No rules
Forum > Free for All > ITT: FFA Forum Rules (My take)
Jed
offline
offline
Originally posted by Cberry
if locking potential threads in the suggestions subforum didnt make you a douche this definitely sealed the deal no offense
If making idiotic joke threads there didn't make you one, this definitely sealed the deal no offense
if locking potential threads in the suggestions subforum didnt make you a douche this definitely sealed the deal no offense
If making idiotic joke threads there didn't make you one, this definitely sealed the deal no offense
Alpha Q
offline
offline
Originally posted by Jed
Originally posted by Cberry
if locking potential threads in the suggestions subforum didnt make you a douche this definitely sealed the deal no offense
If making idiotic joke threads there didn't make you one, this definitely sealed the deal no offense
O SNAP
Originally posted by Cberry
if locking potential threads in the suggestions subforum didnt make you a douche this definitely sealed the deal no offense
If making idiotic joke threads there didn't make you one, this definitely sealed the deal no offense
O SNAP
kretchfoop
offline
offline
My post was obviously a play off of Serenity's joke about censorship. Come on, Jed, you know I post by the rules in Suggestions.
Serenity
offline
offline
Originally posted by kretchfoop
My post was obviously a play off of Serenity's joke about censorship. Come on, Jed, you know I post by the rules in Suggestions.
which was a joke over stuff getting locked for things that schools would teach in 8th grade
My post was obviously a play off of Serenity's joke about censorship. Come on, Jed, you know I post by the rules in Suggestions.
which was a joke over stuff getting locked for things that schools would teach in 8th grade
Jed
offline
offline
Originally posted by ssaints4ever
Jed > Norse in being a douche bag
Oh I'm totally a giant douche. But I'm an equal douche to everyone so it's all good.
Originally posted by kretchfoop
My post was obviously a play off of Serenity's joke about censorship. Come on, Jed, you know I post by the rules in Suggestions.
It still stood out as a great example of what shouldn't be allowed in my eyes. It's not like I'm suspending anyone for things done here (unless it gets REALLY out of control or something, I leave it to the Mods who are normally here....I mean I didn't do anything to the guy who called me a douche....or the other one who did the same thing), but someone had asked me to look at one thread, which lead me to this one and I wanted to chime in.
Jed > Norse in being a douche bag
Oh I'm totally a giant douche. But I'm an equal douche to everyone so it's all good.
Originally posted by kretchfoop
My post was obviously a play off of Serenity's joke about censorship. Come on, Jed, you know I post by the rules in Suggestions.
It still stood out as a great example of what shouldn't be allowed in my eyes. It's not like I'm suspending anyone for things done here (unless it gets REALLY out of control or something, I leave it to the Mods who are normally here....I mean I didn't do anything to the guy who called me a douche....or the other one who did the same thing), but someone had asked me to look at one thread, which lead me to this one and I wanted to chime in.
n:iceman:16
offline
offline
Originally posted by Jed
Originally posted by ssaints4ever
Jed > Norse in being a douche bag
Oh I'm totally a giant douche. But I'm an equal douche to everyone so it's all good.
Apparently not. > isn't an equals sign.
Originally posted by ssaints4ever
Jed > Norse in being a douche bag
Oh I'm totally a giant douche. But I'm an equal douche to everyone so it's all good.
Apparently not. > isn't an equals sign.
ssaints4ever
offline
offline
Originally posted by Jed
Originally posted by ssaints4ever
Jed > Norse in being a douche bag
Oh I'm totally a giant douche. But I'm an equal douche to everyone so it's all good.
No, it's all bad. You're bad.
Very bad.
Worse than drugs.
And drugs are bad mmmkay?
Originally posted by ssaints4ever
Jed > Norse in being a douche bag
Oh I'm totally a giant douche. But I'm an equal douche to everyone so it's all good.
No, it's all bad. You're bad.
Very bad.
Worse than drugs.
And drugs are bad mmmkay?
GIEFF
offline
offline
Originally posted by Jed
Originally posted by GIEFF
I think that's a good set of rules, Jed. Also, maybe we should differentiate between attacking ideas/posts and attacking the person himself.
That already is the case in the rules. Attacking an idea isn't nearly as bad as attacking a person. And attacking a player/team is perfectly fine (as long as there's not excessive swearing/sexual references, which happens sometimes).
Originally posted by GIEFF
And even better would be to have a list of people who do NOT want to be personally attacked. That may be too much work to moderate, but I know that a lot of people here don't mind it at all (myself and Serenity included).
That's probably too much work without multiple people devoted to each major forum (plus other mods devoted to smaller forums)
What about just taking action if the person being attacked complains to a moderator? Making fun of people is half the fun here; the rule should just be meant to stop the insults that are actually hurtful to people, which I suspect is a huge minority. The real thing you should be worried about is people getting upset, and the best way to know if that's the case is to let them tell you instead of just assuming that EVERYONE is upset.
You talked about the "ripping on Serenity." Maybe I'm misreading it, but I don't really think she wants it to stop. If she really does (and if she wasn't a mod), all she'd have to do was PM a mod, and the problem would be solved.
Originally posted by Jed
Originally posted by GIEFF
I still don't see anything wrong with kretch's reply. I found it entertaining, I'm sure a lot of other people did, and isn't entertainment the whole point of this forum?
Well, that is more of a judgment call, I'll give you that, but there has to be a line drawn somewhere. It's obviously spam (you can't really deny that it's completely off-topic and adds nothing to the conversation at hand). It's either you tell people not to do that (other than threads where that's basically the topic) or you let 3/4 or more of the threads turn into people posting crap like that. There's not really a middle-ground without playing favorites or being very subjective.
