User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Oceania AAA Leagues > Oceania AAA #1 > Power Rankings and Projections
Page:
 
jsu4578m
offline
Link
 
seriously? we're talking about the ACC? Might as well argue about the Big East.
 
Masakari
offline
Link
 
BCS + Big East = loss for Bulldogs.
 
Nirav
offline
Link
 
If I am not mistaken in the case of a 3 way tie, it would default to whoever is ranked highest. This of course means that Ponder needs to throw more TD's than Preston Parker against Maryland. Which would not be much of a consolation unless we get the upset against "Teabag" and company in a few weeks. If BC wins out it doesnt matter anyhow.
 
Forces904
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by jsu4578m
seriously? we're talking about the ACC? Might as well argue about the Big East.


The SEC is about to join the Big East for the bottom conference very very soon. The ACC has far younger teams and such. FSU is made up of ALOT of first year starters. So are alot of other teams in the ACC.

This year the SEC has been shit. If your not Florida or Alabama, your not shit. 10 of 12 teams in the SEC suck. Once players start graduating and such the SEC is only going to get worse. The SEC is gradually become the new joke.
Last edited Nov 16, 2008 22:07:24
 
SWVAHoo
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Nirav
If I am not mistaken in the case of a 3 way tie, it would default to whoever is ranked highest.


For 2004 and before, this was correct.
The rules were amended in 2005 to make the ACC title game of relevance.

http://myespn.go.com/blogs/acc/0-2-481/ACC-tiebreaker-rules--Same-as-SEC-and-Big-12.html
 
gatorfan
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by forces904

The SEC is about to join the Big East for the bottom conference very very soon. The ACC has far younger teams and such. FSU is made up of ALOT of first year starters. So are alot of other teams in the ACC.

This year the SEC has been shit. If your not Florida or Alabama, your not shit. 10 of 12 teams in the SEC suck. Once players start graduating and such the SEC is only going to get worse. The SEC is gradually become the new joke.


LOL...I don't know if I'd go THAT far, but I have to admit that the SEC is weaker this year thanks to disappointments from Auburn and Tennessee. Georgia seems to have given up since they dropped out of the NC picture. LSU, Auburn, and Tennessee are very young teams and Ole Miss and Vanderbilt are on the rise. The SEC just doesn't have as many top 25 teams as they usually do, but that doesn't mean they suck!

FSU and Miami will be back to their glory days in another season or two - but Bobby Bowden needs to tighten his reigns on some of those young players or there will be discipline issues (as we have already seen).

I definitely wouldn't claim that 10 of 12 teams suck - it's just an 'off' year for the SEC. I know you guys probably hate hearing about how tough the SEC is constantly...I probably would too. I think the Big 12 is the strongest conference this year.
Last edited Nov 17, 2008 07:26:20
 
Nirav
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by cdcollins
Originally posted by Nirav

If I am not mistaken in the case of a 3 way tie, it would default to whoever is ranked highest.


For 2004 and before, this was correct.
The rules were amended in 2005 to make the ACC title game of relevance.

http://myespn.go.com/blogs/acc/0-2-481/ACC-tiebreaker-rules--Same-as-SEC-and-Big-12.html

http://www.theacc.com/sports/m-footbl/spec-rel/082105aad.html
Here is the official tie-breaker rules from the ACC. Of course the less complicated way is a BC win this week and then a BC loss next week with an FSU win over Maryland. Looking at this again Maryland would come out on top in a 3 way tie, since it would likely hinge on W/L vs Boston College.
Last edited Nov 17, 2008 06:39:33
 
SWVAHoo
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Nirav
Originally posted by cdcollins

Originally posted by Nirav


If I am not mistaken in the case of a 3 way tie, it would default to whoever is ranked highest.


For 2004 and before, this was correct.
The rules were amended in 2005 to make the ACC title game of relevance.

http://myespn.go.com/blogs/acc/0-2-481/ACC-tiebreaker-rules--Same-as-SEC-and-Big-12.html


http://www.theacc.com/sports/m-footbl/spec-rel/082105aad.html
Here is the official tie-breaker rules from the ACC. Of course the less complicated way is a BC win this week and then a BC loss next week with an FSU win over Maryland. Looking at this again Maryland would come out on top in a 3 way tie, since it would likely hinge on W/L vs Boston College.


I'd rather see FSU on top than Maryland. Ugh...
At least there's life, and at least there's next year. FSU's going to be stacked.

 
jsu4578m
offline
Link
 
Florida, Georgia, and Alabama all have young teams. Alabama plays the most freshmen in the country. Florida has NO seniors on defense. And UGA has 2 true freshmen, and a couple of redshirts on the Oline, not to mention the true freshman reciever that leads the SEC in recieving, and Knowshon still has 2 years of elligibility (if he were to stay)
 
gatorfan
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by jsu4578m
Florida, Georgia, and Alabama all have young teams. Alabama plays the most freshmen in the country. Florida has NO seniors on defense. And UGA has 2 true freshmen, and a couple of redshirts on the Oline, not to mention the true freshman reciever that leads the SEC in recieving, and Knowshon still has 2 years of elligibility (if he were to stay)


Exactly.

