User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Goal Line Blitz > New promotion chart flaw
Page:
 
DavyJonesLocker
Arrrrrgh!!
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Painmaker
Originally posted by sturge

Postseason scrimmage wins (not friendlies)
Postseason scrimmage ties (not friendlies)

These should be moved to 13 and 14. Scrimmage games are not more important than playoff games!


Not really the focus of this thread, but since you mentioned it: would it make you happier if Bort changed the name to "playoff consolation bracket games" since that's what they are?

You go into the season knowing the rules for promotion... arguing that games shouldn't be important because you don't think they are important doesn't make sense. Obviously they are important, since they might determine whether or not a team promotes.




As for the OP I can't say as to whether any of the league separations is so huge that it creates a significant disincentive for earning promotion because I don't know enough about the various leagues in question. I do agree that such disincentive would be a bad thing if it exists. The different league levels should be close enough that promoted teams generally have a reasonable opportunity to make the playoffs. That doesn't mean every promoted team should make the playoffs at the next level, nor should they expect to be #1 undefeated seeds at the next level.

I'd say the most elegant way to make this happen is to find a mechanism that encourages economic stratification by league; that is, make league level be the most heavily-weighted factor for determining a team's income so that all teams in a league have the chance to recruit and retain similar talent. Best way to do that is to make tickets and concessions - which are dependent on stadium size - become less dominant in determining income. One method could be to offer seasonal "TV contracts" which make up something like 50% of the league's total income. That way teams with maxed out stadiums only make something like 30% more than teams with small stadiums, but AA teams make measurably more money than A teams.


Originally posted by Randy03Texags
Yep .. Painmaker is right, the issue with FA is two fold, all these lowbie teams can afford to pay L40s, so people go to lowbie leagues like USA BBB to "pwn newbs" and work their way up, that shouldnt be an option.

Pro leagues just arent that different than the rest of the tiers and thats an issue, sure .. most players of a high caliber want to play for Pro level teams, but really there should be no choice, they need to follow the money like it should be.

L40 gear is the driving factor right now in forcing people to large budget teams, but a lot of these contracts are also one year mercenary contracts where the team is at the mercy of the player because of the FA market being as open as it is, pretty much any team can pay these players .. a LOT of high level players and therefore dominate their league.

Painmaker offers a reason that you would want to play in Pro leagues, they are the only ones that can pay you, not level caps .. level caps are pretty dumb, because there are minimal to no level caps on low leagues.


Painmaker, the issue isn't so much being out leveled. It's the money. As Randyo3Texas eluded to with level 40 equipment and level 32 for that matter, some teams just can't afford to pay that. It's not because they were frivolous with their spending and had no financial plan, it's because before season 6 and the league reshuffle new owners got no money and no seats to plant butts in.




Last edited Dec 12, 2008 08:11:44
 
Eamz
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by mantis7
This is a huge concern of mine...If I get promoted into a league where everyone is in their 30's and my whole team is 20-ish......my choices are:

1) gut my whole team during the offseason and scramble to find a new team (which I am not going to do, as I have come to know and like my agents)

2)Be a losing team and play catchup for who knows how long?

AM I missing something or is this a really bad flaw in the game?

(Making 1st season 13 cap team winners go straight into uncapped leagues)


Or instead you could look at this for the long term and keep a core set of players and slowly add in a high lvl free agent here and there that will help your team. I hate to tell all the capped 13 team owners this, but you aren't going to win every year. It would be nice, but it's not gonna happen.

If you win and get promoted your first year, add a 2 or 3 level 30s (yes you may have to get creative when you recruit), and win 4-5 games. The next year get 2 or 3 more level 30s and you'll win 6-8 games and maybe even make the playoffs.

Be honest with your players from the beginning and they will understand you are building a long term focused team instead of a 1-year wonder and they will respect you for it - they may not like getting benched, but they signed knowing it could happen.
 
