User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Discuss GLB Issues With Catch22 > NOT A BUG - CLOSED > Fumbles still a problem (jumping on it early this season)
Page:
 
gambrinus843
offline
Link
 
The Power back on my team has 70+ strength, 52+ speed, 53+ agility, 45 confidence, and 58+ carrying. He also has 6 in cover up and an advanced piece of eq with a 7% resist fumble yet has fumbled the ball 10 times and lost 9 of them. He is equal in level to all of our opponents and until this season had never had 10 fumbles in a season let alone through 3 games. 80% of HB's in the NFL do not fumble the ball 4+ times a season so to have guys coughing up 6 fumbles in one game is ridiculous. If the game is working "as it is intended" then its intentions need to be changed. I personally do not care about what confidence can do to a player, I would be more apt to believe fumbling would cause your player to move slower or lose some agility because he is worried about another fumble which causes him to reduce speed and agility in an effort to protect the ball more consciously. Having him fumble it at the drop of a hat after the first fumble is unrealistic. Just because you fumble twice does not mean the next hit he takes should automatically cause a fumble. 6 fumbles in one game and 3 in another? thats asinine.
 
sxewesley
offline
Link
 
I just had my RB fumble four times in one game. Strength 50, Carrying 48, confidence 33 and stamina 47 for good measure and two in cover up. Not amazing amounts in any of those stats obviously since he is an elusive back, but then again it would not really be possible to raise any of those stats without becoming a power back now would it?

Anyway, the amount of fumbles is ridiculous and with or without what happened to my RB, the amount of fumbles on special teams, particularly those caused by CBs and safties with little to no strength and tackling is ridiculous and still needs to be fixed imo.
 
supgreg
offline
Link
 
Just to counter the argument, whichever side wants to attach itself to it. Here is my HB, check the fumbL coulumn:

http://goallineblitz.com/game/player.pl?player_id=633456

and his attributes/tactics

Power running style
56 agility
43 strength
40 carrying
34 vision
22 confidence
2 cover up

I don't have a problem with fumbles, but I've seen others that do, with better strength and carrying.
 
riptide1977
offline
Link
 
I just had a game where my KR/PR has fumbled 3 times, happened 1 or two times in the previous game as well, but it is highly unlikely for a player to fumble that many times in one game at the same spot. For a level 13 capped team...well 16 now, that just seems insane, especially when it was the only way the opponent could really score on us.

My biggest issue is that these conditions would never happen in real football. I mean twice the ball fumbled into a mop of players, as soon as the ball is picked up the player would be considered down, unless the player has finger tips of crazy glue and can some how plow through 3-4 players pick up the ball in the crowd and run 40 yards for a TD.
Last edited Dec 1, 2008 18:58:24
 
mocfam10
offline
Link
 
I found the correct percentage mix of attributes. strength/speed/carrying.

Percentage of strength to speed
Percentage of carrying to speed

I keep my percentages within the same range when I start distributing SP. So, if I increase speed...then I have to increase my other numbers to get back within that range. I did my analysis after experiencing fumble problems early last season. After a couple of games of not fumbling...I just tried the percentage thing. Because I couldn't think of anything else to do or what could have made me stop fumbling.

Well, long story short, I don't have fumbling issues anymore. And I have only had 1 fumble since coming up with my percentages. Far fetched...but I'm not gonna jinx it.
 
deez11010
offline
Link
 
Our problem isnt that one guy is getting a lot of fumbles, its that everybody that touches the ball is fumbling. We have 12 fumbles on the season attributed to 6 players. It doesnt sound like much, except we have a lot of 'cupcake' teams that are slow builders and gutted. So those fumbles are from 3 games.

Thing is, its not just fumbles. It seems once we fumble, even if we recover it, we head down turnover lane.

