User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Page:
 
Bomber085
offline
Link
 
I see your point and everyone else's too, but I can honestly say, there aren't many leagues out there that are as tight as this one is and most teams are active here. I just think everyone should have the opportunity to have one guy on the team. If you guys want to put it to a vote, that's fine by me..
 
WolfbattXIX
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bomber085
I see your point and everyone else's too, but I can honestly say, there aren't many leagues out there that are as tight as this one is and most teams are active here. I just think everyone should have the opportunity to have one guy on the team. If you guys want to put it to a vote, that's fine by me..


If you really want to have every team represented then you should do it like HS.

1st Team
2nd Team
Honorable mention
 
shakirus
offline
Link
 
The way I think about it is like this: Players are represented by their agents (us) so why should one agent not be deserving of an award if they took the time to build a player that does well in the league rather than the player that gets the award just because we are trying to share. I believe each player should have an equal shot, but I also believe that it should accurately represent those who have been doing well overall this season. As WolfbattXIX said, if you want to give recognition to players from every team, don't make them a Pro Bowl player but rather an honorable mention player seeing as that would be more fitting than saying that they were the best player at that position even when they are undeserving of it.
 
Chefnastee
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by shakirus
The way I think about it is like this: Players are represented by their agents (us) so why should one agent not be deserving of an award if they took the time to build a player that does well in the league rather than the player that gets the award just because we are trying to share. I believe each player should have an equal shot, but I also believe that it should accurately represent those who have been doing well overall this season. As WolfbattXIX said, if you want to give recognition to players from every team, don't make them a Pro Bowl player but rather an honorable mention player seeing as that would be more fitting than saying that they were the best player at that position even when they are undeserving of it.


Well said. I can understand that.
 
GU
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by shakirus
The way I think about it is like this: Players are represented by their agents (us) so why should one agent not be deserving of an award if they took the time to build a player that does well in the league rather than the player that gets the award just because we are trying to share. I believe each player should have an equal shot, but I also believe that it should accurately represent those who have been doing well overall this season. As WolfbattXIX said, if you want to give recognition to players from every team, don't make them a Pro Bowl player but rather an honorable mention player seeing as that would be more fitting than saying that they were the best player at that position even when they are undeserving of it.


Great point! I think that there is no need to include one player from every team. The slow build teams know that their players aren't going to be good for a long time. They should understand why there players aren't on the pro bowl team!
 
GU
offline
Link
 
I was just looking at the Sscores and I just noticed that WRs get a +2 to the total score for every pancake. I think thats bull shit, that a stat made for offensive linemen is figured in so heavily when determining how good a WR is!
 
Mud Turkey 13
offline
Link
 
Blocking WRs are very important for the running game.

 
WolfbattXIX
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Mud Turkey 13
Blocking WRs are very important for the running game.



Maybe, but that is not something that should be a factor for a pro-bowl player. Hell in the NFL they hardly even send the best blocking FBs to the pro-bowl and that is a key blocking position. If they did, Mack Stong would have been to like 10 pro-bowls instead of just 1.
 
GU
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by WolfbattXIX


Maybe, but that is not something that should be a factor for a pro-bowl player. Hell in the NFL they hardly even send the best blocking FBs to the pro-bowl and that is a key blocking position. If they did, Mack Stong would have been to like 10 pro-bowls instead of just 1.


+1

 
onlyrockerfan
offline
Link
 
just hash make it a juice/bangers/dragons/riots(or legends) roster and call it good. save yourself the trouble
 
double_d1365
offline
Link
 
haha or just the dragons roster
 
Mud Turkey 13
offline
Link
 
The NFL Pro Bowl is a popularity contest. It's not based on any kind of skill.

 
GU
offline
Link
 
If you look at the thread about this script

http://goallineblitz.com/game/forum_thread.pl?thread_id=1218134&page=1

At no point in time does it mention that pancakes should be considered for any position except for Olineman! I think that when the Pro Bowl team and MVP are calculated we should make sure that pancakes are not included.

Also I noticed this thing adds in tackles as well. The real reason I don't think the use of pancakes and tackles are not fair is because those to stats are calculated as +2! 1 TD for a WR is calculated as .25 and for a QB or HB as .33! It makes the overall Sscore skewed, I wouldn't mind if pancakes counted evenly with how important they are to a WR being good, but come on 8 times more important than a TD?????
Last edited Dec 10, 2008 22:01:08
 
shakirus
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by GU
If you look at the thread about this script

http://goallineblitz.com/game/forum_thread.pl?thread_id=1218134&page=1

At no point in time does it mention that pancakes should be considered for any position except for Olineman! I think that when the Pro Bowl team and MVP are calculated we should make sure that pancakes are not included.

Also I noticed this thing adds in tackles as well. The real reason I don't think the use of pancakes and tackles are not fair is because those to stats are calculated as +2! 1 TD for a WR is calculated as .25 and for a QB or HB as .33! It makes the overall Sscore skewed, I wouldn't mind if pancakes counted evenly with how important they are to a WR being good, but come on 8 times more important than a TD?????


Actually, if you look at his exact quote:

Originally posted by justafish2002
The Pro Bowl Explanation

Greasemonkey Fixes
1. SScore(season) at the top only displays Passing, Rushing, etc. score.
- does not factor in FumL for any one;
- No receiving nor blocking stats added to score at top for HB, FB, TE
2.CScore (career) adds the totals in each category in career row.
QB
- In 3rd row, you'll see passingScore(arr). Scroll left until you see score = score* (arr)["Pct"]/100). Remove the /100 to get official score.
KR/PR; Punters
- The formula is completely wrong due to some changes.
- Any stat that is not recorded on the Full Season Stats is not included in formula.


It says that blocking stats weren't added for HB, FB and TE, he never said anything about WR.

 
GU
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by shakirus


It says that blocking stats weren't added for HB, FB and TE, he never said anything about WR.



So you think we should add in blocking stats for QBs and WRs, but not for FBs and TEs?? How does that make sense, there FBs and TEs made just for the runnning game where all they do is run block. I realize thats what it says but I think it should be changed to include WRs and QBs as well. Anybody else agree?
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.