User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Page:
 
Adderfist
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by mikelj
Originally posted by Serenity

Originally posted by mikelj


Ok serenity, it SHOULDNT be a problem, that is why its here. 61 vision, this shouldnt happen, first time I have ever pointed this out, but lots of people have said its a problem, put pts in VISION, since for a centerfielder figured it might help if you can "read" the play.



Yeah, I'm saying that the problem is vision doesn't seem to have a big impact on FS's


But shouldnt higher vision make a HUGE impact for FS's? I am glad I found this out after I have put 61 into vision Oh well. Live and learn. SPEED and AGILITY from here on out...


Let me fix that for you Speed from here on out
 
Link
 
So is the problem that he was covering his assignment and then switched to the receiver that caught the ball, or am I just completely confused here? It looks like he starts double teaming the receiver, and then notices the outside receiver is getting the pass thrown to him and changes direction towards him before the pass is caught. He starts to change direction after the ball is caught in response to the receiver's movement, forcing a second correction when the receiver does not cut in towards the field or out of bounds.
I guess I just don't really see it. Yeah, he makes a big cut there, but you can't expect a person to immediately turn 90 degrees with no problem. He thought he could beat him on a straight path, started correcting when he couldn't, chased him down. Looking frame by frame, he seems to be correcting once the receiver hits the 29 yard line, just didn't have the speed to cut the corner like he was trying, saw that, and corrected some more, resulting in the loop. Or maybe my user name is more of an indicator than I would like to think.

What I would wonder abut more, is what that HB was doing running around in circles behind the play?
 
Zoblefu
offline
Link
 
The problem is that his path was this:


----FS__->____WR

Instead of this:

----FS--------WR
---------\\\
------------\\\
---------------\\\

Pardon the crappy ascii drawing. The way it is now, the FS runs to where the WR _IS_, not where the WR is _GOING_, and then has to catch up from behind.
Last edited Nov 1, 2008 19:51:31
 
OttawaShane
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Zoblefu
The problem is that his path was this:


----FS__->____WR

Instead of this:

----FS--------WR
---------\\\
------------\\\
---------------\\\

Pardon the crappy ascii drawing. The way it is now, the FS runs to where the WR _IS_, not where the WR is _GOING_, and then has to catch up from behind.


this is exactly the problem, anyone saying otherwise will be PM'd this diagram.
 
mikelj
offline
Link
 
My point exactly. If my guy had 30 vision or something I understand but it is over 60. I would think he wouldnt run to where the guy WAS.
 
Tobysmith6922
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by mikelj
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=202592&pbp_id=12054650

This is HORRIBLE pathing. Have 61 vision? Can it be fixed?


That play is mild compaired to others I have seen....others have the FS running in circles around the offensive player
Last edited Nov 3, 2008 22:27:46
 
saintedix
offline
Link
 
The problem is with FS's having too much speed and not enough agility. Players with 80 speed and 50-60 agility will do this often. The FS on my team has 71 speed and 68 agility and I've never seen a bad route. Guys, if your agility is 30 points lower than your speed, you are GOING to see problems like this regardless of vision.
Last edited Nov 3, 2008 23:33:03
 
HurricaneBear
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by saintedix
The problem is with FS's having too much speed and not enough agility. Players with 80 speed and 50-60 agility will do this often. The FS on my team has 71 speed and 68 agility and I've never seen a bad route. Guys, if your agility is 30 points lower than your speed, you are GOING to see problems like this regardless of vision.


 
mikelj
offline
Link
 
Just havent had the SP's to get agility up, will after boosts for season 6. Still shouldnt be that way. Since agility is part of acceleration.
 
OttawaShane
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by HurricaneBear
Originally posted by saintedix

The problem is with FS's having too much speed and not enough agility. Players with 80 speed and 50-60 agility will do this often. The FS on my team has 71 speed and 68 agility and I've never seen a bad route. Guys, if your agility is 30 points lower than your speed, you are GOING to see problems like this regardless of vision.




Exactly what is it about agility that causes a player to sprint directly at the spot the ball was caught instead of taking a pursuit angle? You have no idea what you're talking about.
Last edited Nov 4, 2008 07:35:29
 
RAPB
offline
Link
 
The problem is rather like


1.

----FS________________________________________WR (catches ball)

(direction -> )


2.

----------FS____________________________________WR (starting to move)

(direction -> still, for the FS would intersect that slow moving WR pretty much at the same yard line)


3.

-----------------FS_______________________________WR (surprise! the WR is accelerating further on!)


(direction \ now, but still not considering the full speed the WR will reach soon)


4.

-----------------()_________________________________()
---------------------FS______________________________()
------------------------______________________________WR (safety is falling behind...)


-----------------()__________________________________()
---------------------()________________________________()
-------------------------FS_____________________________()
---------------------------______________________________()
------------------------------____________________________WR (now chasing from behind)
Last edited Nov 4, 2008 08:49:11
 
saintedix
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by OttawaShane

Exactly what is it about agility that causes a player to sprint directly at the spot the ball was caught instead of taking a pursuit angle? You have no idea what you're talking about.


Apparently you don't know what agility does in the sim BESIDES acceleration.

Bort is never going to fix this because it isn't a bug. He intended hyper-fast players with low agility to not be able to turn well. Again, show me ANY example of a player with agility near or matching speed and I'll believe this.
 
UmYeah
offline
Link
 
I've chimed in on this with other threads but I dont think it is being addressed any time soon so you might as well stop complaining. The problem is agility based because of the way the FS pathing is programmed. When the catch is made, the FS begins running to the point where the ball carrier is. THIS IS THE WRONG PATH TO TAKE. that is the problem with this bug. It turns into an agility problem because as others have stated, the FS needs to turn to correct his path. The problem a lot of people are having is that they think (rightfully) that the FS should put himself in a position to make a play, and that is not the case in plays like this. He takes himself almost completely out of the play by running to the ball carrier instead of in between that carrier and the end zone which would make sense.
 
OttawaShane
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by saintedix
Originally posted by OttawaShane


Exactly what is it about agility that causes a player to sprint directly at the spot the ball was caught instead of taking a pursuit angle? You have no idea what you're talking about.


Apparently you don't know what agility does in the sim BESIDES acceleration.

Bort is never going to fix this because it isn't a bug. He intended hyper-fast players with low agility to not be able to turn well. Again, show me ANY example of a player with agility near or matching speed and I'll believe this.


Well, yes I do. You haven't seen enough of these replays and you don't know enough about the builds involved. Its not a turning thing - watch the replays - the Free Safeties in question turn quite fine in all situations - I've seen it.

Sprinting to the wrong point on the field has nothing to do with agility and everything to do with pathing.

Quit being an apologist on an issue you don't know anything about.
 
OttawaShane
offline
Link
 
If you think its an agility issue:

Then tell me why on these plays every other player on the field besides the FS take the right pursuit angle?
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.