User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Page:
 
aeakers
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by deez11010
I believe hurries do effect QBs.

This game, my QB threw 6 INTs. While only 1 INT was when an actual hurry was recorded. I think they "rattle" the QB or something.

Hurried 26 times, sacked 8, 54.4% completion, threw 6 INTs with 50+ confidence.
http://goallineblitz.com/game/game.pl?game_id=249960

Before this game he was only sacked twice, had only 6 INTs and a 70%+ completion for the season. That game killed his stats.
http://goallineblitz.com/game/player.pl?player_id=619937

I think hurries effect the QB just fine.


Probably not the hurries. I'm guessing it was the sacks.
 
iMan
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by nixa37
What makes you think that a hurry means you hit the QB while he was throwing? Many times a hurry can just mean that the QB had someone closing in on him when he got rid of the ball.


he is just gets rid of the ball then it should lead to more int
 
ruleslawyer
offline
Link
 
Totally glossing over that most of those throws were between 16-24 yards. In addition to that, none of the hurried passes were uncatchable. Now, put in a vacuum, 54.5% completion might not sound bad but think about that a moment. This guy was 6 of 11 for 160 yards and a TD with 0 INTs when hurried. 22 of 40 for the game, 16 of 29 for 234 yards and 3 INTs when not hurried.

Just seems kinda odd.


Originally posted by Jack Del Rio
Meh out of 11 attempts, 54.5% completion seems well within the realm of what QBs can do when hurried. The result of the play after the catch (like if one goes for a TD) probably happens independently of whether or not there is a hurry. And needless to say it's possible to build a QB to perform well when hurried (I'd say most QBs make a pretty decent investment in vision, confidence, and pocket presence).


Last edited Dec 5, 2008 19:10:31
 
Sarg01
offline
Link
 
What I don't get is why GLB QB's almost never completely miss their guy when hurried. Not deflected, not dropped, just plain incomplete. That happens a few times per game to even the absolute best NFL QBs.
 
Octowned
offline
Link
 
Right, my biggest problem is that no passes are ever INCOMPLETE. It's always right on target, and up to the CB/WR interaction to see what happens. QB's under pressure miss the target. Heck, QBs under pressure dump the ball, toss it out of bounds, etc. Not even programmed into GLB.
 
SWVAHoo
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Sarg01
What I don't get is why GLB QB's almost never completely miss their guy when hurried. Not deflected, not dropped, just plain incomplete. That happens a few times per game to even the absolute best NFL QBs.


This, exactly.
 
pedro617
offline
Link
 
I'm a first year DC so I haven't been doing this for to long, but i'd have to disagree here. I took over the DC job a couple weeks after the season started and totally changed our defense around. We weren't getting any pressure on the QB for the most part when I took over. Ever since then I've been slowly adjusting the AI, and I've seen an increase in PD, int, and yes some incomplete passes that had no chance to be caught. Grant it theres only been a couple of those. I've noticed that the QBs are passing the ball much sooner now then earlier in the season, and their completion percentage seems to be down a bit. Its mostly been off of hurries to, we're still not getting to many sacks though.

We'll see if the trend I'm noticing holds true or not. Especially in the playoffs when I can compare that game against the on earlier in the season. That is of course if we play one of those teams we played before I took over.

It would be interesting to see a team play their normal gameplan against a weak opponent, and not blitz at all against another. They would have to be farily similar for it to work thug. If theres a big differnece in the QBs #s or if theres not, it would be very telling imo.
 
Strokke
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Octowned
Right, my biggest problem is that no passes are ever INCOMPLETE. It's always right on target, and up to the CB/WR interaction to see what happens. QB's under pressure miss the target. Heck, QBs under pressure dump the ball, toss it out of bounds, etc. Not even programmed into GLB.


Epic suggestion
 
chief31
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by pedro617
I'm a first year DC so I haven't been doing this for to long, but i'd have to disagree here. I took over the DC job a couple weeks after the season started and totally changed our defense around. We weren't getting any pressure on the QB for the most part when I took over. Ever since then I've been slowly adjusting the AI, and I've seen an increase in PD, int, and yes some incomplete passes that had no chance to be caught. Grant it theres only been a couple of those. I've noticed that the QBs are passing the ball much sooner now then earlier in the season, and their completion percentage seems to be down a bit. Its mostly been off of hurries to, we're still not getting to many sacks though.

