league, but then your team will basically ruin the competitive balance of that league since they will be a bunch of level 1's.

I would rather move teams from other regions into USA BBB, and move the bum teams/rebuilding teams from USA BBB to the newest cap league, and anyone on the team that is over the cap that they are moving too would become free agents after the move to the lowest league.
 
mike2686
offline
Link
 
The only answer to solve all of these problems in a complete league shakeup. Since the offseason should be longer anyways. I'd Leave the top teams in their respective leagues.

But for the most part alot of teams need to be added and dropped for every league and rearranged. That way the league will be as competetive as they are supposed to be atleast level and talent wise. All CPU Teams GLB wide should be sent to an entire new league such as A new BBB league, reset and handed out first. Move teams up accordingly, rearrange them as stated before.

I truly think this is the only way to fix the current problem. The slowbuilds should also be moved.

It would look something like this:

USA PRO- Same concept
USA AAA- Same concept
USA AA- Same concept
USA A- Uncapped But also rearange it so that the teams are equal.
USA BBB- Level 24 Cap (Rearange all the teams to where this wont screw anyone over and put every team with players 18-21 avg in these leagues,)
USA BB- level 13 Cap (New teams, slowbuilds, and Ex CPU teams)

I think this is the only way, but its very complicated and would take a while to complete. At this point I'm not sure much else can be done. We do have some very intellegent people on here though who will probably come up with something easier and better. This is just my thought.
 
slntkilla
offline
Link
 
Why not just match teams up in a league with other teams with the same skill level?
 
Link
 
Originally posted by Mightyhalo
Originally posted by SteelCity Mafia

Originally posted by Warhawk


Originally posted by Mightyhalo



Stop trying to do realignment/promotions by region only especially if they are going to be moved down and get rid of team swaps.

Someone who wants to move down shouldn't have any choice where they are moved to and I hope you don't allow team swaps again unless it's only for a few extreme cases.



Uh, problem: The good team that moves up would have to switch regions too as a result, and that sure as hell wouldn't fly.


I didn't even understand what he's trying to get at. All promotions/relegations have to stay within the same region to work.

Also, there isn't a problem with doing team swaps either, as long as there's a reason. Why keep a team starting over in a higher league? It wouldn't fix the problem at hand.


You had an example on your post. You know you are rebuilding, and want to move to the bottom in a USA league, but then your team will basically ruin the competitive balance of that league since they will be a bunch of level 1's.

I would rather move teams from other regions into USA BBB, and move the bum teams/rebuilding teams from USA BBB to the newest cap league, and anyone on the team that is over the cap that they are moving too would become free agents after the move to the lowest league.


So, instead of improving your BBB team and promoting, you want to ruin all the other regions? All the new teams that got sold back go to BBB anyway, so that's were a team like mine could compete with a few teams.

Bottom line is, I won't move my team outside of USA (that's where the majority wants to be, and that's where the most competition is of all the regions). For all that, I'd leave it there and allow it to get demoted 1 league per season and just use it for whatever I could, all the while saving money because my stadium is totally maxed out. So moving my team to a brand new league would be unfair to all those teams. Plus, my team will be very good in a few seasons and probably promote out of BBB. It's being ran by the same people who run Monmouth Evil Monkeys.
 
Mightyhalo
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by slntkilla
Why not just match teams up in a league with other teams with the same skill level?


That what the original plan, but then the south america teams went into sombrero/riot mode and forced Bort to abandon the idea.
 
Link
 
Cool new idea Bort but only one thing that I see. So if you "forget" to renew your team there is a way to get it back. But I thought that they got PM's and Alerts that warned them that it is coming? And even if you did what you said it would be a waste of a day yes but I think those teams that are very behind should be aloud to try to recruit, because the offseason is basically a recruiting time for me and loosing a day would be a disaster for some teams.
Last edited Dec 18, 2008 05:54:58
 
Mightyhalo
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by SteelCity Mafia
Originally posted by Mightyhalo

Originally posted by SteelCity Mafia


Originally posted by Warhawk



Originally posted by Mightyhalo




Stop trying to do realignment/promotions by region only especially if they are going to be moved down and get rid of team swaps.

Someone who wants to move down shouldn't have any choice where they are moved to and I hope you don't allow team swaps again unless it's only for a few extreme cases.



Uh, problem: The good team that moves up would have to switch regions too as a result, and that sure as hell wouldn't fly.


I didn't even understand what he's trying to get at. All promotions/relegations have to stay within the same region to work.

Also, there isn't a problem with doing team swaps either, as long as there's a reason. Why keep a team starting over in a higher league? It wouldn't fix the problem at hand.


You had an example on your post. You know you are rebuilding, and want to move to the bottom in a USA league, but then your team will basically ruin the competitive balance of that league since they will be a bunch of level 1's.

I would rather move teams from other regions into USA BBB, and move the bum teams/rebuilding teams from USA BBB to the newest cap league, and anyone on the team that is over the cap that they are moving too would become free agents after the move to the lowest league.


So, instead of improving your BBB team and promoting, you want to ruin all the other regions? All the new teams that got sold back go to BBB anyway, so that's were a team like mine could compete with a few teams.

Bottom line is, I won't move my team outside of USA (that's where the majority wants to be, and that's where the most competition is of all the regions). For all that, I'd leave it there and allow it to get demoted 1 league per season and just use it for whatever I could, all the while saving money because my stadium is totally maxed out. So moving my team to a brand new league would be unfair to all those teams. Plus, my team will be very good in a few seasons and probably promote out of BBB. It's being ran by the same people who run Monmouth Evil Monkeys.


But your team doesn't belong in that league if you go into rebuild mode. You are no longer fielding a competitive team and your team should be moved to the very bottom, and out of the USA if a new league isn't created.

This also brings up a good point about stadiums. If you are moved to the bottom of a league(Not just your regions league) your stadium should probably reset. What you are doing with your team is what is wrong with the game in many ways. Your type of team is creating realignment issues since you will be uncompetitive at the bottom of your current region if you are allowed to be demoted there.

I just think Bort should do game wide realignment, get the rebuilt gut job teams out of their current regions and reset the stadium. It might sound harsh but it's in the best interest of the game. This might force owners to sell, and that would probably be a good thing if they don't truly want to start over.
 
Bort
Admin
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by GG
Dont allow teams to recruit until AFTER promotions/relegations occur? Ie, a "pre-season" period as such where all market activity can start occuring. Not STRAIGHT AFTER playoffs end (ie OFF-season).


That's what I was describing with a roster freeze.
 
GG
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Originally posted by GG

Dont allow teams to recruit until AFTER promotions/relegations occur? Ie, a "pre-season" period as such where all market activity can start occuring. Not STRAIGHT AFTER playoffs end (ie OFF-season).


That's what I was describing with a roster freeze.


Would that not solve the problem then? Especially in a very non-complex, uncomplicated way for all---you and agents and team owners.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.