User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Discuss GLB Issues With Catch22 > NOT A BUG - CLOSED > Medium Coverage is totally f'ed up right now
Page:
 
southlight
offline
Link
 
There were definitely instances of cornerbacks routinely going for the pick despite no deep help in medium coverage before. Just because it may have never happened to you (most likely you simply never noticed) doesn't mean the problem didn't exist. If there was any sort of build problem it was "having too much vision and confidence" in causing the CB to break coverage and go for a failed pick attempt.
 
tautology
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by southlight
There were definitely instances of cornerbacks routinely going for the pick despite no deep help in medium coverage before. Just because it may have never happened to you (most likely you simply never noticed) doesn't mean the problem didn't exist. If there was any sort of build problem it was "having too much vision and confidence" in causing the CB to break coverage and go for a failed pick attempt.


As I mentioned, I am aware of the issue. I do watch every single play of every game, and I would certainly have noticed the problem. I have in fact noticed it on my other teams, and so I actually believe I have a pretty good idea of the build issue that was causing it. Only Bort knows for sure, of course.
 
Mightyhalo
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by tautology
Originally posted by southlight

There were definitely instances of cornerbacks routinely going for the pick despite no deep help in medium coverage before. Just because it may have never happened to you (most likely you simply never noticed) doesn't mean the problem didn't exist. If there was any sort of build problem it was "having too much vision and confidence" in causing the CB to break coverage and go for a failed pick attempt.


As I mentioned, I am aware of the issue. I do watch every single play of every game, and I would certainly have noticed the problem. I have in fact noticed it on my other teams, and so I actually believe I have a pretty good idea of the build issue that was causing it. Only Bort knows for sure, of course.


I remember that thread because I was suspicious of people claiming they were in close/medium coverage because many of the replays looked like the CB's were actually playing aggressively even though people were claiming they weren't.O_O
 
RAPB
offline
Link
 
Hold your guns, guys.

1.
There was an issue with medium coverage style for sure. Guys obviously went for the pick without help over the top. So that needed to be adressed. I hope we can agree on that - for the actual behavior was contrary to what the description of the setting "medium" said.

2.
There is another issue of CBs set to Man Coverage Distance "close" in fact giving cushion right from the start on a lot of plays. We noticed that for our lowest level CB by end of last year: though he was set to close/medium, he played like medium/medium.

If I had to guess: it was about his speed and agility compared to the speed/agility of the opposing WR and the recent receptions of this WR. Bort confirmed, that there's a part of the code considering that (to prevent the CB from getting burned all the time).

Maybe - just maybe - you guys faced a freak with 10 or 15 more speed than your guy? If so, this part of the code might just have triggered.

3.
Without watching at least 2 games and considering the behavior of all CBs, I don't think a fair judgement can be made. Unfortunately, the teams I'm on haven't played under the new code (one team just played a crap opponent). So I like to encouage you to look at all CBs set to close/medium - not just your guy - for at least 2 games and posting the CBs build when pointing a issue out.

 
Mr. Me2
offline
Link
 
It seems that systematically, every change being made to the game is benefiting the offense. First the players not going out for routes and blocking when a blitz is coming, now this. In real football, not all players recognize the blitz right away or at all. They are late for blocks or don't make them because they run their route. In other words, it's not 100% fail safe like it is on this game. I'm fine with it being in there, but the likelihood that they pick up the block should be based on agility and the likelihood that they even see the blitz should be based on vision. And the defenders should have the ability to then disguise their blitzes based on a certain stat. Then that at least makes it fair.

I can't think of a way to make this fair.
 
cowcards
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by RAPB
Hold your guns, guys.

1.
There was an issue with medium coverage style for sure. Guys obviously went for the pick without help over the top. So that needed to be adressed. I hope we can agree on that - for the actual behavior was contrary to what the description of the setting "medium" said.