I see your point about threads with a purpose (like this one) getting derailed by spam, but honestly that's far less than 5% of threads, and not a big deal. Even if a "serious" thread does get derailed, what is the problem, really? It's not affecting anybody's ability to discuss the game of GLB, it's not hurting anyone's feelings, it's not hateful, it's just fun.
This again might be too much work, but could a poster just put something in the title to let people know it is a "serious" thread and that spam won't be tolerated? It would be awesome if there was a box you could check, but I don't want to take up any coding time, and just saying "(serious thread)" after those few threads that are created for a purpose does the same thing.
Originally posted by GIEFF
I think that's a good set of rules, Jed. Also, maybe we should differentiate between attacking ideas/posts and attacking the person himself.
That already is the case in the rules. Attacking an idea isn't nearly as bad as attacking a person. And attacking a player/team is perfectly fine (as long as there's not excessive swearing/sexual references, which happens sometimes).
Originally posted by GIEFF
And even better would be to have a list of people who do NOT want to be personally attacked. That may be too much work to moderate, but I know that a lot of people here don't mind it at all (myself and Serenity included).
That's probably too much work without multiple people devoted to each major forum (plus other mods devoted to smaller forums)
What about just taking action if the person being attacked complains to a moderator? Making fun of people is half the fun here; the rule should just be meant to stop the insults that are actually hurtful to people, which I suspect is a huge minority. The real thing you should be worried about is people getting upset, and the best way to know if that's the case is to let them tell you instead of just assuming that EVERYONE is upset.
You talked about the "ripping on Serenity." Maybe I'm misreading it, but I don't really think she wants it to stop. If she really does (and if she wasn't a mod), all she'd have to do was PM a mod, and the problem would be solved.
Originally posted by Jed
Originally posted by GIEFF
I still don't see anything wrong with kretch's reply. I found it entertaining, I'm sure a lot of other people did, and isn't entertainment the whole point of this forum?
Well, that is more of a judgment call, I'll give you that, but there has to be a line drawn somewhere. It's obviously spam (you can't really deny that it's completely off-topic and adds nothing to the conversation at hand). It's either you tell people not to do that (other than threads where that's basically the topic) or you let 3/4 or more of the threads turn into people posting crap like that. There's not really a middle-ground without playing favorites or being very subjective.
I see your point about threads with a purpose (like this one) getting derailed by spam, but honestly that's far less than 5% of threads, and not a big deal. Even if a "serious" thread does get derailed, what is the problem, really? It's not affecting anybody's ability to discuss the game of GLB, it's not hurting anyone's feelings, it's not hateful, it's just fun.
This again might be too much work, but could a poster just put something in the title to let people know it is a "serious" thread and that spam won't be tolerated? It would be awesome if there was a box you could check, but I don't want to take up any coding time, and just saying "(serious thread)" after those few threads that are created for a purpose does the same thing.
kppk11
offline
offline
Originally posted by Serenity
Originally posted by kretchfoop
I agree...the forum rules are a joke here. Add more and more rules and you are actually hurting your cause. Keep it simple. The real problem lies in the inconsistent application of rules by the Mods. You add more rules and you just magnify this problem.
Sex me, Bort.
saying sex ban
you said it too serenity!
Originally posted by kretchfoop
I agree...the forum rules are a joke here. Add more and more rules and you are actually hurting your cause. Keep it simple. The real problem lies in the inconsistent application of rules by the Mods. You add more rules and you just magnify this problem.
Sex me, Bort.
saying sex ban
you said it too serenity!
GIEFF
offline
offline
Originally posted by Jed
You edited after I quoted
Originally posted by GIEFF
Or are you worried about children under 13 reading it? If it's the latter, why not institute a COPPA "Over 13 in FFA" policy and require every user to agree to it before accessing the forum?
That gets pretty sticky. I don't know if Bort would want to do something like that, but it would somewhat limit potential of the site as a whole if that were to happen.
Also, that was one of the reasons private forums were put into place. Want to curse people out, spam the hell out of everything, etc? One of those is supposed to be the place to do it. The public forums are moderated, that's just how it works.
It would JUST be for posting on the FFA forum; I'd be surprised if that cost the site a single dollar. And pornography would still be allowed; it would just make the moderator's job easier because pornography is much easier to spot than something like "inappropriate sexual content" (which, again, the word "MASTURBATION" is not).
Also, it makes no sense to call Jed a douche for this thread; he's discussing the problem, which is better than can be said of any other mod on the site.
You edited after I quoted

Originally posted by GIEFF
Or are you worried about children under 13 reading it? If it's the latter, why not institute a COPPA "Over 13 in FFA" policy and require every user to agree to it before accessing the forum?
That gets pretty sticky. I don't know if Bort would want to do something like that, but it would somewhat limit potential of the site as a whole if that were to happen.
Also, that was one of the reasons private forums were put into place. Want to curse people out, spam the hell out of everything, etc? One of those is supposed to be the place to do it. The public forums are moderated, that's just how it works.
It would JUST be for posting on the FFA forum; I'd be surprised if that cost the site a single dollar. And pornography would still be allowed; it would just make the moderator's job easier because pornography is much easier to spot than something like "inappropriate sexual content" (which, again, the word "MASTURBATION" is not).
Also, it makes no sense to call Jed a douche for this thread; he's discussing the problem, which is better than can be said of any other mod on the site.
Deathblade
offline
offline
Originally posted by Serenity
which was a joke over stuff getting locked for things that schools would teach in 8th grade
Not in the US...we hide sex until sophomore year of college.
which was a joke over stuff getting locked for things that schools would teach in 8th grade
Not in the US...we hide sex until sophomore year of college.
You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.





























