User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > FAQ's, Player Guides and Newbie Help > My slow build strategy good?
Page:
 
FatNasty
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Jack Del Rio
I won't be boosting them, I'm just going to retire them after I've found something conclusive. That shouldn't have any effect if they ALL don't boost, right?
Stats are open btw.


Token boosts. This...

Originally posted by Jack Del Rio
...and every bonus token will go toward temp boosts, and every SP that comes from that will go into blocking...
 
FatNasty
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Jack Del Rio
Stats are open btw.


Thanks!
 
TJ Spikes
online
Link
 
I'll throw another layer of speculation into this --- applicable during the season when players are gaining XP.

If the object of this is to get 1 attribute to the cap as fast as possible doesn't it make more sense to train relaxed with no activity?

I guess I'll wait and see how many days it takes to gain 3 levels, since that seems to be about the right number of skill points for most people to hit the first soft cap.

My hunch is that if it takes 10 days or more then it makes much more sense to train on relaxed. If it's like 5 days then the bonus token skill point is probably better.

I've also got 3 guys I'm tracking now. One has a 16 STR, One has a 17 STR, and the last has 22 STR.

I'll be tracking the % gains with relaxed traing every day. Maybe JDR can track gains with his intense training?

btw, the math on this seems crazy

everyone gets 2 training points every day, intense training costs 5 training points. So every 10 days a player will get 2 bonus tokens. So it takes 20 days to get 4 tokens. Which means only 2 free skill points (not attribute points remember) can be gained per the regular 40 day season. Maybe 3 skill points could be gained per season including the off time post/pre season.

Are those 3 points really worth it? To me it seems like an obvious no, and it will come down to the difference between the "small training bonus" gained with relaxed training, and the "training bonus" gained with intense training.
Last edited Nov 9, 2008 18:22:18
 
TheGreatPuma
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Jack Del Rio
I created 3 C's all with 19 blocking. They are all going to end up with blocking at the 3rd cap. The first will train until they can 1st cap it with available SP, and then continue to pump it to the 3rd cap while training something else. The second will train until they can 2nd cap it with available SP, and then continue to pump it to the 3rd cap while training something else. The third will just keep training it until they have enough SP to 3rd cap it. I'm really not good at explaining things, and it's a real bitch to figure this stuff out on paper with making at best, educated guesses about how much a single training session will add to an attribute when it is at ##. So I'll get back to you guys, but I just have a feeling that the third guy will have blocking at the 3rd cap the quickest.

They'll all be doing intense training on strength/blocking, and every bonus token will go toward temp boosts, and every SP that comes from that will go into blocking, too. After the first guy first caps blocking he will intense train something else so he still gets the bonus tokens and SP to put into blocking, same with the 2nd guy.




You can do that if you want. I decided it'd take about 15 minutes to re-work my Build Strategies Spreadsheet to test your theory.

Instead of doing Blocking I did Str, because for centers it makes more sense to do str first because of the Intense training options (i.e. there's a Blk/Agi but no str/agi)

All of my data for training % is based off actual approx % numbers thrown together from my own players and others on here helping out.

The Center started with 19 str, 21 blk, 10 agi. The rest doesn't matter for this test.

Build 1 - created Season X Day 0
Center trains str/blk until can single cap str. Single caps and then trains blk/agi while double then triple capping str.


This player is able to triple cap Strength at level 10 on day 31. He finishes with:

7 unused SPs
68.0 str
34.0 blk
16.8 agi

Build 2 - created Season X Day 0
Center trains str/blk until can double cap str. Double caps and then trains blk/agi while triple capping str.


This player is able to triple cap Strength at level 10 on day 31. He finishes with:

5 unused SPs
68.0 str
34.0 blk
14.8 agi

net SP lost by not capping ASAP = 4


Build 3 - created Season X Day 0
Center trains str/blk until can triple cap str.


This player is unable to triple cap Strength at level 10 on day 31. He finishes with:

63 unused SPs
32.0 str
34.0 blk
11.8 agi

Net SP Lost: > 4


The numbers can be found here:
http://spreadsheets.google.com/ccc?key=pbmck92KTeeXmtc3nbUX4KA
 
TheGreatPuma
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by TJ Spikes
I'll throw another layer of speculation into this --- applicable during the season when players are gaining XP.

If the object of this is to get 1 attribute to the cap as fast as possible doesn't it make more sense to train relaxed with no activity?


Yes. If the object is to get just one attribute. But for the most part most players generally want 2 or more there ASAP, so training one costs more than it's worth.