2.
There is another issue of CBs set to Man Coverage Distance "close" in fact giving cushion right from the start on a lot of plays. We noticed that for our lowest level CB by end of last year: though he was set to close/medium, he played like medium/medium.

If I had to guess: it was about his speed and agility compared to the speed/agility of the opposing WR and the recent receptions of this WR. Bort confirmed, that there's a part of the code considering that (to prevent the CB from getting burned all the time).

Maybe - just maybe - you guys faced a freak with 10 or 15 more speed than your guy? If so, this part of the code might just have triggered.

3.
Without watching at least 2 games and considering the behavior of all CBs, I don't think a fair judgement can be made. Unfortunately, the teams I'm on haven't played under the new code (one team just played a crap opponent). So I like to encouage you to look at all CBs set to close/medium - not just your guy - for at least 2 games and posting the CBs build when pointing a issue out.



The thing is they didnt start playing this loose coverage until after the code was changed. my teams have played 2 games now and it is definitely different as before they would be playing close as set(never played away before no matter what level or build the opposing WR had) and now they are playing off as if in medium or loose coverage.
 
datongw
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by RAPB
Hold your guns, guys.

1.
There was an issue with medium coverage style for sure. Guys obviously went for the pick without help over the top. So that needed to be adressed. I hope we can agree on that - for the actual behavior was contrary to what the description of the setting "medium" said.

2.
There is another issue of CBs set to Man Coverage Distance "close" in fact giving cushion right from the start on a lot of plays. We noticed that for our lowest level CB by end of last year: though he was set to close/medium, he played like medium/medium.

If I had to guess: it was about his speed and agility compared to the speed/agility of the opposing WR and the recent receptions of this WR. Bort confirmed, that there's a part of the code considering that (to prevent the CB from getting burned all the time).

Maybe - just maybe - you guys faced a freak with 10 or 15 more speed than your guy? If so, this part of the code might just have triggered.

3.
Without watching at least 2 games and considering the behavior of all CBs, I don't think a fair judgement can be made. Unfortunately, the teams I'm on haven't played under the new code (one team just played a crap opponent). So I like to encouage you to look at all CBs set to close/medium - not just your guy - for at least 2 games and posting the CBs build when pointing a issue out.



I've watched at least 2 games and it's happening in all games. I also checked the WRs, in one case the WR's bars were all yellow (can't be that fast or agile) while the CB has speed over 90 and was running away from the WR like he's the plague.

Bottom line is that there is that there is the "loose" coverage, if people felt that their DBs were gambling too much and getting burned, they can change it to loose. There is no need to modify medium when most people are running it and have no problem with it.
Last edited Nov 28, 2008 08:46:50
 
MD
offline
Link
 
So the guys that are playing Close distance but Medium Style, in every play that you think is bad, where is the Safety.

Cause alot of these examples, the CB sticks with the man from the start, then when the pass is coming towards the WR, the CB takes a step back if theres no deep help. Isnt that exactly what the settings call for. Stick to your man like glue BUT only go for the Int if you have deep help.

Maybe it could be slightly fine tuned. But maybe its more a problem with the Safety not staying in his Deep and helping with the CB. Cause plenty of times you see the Safety just sitting in the middle of the field, even if theres only 1 deep WR route, he doesnt go and help out like he should.
 
MD
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by datongw


Bottom line is that there is that there is the "loose" coverage, if people felt that their DBs were gambling too much and getting burned, they can change it to loose. There is no need to modify medium when most people are running it and have no problem with it.


Nah. Medium was pretty much the same as Close before. Why have 2 that do the same thing.

And obviously "most" people were having problems with it.

 
Yellow
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by tautology
Originally posted by UCHI_MATA_MASTER

Bort made the change last night, due to some guys being too close and going for interceptions when they shouldn't in medium coverage. I'm happy he tried but this is ridiculous. Almost like giving the guys a free reception.


PLEASE CHANGE THIS BACK!

I, and many many other folks had no problems at all with the previous coverage style.

