User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > South America A Leagues > South America A #3 > Pro Bowl Voting and End of Year Awards...
Page:
 
oakland360
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Chaka
If you consider missed tackles for the defense and INTs for QBs why not fumbles and drops for HBs and WRs?


because you don't need to consider fumbles for a HB to determine who should and shouldn't be in consideration... by looking at total yards, touchdowns and ypc. Than the choice is easy to make.

Drops could be considered, for WR's, that could be done. But even without drops added to the picture, with just the stats listed, the players who should be there will be easy to spot.

But I considered missed tackles for defensive players, because defensive players on really bad teams will have higher numbers, since they're forced to play on defense more. And by taking into consideration how many tackles they missed. The process of elimination becomes easier.
 
oakland360
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by brettlevy
Originally posted by Chaka

If you consider missed tackles for the defense and INTs for QBs why not fumbles and drops for HBs and WRs?


Probably because Oakland's pride and joy (Darren McDragon) runs with butter on his hands. That's why I didn't vote for him (and the fact that he played against defenders who were more tired). In all fairness, my RB was pretty good this year, but I thought he lost too many fumbles for me to vote for him, too.


sure consider fumbles if you want... but the fact that McDragon scored more TD's than anyone, had a higher average than almost everyone, split time and carries pretty much 50/50 all season long. Would make fumbles a meaningless stat for him anyway. Over 3500 yards, and over 9 ypc as the #2 RB, means he's easily one of the top 2 RB's in the league no matter what. And I didn't even bring in the fact that he has more broken tackles than anyone. Oh and did I forget to mention that he's the only back to put up 100 on pretty much everyone he played this season?

And hate to break it to you, but your vote doesn't count anyway. Your not a GM or owner here. And unfortunately for you, you attached your fortunes to that of GoodBoy who doesn't matter here any longer. Fisher get's no votes. But in all fairness, I still will be putting your FB in the Pro-Bowl because he deserves it.
Last edited Dec 14, 2008 14:38:11
 
brettlevy
offline
Link
 
Easy to break tackles against tired defenders. McDragon is really good, but hasn't proven anything playing against tired guys. Fu Su Lu is your better RB easily
 
oakland360
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by brettlevy
Easy to break tackles against tired defenders. McDragon is really good, but hasn't proven anything playing against tired guys. Fu Su Lu is your better RB easily


Actually ,their builds are almost identical... And they split carries & plays. One plays 1 play, while the other takes a breather. Than they switch. They truly split time 50/50. And being tired for a defense means nothing. Not an excuse when playing on 2nd down. It's not like McDragon only plays in the 2nd half. He plays all game, every other play.

So stop trying to come up with reasons McDragon has stats he does... there isn't another back in this league that could've done what McDragon did this season as the #2 RB for his team. That right there shows why he's in the conversation. For a #2 RB to put up the 2nd most yards in the league with way less carries. For that same RB to score more TD's than any other RB in the league, and have a higher ypc average, and ypg average. Come on now. Those are insane numbers there. You need to give credit where credit is due.

But like I said, since your not a GM or owner here, your opinion really means nothing on this issue.
Last edited Dec 14, 2008 14:49:41
 
pburgh80
offline
Link
 
McDragon has a lot of fumbles for splitting time 50/50. and lost 8 of them, that is not good.
 
oakland360
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by pburgh80
McDragon has a lot of fumbles for splitting time 50/50. and lost 8 of them, that is not good.


Still scored, more... Has more yards... That trumps all, especially when you factor in this stat.

16-0
Last edited Dec 15, 2008 01:19:00
 
PeeJJK
SM4LL
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by oakland360
Originally posted by pburgh80

McDragon has a lot of fumbles for splitting time 50/50. and lost 8 of them, that is not good.


Still scored, more... Has more yards... That trumps all, especially when you factor in this stat.

16-0


No, go home, Fu Su Lu dominates!
 
oakland360
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by GoodBoy
Originally posted by oakland360

Originally posted by pburgh80


McDragon has a lot of fumbles for splitting time 50/50. and lost 8 of them, that is not good.


Still scored, more... Has more yards... That trumps all, especially when you factor in this stat.

16-0


No, go home, Fu Su Lu dominates!


You don't matter here... and it's funny. Cause for someone who doesn't want to be part of this league. You sure do come and post here alot. What's with that? Kinda weird that you say you're happy with your new leagues. But this is where you're spending your time? Ya dude, you make a whole lot of sense there.
Last edited Dec 15, 2008 13:25:34
 
Koi
offline
Link
 
Fumbles or not, Oak's HB was a beast.
 
oakland360
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Koi
Fumbles or not, Oak's HB was a beast.


thank you Koi... since you've been able to get an early peek at his build, you at least have some kinda idea about him unlike the others.
 
Mr. Dumass
offline
Link
 
Did Koi and McDragon have a late night date the 'Rainbow Cattle Room"?
 
pburgh80
offline
Link
 
Tinker will also be submitting a vote. good luck to all of you in the playoffs still.
 
pburgh80
offline
Link
 
offensive

QB HotPotato Harry

RB Flash Stanley
RB Fu Su Lu

FB Ryan Foles

WR Touche Turtle
WR Skeets Grim

TE Tight Goodman

G Guarding Goodman
G Will "Danger" Robinson

OT Mr. Goodcat
OT Philly Cheesesteak

C Out Streched
 
oakland360
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by pburgh80
offensive

QB HotPotato Harry

RB Flash Stanley
RB Fu Su Lu

FB Ryan Foles

WR Touche Turtle
WR Skeets Grim

TE Tight Goodman

G Guarding Goodman
G Will "Danger" Robinson

OT Mr. Goodcat
OT Philly Cheesesteak

C Out Streched


you were supposed to submit the players from your own team you felt were deserving... with the stats listed in the OP to help narrow down the winners.
 
jfischer75
offline
Link
 
My vote (the entire league) I'm DC for the Pirates


offense

QB: Hot Potato Harry (Short Bus Riders)
RB: Paul Thorn (San Juan Scorpions)
RB: Miles "Tails" Prowler (Punata Primates)
FB: Ryan Foles (Fisher Bunnies)
WR: Skeets Grim (Trujillo Demons)
WR: Touche Turtle (Short Bus Riders)
TE: Hans Solo (Amazon Cannibals)
OT: Dave DaBull (Cape Horn Skull Crushers)
OT: Tex Schnellenbaumgardner IV (Fisher Bunnies)
G: Hardcorp Marine (Israel Camel Toes)
G: Mike Rushoder (Medellin Slashers)
C: Fatty McPooper (Rio De Janeiro Titans)


defense

DE - Agent X (Cape Horn Skull Crushers)
DE - Dustin Diamond (Trujillo Demons)
DT - Brick With Eyes (Rio De Janeiro Titans)
NT - Jay Jones (Trujillo Demons)
OLB - Killa Killer (Trujillo Demons)
OLB - Jack Lambertson (Rio De Janeiro Titans)
MLB - Yen Ayukawa (Ciudad del Este Golden Jaguars)
CB - Sooner Calhoun (Cape Horn Skull Crushers)
CB - Rob Samuel (Porto Alegre Hitmen)
FS - Tiger Force Jr. ( Winsted Crew)
SS - Clueless Joe ( Tallinn Nightmare)

ST

K - Jarryd Bridges Jr. (Cape Horn Skull Crushers)
P - Bill Wallace (Short Bus Riders)
KR - Downtown Timmy Brown (Cape Horn Skull Crushers)
PR - Percy Garritt (Fisher Bunnies)
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.