This game, we had 5 strait drives with a fumble or INT, 4 strait drives ending in a turnover. Lost 26-48
http://goallineblitz.com/game/game.pl?game_id=249866&mode=pbp

This game, we had 2 strait drives with a fumble lost and a INT. Lost 21-30
http://goallineblitz.com/game/game.pl?game_id=249964&mode=pbp

This game, we had 4 turnovers in 6 strait drives. Fumble lost, FG, INT, INT, TD, Fumble lost. Lost 48-52
http://goallineblitz.com/game/game.pl?game_id=249900&mode=pbp

This game, we had 6 INTs, which I'll mostly attribute from defenders hangin off his arm from 8 sacks and 26 hurries. Look at the drive chart, first 4 drives INT, Punt, Punt, INT. Then half way through the 3rd quarter, INT, TD, INT, Punt, INT, INT. Lost 23-58
http://goallineblitz.com/game/game.pl?game_id=249960



At our level (28-32 average) what should everybodys confidence be? That is the only thing I can think of as to why all the turnovers. The QBs vision is almost 60 and confidence over 50. Is that low for level 30? What should the skill positions have for confidence to keep from sliding down the turnover path?
 
mocfam10
offline
Link
 
Well, the downhill slide is directly related to confidence. So, if you continue to see the downward spiral, then you definitely need more confidence across the board. I can't really give you a definite number that a level 30 should have in confidence because it varies per position. But mor my two main teams, when we invested in confidence, we went from 3rd round playoff losers in consecuitve seasons, to winners. And even this season, we went down big a couple of times and fought back. Things we definitely weren't doing in previous years.
 
deez11010
offline
Link
 
Ok, so mainly you're saying just soft cap it on every position? Go above the soft cap? The reason I ask, is because I dont want to spend the next 8 levels forcing my team to put everything into confidence, if they are far and away above what it should be for the average for their level. I mean, what good is three times more confidence than any other team, if the other attributes are lacking?

Just for an example, what were your teams average confidence before, and then what was it when you turned the team around?

Just so I have an idea to see if we're even on track or what.
 
KilgoFoSho
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by gambrinus843
The Power back on my team has 70+ strength, 52+ speed, 53+ agility, 45 confidence, and 58+ carrying. He also has 6 in cover up and an advanced piece of eq with a 7% resist fumble yet has fumbled the ball 10 times and lost 9 of them. He is equal in level to all of our opponents and until this season had never had 10 fumbles in a season let alone through 3 games. 80% of HB's in the NFL do not fumble the ball 4+ times a season so to have guys coughing up 6 fumbles in one game is ridiculous. If the game is working "as it is intended" then its intentions need to be changed.


That's interesting... I'm concerned about the specials and the advanced equipment too. My RB has 70 strength and 52ish carrying, and more speed and agility than the guy quoted above. I have 6 in Cover Up as well, and the advanced piece of equipment with 7% Not Fumble Chance.

I have 10 fumbles in 11 games this season, with 7 lost. I had 9 fumbles in the previous three seasons combined. Every single fumble of mine has been in games we won.

Today's was on this drive:
E.D. Jackson rush up the middle (5.5 yd gain) [tackle: Cromartie Sanders]
E.D. Jackson rush to the right (4 yd gain) [tackle: Boomer Hurricane]
E.D. Jackson rush to the right (4 yd gain) [tackle: Boomer Hurricane]
E.D. Jackson rush [missed tackle: Mike Chen] [missed tackle: Boomer Hurricane] [missed tackle: The Punisher] to the right (22.5 yd gain) [tackle: Jon Bean]
E.D. Jackson rush to the right (6.5 yd gain) [diving tackle: Mikkel Mørk]
E.D. Jackson rush up the middle (14 yd gain) [tackle: Paul Wright] Replay
E.D. Jackson rush[forced fumble: Boomer Hurricane], fumbled , recovered by CJ Holton, -0 yds (touchback)

So confidence (around 40ish) probably isn't an issue.