The only explanation that I can find for the folks who were having problems has to do with builds ( I know this gets said a lot, perhaps too much...but there you have it).

Once again, we have made a change due to a small but vocal minority claiming there was a "bug."

I am quite familiar with that thread and those issues, and I am somewhat sympathetic...but not so sympathetic that I can live with my CBs who were shutdown quality and never experiencing problems suddenly playing off the WRs all too often.

PLEASE STOP MAKING CHANGES SIMPLY TO APPEASE PEOPLE!

If there is really a bug, please confirm it's existence and determine whether the player build is reasonably at fault, or if indeed there is a widespread problem.

The voices of 10 people on the forums with similar issues is not enough to suggest that a problem exists with the sim...please consider the many many folks who are not experiencing these problems.

Thank you.

/rant


Agreed 100%.


I had no problems with Medium Coverage distance and felt it was working as intended. As was mentioned, there IS a "Loose" coverage setting that people can use if they're getting beaten too often. Medium is totally screwed now and this leaves only Aggressive as an option, which means even more people are going to get beaten.

I would really recommend reverting this change to the original settings and doing some further testing before making a fix in this case.

Please?
 
tautology
offline
Link
 
Bort,

At the very least, please put in a 4th option for pass defense settings called "blanket coverage," and make it exactly how things were (for medium aggressiveness) before the recent change.

This setting allows the CB to drape the WR and deflect the ball, rather than just sitting back when no over-the-top help is available.

PLEASE!
Last edited Nov 28, 2008 12:54:52
 
tautology
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by MD
So the guys that are playing Close distance but Medium Style, in every play that you think is bad, where is the Safety.

Cause alot of these examples, the CB sticks with the man from the start, then when the pass is coming towards the WR, the CB takes a step back if theres no deep help. Isnt that exactly what the settings call for. Stick to your man like glue BUT only go for the Int if you have deep help.

Maybe it could be slightly fine tuned. But maybe its more a problem with the Safety not staying in his Deep and helping with the CB. Cause plenty of times you see the Safety just sitting in the middle of the field, even if theres only 1 deep WR route, he doesnt go and help out like he should.


I hear your point, but the more important issue is this:

It used to be that medium aggressiveness would "drape" the WR, whereas aggressive would let him "jump the route." Some folks complained that there was too much route-jumping when no over-the-top help was available (somewhat understandably).

Now, the same CB will literally come off the WR and sit back when the pass is thrown, allowing an easy catch. This happens when no over the top help is available.

For those folks who had a well tuned and extremely effective pass defense, this is devastating.

I don't want to have to go to cover 2 and cover 3 defenses just to get my CBs to play tight, without jumping routes.

Please create a 4th setting, called "blanket coverage," and make it the exact same as the medium aggresiveness setting before the change.
Last edited Nov 28, 2008 13:01:53
 
wlarson
offline
Link
 
This is how it used to work:
- loose = tackle
- medium = PD
- aggressive = INT

Now it works like:
- loose = tackle
- medium = tackle
- aggressive = PD/INT

Guess which I'll be using next game...
 
Yellow
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by tautology






Now, the same CB will literally come off the WR and sit back when the pass is thrown, allowing an easy catch. This happens when no over the top help is available.




For example: http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=224712&pbp_id=6663389

The CB was playing Close/Medium.
 
Yellow
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by wlarson
This is how it used to work:
- loose = tackle
- medium = PD
- aggressive = INT

Now it works like:
- loose = tackle
- medium = tackle
- aggressive = PD/INT

Guess which I'll be using next game...


Aggressive means PD/INT/TD catch now:

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=224712&pbp_id=6665889

51 jumping, 52 vision, 7 Super Vision.

Now it's almost like my guy gets penalized for having too much vision in this instance.

To clarify: i was aware of the bug so i switched from medium/medium (which i had been playing all season) to medium/aggressive, and my player had 3 or 4 plays just like this in his game today.
Last edited Nov 28, 2008 13:15:50
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.