An SEC team has won the NC the last two years in a row - in a blowout, no less. We currently have 2 teams in the top 5. While I certainly agree that FSU and Miami are right around the corner, I think it's awfully unwise to talk smack until your conference is being talked about in a BCS conversation.

It's good to have pride, but let's not get ahead of ourselves.
 
Stubbs
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by gatorfan
Originally posted by jsu4578m

Florida, Georgia, and Alabama all have young teams. Alabama plays the most freshmen in the country. Florida has NO seniors on defense. And UGA has 2 true freshmen, and a couple of redshirts on the Oline, not to mention the true freshman reciever that leads the SEC in recieving, and Knowshon still has 2 years of elligibility (if he were to stay)


Exactly.

An SEC team has won the NC the last two years in a row - in a blowout, no less. We currently have 2 teams in the top 5. While I certainly agree that FSU and Miami are right around the corner, I think it's awfully unwise to talk smack until your conference is being talked about in a BCS conversation.

It's good to have pride, but let's not get ahead of ourselves.


Go Big 12!!!!
 
gatorfan
offline
Link
 
The following is from this chat with ESPN's Chris Low today: http://proxy.espn.go.com/chat/chatESPN?event_id=23693

J.B. (Dunmore, PA): Mr. Low: Is it just me or aside from maybe three teams is the SEC a pretty average conference this season?

Chris Low: (1:08 PM ET ) Overall, I do think the SEC is a tad down, although extremely good at the top. I'd put Bama, Florida and Georgia against the top three teams from any other conference in the country, including the Big 12. What hurts the SEC this year is Auburn and Tennessee being so bad, and LSU has also underachieved.
 
SWVAHoo
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by gatorfan
The following is from this chat with ESPN's Chris Low today: http://proxy.espn.go.com/chat/chatESPN?event_id=23693

J.B. (Dunmore, PA): Mr. Low: Is it just me or aside from maybe three teams is the SEC a pretty average conference this season?

Chris Low: (1:08 PM ET ) Overall, I do think the SEC is a tad down, although extremely good at the top. I'd put Bama, Florida and Georgia against the top three teams from any other conference in the country, including the Big 12. What hurts the SEC this year is Auburn and Tennessee being so bad, and LSU has also underachieved.


The Top 3 teams in the Big XII would go 2-1 against the Top 3 teams in the SEC. Only Florida would win, IMO.
 
gatorfan
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by cdcollins
The Top 3 teams in the Big XII would go 2-1 against the Top 3 teams in the SEC. Only Florida would win, IMO.


Very possible.

I think it would be a great matchup to watch...the Big 12 is loaded with good offenses and the SEC has better defenses IMO. It would be fun to watch. I think Georgia would lose because they rarely play to their potential (sorry jsu4578m), but the Bama and Florida games would be very close.
 
Forces904
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by gatorfan
Originally posted by forces904


The SEC is about to join the Big East for the bottom conference very very soon. The ACC has far younger teams and such. FSU is made up of ALOT of first year starters. So are alot of other teams in the ACC.

This year the SEC has been shit. If your not Florida or Alabama, your not shit. 10 of 12 teams in the SEC suck. Once players start graduating and such the SEC is only going to get worse. The SEC is gradually become the new joke.


LOL...I don't know if I'd go THAT far, but I have to admit that the SEC is weaker this year thanks to disappointments from Auburn and Tennessee. Georgia seems to have given up since they dropped out of the NC picture. LSU, Auburn, and Tennessee are very young teams and Ole Miss and Vanderbilt are on the rise. The SEC just doesn't have as many top 25 teams as they usually do, but that doesn't mean they suck!

FSU and Miami will be back to their glory days in another season or two - but Bobby Bowden needs to tighten his reigns on some of those young players or there will be discipline issues (as we have already seen).

I definitely wouldn't claim that 10 of 12 teams suck - it's just an 'off' year for the SEC. I know you guys probably hate hearing about how tough the SEC is constantly...I probably would too. I think the Big 12 is the strongest conference this year.


I don't go by top 25 teams. I don't really rely on people's opinions. OSU is not a top 25 team. Yet they'll forever be embedded in the top 25.

But so many teams such as LSU, Auburn, Tennessee, South Carolina, Kentucky, Arkansas, and Georgia have all gotten worse from last year. Considerably. The Big 12 IMO is the strongest at the moment. The ACC is not strong yet but teams have mostly improved from last year instead of gotten worse.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.