User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Southeast Asia A Leagues > Southeast Asia A #7 > Week 7, an undefeated team will lose!
Page:
 
Viscount
offline
Link
 
I was just looking at past seasons records and it seems that Billiton Bullets are perennial playoff chokers. They play great in the regular season going 14-2 in the past 2 seasons only to exit the playoffs early both times losing to Vanuatu (Chicago).
 
Viscount
offline
Link
 
Manila take down another top team via a 58.5 yd TD with 13 seconds left!:

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=250642&pbp_id=8171471
 
GarrettFoster
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Viscount
Manila take down another top team via a 58.5 yd TD with 13 seconds left!:

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=250642&pbp_id=8171471


Ughh, terribly let down by the D. Good game you all. See you in the playoffs.
 
Mob-6
offline
Link
 
Top offense beats top defense everytime. Kathmandu is successful because they have both a top O and D.
 
Raid
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Viscount
Manila take down another top team via a 58.5 yd TD with 13 seconds left!:

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=250642&pbp_id=8171471


nice, yeah that play seems to be fairly devastating this year.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by Mob-6
Top offense beats top defense everytime. Kathmandu is successful because they have both a top O and D.


Are you kidding? A great defense will beat the best offense everyday of the week.

Flashback... Superbowl: Oakland vs. Tampa Bay
#1 Offense vs. #1 Defense

Heck, flashback to OUR matchup... you have the better offense (#2, us #4), and it was our defense that won us that game...the only team to hold you to under 30 pts. Heck, we held the #1 offense, the Rage, to only 10 pts...their next lowest total was to the Bullets, at 45 pts.
Last edited Dec 2, 2008 23:36:36
 
claimoffame
offline
Link
 
What about the bears and colts superbowl? Bears had a superior D but lost.
 
Raid
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by claimoffame
What about the bears and colts superbowl? Bears had a superior D but lost.


colts D was better than bears O

bears D was not as good as colts O


Its not just 'this team has good D'

its 'is this team's D good enough for this O'



on top of all this it is REAL hard to win games even if you have the best defense if your offense cannot score, I have been the DC for the Oakland Raiders over in Oceania A#5 since they started, #1-#2 defensively ranked every year, and yet this is the only year we stand a chance at winning it all, mainly due to having a half passable offense now.

Kathmandu has had a good offense and good leveled defense for a couple years now, but this year we are dominating on D, which is why we are looking so good.

when you reach the end of it all I would rather have the #1 defense in the league than the #1 offense, but if I had to choose between:

#1 D | #32 O
or
#10 D | #5 O

I'll take the latter any day.

but if I had to chose between:

#1 D | #5 O
or
#5 D | #1 O

I'd take Defense first.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by claimoffame
What about the bears and colts superbowl? Bears had a superior D but lost.


Yea, the did lose, but how many of the points they scored were just because of their DEF? Clearly, I'm not talking about situations where you have the worst offense coupled with the best defense, as you can't rely on your Defense TO BE your offense, game in and game out. (Similar to Baltimore years back, even tho they still ended up winning it all...)

But anyhow... a moderate or somewhat weak offense with the best all around defense, should beat a #1 offense with a moderate defense almost every time. If you can shut down your opponent, only minimum pts are needed to get the victory!
 
Mob-6
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by The Angry Beavers
Originally posted by Mob-6

Top offense beats top defense everytime. Kathmandu is successful because they have both a top O and D.


Are you kidding? A great defense will beat the best offense everyday of the week.

Flashback... Superbowl: Oakland vs. Tampa Bay
#1 Offense vs. #1 Defense

Heck, flashback to OUR matchup... you have the better offense (#2, us #4), and it was our defense that won us that game...the only team to hold you to under 30 pts. Heck, we held the #1 offense, the Rage, to only 10 pts...their next lowest total was to the Bullets, at 45 pts.


Do you even read before you hit reply? In regards to our matchup, the only thing saving your #1 D was your #3 ranked O as I stated in my previous post. Your D didn't win it, your O won it with the benefit of having a great D make your job easier. Look at the rankings, top offenses are destroying top defenses. Only Kathmandu and Tokyo have the high ranked defense to back up their high ranked offense.

