User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Suggestions > Teams Attempting to Exploit the System
Page:
 
SWVAHoo
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by greengoose

I'm talking both ends of the spectrum here - i.e. the GLB landscape. If a team players are built well enough to otherwise stop the play if properly positioned a Vision boost might help. The Detroit Lions analogy is the other end of the spectrum.

This change would affect both types of teams - problem is the latter teams would be looking for this to aid them in stopping the opposition but in reality it won't help much.

The real issue is player positioning. There are only two elements that control that - pre-snap formation and in-game Vision. Any in-game changes to that I'd be all for - any changes which make a player physically better than he'd normally be as the game goes on just to compensate for an inability to otherwise stop a play I'm not.

The argument this thread started with is very much like the SA's that give a boost to WR's on 3rd down plays (Sticky Hands) - I'm against them too.

If a guy who otherwise doesn't have the skillset to consistently catch passes on 1st and 2nd down with Sticky Hands- why is he getting an additional boost on 3rd down to his catching ability? That makes absolutely no sense - a clutch player doesn't suddenly learn how to catch in the clutch, he's an already good player that continues that level of performance in the clutch when others crumble. Increase Morale on 3rd down fine - increase Catching ability on 3rd down - that makes no sense.


If vision works as it's actually intended to work (and I'm fairly sure it doesn't), then I'd be more than content to give an in-game increase to vision, granted that the defensive player is literally seeing the same formation in front of him over and over. Perhaps confidence, as he makes the logical connection and becomes more sure of it with each repeated play.
Last edited Dec 5, 2008 01:07:34
 
Ashe
offline
Link
 
In RL players gain experience, and the more they play – and the more plays they face – the more they know what to expect and what to do. The down side of this is the very experienced players get old and simply don't have the physical qualities to do what their brains, via experience, tell their bodies to do.

Seems to me that GLB players should be able to increment their "plays experience" as they get older. This may be a fractional and gradual development and while it doesn't stop an opponent relying on the same plays over and over, older players should have some sort of slowly gained ability to play better. It could be a vision thing, or it could be a small ability to react quicker if the player has encountered that play before.

I'm not sure if there are enough plays and formations yet to make the reaction idea viable, but an increase in vision through experience may work.
 
tautology
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by flames54
Originally posted by Ken1

Originally posted by SteelersInsider


not a new idea, but a good one.

the %'s are WAAAAAAAAAY too high though.

All the messing around with the chemistry bar only has a total effect of 6% I think. I don't think it should even be 10% to attributes. In fact, it should be limited to VISION increase.

Something like a 1% increase in vision for all defenders each time a play is run sounds like the best way.


Fully agree. It should be a Vision increase only.

If it's a Vision increase only, then the numbers are reasonable (as long as the "boost for the rest of the game" means only against that play).


For all I care you can boost the defenses vision to 10000 and it still won't stop the Strong I run.

DD laughed last time I suggested something similar to this, and took the thread off track with his bullshit.

I've been posting for 3 or 4 seasons now about that ONE running play that we all know of to no response from any of the Devs.

It's a game and if you can't code it properly to handle certain plays, take them the fuck out of figure a way to penalize the hell out of a team that keeps running that play over and over.

The vision bonus for realism has no place against exploitation but it deserves some merit in regular gameplay against plays run on a fairly consistent basis with the hitch being it makes play calls that are for instance a play action give the defense a vision penalty if the bonus is in affect against the "more common" play.


Flames is living in the past...the Strong I play is not productive enough for wide exploitation, except perhaps amongst the very strongest running teams who can have the same effect with any number of plays.

The concept of adding a vision bonus (and possibly other bonuses as well)to a defense who sees a play repeatedly (specific numbers are left vague intentionally) is very good.

Bort should be careful to ensure balance in any such implementation.

+1
 
greengoose
offline
Link
 
Lets just say I still have nightmares from the effects that Vision had on my pulling guard a couple of seasons ago. He was better off with no Vision.
 
tautology
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by GG

But yes...the problem which this thread is addressing as well is that whole lack of in-game adjustments.


It took a lot of editing to dig out, but GG finally suggested something useful and relevant.


Dramatically uncreative play-calling should be rewarded by an AI that automatically adjusts towards shutting down 1-play offenses. Let's not take it too far...remember that the playbook is still a somewhat limited volume...though there do seem to be enough plays to have a varied offense of many descriptions at this point. Thanks Bort!

Last edited Dec 5, 2008 01:19:14
 
GG
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by tautology
Originally posted by GG


But yes...the problem which this thread is addressing as well is that whole lack of in-game adjustments.


It took a lot of editing to dig out, but GG finally suggested something useful and relevant.


Dramatically uncreative play-calling should be rewarded by an AI that automatically adjusts towards shutting down 1-play offenses. Let's not take it too far...remember that the playbook is still a somewhat limited volume...though there do seem to be enough plays to have a varied offense of many descriptions at this point. Thanks Bort!



Thank-you. I am genuinely humbled to have received a little accolade from you! lol. I'm cool with you, bro.