He averaged 9.4 yards per carry on that drive, which started on our own 8, and he fumbled at the goal line. The guy that caused it was a LB who just missed a tackle on him three plays before. And he came back on a TD run on the next drive, and ended the game with 210 yards and 13 broken tackles.

I just don't know what else I can do right now, other than suspect that something isn't working correctly.
 
MrMoose
offline
Link
 
I'm wondering if there is some sort of huge modifier when you started to get closer to a defense's red zone. A lot of the fumbles seem to happen on longer drives. This leads me to believe one of a few things:

1) RBs get tired and fumble near the end of a drive -- but if the RBs are tired, shouldn't the defense also be somewhat tired and no more likely to cause a fumble?

2) Confidence is playing a role -- this doesn't seem to be the case either, as some have posted with high confidence and this issue.

3) The fumble rate is artificially increased here.
 
sxewesley
offline
Link
 
This is what bothers me in a nutshell:

When you invest in the skills that seem to be directly related to protecting from fumbles, carrying, cover up, the % based equipment and confidence, I do not see any direct improvment.

On top of that, a disproportinate amount of the fumbles seem to be caused by players who do not have a lot of strength, tackling, or SAs like Big Hit, this much I know from all of my own defensive players, but are instead caused by fast and ostensibly lighter hitting CBs, safties and speed/agility DEs imo.

Finally, the really annoying factor imo is the insane rate of fumbles on KR and PR, once again caused by lighter hitting faster players flying downfield, into a moron who runs in a straight line at them and when the fumble is caused, there are about 5-6 coverage players and no return team players in sight, which 90+% of the time results in a TD.

To add all of these together; because of the propensity for fumbling on KR and PR, you put your Power Backs in at KR and PR BECAUSE they have high strength, carrying, cover up, etc and what do they do? Run VERY slow and then fumble.

I can't possibly fathom how any of the above could be working as intended.

Oh yeah; Kick Return Specialist is a freaking joke and should have been fixed in season four.
 
islander1
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by sxewesley
This is what bothers me in a nutshell:

When you invest in the skills that seem to be directly related to protecting from fumbles, carrying, cover up, the % based equipment and confidence, I do not see any direct improvment.

On top of that, a disproportinate amount of the fumbles seem to be caused by players who do not have a lot of strength, tackling, or SAs like Big Hit, this much I know from all of my own defensive players, but are instead caused by fast and ostensibly lighter hitting CBs, safties and speed/agility DEs imo.

Finally, the really annoying factor imo is the insane rate of fumbles on KR and PR, once again caused by lighter hitting faster players flying downfield, into a moron who runs in a straight line at them and when the fumble is caused, there are about 5-6 coverage players and no return team players in sight, which 90+% of the time results in a TD.

To add all of these together; because of the propensity for fumbling on KR and PR, you put your Power Backs in at KR and PR BECAUSE they have high strength, carrying, cover up, etc and what do they do? Run VERY slow and then fumble.

I can't possibly fathom how any of the above could be working as intended.

Oh yeah; Kick Return Specialist is a freaking joke and should have been fixed in season four.


Completely agree with all of this.
 
raiderdav
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by sxewesley
This is what bothers me in a nutshell:

Concur with wesley.

I'm still convinced there are some hidden tendencies when you roll a player. You can have 2 guys with extremely similar skills perform a lot differently. Some guys just seem to have butter fingers and fumble a lot or drop passes, or shed blocks and get sacks.

 
oten638
offline
Link
 
ok in that first link you had 47 carries...what is you stamina?
 
Bort
Admin
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by MrMoose
1) RBs get tired and fumble near the end of a drive -- but if the RBs are tired, shouldn't the defense also be somewhat tired and no more likely to cause a fumble?


I think this is a common syndrome.

Perhaps velocity just needs to be less of a factor in fumble forcing?

Two really fast guys smashing into each other can generate a decent amount of fumble causing power, on top of any bonuses from big hits, etc.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.