User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Discuss GLB Issues With Catch22 > NOT A BUG - CLOSED > This is Garbage, Just About Quit Today, FIX IT!!!!
Page:
 
GoVikings16
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by cdcollins

Agree in theory, though I might lower the numbers a shade, because you wouldn't want to totally kill a team whose AI randomly calls a Power-I 4 straight times or something of that nature.

It could really revolutionize using one-play exploits, and would definitely make it much more like RL football.


Yeah, if the play is ran 4 straight times they would get huge penalty. However if they ran a different play the stat decrease would go back to 0%. However I have thought it over and that is not realistic.

I think it should be more like this:



If a team runs the same play 5 out of 8 times - 15% boost to the defense
If a team runs the same play 10 out of 16 times - 30% boost to the defense
If a team runs the same play 15 out of 24 times - 45% boost to the defense...

Any time a team runs a play 6 times in a row, the defense get an automatic 5% boost for the rest of the game.
 
greengoose
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by GG
Originally posted by greengoose


Thats because you make Sooooooo many of them they have no idea what to take seriously.


You mean my 'gameplan' in coming up with suggestions is flawed?


It's a little daunting when you look at the sheer numbers of them. The more you have, the more really good ones tend to get drowned out by the not so good ones (from the game designers perspective).
 
GG
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by cdcollins

True, you spend a considerable amount. You did have a thread stickied at one point, though. Didn't go entirely unnoticed.


How the Individual Player Tactics thread never got Epic'd is a travesty! That wasnt even my idea either, but a colloboration from all GLBers. Meanwhile, some people need only cough and the tissue full of phlegm is brought directly to Bort's attention. I wont name names, but some people are kinda like in a circle of trust and always get heard, get their threads seen immediately by admin/mods/bort.

But im not having sour grapes or playing the violin! Seriously. Just saying. And it's not just me. There are billions of great ideas by many people that aren't given the time of day.

What I've learnt therefore is that certain ideas, no matter how great and wonderful they are, will not fit into the "company policy" on what ideas Borts wants, so they just get completely ignored. While ideas bort is interested in hearing, are kinda flagged, so admin/mods look out for them to make Epic.


 
greengoose
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by GoVikings16
Originally posted by cdcollins


Agree in theory, though I might lower the numbers a shade, because you wouldn't want to totally kill a team whose AI randomly calls a Power-I 4 straight times or something of that nature.

It could really revolutionize using one-play exploits, and would definitely make it much more like RL football.


Yeah, if the play is ran 4 straight times they would get huge penalty. However if they ran a different play the stat decrease would go back to 0%. However I have thought it over and that is not realistic.

I think it should be more like this:



If a team runs the same play 5 out of 8 times - 15% boost to the defense
If a team runs the same play 10 out of 16 times - 30% boost to the defense
If a team runs the same play 15 out of 24 times - 45% boost to the defense...

Any time a team runs a play 6 times in a row, the defense get an automatic 5% boost for the rest of the game.


Actually, that wouldn't have helped this guy much at all - what good does it to give a boost to players when they are in the wrong formation to make the plays to begin with?

In the end all that will do is try to compensate for poor gameplanning.

I was gonna give him the benefit of the doubt that he might not have hit "Update" and locked his AI in. But when he said he tried this, that and the other then that told me he really didn't know how to stop that play.
 
GG
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by greengoose

It's a little daunting when you look at the sheer numbers of them. The more you have, the more really good ones tend to get drowned out by the not so good ones (from the game designers perspective).


I am a fuckin' machine, a veritable process-line of ideas. Not all good tho. But I have a desire to see this game be good and so am often thinking about ideas in my spare time and churn them out. One idea right now is that Astralis should PM me a full-sized version of his avatar immediately.

Last edited Dec 4, 2008 23:41:13
 
GoVikings16
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by greengoose
Originally posted by GoVikings16

Originally posted by cdcollins



Agree in theory, though I might lower the numbers a shade, because you wouldn't want to totally kill a team whose AI randomly calls a Power-I 4 straight times or something of that nature.

It could really revolutionize using one-play exploits, and would definitely make it much more like RL football.


Yeah, if the play is ran 4 straight times they would get huge penalty. However if they ran a different play the stat decrease would go back to 0%. However I have thought it over and that is not realistic.

I think it should be more like this:



If a team runs the same play 5 out of 8 times - 15% boost to the defense
If a team runs the same play 10 out of 16 times - 30% boost to the defense
If a team runs the same play 15 out of 24 times - 45% boost to the defense...

Any time a team runs a play 6 times in a row, the defense get an automatic 5% boost for the rest of the game.


Actually, that wouldn't have helped this guy much at all - what good does it to give a boost to players when they are in the wrong formation to make the plays to begin with?

In the end all that will do is try to compensate for poor gameplanning.

I was gonna give him the benefit of the doubt that he might not have hit "Update" and locked his AI in. But when he said he tried this, that and the other then that told me he really didn't know how to stop that play.



By the time it got to a 75% boost it may have helped..

However regardless, something has to be done about team that just runs the same play over and over.
 
SWVAHoo
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by GoVikings16
Originally posted by cdcollins


Agree in theory, though I might lower the numbers a shade, because you wouldn't want to totally kill a team whose AI randomly calls a Power-I 4 straight times or something of that nature.