As for the Oakland vs Tampa Bay comment, you are aware you are playing a video game right? I'm fairly sure NFL does not equal goal line blitz. Look at the pattern of our league, great offenses with mediocre D are beating teams with great D with good O.
 
ronmexico7
offline
Link
 
the offense is a bit overpowering this season - even the close games are 43-45 or something stupid like that. havent seen many games that have been low scoring - not sure if thats a sign of good offenses or bad defenses though - i suppose its easier to get a good offensive AI package together than it is a good defensive AI package.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by Mob-6
[

Do you even read before you hit reply? In regards to our matchup, the only thing saving your #1 D was your #3 ranked O as I stated in my previous post. Your D didn't win it, your O won it with the benefit of having a great D make your job easier. Look at the rankings, top offenses are destroying top defenses. Only Kathmandu and Tokyo have the high ranked defense to back up their high ranked offense.


Uhhhh...

1. I think I have a fairly good idea of what Kathmandu IS and ISNT, being the owner.

2. How do you figure our #3 or #4, whatever it is now, Offense is the only thing saving us? Did we not hold you to your lowest yardage and score totals of the year? Did we not hold you to 10 points in the first half, and only 27 for the game? Heck, your 2 second half TDs likely were only scored because the score was 44-10 at the time, and we were on 'favor backups'.

I mean, unless you consider a 41.7% completion rate, 33.5 net rushing yards, 6 punts, 2 INTs, and 1 Fumble lost a good day. 175.5 of your 393 pass/rush yards came on 3 plays (that's about 45%)... what about the other 52 plays??

We could have counted just our 3rd quarter scoring and still won the game 28-27.

So I guess I don't really follow what you mean by "our D didnt win it"... ?!? You make it sound as if it was a shootout and we fired the last shot in a close battle, but the stats don't lie... Our defense shut you down all day, with the exception of those 3 bombs. You didn't have a single drive that that resulted in a TD from less than 45 yards away, just a few long field goals or turnovers.
 
Mob-6
offline
Link
 
Look at the league stats, rankings, W/L column for teams, etc. I can't make a blind man see, you'll have to do the leg work yourself. If you had the number 1 D and a mediocre offense you wouldn't have beat us by holding us to 27 points.


You didn't win the Manilla game because your defense held us to 27 points, you won because your offense scored 72. You could have let in 40 more points and still won. Your D was hardly a difference maker. Don't you find it strange that the 3 best teams in our conference also comprise 3 of the best rated offenses in the league? Two of those teams, Nagasaki and Manilla, have average defenses (10th and 15th respectively).

The fact you point out you scored 28 points in 1 quarter just goes to prove that your offense won it for you. If your O is scoring over 100 points a game (Taking that 28 point quarter and multiply it by 4 to simulate a game) then your defense can let in 99 points a game right? If the team you are playing doesn't average 100 points a game, that isn't your D winning now is it? When have you actually been in a close battle where your D actually was able to make a discernable difference to change the outcome of the game? Exactly, it hasn't because you offense puts so many points on the board it makes your D irrelevant most of your games.

 
Mob-6
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by The Angry Beavers

Our defense shut you down all day, with the exception of those 3 bombs.


And our D shut you down with the exception of those 10-13 plays where you scored.

If your offense was not a top offense you would not have sustained drives each time you had the ball and would have punted far more often putting the ball back in the hands of our offense. And guess what, with more opportunities, those three bombs would have been 6 bombs or more with the increased opportunities.


I'm not here to get in a pissing match about my team vs your team, your team is the best in the conference. You could have a much worse D and still be a high ranked team with your offense, you couldn't have a worse offense and still be a top team on D and win as much. The fact that your team has both at top levels makes you close to unstoppable.

Last edited Dec 3, 2008 15:58:20
 
Link
 
Im not saying our offense isn't good and has 'won' us games, but I'm saying, if you look at your team, Manilla, it's an offensive powerhouse, and I do consider it a victory by the defense to hold you to just 27 points. Sure, we could have won still if you scored a lot more, but you didn't, because our defense was solid. Just because we put up 72 points, doesn't mean our defense didn't win it for us. If we had some run of the mill #20 defense, for example, you'd have put up 72 right back, no doubt. If someone on our squad had a PICK6 to end the game, would you consider that a "Defensive Win"?

IF yes, I guess I'd have to agree in the technical sense of the word, but honestly, how can you say a defense won you a game where your opponent scored 72.

On the other side of it, let say your facing a offensive powerhouse, who regularly puts up about 80 points, with few to no exceptions, and you hold them to 27. That's what I'd call a defensive victory, regardless of how many points our offense put up in the win.

I see your point, but do YOU SEE MINE? A good defense isn't always about 1 or two big plays that win you a game, but everything in between that stunts your opponents progress, allowing you to build a lead and secure the eventual win.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.