Originally posted by greengoose
I'm talking both ends of the spectrum here - i.e. the GLB landscape. If a team players are built well enough to otherwise stop the play if properly positioned a Vision boost might help. The Detroit Lions analogy is the other end of the spectrum.
This change would affect both types of teams - problem is the latter teams would be looking for this to aid them in stopping the opposition but in reality it won't help much.
The real issue is player positioning. There are only two elements that control that - pre-snap formation and in-game Vision. Any in-game changes to that I'd be all for - any changes which make a player physically better than he'd normally be as the game goes on just to compensate for an inability to otherwise stop a play I'm not.
The argument this thread started with is very much like the SA's that give a boost to WR's on 3rd down plays (Sticky Hands) - I'm against them too.
If a guy who otherwise doesn't have the skillset to consistently catch passes on 1st and 2nd down with Sticky Hands- why is he getting an additional boost on 3rd down to his catching ability? That makes absolutely no sense - a clutch player doesn't suddenly learn how to catch in the clutch, he's an already good player that continues that level of performance in the clutch when others crumble. Increase Morale on 3rd down fine - increase Catching ability on 3rd down - that makes no sense.
If vision works as it's actually intended to work (and I'm fairly sure it doesn't), then I'd be more than content to give an in-game increase to vision, granted that the defensive player is literally seeing the same formation in front of him over and over. Perhaps confidence, as he makes the logical connection and becomes more sure of it with each repeated play.
I'm talking both ends of the spectrum here - i.e. the GLB landscape. If a team players are built well enough to otherwise stop the play if properly positioned a Vision boost might help. The Detroit Lions analogy is the other end of the spectrum.
This change would affect both types of teams - problem is the latter teams would be looking for this to aid them in stopping the opposition but in reality it won't help much.
The real issue is player positioning. There are only two elements that control that - pre-snap formation and in-game Vision. Any in-game changes to that I'd be all for - any changes which make a player physically better than he'd normally be as the game goes on just to compensate for an inability to otherwise stop a play I'm not.
The argument this thread started with is very much like the SA's that give a boost to WR's on 3rd down plays (Sticky Hands) - I'm against them too.
If a guy who otherwise doesn't have the skillset to consistently catch passes on 1st and 2nd down with Sticky Hands- why is he getting an additional boost on 3rd down to his catching ability? That makes absolutely no sense - a clutch player doesn't suddenly learn how to catch in the clutch, he's an already good player that continues that level of performance in the clutch when others crumble. Increase Morale on 3rd down fine - increase Catching ability on 3rd down - that makes no sense.
If vision works as it's actually intended to work (and I'm fairly sure it doesn't), then I'd be more than content to give an in-game increase to vision, granted that the defensive player is literally seeing the same formation in front of him over and over. Perhaps confidence, as he makes the logical connection and becomes more sure of it with each repeated play.
Last edited Dec 5, 2008 01:07:34






























