Originally posted by Painmaker
Originally posted by sturge
Postseason scrimmage wins (not friendlies)
Postseason scrimmage ties (not friendlies)
These should be moved to 13 and 14. Scrimmage games are not more important than playoff games!
Not really the focus of this thread, but since you mentioned it: would it make you happier if Bort changed the name to "playoff consolation bracket games" since that's what they are?
You go into the season knowing the rules for promotion... arguing that games shouldn't be important because you don't think they are important doesn't make sense. Obviously they are important, since they might determine whether or not a team promotes.
As for the OP I can't say as to whether any of the league separations is so huge that it creates a significant disincentive for earning promotion because I don't know enough about the various leagues in question. I do agree that such disincentive would be a bad thing if it exists. The different league levels should be close enough that promoted teams generally have a reasonable opportunity to make the playoffs. That doesn't mean every promoted team should make the playoffs at the next level, nor should they expect to be #1 undefeated seeds at the next level.
I'd say the most elegant way to make this happen is to find a mechanism that encourages economic stratification by league; that is, make league level be the most heavily-weighted factor for determining a team's income so that all teams in a league have the chance to recruit and retain similar talent. Best way to do that is to make tickets and concessions - which are dependent on stadium size - become less dominant in determining income. One method could be to offer seasonal "TV contracts" which make up something like 50% of the league's total income. That way teams with maxed out stadiums only make something like 30% more than teams with small stadiums, but AA teams make measurably more money than A teams.
Originally posted by Randy03Texags
Yep .. Painmaker is right, the issue with FA is two fold, all these lowbie teams can afford to pay L40s, so people go to lowbie leagues like USA BBB to "pwn newbs" and work their way up, that shouldnt be an option.
Pro leagues just arent that different than the rest of the tiers and thats an issue, sure .. most players of a high caliber want to play for Pro level teams, but really there should be no choice, they need to follow the money like it should be.
L40 gear is the driving factor right now in forcing people to large budget teams, but a lot of these contracts are also one year mercenary contracts where the team is at the mercy of the player because of the FA market being as open as it is, pretty much any team can pay these players .. a LOT of high level players and therefore dominate their league.
Painmaker offers a reason that you would want to play in Pro leagues, they are the only ones that can pay you, not level caps .. level caps are pretty dumb, because there are minimal to no level caps on low leagues.
Painmaker, the issue isn't so much being out leveled. It's the money. As Randyo3Texas eluded to with level 40 equipment and level 32 for that matter, some teams just can't afford to pay that. It's not because they were frivolous with their spending and had no financial plan, it's because before season 6 and the league reshuffle new owners got no money and no seats to plant butts in.
Originally posted by sturge
Postseason scrimmage wins (not friendlies)
Postseason scrimmage ties (not friendlies)
These should be moved to 13 and 14. Scrimmage games are not more important than playoff games!
Not really the focus of this thread, but since you mentioned it: would it make you happier if Bort changed the name to "playoff consolation bracket games" since that's what they are?
You go into the season knowing the rules for promotion... arguing that games shouldn't be important because you don't think they are important doesn't make sense. Obviously they are important, since they might determine whether or not a team promotes.
As for the OP I can't say as to whether any of the league separations is so huge that it creates a significant disincentive for earning promotion because I don't know enough about the various leagues in question. I do agree that such disincentive would be a bad thing if it exists. The different league levels should be close enough that promoted teams generally have a reasonable opportunity to make the playoffs. That doesn't mean every promoted team should make the playoffs at the next level, nor should they expect to be #1 undefeated seeds at the next level.
I'd say the most elegant way to make this happen is to find a mechanism that encourages economic stratification by league; that is, make league level be the most heavily-weighted factor for determining a team's income so that all teams in a league have the chance to recruit and retain similar talent. Best way to do that is to make tickets and concessions - which are dependent on stadium size - become less dominant in determining income. One method could be to offer seasonal "TV contracts" which make up something like 50% of the league's total income. That way teams with maxed out stadiums only make something like 30% more than teams with small stadiums, but AA teams make measurably more money than A teams.
Originally posted by Randy03Texags
Yep .. Painmaker is right, the issue with FA is two fold, all these lowbie teams can afford to pay L40s, so people go to lowbie leagues like USA BBB to "pwn newbs" and work their way up, that shouldnt be an option.
Pro leagues just arent that different than the rest of the tiers and thats an issue, sure .. most players of a high caliber want to play for Pro level teams, but really there should be no choice, they need to follow the money like it should be.
L40 gear is the driving factor right now in forcing people to large budget teams, but a lot of these contracts are also one year mercenary contracts where the team is at the mercy of the player because of the FA market being as open as it is, pretty much any team can pay these players .. a LOT of high level players and therefore dominate their league.
Painmaker offers a reason that you would want to play in Pro leagues, they are the only ones that can pay you, not level caps .. level caps are pretty dumb, because there are minimal to no level caps on low leagues.
Painmaker, the issue isn't so much being out leveled. It's the money. As Randyo3Texas eluded to with level 40 equipment and level 32 for that matter, some teams just can't afford to pay that. It's not because they were frivolous with their spending and had no financial plan, it's because before season 6 and the league reshuffle new owners got no money and no seats to plant butts in.
Last edited Dec 12, 2008 08:11:44






























