User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Suggestions > Laying in the Team AI (Also Solves League Parity)
Page:
 
Ken1
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Lucius
Originally posted by didymus

Personality wise, I do not have any patience for this training wheel approach.

Throw the damn kid in the water and make him swim.


Right, which is a very fair point.

The question is, which group does GLB ultimately need to appeal to?

They can cater to the hardcore base, like yourself, or they can risk annoying that base to reach a broader audience and perhaps bring more people into the game.

That's the absolute toughest thing for them to balance, it's not an easy decision by any means. You have to be very careful, if they go too extreme in either direction, it blows up. However, I think the above's biggest flaw is that it wasn't like this from the start and if it was going to be the way I am suggesting, it likely should have been from day one. Nonetheless, they do call it beta


The big flaw is that owners in BBB didn't necessarily choose to be there, and the skills required to promote are not the same ones that help you do well with advanced AI.

Bort has mentioned making "basic" leagues, which one could sign up to own in; and if he wants to do that, that's fine. But to take away options from people with no choice would be horrendous.
 
Lucius
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by didymus
I truly believe the owner who is going to be overwhelmed his first year, is better off for it. He will be that much smarter his second year.

He might not like struggling and bearing it out. But he will be thankful afterwards.



Pain is weakness leaving the body.


Dude, this is a game! It should be about having fun.

You are in the vast minority if you want to spend your money and countless hours on a game before you get any reward out of it.


Originally posted by Ken1
The big flaw is that owners in BBB didn't necessarily choose to be there, and the skills required to promote are not the same ones that help you do well with advanced AI.

Bort has mentioned making "basic" leagues, which one could sign up to own in; and if he wants to do that, that's fine. But to take away options from people with no choice would be horrendous.


Well, if he continues to move all CPU teams down and bump everyone else up. All new teams will start in BBB. Thus, this is effectively a team leveling system, as I said before.

And as to the first point, that's kind of the point. Each new level would give an owner a challenge, that is reasonable, to master before they can advance to the next level. First you learn to recruit, then you learn basic tactics, then you learn... etc.
Last edited Nov 18, 2008 01:07:15
 
Ken1
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Lucius
Originally posted by didymus

I truly believe the owner who is going to be overwhelmed his first year, is better off for it. He will be that much smarter his second year.

He might not like struggling and bearing it out. But he will be thankful afterwards.



Pain is weakness leaving the body.


Dude, this is a game! It should be about having fun.

You are in the vast minority if you want to spend your money and countless hours on a game before you get any reward out of it.


Originally posted by Ken1

The big flaw is that owners in BBB didn't necessarily choose to be there, and the skills required to promote are not the same ones that help you do well with advanced AI.

Bort has mentioned making "basic" leagues, which one could sign up to own in; and if he wants to do that, that's fine. But to take away options from people with no choice would be horrendous.


Well, if he continues to move all CPU teams down and bump everyone else up. All new teams will start in BBB. Thus, this is effectively a team leveling system, as I said before.

And as to the first point, that's kind of the point. Each new level would give an owner a challenge, that is reasonable, to master before they can advance to the next level. First you learn to recruit, then you learn basic tactics, then you learn... etc.


What if you're a better tactician than anything else, but you can't win through tactics because they're locked out from you?

I'm totally fine with some sort of "basic league" for people who want a league that uses only basic tactics; but not for locking the richness of the game away from people who want it.
 
Lucius
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Ken1
What if you're a better tactician than anything else, but you can't win through tactics because they're locked out from you?

I'm totally fine with some sort of "basic league" for people who want a league that uses only basic tactics; but not for locking the richness of the game away from people who want it.


It takes more than tactics to succeed. To make pro, you need to be good at everything and that wouldn't change in this system.

It just starts with the logical first step: recruiting. Recruiting leads to friends. Friends leads to more people who know things. That helps you when you reach the more complex things.

Thus, your first step is to make friends. Fact is, no sane human can manage an entire team alone now. It's a full time job. Thus, you need a social safety net for this to be an accessible product. By putting recruiting and thus social networking first, you make sure they have that safety net when things get complex.

If I'm a great tactician and terrible recruiter, then I need to find a recruiter. Maybe, I agree to go GM someone else's team, and they recruit for my lower level team.

It's those bonds that hold the game together, which is why I suggest recruiting be the first step.
 
william78
offline
Link
 
+1 Great Idea to OP
 
didymus
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by william78
+1 Great Idea to OP


So you are ok losing some of your tactic settings?

'A' league is pretty low you know. The OP would chop away at you.
 
Adderfist
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by william78
+1 Great Idea to OP


Would raise the retention rate of players. I can see it being very good for the game.

As is right now, you can pretty much expect about 1/2 the lower conferences moving up.
 
didymus
offline
Link
 
Moving up to leagues where the owners have more experience with more of the AI.
 
Lucius
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by didymus
Moving up to leagues where the owners have more experience with more of the AI.


...as tends to happen in real life. Again, more realistic

When guys jump to the NFL, there is far more complexity than at a lower level and they must adjust.
 
didymus
offline
Link
 
We've been around this block already.

I still feel promoted owners will be better prepared by letting them make their mistakes early with the AI.

Learning the AI amongst your peers is one thing. Tossed into a pool with more experienced owners is a worse place to 'learn' the AI.

I guess this boils down to opinion.

What I haven't figured out is why you and I are batting this back and forth when it won't effect us.

The real opinions that matter would be those on the waiting list.
 
blitz2670
offline
Link
 
Good suggestion. Now if we could also get those Special Team Depth Charts we would really have something.
 
Rage Kinard
offline
Link
 
In this game there is already a progression new owners can follow

1. Create a player
2. Put player in D-league (and hopefully read in the forums and ask questions about how to build your player)
3. Get player on human owned team and listen to advice
4. Offer to do things like scouting and helping recruit
5. Get a GM position (some teams offer assistant GM positions to learn the ropes before moving on to full GM)
6. Learn as much as you can as a GM
7. At this point you should be ready to buy a team


BTW - If a new owner doesn't create 1/2 his team, and/or doesn't know how to recruit. Recruiting is 10 times tougher and more time consuming than learning the AI.
Last edited Nov 18, 2008 03:08:38
 
GG
offline
Link
 
I think it's a bad idea personally. I would be opposed to it.
 
didymus
offline
Link
 
Hey GG.

GG will tell you what a mess I was. I was practically punting the wrong direction.

Thanks for the big assist.

edit: I concur with Kinard regarding recruiting being 10 times harder than the AI. you can learn the AI, recruiting seems completely out of your control. I'd put training wheels on that before anything else.
Last edited Nov 18, 2008 04:02:17
 
GG
offline
Link
 
Recruiting is the only factor that determines whether you win or lose. Tactics themselves are mostly irrelevant except when you have two identically matched teams. Then it becomes important.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.