User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Suggestions > Players adapting to overused plays
Page:
 
23yrwej
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Homsar16
Originally posted by jrry32

Bump for more opinions.


What opinions? Should be a boost to vision, and the idea should be epicced. Good coordinating is a shit argument against it. It's about the players, not the management. +10 for the idea.


Well I am just guessing the mods want more opinions before they epic it?

 
bmedders
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Homsar16
Originally posted by jrry32

Bump for more opinions.


What opinions? Should be a boost to vision, and the idea should be epicced. Good coordinating is a shit argument against it. It's about the players, not the management. +10 for the idea.


I don't like the boost to vision. IMO, that isn't realistic. Take the Strong I rush - will a simple boost to vision fix that? I doubt it.

The fix to this involves allowing it to be a team or possibly players setting that says "Modify my assignments when X play is run Y number of times". In the example of the Strong I rush, it would mean DTs attacking different gaps, LBs blitzing in to the "right" gaps, and the SS reacting much, much quicker to the play. This also provides a penalty to the defense if the offense pulls out a play to the other side, or a pass out of Strong I.

How exactly it should all be coded is a different matter entirely, but for those saying it should be a vision boost, I think you are greatly overvaluing the effects of vision in this game.
 
23yrwej
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by bmedders
Originally posted by Homsar16

Originally posted by jrry32


Bump for more opinions.


What opinions? Should be a boost to vision, and the idea should be epicced. Good coordinating is a shit argument against it. It's about the players, not the management. +10 for the idea.


I don't like the boost to vision. IMO, that isn't realistic. Take the Strong I rush - will a simple boost to vision fix that? I doubt it.

The fix to this involves allowing it to be a team or possibly players setting that says "Modify my assignments when X play is run Y number of times". In the example of the Strong I rush, it would mean DTs attacking different gaps, LBs blitzing in to the "right" gaps, and the SS reacting much, much quicker to the play. This also provides a penalty to the defense if the offense pulls out a play to the other side, or a pass out of Strong I.

How exactly it should all be coded is a different matter entirely, but for those saying it should be a vision boost, I think you are greatly overvaluing the effects of vision in this game.


Well the boost to vision wasn't the only thing in my idea...I also said they should cheat over to where the play has been run but yeah I totally agree with this. Not sure how hard it would be for Bort to program it but it seems like a fair fix.

 
bmedders
offline
Link
 
Yeah I wasn't necessarily saying that was your idea, I just hate the idea that it should solely be a "vision boost".

IMO, it should be a vision check in two ways -

1) Players with higher vision recognize the play after fewer repeats and
2) Players with higher vision should go back to their original assignments faster once the recognize it's not the same play.
 
MikeV99
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by bmedders
Yeah I wasn't necessarily saying that was your idea, I just hate the idea that it should solely be a "vision boost".

IMO, it should be a vision check in two ways -

1) Players with higher vision recognize the play after fewer repeats and
2) Players with higher vision should go back to their original assignments faster once the recognize it's not the same play.


Perfect
 
Link
 
Originally posted by bmedders


I don't like the boost to vision. IMO, that isn't realistic. Take the Strong I rush - will a simple boost to vision fix that? I doubt it.

The fix to this involves allowing it to be a team or possibly players setting that says "Modify my assignments when X play is run Y number of times". In the example of the Strong I rush, it would mean DTs attacking different gaps, LBs blitzing in to the "right" gaps, and the SS reacting much, much quicker to the play. This also provides a penalty to the defense if the offense pulls out a play to the other side, or a pass out of Strong I.

How exactly it should all be coded is a different matter entirely, but for those saying it should be a vision boost, I think you are greatly overvaluing the effects of vision in this game.


100% agree
 
23yrwej
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by bmedders
Yeah I wasn't necessarily saying that was your idea, I just hate the idea that it should solely be a "vision boost".

IMO, it should be a vision check in two ways -

1) Players with higher vision recognize the play after fewer repeats and
2) Players with higher vision should go back to their original assignments faster once the recognize it's not the same play.


Totally agreed. I'll edit this into the OP.
 
Link
 
hey jrry totally off topic you ever think about evil monkey cutting himself while crying?
 
23yrwej
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by jared
hey jrry totally off topic you ever think about evil monkey cutting himself while crying?


