User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > South America AAA Leagues > South America AAA #1 > NFC South = Best Division in the NFL?
Page:
 
masqu3rade
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Nixhex
Originally posted by Pepperz90

Originally posted by Nixhex


I think the NFC South has benefited from playing the weak ass AFC West this year.


Not like it was our choice...


Never said it was. That still doesn't take away from the fact they got to play the worst division in the AFC. I'll go on record and say that an NFC South team will not be in the Superbowl.


Again one team does not a best conference make. Just because you win the Superbowl or even just make it to the Superbowl doesn't mean you automatically have the best conference. Every year the Patriots won or made it to the Superbowl there is NO WAY you'd say that the AFC East was the best conference based on the recent past history of the Jets, Bills, and Miami.

That being said I think the best judge would be the number of teams from a conference to make it into the playoffs, and three is a strong possibility for the NFC South. And I think both conferences are benefiting from smacking down the NFC West.


Food for thought, and a little strange:
NFC South is dominating the comparable teams match up(i.e., Panthers beat Arizona, Saint Louis, and Chicago all teams that the NFC East has lost to this year). Surprisingly, the teams that the NFC East seems to be losing to the NFC South is beating consistently.

NFC South also has the better overall and conference records.

However, the few teams the NFC South has lost to have been in the NFC East, albeit in very close games:
Falcons lost to the Eagles
Bucs lost to the Cowboys
Saints lost to the Redskins
Panthers play the Giants at the end of the year

NFC East will boast of head-to-head, NFC South the better consistency; Continue discussing.

Last edited Dec 5, 2008 20:17:43
 
cptafw163
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by taurran
NFC East. No contest.


Are you from Philly?
 
dook
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by masqu3rade


Food for thought, and a little strange:
NFC South is dominating the comparable teams match up(i.e., Panthers beat Arizona, Saint Louis, and Chicago all teams that the NFC East has lost to this year). Surprisingly, the teams that the NFC East seems to be losing to the NFC South is beating consistently.

NFC South also has the better overall and conference records.

However, the few teams the NFC South has lost to have been in the NFC East, albeit in very close games:
Falcons lost to the Eagles
Bucs lost to the Cowboys
Saints lost to the Redskins
Panthers play the Giants at the end of the year


NFC East will boast of head-to-head, NFC South the better consistency; Continue discussing.



How do you figure the NFC South is dominating the NFC East's comparable matchups? Please be a little more clear on that one....

Your second thing in bold..
Falcons got their ass handed to them by Philly
Bucs lost to a Romo-less Cowboys (HATE the Cowboys)
Redskins beat the Saints
Carolina won't get it done on the road in NY
Last edited Dec 5, 2008 21:13:42
 
Pepperz90
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by dook1e

Carolina won't get it done on the road in NY


Carolina does their best when they are the under dogs. Plus, Any Given Sunday. Learn from it.

Carolina beat the dog shit out of the Redskins in the Pre-Season 47-3. Yes, Yes I know it's the pre-season and no one cares. But mostly everyone plays their starters atleast 1 1/2 quarters to halftime in the pre-season. In the first 2 quarters the Panthers were up on the Skins 33-0. And we'll look at statistics from starters.

Delhomme - 11/19 - 159 yds - 2td - 1int
Campbell - 6/10 - 39 yds - 0 - 0

D-Will - 9 carries - 101 yds - 1td - 11.2 avg
J-Stew - 10 carries - 100 yds - 1td - 10 avg
Portis - 8 carries - 32 yds - 0 - 4 avg

Smith - 4 catches - 60 yds - td
Cooley - 1 catches - 15 - 0

Almost all of these stats are starters v. starters.
Last edited Dec 5, 2008 23:17:11
 
Hitmang
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Pepperz90
Originally posted by dook1e


Carolina won't get it done on the road in NY


Carolina does their best when they are the under dogs. Plus, Any Given Sunday. Learn from it.