We'll see if the trend I'm noticing holds true or not. Especially in the playoffs when I can compare that game against the on earlier in the season. That is of course if we play one of those teams we played before I took over.

It would be interesting to see a team play their normal gameplan against a weak opponent, and not blitz at all against another. They would have to be farily similar for it to work thug. If theres a big differnece in the QBs #s or if theres not, it would be very telling imo.


In your last game, a 104-3 win, the opponents QB was Hurried four times. He went 4-4, on those four plays. http://goallineblitz.com/game/game.pl?game_id=250987

In the previous game, against The Pekin Dragons, there were two Hurries, with a 50% completion mark. One percent lower than their overall completion percentage for the game. http://goallineblitz.com/game/game.pl?game_id=250986

Against The Seoul Redemption you had seven hurries, with three going for completions. That is 42.8%. Right on pace with their overall for the game, of 42.9. http://goallineblitz.com/game/game.pl?game_id=250985

The previous game had the opponent (Chappell Island Tiger Snakes) go 3/5 for 60% while Hurried. A slight upgrade from the overall of 58.6%. http://goallineblitz.com/game/game.pl?game_id=250984

I am done evaluating your claims there.

Having gone 11/18 while hurried(61%), against 73/148 overall(49.3%), over your last four games, I just don't see where you are coming from.

Also, just for the record, none of those 18 hurried attempts were intercepted (0%). While 5 of the overall 148 attempts were intercepted. (3.4%)

Hell, I'll even add your teams numbers through the same four games.

When hurried, your teams QBs went 4/5 (80%), with two TDs. Overall, they were 99/131(75.6%)

It seems, from those numbers, that opposing QBs are doing better when they are hurried.


Also, just for the record, none of those 18 hurried attempts were intercepted (0%). While 5 of the overall 148 attempts were intercepted. (3.4%)

Hell, I'll even add your teams numbers through the same four games.

When hurried, your teams QBs went 4/5 (80%), with two TDs. Overall, they were 99/131(75.6%)



Last edited Dec 5, 2008 23:37:58
 
PDO
offline
Link
 
Glad to see that this has gained a lot of discussion... I just can't help believe that (perhaps due to SA's?) hurries are hurting defenses. I posted this in the bug forum rather than suggestions because I think it's clear to anyone who has watched football at any level that getting pressure on the QB is a GOOD thing for the defense.

In this game, unless it's a sack, it's a bad thing.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by PDO
I posted this in the bug forum rather than suggestions because I think it's clear to anyone who has watched football at any level that getting pressure on the QB is a GOOD thing for the defense.

In this game, unless it's a sack, it's a bad thing.


agreed! hurries are muted in this game and the passing game is overpowered. this game does feel like success/failure comes from a sack or nothing. also deflections are meant to put the ball away from the receiver, no? well there have been numerous instances where the ball is deflected and it lands in the hands of the catcher

its frustrating to say the least
 
Oborona
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by greengoose
There are a couple issues with the passing game in my book.

1) Sticky Hands should not make receivers even better on 3rd down than it already makes them on 1st and 2nd down. Clutch players are already very good players who continue that same level of performance when everybody else struggles to in clutch situations - they are not even better than they normally could possibly be. This is part of the reasons teams complete a lot of 3rd down passes and convert 1st downs when they couldn't hit the broad side of a barn in the game otherwise.

2) Pocket Presence negates the effects of Hurries too much.

3) QB's complete way too many passes off their back foot - i.e. running backwards to avoid the sack (leading to the hurry) and still completing 30 yard passes downfield. In most cases in real football if a QB throws continuously off his back foot there are a LOT of ducks flying around the stadium that day.


+1 to everything



 
Darkstrand
offline
Link
 
I'm pretty sure it's because your DE was exposed as a paper tiger that can't perform in the clutch that causes the QBs to not be intimidated.

Ho Playbook has no troubles with hurries intimidating the QB:
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=219342&pbp_id=8951130
 
El_Windex
Baby Executive
offline
Link
 
I've been thinking lately that it was pointless to get pressure because it really wasn't helping unless it was a sack. Glad to see the numbers agree.

+1
 
Link
 
Originally posted by El_Windex
I've been thinking lately that it was pointless to get pressure because it really wasn't helping unless it was a sack. Glad to see the numbers agree.

+1


I've been thinking about your mom lately.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.