It could really revolutionize using one-play exploits, and would definitely make it much more like RL football.


Yeah, if the play is ran 4 straight times they would get huge penalty. However if they ran a different play the stat decrease would go back to 0%. However I have thought it over and that is not realistic.

I think it should be more like this:



If a team runs the same play 5 out of 8 times - 15% boost to the defense
If a team runs the same play 10 out of 16 times - 30% boost to the defense
If a team runs the same play 15 out of 24 times - 45% boost to the defense...

Any time a team runs a play 6 times in a row, the defense get an automatic 5% boost for the rest of the game.


I think the 5/8 percentage may still be a bit low, and likewise the %-boost may be too low, but this is a great place to start. The point remains, though: it would be WONDERFUL to stop the "one-play" exploit. Heck, it may be part of the tonic to cure the "overpowered offense" problem people often bring up.

 
greengoose
offline
Link
 
How is it gonna help the LB and SS who dropped into coverage when they should be filling the hole? Make them so fast and make them react so quickly it's like they have a warp drive attached to their back?

In the end before a player boost can really be effective - the players need to be in the right formations and spots on the field to make the plays to begin with.

I believe thats called auto adjust - the AI can't do that if you untick the box in favor of a gameplan that is flawed.
 
SWVAHoo
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by GG
Originally posted by cdcollins


True, you spend a considerable amount. You did have a thread stickied at one point, though. Didn't go entirely unnoticed.


How the Individual Player Tactics thread never got Epic'd is a travesty! That wasnt even my idea either, but a colloboration from all GLBers. Meanwhile, some people need only cough and the tissue full of phlegm is brought directly to Bort's attention. I wont name names, but some people are kinda like in a circle of trust and always get heard, get their threads seen immediately by admin/mods/bort.

But im not having sour grapes or playing the violin! Seriously. Just saying. And it's not just me. There are billions of great ideas by many people that aren't given the time of day.

What I've learnt therefore is that certain ideas, no matter how great and wonderful they are, will not fit into the "company policy" on what ideas Borts wants, so they just get completely ignored. While ideas bort is interested in hearing, are kinda flagged, so admin/mods look out for them to make Epic.




I tend to agree with this, on the whole. GLB's all about connections.

 
GoVikings16
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by cdcollins

I think the 5/8 percentage may still be a bit low, and likewise the %-boost may be too low, but this is a great place to start. The point remains, though: it would be WONDERFUL to stop the "one-play" exploit. Heck, it may be part of the tonic to cure the "overpowered offense" problem people often bring up.



I agree. I didn't know what the numbers should be, more just saying something needs to be done. Help me out a bit and I will post it on the Suggestions forum.... mind you that is useless 99% of the time.
 
GoVikings16
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by greengoose
How is it gonna help the LB and SS who dropped into coverage when they should be filling the hole? Make them so fast and make them react so quickly it's like they have a warp drive attached to their back?

In the end before a player boost can really be effective - the players need to be in the right formations and spots on the field to make the plays to begin with.

I believe thats called auto adjust - the AI can't do that if you untick the box in favor of a gameplan that is flawed.


It wouldn't help this guys game plan.



But it would help the main problem.... IDIOTS ATTEMPTING TO BEAT THE SYSTEM.
 
Link
 
Yeah, eventually the defense would realize "hey, we shouldn't be in a 3-4 and pass-rushing, we should be in a 4-3 focusing on the run .... our defensive coordinator is incompetent, let's fire him"

So I guess Bort needs to program something in that makes horribly bad coordinators, coaches, and GMs get fired, right?

Heck, even the Detroit Lions (who would not be able to stop a play, even if you ran it 71 times in a row against them) were eventually bright enough to fire Matt Millen.

This game is not realistic. If you do a bad job, you still get to keep your job.
 
SWVAHoo
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by GoVikings16
Originally posted by cdcollins


I think the 5/8 percentage may still be a bit low, and likewise the %-boost may be too low, but this is a great place to start. The point remains, though: it would be WONDERFUL to stop the "one-play" exploit. Heck, it may be part of the tonic to cure the "overpowered offense" problem people often bring up.



I agree. I didn't know what the numbers should be, more just saying something needs to be done. Help me out a bit and I will post it on the Suggestions forum.... mind you that is useless 99% of the time.


Sad, but true.
I was thinking 75% for the number of plays. 3/4, 6/8, 12/16, etc.
I was also thinking perhaps 25% for the defensive boost within the ratio.

Or, we really could do it on a sliding scale, by percentage. 2 plays = 4%, 3 plays =6%, 4 plays =8%, etc.

 
greengoose
offline
Link
 
There is no unstoppable play in the game - but you have to have good scouting and the right defensive set to slow it down to the point that you get the upper hand.

We had a team try that on us in the playoffs last season - they got 70 yards rushing for the entire game. You just got to know what to do and how to stop it first. Part of that is playing experience, part of that is being networked with other players and sharing ideas.

TBH, if I was a DC I'd want the opposition to run 1 play every time - it means I have to spend a fraction of the time to prepare for them.
 
GoVikings16
offline
Link
 
I agree with that.
Its worth a try though.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.