 
Meatdawg
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Jack Del Rio
I created 3 C's all with 19 blocking. They are all going to end up with blocking at the 3rd cap. The first will train until they can 1st cap it with available SP, and then continue to pump it to the 3rd cap while training something else. The second will train until they can 2nd cap it with available SP, and then continue to pump it to the 3rd cap while training something else. The third will just keep training it until they have enough SP to 3rd cap it. I'm really not good at explaining things, and it's a real bitch to figure this stuff out on paper with making at best, educated guesses about how much a single training session will add to an attribute when it is at ##. So I'll get back to you guys, but I just have a feeling that the third guy will have blocking at the 3rd cap the quickest.

They'll all be doing intense training on strength/blocking, and every bonus token will go toward temp boosts, and every SP that comes from that will go into blocking, too. After the first guy first caps blocking he will intense train something else so he still gets the bonus tokens and SP to put into blocking, same with the 2nd guy.


As proven above by the spread sheet break down, it is ALWAYS better to cap at the 1st soft cap to take advantage of natural level gains.

Think about it, if your cap'd at 49, and you gain 1 point per level, it would take you 2 sp to get that 1 point. It's pretty straight forward.

Don't bother creating 3 centers just to see what one ends up better, the example that was broken down and listed for you is exactly what will happen.

Bottom line, ALWAYS cap as soon as you can to take advantage of natural level gains.
 
TheGreatPuma
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Meatdawg

As proven above by the spread sheet break down, it is ALWAYS better to cap at the 1st soft cap to take advantage of natural level gains.


Be careful with always, meatdawg, because it can bite you in the ass so to speak. There are times when waiting a level or 2 can actually benefit you. For instance:

Say you're building a CB with 6 primaries. Each will get .33 SP per level. If your training nets you more than the level bonus buys you, it pays to wait on the next level.

In another instance, lets say your speed is at 21.33, and you have 27 SPs at level 3. Sure, you could go ahead and cap. But it's not buying you anything. You'd be better to wait to level 5 and continue training Speed up to say 23.99 (possibly higher/lower depending on how long it takes to level) and then cap with 25 SP. At that point the only thing you lost was some minimal training on a tertiary attribute. AND you gain 2 SP by not spending ASAP, without actually losing any level bonus.
Last edited Nov 9, 2008 19:50:44
 
Meatdawg
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by TheGreatPuma
Originally posted by Meatdawg


As proven above by the spread sheet break down, it is ALWAYS better to cap at the 1st soft cap to take advantage of natural level gains.


Be careful with always, meatdawg, because it can bite you in the ass so to speak. There are times when waiting a level or 2 can actually benefit you. For instance:

Say you're building a CB with 6 primaries. Each will get .33 SP per level. If your training nets you more than the level bonus buys you, it pays to wait on the next level.

In another instance, lets say your speed is at 21.33, and you have 27 SPs at level 3. Sure, you could go ahead and cap. But it's not buying you anything. You'd be better to wait to level 5 and continue training Speed up to say 23.99 (possibly higher/lower depending on how long it takes to level) and then cap with 25 SP. At that point the only thing you lost was some minimal training on a tertiary attribute. AND you gain 2 SP by not spending ASAP, without actually losing any level bonus.


Correct but thats micromanaging which is a given, I was more generalizing, as in all your examples you are still caping at the 1st softcap.

Also with your example,

level 3
21.33 gains .33 a level I cap at 3 and am at 48.33. At level 5 I am at 48.99

In the time you take to continue training it to level 5 you are only gaining 2 sp, where if you had confidence at 14 you could of gained 3 or 4.

If you have any attribute that returns more when training it is more beneficial to train that attribute and cap this one now since you start to get diminishing returns.
 
TheGreatPuma
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Meatdawg

Correct but thats micromanaging which is a given, I was more generalizing, as in all your examples you are still caping at the 1st softcap.

Also with your example,

level 3
21.33 gains .33 a level I cap at 3 and am at 48.33. At level 5 I am at 48.99

In the time you take to continue training it to level 5 you are only gaining 2 sp, where if you had confidence at 14 you could of gained 3 or 4.

If you have any attribute that returns more when training it is more beneficial to train that attribute and cap this one now since you start to get diminishing returns.


Well-made point.

I agree that it's micromanaging, but I've seen Super Slow Build people concerning themselves with the .03 SP you can gain by training attributes at their lowest levels (i.e. before the leveling bonus moves them up). Everyone has a point at which the time spent to figure out how to squeeze the last SP out of your build stops being worth the additional SP.
 
FatNasty
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by TJ Spikes
btw, the math on this seems crazy

everyone gets 2 training points every day, intense training costs 5 training points. So every 10 days a player will get 2 bonus tokens. So it takes 20 days to get 4 tokens. Which means only 2 free skill points (not attribute points remember) can be gained per the regular 40 day season. Maybe 3 skill points could be gained per season including the off time post/pre season.

