Originally posted by GMathiasf
From the standpoint of someone who has dealt with these, blank ballots are less likely to be returned. People are lazy and tbh, sorting through the 32+ options at each position can be daunting for the average user. I've never understood how offended people are by allowing a player from every team to be involved. For a strong league, it's important to have ALL teams involved, not just the elite teams. I do believe in Democracy though and would be interested in having votes on how to run this thing. I believe our goals should be maximum participation above anything else. I really don't want any part of a pro-bowl team that is just for the elite teams to pat each other on the back about how great their players are personally. So for the sake of arguing, I'll start some ideas based on what's been posted to see where we can find some agreement or set up a poll to decide.
Ballot options:
Blank
Nominees chosen by team owners/GMs for their own teams
Nominees chosen by myself and/or bigpimpin
Nominees chosen via script based solely on statistical comparison
Rules options:
Limit voting on players from own team
No Limit
Require one player from each team on every ballot
Require one player from each team on final pro-bowl team even if they receive fewer votes
Require one player from each team on final pro-bowl team even if expanding roster to fit them
No Vote Requirement. Require one player from each team to be on the nomination ballot, however.
No requirement at all.
Voting method:
vote via online poll
vote via ballot PM'd to pro-bowl team adminstrator
Voting inclusion:
Limit filled out ballots by one team in some way (i.e. only owner can turn in final ballot)
All agents allowed to vote.
Roster options:
Starters chosen by vote, backups chosen by #1 seed in the playoffs
All players chosen by vote
I'm OK with having at least one player from every team on the ballot, but giving them a spot on the roster just because of the team they are on isn't really fair. Not everyone will be from the elite teams, and we could add a limit to how many players from each team can be on it.
Here's the ideas I had in mind for creating a ballot:
1. Send a nomination sheet to every team to fill out (like the one above)
2. Ask teams for x amount (probably ~5) player nominations from their own team and create the ballot from there.
3. Use a script to create a ballot. If anyone feels their player should be on it and is not, I will review and decide.
Then for voting could be these ways:
1. A poll as you said. We'd need a good site that doesn't allow multiple votes to avoid cheating.
2. Team voting. Each participating team posts the ballot on the forum and puts together what they think should be the Pro Bowl roster.
3. Individual voting. This would be a LOT of work I'm sure. Might be a little off because obviously I can't PM every player in our league.
And possibly in voting you cannot vote for your own teammates. Obviously we couldn't keep track of that in a poll but for 2 and 3. Or we could just have it so you can't vote for your own player.
We could also have MVP, OPY, and DPY I guess. I would rather take individual votes with no ballot for that.
From the standpoint of someone who has dealt with these, blank ballots are less likely to be returned. People are lazy and tbh, sorting through the 32+ options at each position can be daunting for the average user. I've never understood how offended people are by allowing a player from every team to be involved. For a strong league, it's important to have ALL teams involved, not just the elite teams. I do believe in Democracy though and would be interested in having votes on how to run this thing. I believe our goals should be maximum participation above anything else. I really don't want any part of a pro-bowl team that is just for the elite teams to pat each other on the back about how great their players are personally. So for the sake of arguing, I'll start some ideas based on what's been posted to see where we can find some agreement or set up a poll to decide.
Ballot options:
Blank
Nominees chosen by team owners/GMs for their own teams
Nominees chosen by myself and/or bigpimpin
Nominees chosen via script based solely on statistical comparison
Rules options:
Limit voting on players from own team
No Limit
Require one player from each team on every ballot
Require one player from each team on final pro-bowl team even if they receive fewer votes
Require one player from each team on final pro-bowl team even if expanding roster to fit them
No Vote Requirement. Require one player from each team to be on the nomination ballot, however.
No requirement at all.
Voting method:
vote via online poll
vote via ballot PM'd to pro-bowl team adminstrator
Voting inclusion:
Limit filled out ballots by one team in some way (i.e. only owner can turn in final ballot)
All agents allowed to vote.
Roster options:
Starters chosen by vote, backups chosen by #1 seed in the playoffs
All players chosen by vote
I'm OK with having at least one player from every team on the ballot, but giving them a spot on the roster just because of the team they are on isn't really fair. Not everyone will be from the elite teams, and we could add a limit to how many players from each team can be on it.
Here's the ideas I had in mind for creating a ballot:
1. Send a nomination sheet to every team to fill out (like the one above)
2. Ask teams for x amount (probably ~5) player nominations from their own team and create the ballot from there.
3. Use a script to create a ballot. If anyone feels their player should be on it and is not, I will review and decide.
Then for voting could be these ways:
1. A poll as you said. We'd need a good site that doesn't allow multiple votes to avoid cheating.
2. Team voting. Each participating team posts the ballot on the forum and puts together what they think should be the Pro Bowl roster.
3. Individual voting. This would be a LOT of work I'm sure. Might be a little off because obviously I can't PM every player in our league.
And possibly in voting you cannot vote for your own teammates. Obviously we couldn't keep track of that in a poll but for 2 and 3. Or we could just have it so you can't vote for your own player.
We could also have MVP, OPY, and DPY I guess. I would rather take individual votes with no ballot for that.






