Kirghiz
offline
Link
 
To be honest, you can compete every season. You won't go undefeated, but you can be a playoff team every year if you know what you are doing. The thing is, most 13 capped teams that have the potential of being promoted can beat the bottom 8 teams in the conference above them by the end of the season when their players are in the level 21-23 range. My WEBBB team has beaten an 8-8 team from USA BBB and a 6-10 team from Canada A in scrimmages this season. Secondly, with CPU realignment now, the two best teams on average in the conference you are getting promoted to are getting promoted themselves, so you won't have to face them. What is more, there are teams that have gotten promoted and went on and won the championship again the next season.

If you get promoted, you should very easily be able to go 8-8 in the following season, but 13-3 or 12-4 is just as possible.
 
Seth0194
offline
Link
 
I agree with the whole lvl thing, it would suck to move from a lvl capped league to uncapped so as I see it there's one of a few options.

1- Bort needs to advance teams moving up some extra money (call it a endorsement money for moving into a new league) This way the teams who move up who are down 2 million to 35 million can compete with salaries and still build stadium sections.

2- If you have a team with some good agents and you don't want to look for new ones you all will have to suck it up and rebuild for a season or two. This happens all the time in this sport.

3- You cant be dominate all the time, if you think you can then you aren't in it for competition, you just want to beat down teams, Competition is always on the up and up.


I should include I'm against the move ups, (I know Bort has to do something about all the CPU teams) Im just not sure this is the right thing to do.
 
Kirghiz
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Kirghiz
To be honest, you can compete every season. You won't go undefeated, but you can be a playoff team every year if you know what you are doing. The thing is, most 13 capped teams that have the potential of being promoted can beat the bottom 8 teams in the conference above them by the end of the season when their players are in the level 21-23 range. My WEBBB team has beaten an 8-8 team from USA BBB and a 6-10 team from Canada A in scrimmages this season. Secondly, with CPU realignment now, the two best teams on average in the conference you are getting promoted to are getting promoted themselves, so you won't have to face them. What is more, there are teams that have gotten promoted and went on and won the championship again the next season.

If you get promoted, you should very easily be able to go 8-8 in the following season, but 13-3 or 12-4 is just as possible.


To add to this, check out this league:
http://goallineblitz.com/game/league.pl?league_id=107

Toronto Peace, Queensland Exiles, Kodiak Bears, South Park Pee Wee (Gutted after being promoted), and Revelstoke Rebels all were promoted to this league this season. With the exception of South Park who were sold back, none of them look like they are just getting killed in their new league.

I really don't see this being a big deal to be honest.


Last edited Dec 12, 2008 09:22:21
 
DavyJonesLocker
Arrrrrgh!!
offline
Link
 
I guess you guys really aren't following along very well here. It's a money issue, not a level cap issue. All the level capped teams started out on a level playing field.

Teams like mine, that took over a team before season 6 and the big league re-shuffling were in a league with teams already having a foundation and stability. Some teamsNOT IN CAPPED LEAGUES started out with less than $1,000,000 and 2400 seats in Leagues that had teams with $6,000,000 and the whole lower bowl completed.

Now if said team struggled their asses off to build a good team and be competitive to the level where they could get promoted, then a promotion would just kill those teams. Now they will be elevated to a group who has been around even longer than the competition they just faced the season before. A group who's ticket revenue is even greater than the competition the season before. This is still the same team who 2 season prior had $200,000 and 2400 seats to start off with.

See the difference?
Last edited Dec 12, 2008 09:37:56
 
Kirghiz
offline
Link
 
Sure, there is a money difference, but it really isn't a big deal because these teams still have to recruit the talent to be able to spend the money on the talent. Most of these "rich" teams aren't replacing 20 of their players with high priced talent every offseason. The ones that do, well you will lose to them and than you won't have to face them next season after they get promoted.

