User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Suggestions > Weight Classes
Page:
 
Link
 
Originally posted by Knick
Originally posted by TheInfinity

I hate to be against the man on this but I have to be.

First, its looking like you're trying to solve the Defensive End vs. Offensive Tackle problem with this.


If he is then I'll handle the rest of the post. However I think this is just a good idea. Bigger people are slower. More adding an element of realism than trying to "fix" a "problem"


One, this has been suggested since season 2 by multiple people before the DE "problem"

Two, I don't see how this would fix it since it would make the OT's slower than it would make the DE's
 
the man of doom
Miracles happen
offline
Link
 
Bort read this hurries need to be changed
http://goallineblitz.com/game/forum_thread.pl?thread_id=1497265&page=1
 
SwagOnLock
offline
Link
 
Whatever the motivation, can this please not be the main priority? Please? Please? There is a beautiful Epic Suggestions forum right above us full of things I'd much rather see Bort pondering while driving around.
 
InRomoWeTrust
Lead Mod
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by SwagOnLock
Whatever the motivation, can this please not be the main priority? Please? Please? There is a beautiful Epic Suggestions forum right above us full of things I'd much rather see Bort pondering while driving around.


I think I'd agree to this. For immediate concerns (aka stuff to be done THIS season) I don't think weight/height classes are a necessity. Even at that I'd like to see the playbook/scheming amped up even further before we do anything (both offensively and defensively).
 
HighRoller74
offline
Link
 
I love it.

Bort posts a suggestions and everyone starts pitching there own ideas, or referencing him to other ideas

Same thing goes for any other forum as well.
 
Bort
Admin
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Knick
Originally posted by TheInfinity

I hate to be against the man on this but I have to be.

First, its looking like you're trying to solve the Defensive End vs. Offensive Tackle problem with this.


If he is then I'll handle the rest of the post. However I think this is just a good idea. Bigger people are slower. More adding an element of realism than trying to "fix" a "problem"


I wasn't actually thinking about DE/OT actually, though I guess it would apply some. I was thinking it would be an interesting way to show the effect of weight and add another customizability option.

Also, how many 250 lb linebackers can run the same 40 as a 170 lb WR?
 
Link
 
Originally posted by High_Roller74
I love it.

Bort posts a suggestions and everyone starts pitching there own ideas,


This happens with other peoples suggestions as well. People do improve on more than just Borts suggestion

 
Knick
Sknickers
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort

I wasn't actually thinking about DE/OT actually, though I guess it would apply some. I was thinking it would be an interesting way to show the effect of weight and add another customizability option.

Also, how many 250 lb linebackers can run the same 40 as a 170 lb WR?


Pretty much.

I'm all for this.
 
TheInfinity
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by driftinggrifter
Originally posted by Knick

Originally posted by TheInfinity


I hate to be against the man on this but I have to be.

First, its looking like you're trying to solve the Defensive End vs. Offensive Tackle problem with this.


If he is then I'll handle the rest of the post. However I think this is just a good idea. Bigger people are slower. More adding an element of realism than trying to "fix" a "problem"


One, this has been suggested since season 2 by multiple people before the DE "problem"

Two, I don't see how this would fix it since it would make the OT's slower than it would make the DE's


Every WR/DB will be 160lbs. Every speed back will be 160lbs. Thats almost certain. Anything to get a boost in Speed/Agility. Why? Because Strength is not valuable enough at the moment. The most glaring example of that is the DE/OT battle. When I first had my DE he wasn't too good but I upped his strength and I thought "aha, wow, the OT was manhandling him but now he can shake loose and get all the way around" apparently I was wrong but that feels like what it should have been.
 
Also Banned
offline
Link
 
IMO i think Height and Weight should have an effect. 7 ft guy with 100 speed is slower than a 5ft 8 guy with 100 speed
 
Bort
Admin
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by SwagOnLock
Whatever the motivation, can this please not be the main priority? Please? Please? There is a beautiful Epic Suggestions forum right above us full of things I'd much rather see Bort pondering while driving around.


Check the changelog for "current projects"

My main focus as far as "big updates" for next season is currently veteran skills and fame, which I think is very important as to keeping higher level players engaged. I was trying to think of more ideas for it, and this came into my head, so here it is for scrutiny.
 
InRomoWeTrust
Lead Mod
offline
Link
 
My concern is that there will be no point in being "larger" based on your position. Take CB for example, there won't be any real advantage to being 195 lbs as compared to 170. Just food for thought.

We don't have any sort of bump and run or jamming at the line.
Last edited Nov 23, 2008 20:02:44
 
Knick
Sknickers
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by TheInfinity

Every WR/DB will be 160lbs. Every speed back will be 160lbs. Thats almost certain. Anything to get a boost in Speed/Agility. Why? Because Strength is not valuable enough at the moment. The most glaring example of that is the DE/OT battle. When I first had my DE he wasn't too good but I upped his strength and I thought "aha, wow, the OT was manhandling him but now he can shake loose and get all the way around" apparently I was wrong but that feels like what it should have been.


Step away from the DE/OT.

Everyone knows if you want a successful outside rushing game your WR's need to block. So this gives players the option to pump SP into Str/Block or increase the weight.
 
Dianwei32
offline
Link
 
+1 I like the idea, but I think that there could/should also be some way to have the weight (and subsequent speed/agility implications) factor into breaking/avoiding tackles for different style HBs. So if there were 2 Power HBs, and one was in a higher weight class he would break more tackles (more momentum) than the lighter guy, but be slower as a cost.

For Elusive style backs it could work where you are faster and can avoid more tackles, but since you are now a smaller/lighter HB, if the defender even gets a hand on you it's a guaranteed tackle.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by Mat McBriar

We don't have any sort of bump and run or jamming at the line.


+1

 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.