Are those 3 points really worth it? To me it seems like an obvious no, and it will come down to the difference between the "small training bonus" gained with relaxed training, and the "training bonus" gained with intense training.


TheGreatPuma, I'm save all bonus tokens for AVG for +SAs. Is this wise or do you recommend using them to soft cap quicker? At the outset seems a minimal gain when compared to AVG.
 
TheGreatPuma
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by FatNasty


TheGreatPuma, I'm save all bonus tokens for AVG for +SAs. Is this wise or do you recommend using them to soft cap quicker? At the outset seems a minimal gain when compared to AVG.


IMO, this is a personal decision. I personally use them for attributes because I get to the cap faster. And you can use the +5 on stamina to get extra plays.

OTOH if you can find the right gear and you save bonus tokens from early in your career, you could end up with 2 (or maybe 3) kick ass pieces of Advance Equipment.

Just remember level 40 upgrades (gets your SA to +4) to a piece of AE costs 48 bonus tokens which takes three full seasons to amass. To do that more than once, you definitely need to start saving early!
Last edited Nov 9, 2008 21:36:55
 
FatNasty
offline
Link
 
ty ^
 
Jack Del Rio
offline
Link
 
I probably should have picked a different position, like WR, and Speed. A C's main attributes increase too quickly on their own for training to remain worthwhile imo, but a player that gets 0.33 gains on their mains on levelups might be able to benefit from my strategy if they want to whore that skill to the 3rd or 4th cap as soon as possible, at the expense of other attributes.

edit: done
Last edited Nov 9, 2008 22:22:13
 
TheGreatPuma
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Jack Del Rio
I probably should have picked a different position, like WR, and Speed. A C's main attributes increase too quickly on their own for training to remain worthwhile imo, but a player that gets 0.33 gains on their mains on levelups might be able to benefit from my strategy if they want to whore that skill to the 3rd or 4th cap as soon as possible, at the expense of other attributes.


I really thought you were correct and wasn't going to bother with the numbers. But I've been fooled in the past so I ran em.

Assume a fake player that gets .33 level bonus all other things equivalent on the same spreadsheet. (essentially I just changed the level bonus from the old sheet to .33 and went back and fixed all the training numbers)


This hypothetical player started with 19 str, 21 blk, 10 agi, a primary level bonus of .33 and secondary of .20 (agi being the only secondary we're looking at)

Build 1 - created Season X Day 0
Trains str/blk until can single cap str. Single caps and then trains blk/agi while double then triple capping str.


This player is able to triple cap Strength at level 11 on day 38. He finishes with:

0 unused SPs
68.33 str
29.33 blk
18.00 agi

Build 2 - created Season X Day 0
Trains str/blk until can double cap str. Double caps and then trains blk/agi while triple capping str.


This player is able to triple cap Strength at level 11 on day 38. He finishes with:

0 unused SPs
68.33 str
29.33 blk
17.00 agi

net SP lost by not capping ASAP = 1


Build 3 - created Season X Day 0
Trains str/blk until can triple cap str.


This player is able to triple cap Strength at level 11 on day 38. He finishes with:

1 unused SPs
68.33 str
29.33 blk
12.00 agi

Net SP Lost: 5


The numbers can be found here:
http://spreadsheets.google.com/ccc?key=pbmck92KTeeUnxw8qXY_VMw





Feel free to continue with your test. I've never had a real life cross check of my spreadsheet numbers. I'd like to know how accurate they are.
Last edited Nov 9, 2008 22:54:54
 
TJ Spikes
online
Link
 
Originally posted by TheGreatPuma
Originally posted by TJ Spikes

I'll throw another layer of speculation into this --- applicable during the season when players are gaining XP.

If the object of this is to get 1 attribute to the cap as fast as possible doesn't it make more sense to train relaxed with no activity?


Yes. If the object is to get just one attribute. But for the most part most players generally want 2 or more there ASAP, so training one costs more than it's worth.



Yes but by finishing one faster you can move on to the second one faster and move onto the third. etc.

Started tracking this last night

OT - Str 16, 85% complete, Training listed as 42%, Actual gain 45% => Str 17, 30% complete

OG - Str 17, 81% complete, Training listed as 41%, Actual gain 44% => Str 18, 25% complete

OC - Str 22, 51% complete, Training listed as 34%, Actual gain 37% => Str 22, 88% complete

So it looks like the "small training bonus" is 3%, at least for L1 players. I'll be adding XP tracking to this later because another perk of doing relaxed training is being able to buy a set of +4 stam gear so I'll probably also add number of plays per game.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.