User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Suggestions > Fame suggestions for Bort
Page:
 
tjsexkitten82
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by GIEFF
I have a macro that looks at the defensive player who made a sack and calculates which O-lineman that player was closest to for the majority of the play, and assigns sack blame that way.

I think something like that shouldn't be difficult to implement for each game, Bort.


how much drain would it put on the simulation to run that every play?
 
Bort
Admin
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by GIEFF
I have a macro that looks at the defensive player who made a sack and calculates which O-lineman that player was closest to for the majority of the play, and assigns sack blame that way.

I think something like that shouldn't be difficult to implement for each game, Bort.


Does it seem to always get it right, or is it wrong frequently? How would it work with double teams, or players who got blocked by one guy and then swapped to another, etc?
 
GIEFF
offline
Link
 
It would only have to be run for plays in which the quarterback was sacked. You could run it for hurries if you wanted, too, but that is a small subset of all plays.
 
tjsexkitten82
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Originally posted by GIEFF

I have a macro that looks at the defensive player who made a sack and calculates which O-lineman that player was closest to for the majority of the play, and assigns sack blame that way.

I think something like that shouldn't be difficult to implement for each game, Bort.


Does it seem to always get it right, or is it wrong frequently? How would it work with double teams, or players who got blocked by one guy and then swapped to another, etc?


What about the RT dumping off to the TE, or the HB coming in after he gets around the OT? I'm very curious to see this macro GIEFF
 
GIEFF
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Originally posted by GIEFF

I have a macro that looks at the defensive player who made a sack and calculates which O-lineman that player was closest to for the majority of the play, and assigns sack blame that way.

I think something like that shouldn't be difficult to implement for each game, Bort.


Does it seem to always get it right, or is it wrong frequently? How would it work with double teams, or players who got blocked by one guy and then swapped to another, etc?


It's not perfect by any means, but it isn't perfect in real life, either. There is no way to accurately assign sack blame, but this way gets pretty close to what actually happens. When I track them myself, the macro is always very close to what I assume from watching the replay visually.

Here is an example: http://spreadsheets.google.com/ccc?key=pJpYEUCR9_4I3gNv9uh78NQ&hl=en

Look at the "O-line performance tab" in columns E & F.
 
Guppy, Inc
offline
Link
 
what about the LOT who is already engaged with the RDE but then the ROLB shoots around the outside for the sack? Hard to blame that on the LOT.
 
trazer
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by tjking82
Originally posted by trazer

A CB with 100 tackles isnt necessarily a good CB. Etc etc etc. You know the routine.


No that's right. Also, OTs have insufficient stats for pass blocking, obviously. But fame is gonna have to come from somewhere, and in most instances, stats seem like the best option. People know the guys who throw the most TDs or get the most picks or kick the longest FGs, those stats are bandied about the forums. They're "famous." If you pick the right stats, most every position can be fairly well translated from stats to fame. OL is the notable exception imo.


Uh...the most notable exception is the CB.
 
Bort
Admin
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Guppy, Inc
what about the LOT who is already engaged with the RDE but then the ROLB shoots around the outside for the sack? Hard to blame that on the LOT.


Yeah, but that method probably would, because he'd be closest the the play.

There's a reason we don't have a sacks allowed stat...it's not cut and dry like "pancakes" so it's hard to figure out
 
Darkus Black
FFA Mod
offline
Link
 
Hooty hoo!
 
GIEFF
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Guppy, Inc
what about the LOT who is already engaged with the RDE but then the ROLB shoots around the outside for the sack? Hard to blame that on the LOT.


Who else could you blame it on, though? The LOT is more responsible than anybody else.
 
Guppy, Inc
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Originally posted by Guppy, Inc

what about the LOT who is already engaged with the RDE but then the ROLB shoots around the outside for the sack? Hard to blame that on the LOT.


Yeah, but that method probably would, because he'd be closest the the play.

There's a reason we don't have a sacks allowed stat...it's not cut and dry like "pancakes" so it's hard to figure out


are pancakes cut and dry when a defender gets double teamed and pancaked? Not that I can recall ever seeing it, but wouldnt the double team make it easier for the player to go down?

Originally posted by GIEFF
Originally posted by Guppy, Inc

what about the LOT who is already engaged with the RDE but then the ROLB shoots around the outside for the sack? Hard to blame that on the LOT.


Who else could you blame it on, though? The LOT is more responsible than anybody else.


cant expect him to block the RDE AND the ROLB...
Last edited Dec 17, 2008 14:31:28
 
tjsexkitten82
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Guppy, Inc
what about the LOT who is already engaged with the RDE but then the ROLB shoots around the outside for the sack? Hard to blame that on the LOT.


In that case, if there's no HB blocking, I would think the LT is supposed to disengage and block the ROLB, and shift RDE responsibility to the LG?
 
trazer
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Originally posted by GIEFF

I have a macro that looks at the defensive player who made a sack and calculates which O-lineman that player was closest to for the majority of the play, and assigns sack blame that way.

I think something like that shouldn't be difficult to implement for each game, Bort.


Does it seem to always get it right, or is it wrong frequently? How would it work with double teams, or players who got blocked by one guy and then swapped to another, etc?


Might there be some way to integrate it so that it looks at which linemen actually blocked a Dl or LB that made the sack? (obviously bort would have to adjust it some to do that)

Oh and on a double team you would have to give 1/2 a sack given up to each one? As for unblocked sacks that just goes to the whole team as 20% of a sack given up? or something along those lines.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by GIEFF
Originally posted by Guppy, Inc

what about the LOT who is already engaged with the RDE but then the ROLB shoots around the outside for the sack? Hard to blame that on the LOT.


Who else could you blame it on, though? The LOT is more responsible than anybody else.


The FB, The RB, the G, the TE... maybe a pulling G should have blocked him, but hey, he fell on his face and missed, allowing a sack.
 
tjsexkitten82
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by tjking82
Originally posted by Guppy, Inc

what about the LOT who is already engaged with the RDE but then the ROLB shoots around the outside for the sack? Hard to blame that on the LOT.


In that case, if there's no HB blocking, I would think the LT is supposed to disengage and block the ROLB, and shift RDE responsibility to the LG?


Ahem. This seems to be the RL solution. If there's an HB or FB in the backfield, he blocks. If it's empty backfield, it IS the LT's responsibility.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.