Carolina beat the dog shit out of the Redskins in the Pre-Season 47-3. Yes, Yes I know it's the pre-season and no one cares. But mostly everyone plays their starters atleast 1 1/2 quarters to halftime in the pre-season. In the first 2 quarters the Panthers were up on the Skins 33-0. And we'll look at statistics from starters.

Delhomme - 11/19 - 159 yds - 2td - 1int
Campbell - 6/10 - 39 yds - 0 - 0

D-Will - 9 carries - 101 yds - 1td - 11.2 avg
J-Stew - 10 carries - 100 yds - 1td - 10 avg
Portis - 8 carries - 32 yds - 0 - 4 avg

Smith - 4 catches - 60 yds - td
Cooley - 1 catches - 15 - 0

Almost all of these stats are starters v. starters.


The fuggin' Lions were 4-0/unbeaten in the preseason

The NFC East is the best division in football.

'nuff said.

 
Pepperz90
offline
Link
 
Care to elaborate?
 
Hitmang
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Pepperz90
Care to elaborate?


I thought that the previous post from dook1e, was convincing enough:

Originally posted by dook1e
Falcons got their ass handed to them by Philly
Bucs lost to a Romo-less Cowboys (HATE the Cowboys)
Redskins beat the Saints
Carolina won't get it done on the road in NY


Or do I need to post individual statistics from a Giants pre-season game?

The fug outta here
 
dook
offline
Link
 
Seriously dood. Youre going to bring up PRESEASON games?!? You just lost any and all notoriety with that statement. Considering the Pats went 1-3 last year in the the preseason means there is NO WAY they could go 16-0, right? "The fug outta here"

You still haven't told me how the NFC South is "dominating" like opponents.

Before you get all preseason on me, come with some games that mattered. TIA.
 
Pepperz90
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by masqu3rade

(i.e., Panthers beat Arizona, Saint Louis, and Chicago all teams that the NFC East has lost to this year).


Since when did the Panthers beat St. Louis? In the 2007 season yes. But not this season. Haven't played.
 
Pepperz90
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by dook1e

Carolina won't get it done on the road in NY



Any given sunday.
Last edited Dec 6, 2008 13:21:45
 
dook
offline
Link
 
Just like the preseason, right?
 
stnaigkroywen
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Pepperz90
Originally posted by dook1e


Carolina won't get it done on the road in NY



Any given sunday.


The Giants learned their lesson against the Browns this season, they will overlook no one from now on. Carolina will put up a fight, but the Gmen have too much power for the Panthers to keep up with.




btw, NFCE is still the best.
 
Pepperz90
offline
Link
 
Ok I give up. You win. I'm now a giants fan. ya! Look at me I'm a band wagoner.
 
masqu3rade
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Pepperz90
Originally posted by masqu3rade


(i.e., Panthers beat Arizona, Saint Louis, and Chicago all teams that the NFC East has lost to this year).


Since when did the Panthers beat St. Louis? In the 2007 season yes. But not this season. Haven't played.


My bad I was writing that fast and late, and I've looked at it but I have NO IDEA why I wrote Saint Louis.
 
masqu3rade
offline
Link
 
The only two teams that the NFC South has lost to (that isn't a NFC South or East team) are the Vikings and the Broncos and no NFC East team has played the Broncos, or the Vikings.

The NFC East has lost to the Browns, the Steelers, the Ravens, tied the Bengals (read: AFC North), the Cardinals, the Rams, and the Bears.

The NFC South has beaten the Cardinals and the Bears; haven't played the others.

And by further extension; the Broncos and Vikings are leading their conferences, the Rams, Browns, and Bengals are far from Division Leaders. Arizona is a respectable loss, and the top half of the AFC North also beat the NFC East.


Sooooo, maybe Ronald was right he just had the wrong supporting argument. If the NFC East is beating the NFC South head-to-head, and the AFC North is beating the NFC East head-to-head then maybe the AFC North is the best conference...
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.