SNYPAH
Forum > Suggestions > Llyr's Defensive AI suggestions
Llyranwyar
offline
offline
I realized that it is not sufficient to just place a player on a flat zone and default him to the side he plays on. That would cause issues if a player wanted the MLB to play a flat zone since he plays neither weak no strong side. that could cause some SNAFU's. Left flat and right flat would have to be designated.
Last edited Nov 29, 2008 17:53:43
Llyranwyar
offline
offline
I never was really satisfied with the concept that the sim would just read the number of guys marked for coverage and place them into a defensive formation. What I really found unsatisfying in that situation was the lack of a way to both bring the safety up for run support and still play 2 safeties in coverage.
The way I could see fixing that situation is to change the formation selections somewhat. As it is, you select 4-3, 3-4, 4-2-5, etc. The difference between playing a 4-6 and a 4-3 is the selection of cover 1 zone. What ends up being missed is something like being able to play cover 2 once you bring the safety up closer to the line.
I suppose with this system, depending on how its implemented, you could try to drop the safety back in a deep zone to approximate the cover 2. Still, I see that as being very lacking. Also, you couldn't arrange a safety to be blitzed from his original position.
What would solve this is if by selecting a 4-3 you get the two safeties lining up in the typical 4-3-cover 2 look, but when the ball is snapped they rush to their cover postions. With a 4-6-1 selection, you will get what looks like the basic 4-3-cover 1 line-up. When the ball is snapped, the strong safety would have to attempt to back-pedal hard to get to his coverage zone if he were placed in one. You get the benefit of the safety playing up to the line, but take the risk of having the safety out of position if he isn't fast enough to get back.
I know this has probably been suggested somewhere else before, but I am not sure where it was suggested or by whom. What gets missed with that change to formations is that you lose the ability to line up a safety directly on a man for man defense (think cover 0).
With cover 0 in mind...perhaps there should be a force coverage-disguise option in mind. just check a disguise box and your safeties and linebackers are forced to play from their original positions for the formation chosen. Leave it unchecked and the Safeties and LB's line up directly over their man assignments.
The way I could see fixing that situation is to change the formation selections somewhat. As it is, you select 4-3, 3-4, 4-2-5, etc. The difference between playing a 4-6 and a 4-3 is the selection of cover 1 zone. What ends up being missed is something like being able to play cover 2 once you bring the safety up closer to the line.
I suppose with this system, depending on how its implemented, you could try to drop the safety back in a deep zone to approximate the cover 2. Still, I see that as being very lacking. Also, you couldn't arrange a safety to be blitzed from his original position.
What would solve this is if by selecting a 4-3 you get the two safeties lining up in the typical 4-3-cover 2 look, but when the ball is snapped they rush to their cover postions. With a 4-6-1 selection, you will get what looks like the basic 4-3-cover 1 line-up. When the ball is snapped, the strong safety would have to attempt to back-pedal hard to get to his coverage zone if he were placed in one. You get the benefit of the safety playing up to the line, but take the risk of having the safety out of position if he isn't fast enough to get back.
I know this has probably been suggested somewhere else before, but I am not sure where it was suggested or by whom. What gets missed with that change to formations is that you lose the ability to line up a safety directly on a man for man defense (think cover 0).
With cover 0 in mind...perhaps there should be a force coverage-disguise option in mind. just check a disguise box and your safeties and linebackers are forced to play from their original positions for the formation chosen. Leave it unchecked and the Safeties and LB's line up directly over their man assignments.
Last edited Dec 1, 2008 18:38:45
You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.






