Smart owners on capped teams are spending every dime they can on stadium upgrades anyway, and at some point they'll catch up to the league above them. If you look around at the league above you, you'll probably see half those teams have very negligible stadiums, and only the best teams have the big stadiums. The best teams of course are the ones getting promoted, so again, you won't face them. Moving from BBB to A isn't that big of a jump financially.
 
Link
 
I'm curious about one thing, does anyone take into account RL money? No one likes stupid buys so why would you honestly pay to lose for a few seasons just to build up funds? Don't get me wrong I'm waiting on a team as well for 4 seasons to start out with but is it really necessary to get crushed off the bat without any real hope? I used to be decent with money to throw away but not anymore maybe 2009 will be better for the economy and me.

I bet the Admin(s) can figure this out in time as it would be nice to build to something without wasting money waiting to get to the right league.
 
blkwdw13
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by harshmellow
Originally posted by leenad

I disagree with all of you... My team was in a capped league last year and just got promoted to uncapped Africa AA. We are the 4th place seed going into the playoffs.


For every team like that there are 10 more that get beat on all year. My WR is on this team http://goallineblitz.com/game/team.pl?team_id=5382 that got promoted straight from a first year capped league into an uncapped league where most of the teams were in their mid-30s. Not a single game against those teams was competitive all season and the team is probably disbanding this offseason because it's just no fun.


This is wrong also just look at this league http://goallineblitz.com/game/league.pl?league_id=86 they had ten promotions and nine of them are very competitive with all but two making the playoffs in their first season of promotion. Some gutted there teams and some kept most of their roster so it works both ways.
 
thechief
offline
Link
 
Just saw this thread, I started a suggestion thread about this:

http://goallineblitz.com/game/forum_thread.pl?thread_id=1615357
 
Modok
offline
Link
 
While I agree with the OP's point, it's not impossible. We promoted out of Canada BBB last season and just finished 12-4 in Canada A. We will also have every section in the stadium completed with the exception of the 3rd level come Day 1 of next season.
 
jsully75
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Modok
While I agree with the OP's point, it's not impossible. We promoted out of Canada BBB last season and just finished 12-4 in Canada A. We will also have every section in the stadium completed with the exception of the 3rd level come Day 1 of next season.


Actually, I GM on a capped team from last season in Africa A that went to AA. There were 2 other teams promoted with us from Africa A3. Of those 3 teams all of them are in the playoffs and 2 of the three have home playoff games. In fact, one of the other promoted teams will also have a home playoff game, so out of 8 home playoff spots almost half are going to teams that were capped the previous season and still have almost the same roster.

Also, we will have all of the stadium excluding the 300 level.
Last edited Dec 12, 2008 10:17:43
 
jsully75
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by jsully75
Originally posted by Modok

While I agree with the OP's point, it's not impossible. We promoted out of Canada BBB last season and just finished 12-4 in Canada A. We will also have every section in the stadium completed with the exception of the 3rd level come Day 1 of next season.


Actually, I GM on a capped team from last season in Africa A that went to AA. There were 2 other teams promoted with us from Africa A3. Of those 3 teams all of them are in the playoffs and 2 of the three have home playoff games. In fact, one of the other promoted teams will also have a home playoff game, so out of 8 home playoff spots almost half are going to teams that were capped the previous season and still have almost the same roster.

Also, we will have all of the stadium excluding the 300 level.


So looking it looks like 5 out of seven promoted teams will be in the playoffs in Africa AA2, without major roster changes.
 
Kirghiz
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by jsully75

So looking it looks like 5 out of seven promoted teams will be in the playoffs in Africa AA2, without major roster changes.


In conclusion, some people just like to freak out when they hear the word "promotion" tossed around when it pertains to their team, but it really isn't a big deal.

[/thread]
 
thechief
offline
Link
 
Forcing a capped team going to an uncapped league forces a team to:
a) Play from behind for a season or more (level, current money, and stadium size)
b) recruit alot of upper level players so that they can compete immediately ... thus negating his whole "try to stay with the same team" concept he's trying to achieve.
Last edited Dec 12, 2008 10:29:49
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.