Originally posted by SCACE
Originally posted by Ken1
And by the way, this has turned into a discussion about a more complex delay by position discussion.
That might be a good or bad idea (I haven't decided which side of that I'm on); but whether that is implemented or not, at the least the LB drop should be replaced with a delay of the same length as when the LB blitzes. LB's expecting a run should not drop off unless they badly misread the play.
Offenses, with the recent changes, will probably be realistically okay without the dropoff (although by all means Bort should test it on his server first), and if they aren't, then there has to be a better way to balance them.
I have to question whether "testing" is going on to the lengths required right now, or to be more accurate, whether both sides of the ball are being taken into account when testing. I don't think I'm the only one getting fed up with each season being about one side of the ball or the other...I can't remember the last time I've seen a good balance, either on the field of play, gameplanning abilities, or heaven forbid...both.
I actually think that Season 5 was pretty much balanced between offense and defense, with the exception of the super-DE's.
People thought Season 5 was offense-dominated because scores were high; but a fair amount of those points came from interception returns and the like, and the games simply have more plays than real football games did. No one wants that to be changed, as it makes it more possible to get everyone experience. Yards per rush and per pass attempt were realistic.
Now, I expect Season 6, if nothing else is done, will turn out to be too offense-dominated. If O and D were balanced in Season 5, the offenses were given a bunch of new tools in Season 6 (as they were), and the defenses were given comparatively little (as they were), one would expect offense to become too strong relative to real life. I think it's happened, but I'm not 100% sure.
I'd reign that in by turning the LB auto-drop into a small delay, improving zones probably more than they have, and it appears (I'm almost afraid to say this, as it was way overdone before) that QB's need to make a few more bad passes-- not dropped, deflected, or intercepted, but just off target-- especially when pressured.
But, I'd want Bort to test it all first, as I'd hate to see it overadjusted. I don't want offensive domination, but I'd take it over defensive domination if those are the only two options. Offense sells tickets in real life for a reason.
Again, though, I agree with reigning offense in to realistic levels, and I think that needs to be done.