If I had the super avatar creating abilities...I'd totally do it. Except the Evil Monkey is happy right now that he won the Conference Championship.
 
Homsar16
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by bmedders
I don't like the boost to vision. IMO, that isn't realistic. Take the Strong I rush - will a simple boost to vision fix that? I doubt it.

The fix to this involves allowing it to be a team or possibly players setting that says "Modify my assignments when X play is run Y number of times". In the example of the Strong I rush, it would mean DTs attacking different gaps, LBs blitzing in to the "right" gaps, and the SS reacting much, much quicker to the play. This also provides a penalty to the defense if the offense pulls out a play to the other side, or a pass out of Strong I.

How exactly it should all be coded is a different matter entirely, but for those saying it should be a vision boost, I think you are greatly overvaluing the effects of vision in this game.


I think if vision affects how quick the jump on the ball is, as it's supposed to, then I don't see the issue and think it will help as much as it would in real life. What else is there really to be done?

And if the offense calls run 6 times in a row, the defense creeps, and the offense throws a screen pass? Good gameplanning by the offense.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by Homsar16
Originally posted by bmedders

I don't like the boost to vision. IMO, that isn't realistic. Take the Strong I rush - will a simple boost to vision fix that? I doubt it.

The fix to this involves allowing it to be a team or possibly players setting that says "Modify my assignments when X play is run Y number of times". In the example of the Strong I rush, it would mean DTs attacking different gaps, LBs blitzing in to the "right" gaps, and the SS reacting much, much quicker to the play. This also provides a penalty to the defense if the offense pulls out a play to the other side, or a pass out of Strong I.

How exactly it should all be coded is a different matter entirely, but for those saying it should be a vision boost, I think you are greatly overvaluing the effects of vision in this game.


I think if vision affects how quick the jump on the ball is, as it's supposed to, then I don't see the issue and think it will help as much as it would in real life. What else is there really to be done?

And if the offense calls run 6 times in a row, the defense creeps, and the offense throws a screen pass? Good gameplanning by the offense.


therre shouldn't be a set number, because as homsar eludes too it will eventually be exploited, it should be a constantly growing/evolving multiplier
 
Homsar16
offline
Link
 
I like the idea of the exploit though. I think it's realistic. Say you run over and over on 1st down and get less and less yards. Then in the 2nd half you throw on your 1st first down and get a huge gain. Diminishing returns followed by a big reward, and it all basically evens out. I think it would add a lot to the strategy.
 
23yrwej
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Homsar16
I like the idea of the exploit though. I think it's realistic. Say you run over and over on 1st down and get less and less yards. Then in the 2nd half you throw on your 1st first down and get a huge gain. Diminishing returns followed by a big reward, and it all basically evens out. I think it would add a lot to the strategy.


Makes sense imo
 
Link
 
Originally posted by Homsar16
I like the idea of the exploit though. I think it's realistic. Say you run over and over on 1st down and get less and less yards. Then in the 2nd half you throw on your 1st first down and get a huge gain. Diminishing returns followed by a big reward, and it all basically evens out. I think it would add a lot to the strategy.


yeah I guess it does makes sense, first time I read it over I was on exploit alert, but yeah I realize the strategy aspect of it, I still don't like the set number cuz the surprise element can remain with an evolving multiplier, and would probably create bigger plays from the surprise attack as the defense would be caught totally off guard
 
bmedders
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by jared
Originally posted by Homsar16

I like the idea of the exploit though. I think it's realistic. Say you run over and over on 1st down and get less and less yards. Then in the 2nd half you throw on your 1st first down and get a huge gain. Diminishing returns followed by a big reward, and it all basically evens out. I think it would add a lot to the strategy.


yeah I guess it does makes sense, first time I read it over I was on exploit alert, but yeah I realize the strategy aspect of it, I still don't like the set number cuz the surprise element can remain with an evolving multiplier, and would probably create bigger plays from the surprise attack as the defense would be caught totally off guard


I think a set number is a bad idea in general - BUT - if it were an individual tactic, it would add a lot to gameplanning. It goes back to the vision thing though - that DE with 25 vision? Maybe you don't want him cheating - but the safety with 10 in super vision and 60+ vision? Absolutely.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.