User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Suggestions > A real fix to speed
Page:
 
keith_dude
offline
Link
 
true, but this thread's got bort's attention...figured it was worth a shot....
 
Dianwei32
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Knick
Originally posted by Bort

So the real suggestion here breaks down to:

Stop listening to the squeaky wheels, and just do what you originally intended to do?


 
sully
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
I have tried to increase the value of strength and tackling, etc, in the past. All I get in return is 100 bug threads about how players miss too many tackles, because everyone's 20 tackling CB is god's gift to GLB.


Then maybe they need to work on tackling. I paid attention to tackling early and my tackling attribute is right around 40. In spite of that, my guy is still solid in coverage.

If corners don't want to miss tackles, well, it's pretty easy for them to fix it. Unless of course, they're truly convinced that Leon can't do everything.

 
Dianwei32
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by sully
Originally posted by Bort

I have tried to increase the value of strength and tackling, etc, in the past. All I get in return is 100 bug threads about how players miss too many tackles, because everyone's 20 tackling CB is god's gift to GLB.


Then maybe they need to work on tackling. I paid attention to tackling early and my tackling attribute is right around 40. In spite of that, my guy is still solid in coverage.

If corners don't want to miss tackles, well, it's pretty easy for them to fix it. Unless of course, they're truly convinced that Leon can't do everything.



Make Strength more important like you want to, but couple it with a formal announcement beforehand that the change will happen and that defenders will need to work on their strength to keep up.

Once the change is made, make "Bug" threads about "my CB is missing too many tackles" from people who still have 20 Tackling/Strength ban-worthy.
 
czman
offline
Link
 
Again I think it is important to not only increase the overall importance of strength but to pair that with an adjustment to coverage.

Only fixing one still causes there to be a greater importance on speed/agility.
 
Xiong Yoshi
offline
Link
 
Do away with a lot of the complaints really simply - introduce a mechanism to allow Players to reroll their stats at any time, as long as they are a FA.

Basically, the Agent would roll up a new Player that had the same name, position, and experience as the previous one.. but would lose all of their nightly training, bonus token training.. basically everything else. The drawback would be pretty big, especially for high level Players, but atleast having the option would be a way to quiet the "I built my player under the old rules, you changed the rules" argument.

Another option that I would argue for is to allow Players to be retired with NO LOST FPs while the game remains in Beta.

Either way, your choices are either to do something about complaints, or to do nothing. But I think we all know that an unbalanced game isn't what you want for the end product.
 
Guppy, Inc
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
So the real suggestion here breaks down to:

Stop listening to the squeaky wheels, and just do what you originally intended to do?


too many people think their players should never miss a tackle or drop a ball or fumble and thats just not realistic. Its impossible to have a league only consisting of all-stars because if everyone was perfect, they all would by definition be average compared to their fellow players.

There should be a real life correlation between attributes, like a 100 in speed is a 4.10 40, or 100 in jumping is a 40 inch vertical, etc. then program the game based on what can be done in real life if you had those abilities.

I definitely agree that zone coverage should be much better, and I think a huge reason it isnt is because the QB seems to be able to throw a pass downfield 20 yards yet the secondary does not react at all. In real life the secondary would have a few seconds to react to the ball being in the air. Same with punting, punters with high hang time still get the ball to the returner so fast that nearest tackler is still 20 yards up field when in reality, that returner is likely to get creamed the second he catches it.

Stop letting the exploit hounds drive the game. If their players arent well balanced, they should suck and its their own fault. This game cant survive if it attempts to allow everyone to be a stud.
 
Modok
offline
Link
 
I think most people will be open to changes if they come at a gradual rate. The changes that get under people's skin are these:

1) Changes coming in mid-season after ALOT of people have already used their boosts.

2) Changes made that completely make some builds obsolete or ineffective.

3) Changes that are too strong out of the gate. I think if everyone was told that, "Hey, we are going to up the importance of tackling gradually over the season, prepare yourself," things may be received in a better light.
Last edited Nov 24, 2008 05:11:54
 
clarky728
offline
Link
 
i still find alot of these builds funny that i see people making i saw a de complaining that he is not as good now as he was last season. and is moaning how a guy can knock him down.

the guy he was moaning about had a balanced character while the de just had speed and agi.

now if you have 10 strengh blocking or tackling and u run into a guy with 60 strngh 56 block 56 tackle with soft cap speed and agi of course your gonna lose 99% of the time.

commence sence. you can't knock down a wall without power
 
Modok
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by clarky728
i still find alot of these builds funny that i see people making i saw a de complaining that he is not as good now as he was last season. and is moaning how a guy can knock him down.

the guy he was moaning about had a balanced character while the de just had speed and agi.

now if you have 10 strengh blocking or tackling and u run into a guy with 60 strngh 56 block 56 tackle with soft cap speed and agi of course your gonna lose 99% of the time.

commence sence. you can't knock down a wall without power


The same goes in reverse. An OT with 80 STR, 80 BLK, 20 SPD, 20 AG shouldnt be effective either.
 
clarky728
offline
Link
 
he should be for blocking tho. making not if the DE is trying to run around him but a DE should not be able to burst throw him.

but basicly i think anyway with unrelistic builds should fail lol
Last edited Nov 24, 2008 05:19:04
 
czman
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Guppy, Inc


Stop letting the exploit hounds drive the game. If their players arent well balanced, they should suck and its their own fault. This game cant survive if it attempts to allow everyone to be a stud.


Agreed. Specialization is OK if there is a negative equal to the positive.

The problem is when by only using one stat a player is able to do all things well.
Last edited Nov 24, 2008 13:47:01
 
TheInfinity
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by czman
Originally posted by Guppy, Inc



Stop letting the exploit hounds drive the game. If their players arent well balanced, they should suck and its their own fault. This game cant survive if it attempts to allow everyone to be a stud.


Agreed. Specialization is OK if there is a negative equal to the positive.

The problem is when by only using one stat a player is able to do all things well.


Exactly! Strength, tackling, and everything else need to become essential to some aspects of the game. Even if Speed/Agility remain the most dominant attributes (which sort of makes sense because of how valuable 40-yard dash times are) you need to make people spend on other things based on positions. Those DTs should need strength, those LBs should need strength. Likewise though, it feels like you will have to revamp the whole system.

Defenders need to stay with the Offensive Team and also need to be able to make tackles. For the secondary this stands out because of how fast a WR can be and the fact that if a RB gets through the front seven they need to take him down. Its very easy to break the system if we don't find some kind of balance where they can be good coverage guys and also be somewhat competent at making a tackle or atleast slowing a guy down so someone who is competent can make it.
 
PinTBC
offline
Link
 
I wouldn't mind seeing strength needed for defenders to actually get off blocks.

I also wouldn't mind seeing a strength check made at the point of contact to see if the blocker can handle the defender, if this is a graduated scale, it can fail badly (pancake), Miss (ineffective block), or set up a control check where you get your agility and specials added in with your strength to see if you can break the block.

Speed in the line plays is something that frankly surprised me when I started playing this game. I had expected strength and agility on linemen to be king.

PinTBC
 
Link
 
Originally posted by PinTBC
I wouldn't mind seeing strength needed for defenders to actually get off blocks.

I also wouldn't mind seeing a strength check made at the point of contact to see if the blocker can handle the defender, if this is a graduated scale, it can fail badly (pancake), Miss (ineffective block), or set up a control check where you get your agility and specials added in with your strength to see if you can break the block.

Speed in the line plays is something that frankly surprised me when I started playing this game. I had expected strength and agility on linemen to be king.

PinTBC


this is good stuff
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.