bump
Forum > Suggestions > Same play decay
I think what it really should be is a combination of player tactics.
The first one should be for recognizing repeated plays or more likely formations. Something like "aggressively react to repeated plays" - "medium react to repeated plays" - "don't react to repeated plays".
The second one should be for recognizing position changes, such as if the team qas 2 QBs, one a passer & one a runner you can chose to "spy" on the running QB to be wary of the run. Or if a team has a power back you can chose to favor inside running and less towards outside runs. Etc...
The first one should be for recognizing repeated plays or more likely formations. Something like "aggressively react to repeated plays" - "medium react to repeated plays" - "don't react to repeated plays".
The second one should be for recognizing position changes, such as if the team qas 2 QBs, one a passer & one a runner you can chose to "spy" on the running QB to be wary of the run. Or if a team has a power back you can chose to favor inside running and less towards outside runs. Etc...
carumba10
offline
offline
Originally posted by OttawaShane
agree entirely. After a play is run 3 or 4 times, there should be a 5% (or whatever) vision boost for the defence each time the play is subsequently run.
Its been discussed before and its an outstanding idea, perfectly fitting in with RL football.
100% agree
agree entirely. After a play is run 3 or 4 times, there should be a 5% (or whatever) vision boost for the defence each time the play is subsequently run.
Its been discussed before and its an outstanding idea, perfectly fitting in with RL football.
100% agree
Mightyhalo
offline
offline
I agree. There are too many players in games like this that will always look for the exploit play and abuse it.
Ilok
offline
offline
This would be ok if play decay worked both offensively and defensively.
If a team blitzes 100%, the team should get huge penalties. Seriously what team blitzes 100% of the time?
If a team blitzes 100% against a certain formation, it should be penalized.
If 1 player blitzes 100% of the time, he should be penalized.
If 1 player blitzes 100% of the time out of a certain formation, he should be penalized.
If a team runs the same blitz more than 5 times, it should be penalized.
If a team runs the same coverage scheme the entire game, they should be penalized.
If a team runs the same coverage scheme against a certain formation, it should be penalized.
You get the point.
No more ROLB blitz every time.
No more 90 speed 70 agility corner blitzing every 5 wide set or 3 wide shotgun.
No more all out blitzes on goal line.
You can't have it both ways people.
the play in question that people are complaining about is the WR screen. Do some freaking research and find out how to stop it and stop bitching and moaning. Seriously, it should be your benefit if a player uses the same play over and over again. Every offensive play has a defense. Scout the team out and build your AI accordingly.
There is already a way to penalize a team for running the same play over and over again. It's called scouting.
Jim Tressel is one of the most successful college coaches of all time and he has been running the same 10 plays since he was at Youngstown State and he has had pretty good results doing it.
I have a very detailed OAI i spent hours and days perfecting, I use the entire play book but I do use certain plays at high percentages in certain situations. Do you know how tough it will be to try and set the AI so that you don't accidentally run a play X number of times and get a huge penalty on it.
If a team blitzes 100%, the team should get huge penalties. Seriously what team blitzes 100% of the time?
If a team blitzes 100% against a certain formation, it should be penalized.
If 1 player blitzes 100% of the time, he should be penalized.
If 1 player blitzes 100% of the time out of a certain formation, he should be penalized.
If a team runs the same blitz more than 5 times, it should be penalized.
If a team runs the same coverage scheme the entire game, they should be penalized.
If a team runs the same coverage scheme against a certain formation, it should be penalized.
You get the point.
No more ROLB blitz every time.
No more 90 speed 70 agility corner blitzing every 5 wide set or 3 wide shotgun.
No more all out blitzes on goal line.
You can't have it both ways people.
the play in question that people are complaining about is the WR screen. Do some freaking research and find out how to stop it and stop bitching and moaning. Seriously, it should be your benefit if a player uses the same play over and over again. Every offensive play has a defense. Scout the team out and build your AI accordingly.
There is already a way to penalize a team for running the same play over and over again. It's called scouting.
Jim Tressel is one of the most successful college coaches of all time and he has been running the same 10 plays since he was at Youngstown State and he has had pretty good results doing it.
I have a very detailed OAI i spent hours and days perfecting, I use the entire play book but I do use certain plays at high percentages in certain situations. Do you know how tough it will be to try and set the AI so that you don't accidentally run a play X number of times and get a huge penalty on it.
bmedders
offline
offline
Originally posted by Ilok
There is already a way to penalize a team for running the same play over and over again. It's called scouting.
I agree with this. The WR screen is probably the easiest play in the game to stop if you know it's coming.
Unfortunately, if a team just springs it on you, there is currently no way for a defense to react whatsoever. That is good gameplanning by the offense, and should be rewarded as such, but there should be an inherent adaptation by the defense of SOME kind. The same does hold true for the offense though. I don't know that I'd go to the extreme of every little situation, but if a defense sits in cover 2 and blitzes the ROLB all day, damn right the offense should adapt a bit.
There is already a way to penalize a team for running the same play over and over again. It's called scouting.
I agree with this. The WR screen is probably the easiest play in the game to stop if you know it's coming.
Unfortunately, if a team just springs it on you, there is currently no way for a defense to react whatsoever. That is good gameplanning by the offense, and should be rewarded as such, but there should be an inherent adaptation by the defense of SOME kind. The same does hold true for the offense though. I don't know that I'd go to the extreme of every little situation, but if a defense sits in cover 2 and blitzes the ROLB all day, damn right the offense should adapt a bit.
domenick2x
offline
offline
Originally posted by bmedders
Originally posted by Ilok
There is already a way to penalize a team for running the same play over and over again. It's called scouting.
I agree with this. The WR screen is probably the easiest play in the game to stop if you know it's coming.
Unfortunately, if a team just springs it on you, there is currently no way for a defense to react whatsoever. That is good gameplanning by the offense, and should be rewarded as such, but there should be an inherent adaptation by the defense of SOME kind. The same does hold true for the offense though. I don't know that I'd go to the extreme of every little situation, but if a defense sits in cover 2 and blitzes the ROLB all day, damn right the offense should adapt a bit.
Agreed on all points. WR screen is simple to stop IF you have enough tape to see it coming - and the teams that exploit it certainly do. I faced a team that ran it heavy, I added a playcall to the D to counter - of my 4 options, 3 worked very well and one didn't, so now that's cut out of the DAI.
Back to the original point, adaptation has to happen on both sides. If the D sits in C2 all day, then the offense would adapt to running certain high-percentage plays against it.
I've yet to see a team go 90% with one playcall without telegraphing it for several games.
Originally posted by Ilok
There is already a way to penalize a team for running the same play over and over again. It's called scouting.
I agree with this. The WR screen is probably the easiest play in the game to stop if you know it's coming.
Unfortunately, if a team just springs it on you, there is currently no way for a defense to react whatsoever. That is good gameplanning by the offense, and should be rewarded as such, but there should be an inherent adaptation by the defense of SOME kind. The same does hold true for the offense though. I don't know that I'd go to the extreme of every little situation, but if a defense sits in cover 2 and blitzes the ROLB all day, damn right the offense should adapt a bit.
Agreed on all points. WR screen is simple to stop IF you have enough tape to see it coming - and the teams that exploit it certainly do. I faced a team that ran it heavy, I added a playcall to the D to counter - of my 4 options, 3 worked very well and one didn't, so now that's cut out of the DAI.
Back to the original point, adaptation has to happen on both sides. If the D sits in C2 all day, then the offense would adapt to running certain high-percentage plays against it.
I've yet to see a team go 90% with one playcall without telegraphing it for several games.
You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.






