Last edited Dec 5, 2008 01:20:37
 
GG
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by greengoose

I'm talking both ends of the spectrum here - i.e. the GLB landscape. If a team players are built well enough to otherwise stop the play if properly positioned a Vision boost might help. The Detroit Lions analogy is the other end of the spectrum.

This change would affect both types of teams - problem is the latter teams would be looking for this to aid them in stopping the opposition but in reality it won't help much.

The real issue is player positioning. There are only two elements that control that - pre-snap formation and in-game Vision. Any in-game changes to that I'd be all for - any changes which make a player physically better than he'd normally be as the game goes on just to compensate for an inability to otherwise stop a play I'm not.

The argument this thread started with is very much like the SA's that give a boost to WR's on 3rd down plays (Sticky Hands) - I'm against them too.

If a guy who otherwise doesn't have the skillset to consistently catch passes on 1st and 2nd down with Sticky Hands- why is he getting an additional boost on 3rd down to his catching ability? That makes absolutely no sense - a clutch player doesn't suddenly learn how to catch in the clutch, he's an already good player that continues that level of performance in the clutch when others crumble. Increase Morale on 3rd down fine - increase Catching ability on 3rd down - that makes no sense.


I think this is a good post too. Good points made regarding the sticky hands. There's a lot of room for improvement imo with how the whole SAs exists, and what things they specifically give. Should be focused more on skills achieved/unlocked, rather than boosts and bonuses.
 
greengoose
offline
Link
 
Any SA that gives a boost to a physical type skill (that includes Carrying, Catching, Blocking and Tackling) is fine - but that boost needs to be constant no matter what the down or distance is.

If they want to increase the likelihood of "clutch play" then that needs to come in the form of Morale or Vision.
 
flames54
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by tautology
Originally posted by flames54

Originally posted by Ken1


Originally posted by SteelersInsider



not a new idea, but a good one.

the %'s are WAAAAAAAAAY too high though.

All the messing around with the chemistry bar only has a total effect of 6% I think. I don't think it should even be 10% to attributes. In fact, it should be limited to VISION increase.

Something like a 1% increase in vision for all defenders each time a play is run sounds like the best way.


Fully agree. It should be a Vision increase only.

If it's a Vision increase only, then the numbers are reasonable (as long as the "boost for the rest of the game" means only against that play).


For all I care you can boost the defenses vision to 10000 and it still won't stop the Strong I run.

DD laughed last time I suggested something similar to this, and took the thread off track with his bullshit.

I've been posting for 3 or 4 seasons now about that ONE running play that we all know of to no response from any of the Devs.

It's a game and if you can't code it properly to handle certain plays, take them the fuck out of figure a way to penalize the hell out of a team that keeps running that play over and over.

The vision bonus for realism has no place against exploitation but it deserves some merit in regular gameplay against plays run on a fairly consistent basis with the hitch being it makes play calls that are for instance a play action give the defense a vision penalty if the bonus is in affect against the "more common" play.


Flames is living in the past...the Strong I play is not productive enough for wide exploitation, except perhaps amongst the very strongest running teams who can have the same effect with any number of plays.

The concept of adding a vision bonus (and possibly other bonuses as well)to a defense who sees a play repeatedly (specific numbers are left vague intentionally) is very good.

Bort should be careful to ensure balance in any such implementation.

+1


Call it living in the past all you want but it doesn't change the fact that the plays been broken forever and everybody has rose colored glasses on when they talk about solutions to it.

http://goallineblitz.com/game/team.pl?team_id=1509 is the perfect example, that is ALL they run yet they don't get stopped and even though it will probably happen in the playoffs something needs to be done to stop this kind of play.

 
greengoose
offline
Link
 
I gotta agree with Flames54 here - if an entire Pro league knows a team is only running 1 play and nobody can stop it - I'd say that play constitutes an overpowered play.

We are beyond talking about builds at that point.
Last edited Dec 5, 2008 01:39:41
 
flames54
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by greengoose
I gotta agree with Flames54 here - if an entire Pro league knows a team is only running 1 play and nobody can stop it - I'd say that play constitutes an overpowered play.

We are beyond talking about builds at that point.


Just because it can be stopped with a ton of experimentation, near perfect builds and some luck doesn't make it a balanced play. If a runs one play all game it really should not be very hard to stop.
 
Link
 
The NFL needs to penalize the Broncos and that zone blocking shit they do/did because it was too powerful. Any shitty RB they put in there got 5 ypc. That is unrealistic.

The NFL is borked. lolNFLdots.


2000+ yard rushing for T.Davis? lol. That is unrealistic.
 
flames54
offline
Link
 
Exactly the attitude that prevents this game from getting better.
 
SWVAHoo
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by flames54
Exactly the attitude that prevents this game from getting better.


Agreed.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by flames54
Exactly the attitude that prevents this game from getting better.


don't give me that shit. I've done as much as you to help this game get better.

Making it so that any shitty defense with any shitty builds can stop every play isn't the answer either.

Bort isn't an idiot. He probably has yards per play averages on each play when he tests them. He knows that he could probably stand to have a defense that is better against the run. I'm sure he is working on it. Chill out.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.