User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Discuss GLB Issues With Catch22 > NOT A BUG - CLOSED > Wrap up tackling....still overpowered
Page:
 
SCACE
offline
Link
 
Just to clarify...

I'm not saying that wrap up tackling should cause no fumbles. I'm saying it causes too many and there really just isn't a reason to play on anything else right now, at least from my experience across various teams.

MudBugs -- Bort removed the missed tackle text from attempting a tackle but being blocked -- my guess is your player has more instances where he might have made a tackle but didn't b/c he was on power, it just wasn't reflected in the text. 4 FF's at this point is solid, but there are players with many more playing on wrap up across the game.

Schaffer -- so your argument is that we won't peak until Season 10 (which I know is the case, but bear with me). If low strength/tackling CB's and safeties, even some linebackers, are already causing an absurd amount of fumbles, and if fumbling is already at more than 2x NFL levels, what can we expect when we get to season 10? Players are just going to get faster, stronger and better at tackling, we assume, through training and what not -- how many fumbles per game will need to occur before enough is enough?

Personally, I think if you are going to have 3 settings for tackling, each one should be useful -- there should not be one dominant setting that 90% (being conservative here) of the GLB population uses.
 
Mike Rogers
Lead Tester
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by supersoul
If I'm not mistaken, form tackling also involves putting your hat wherever the ball carrier is cradling it. So there's some chance to cause a fumble.



Form Tackling teaches you to keep your head in a SAFE position to avoid injury, not to use it to attack the ball.

It is not unusual to be taught to put your lid on the ball, but this is an addition or evolution and not the Basics, and should always include allowances to make it safe to do so.

The break down is the same, but the technique is subtly different, with legs and back position altered.

This creates a tackle that is more focussed on the ball, but where the tackler is less 'planted to the ground'.

The worst injuries happen if your true Form tackling and have you head in the wrong position and the neck is stressed to much.

And SCACE is right here, we have three tackling styles and 90% or more of people using only one, that is a damning indictment in itself.
Last edited Nov 27, 2008 08:11:46
 
lunchbox6186
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by SCACE
If low strength/tackling CB's and safeties, even some linebackers, are already causing an absurd amount of fumbles, and if fumbling is already at more than 2x NFL levels, what can we expect when we get to season 10? Players are just going to get faster, stronger and better at tackling, we assume, through training and what not -- how many fumbles per game will need to occur before enough is enough?


The WR's and HB's are also going to get stronger and have more points in carry.
Last edited Nov 27, 2008 08:27:31
 
Schaffer05
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by SCACE
Just to clarify...

I'm not saying that wrap up tackling should cause no fumbles. I'm saying it causes too many and there really just isn't a reason to play on anything else right now, at least from my experience across various teams.

MudBugs -- Bort removed the missed tackle text from attempting a tackle but being blocked -- my guess is your player has more instances where he might have made a tackle but didn't b/c he was on power, it just wasn't reflected in the text. 4 FF's at this point is solid, but there are players with many more playing on wrap up across the game.

Schaffer -- so your argument is that we won't peak until Season 10 (which I know is the case, but bear with me). If low strength/tackling CB's and safeties, even some linebackers, are already causing an absurd amount of fumbles, and if fumbling is already at more than 2x NFL levels, what can we expect when we get to season 10? Players are just going to get faster, stronger and better at tackling, we assume, through training and what not -- how many fumbles per game will need to occur before enough is enough?

Personally, I think if you are going to have 3 settings for tackling, each one should be useful -- there should not be one dominant setting that 90% (being conservative here) of the GLB population uses.


Tacklers will be getting better, but ball carriers will as well. I honestly think you may see it get slightly worse, but for the most part it will stay about even. One thing I've noticed this season is our QB throwing a lot more INTs.
 
SCACE
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by lunchbox6186
Originally posted by SCACE

If low strength/tackling CB's and safeties, even some linebackers, are already causing an absurd amount of fumbles, and if fumbling is already at more than 2x NFL levels, what can we expect when we get to season 10? Players are just going to get faster, stronger and better at tackling, we assume, through training and what not -- how many fumbles per game will need to occur before enough is enough?


The WR's and HB's are also going to get stronger and have more points in carry.


You are missing the point -- fumbles have been getting worse as levels increase. One can hypothesize that as levels continue to increase, fumbles will follow the same trend unless something is done about the way fumbles are caused.

We know that velocity has a huge part in causing fumbles -- players are just going to get faster and faster over time. DB's can increase strength and tackling faster than most HB's can increase carrying (many are already soft capped in carrying, not many DB's are soft capped in either strength or tackling, let along both).
 
SCACE
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Schaffer05
Originally posted by SCACE

Just to clarify...

I'm not saying that wrap up tackling should cause no fumbles. I'm saying it causes too many and there really just isn't a reason to play on anything else right now, at least from my experience across various teams.

MudBugs -- Bort removed the missed tackle text from attempting a tackle but being blocked -- my guess is your player has more instances where he might have made a tackle but didn't b/c he was on power, it just wasn't reflected in the text. 4 FF's at this point is solid, but there are players with many more playing on wrap up across the game.

Schaffer -- so your argument is that we won't peak until Season 10 (which I know is the case, but bear with me). If low strength/tackling CB's and safeties, even some linebackers, are already causing an absurd amount of fumbles, and if fumbling is already at more than 2x NFL levels, what can we expect when we get to season 10? Players are just going to get faster, stronger and better at tackling, we assume, through training and what not -- how many fumbles per game will need to occur before enough is enough?

Personally, I think if you are going to have 3 settings for tackling, each one should be useful -- there should not be one dominant setting that 90% (being conservative here) of the GLB population uses.


Tacklers will be getting better, but ball carriers will as well. I honestly think you may see it get slightly worse, but for the most part it will stay about even. One thing I've noticed this season is our QB throwing a lot more INTs.


Reviewed INT's this morning over here:

http://goallineblitz.com/game/forum_thread.pl?thread_id=1520575

INT's aren't really out of control, not in the same way as fumbles are. But INT returns for TD are absurd.
 
RMiller517
offline
Link
 
Thread locked by moderator.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.