User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Suggestions > How to improve Pass Blocking Assignments and still allow realistic levels of Pass Rush Pressure
Page:
 
Mike Rogers
Lead Tester
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by chief31
Originally posted by Mike Rogers

Originally posted by chief31



But, I also wanted to add another problem. The offense never seems to learn during the game. I mean, once a guy has four sacks in the game, the offense (in reality) would adjust to find double-teams against that player, or start going with very short, quick-release passes.

I don't think that this is as easy a change to make to the sim, but it is something that is amplifying the problem.



Maybe not the quick pass stuff, but possibly the HB/FB actions???

How about an option in tactics screen as follows...

* If x amount of sacks/hurries then HB/FB stays in and blocks more on passing plays???


Something like that. That would definitely be a helpful step. Screen passes would be great too. I know that alot of NFL teams will use screens to slow-down a pesky pass-rushing DE.


I think its possible to adjust for that with the tactics we have currently.

I know when I face a super build DE with 10 sacks a game average I go to the HB pass often and it is pretty successful.

Same with LB blitzing, I go to the open TE etc

but the idea of keeping the FB/HB/TE in to block has been suggested and Bort seems to like it as an option, but I'll add it to the list of suggestions.
 
Ken1
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Mike Rogers
Originally posted by chief31


But, I also wanted to add another problem. The offense never seems to learn during the game. I mean, once a guy has four sacks in the game, the offense (in reality) would adjust to find double-teams against that player, or start going with very short, quick-release passes.

I don't think that this is as easy a change to make to the sim, but it is something that is amplifying the problem.



Maybe not the quick pass stuff, but possibly the HB/FB actions???

How about an option in tactics screen as follows...

* If x amount of sacks/hurries then HB/FB stays in and blocks more on passing plays???


Interesting idea.
 
jdros13
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Ken1
Originally posted by turnerhero

I don't think very much at all is wrong with pass protection, aside from shitty builds OTs try to pass off as 'good'


I want to contest this comment, because OT's should not need much Speed. Real life OT's can be slow as hell. They should need good Agility, maybe even soft capped by Level 30ish. But there's no race going on. Speed DE's have that Speed to get to the QB. The OT only has to move a few steps. That's quickness (Agility), not Speed.


Ken, you own a team that has given up 32 sacks on the season or 2 per game on average and is right in the middle of the league. There are many other teams in the same league that have given up less than 10 the entire year. The Orlando team you GM has given up 8 the entire year and there is a team in that league that has never been sacked on 384 attempts. There are at least some OLine builds that seem to be neutralizing most of the top pass rushers. Even the Alpine Golfers, with their poster child for the Speed DE build has been held to 2 or fewer sacks in 2 of their last 4 games.
 
chief31
offline
Link
 
Have you added that SPEED is not relative to size/weight? That one may not be terribly popular with some, but still applicable, IMO.
 
Jed
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Mike Rogers
Can we be sure its not a Spin move?

Does it happen a lot or is it something that happens now and then.

If you say it happens often its on the list.


I can't be sure since it's just my interpretation of dots. But it seems when I see Shock Block fire, if the defender doesn't run straight back into the Guard, it starts to screw with the OT.
 
Deathblade
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Jed

I can't be sure since it's just my interpretation of dots. But it seems when I see Shock Block fire, if the defender doesn't run straight back into the Guard, it starts to screw with the OT.


See my other post...

It is partly from the G charging at the DT. Guards shouldn't be taking steps forward to get to the DT lined up over top of him, and definitely shouldn't continue to step forward after initial contact. It honestly looks like guards are programmed to run-block for pass plays, but are given 0% chance to push the defender back.
 
Mike Rogers
Lead Tester
offline
Link
 
OK so basically we have (In Jeds example: http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=139642&pbp_id=4806693)

OG Shock Blocks DT.
DT recovers and runs near OT.
OT leaves his block on the DE and goes for the DT.
De has easy pressure.

Is that it?

And it combines with the OG having what appears to be a Run Blocking assigment (Go for a specific player rather than protect a certain area.
Last edited Oct 18, 2008 19:58:06
 
Koncorde
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Deathblade
I've seen that on several occasions as well Jed. Part of that problem appears to be the guards firing out like it is a run play...

Guards normally drop back, not as far as the OT, but they still drop back. For some reason, guards seem to be programmed to fire out similar to running plays during pass protection.


This is true, I'll try and find the replays but we have several significant instances of the G actually pushing the D-Lineman that far back that by the end of the play he's been 10 yards downfield (with no exaggeration).

I've also seen a LT smash a DE so hard that the DE dropped back a yard, the LT stepped into the gap...and the edge rushing LB (moving at 10 speed) actually got a sack running in behind. Admittedly in this case it was a D-League game, but still - it happens
 
Ken1
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by jdros13
Originally posted by Ken1

Originally posted by turnerhero


I don't think very much at all is wrong with pass protection, aside from shitty builds OTs try to pass off as 'good'


I want to contest this comment, because OT's should not need much Speed. Real life OT's can be slow as hell. They should need good Agility, maybe even soft capped by Level 30ish. But there's no race going on. Speed DE's have that Speed to get to the QB. The OT only has to move a few steps. That's quickness (Agility), not Speed.


Ken, you own a team that has given up 32 sacks on the season or 2 per game on average and is right in the middle of the league. There are many other teams in the same league that have given up less than 10 the entire year. The Orlando team you GM has given up 8 the entire year and there is a team in that league that has never been sacked on 384 attempts. There are at least some OLine builds that seem to be neutralizing most of the top pass rushers. Even the Alpine Golfers, with their poster child for the Speed DE build has been held to 2 or fewer sacks in 2 of their last 4 games.


Yep, I've figured out some tricks and I also try to get specific builds on OT's. The team I GM has my LOT, with softcapped Agility, Blocking over Strength, and very high Protect.

But the team I own, whenever we face a monster pass rusher, it becomes the focus of our planning to prevent him from teeing off on us. It shouldn't be. I know how to adapt to the current balance fairly well, but it isn't a real balance as it should be.
 
Deathblade
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Koncorde

This is true, I'll try and find the replays but we have several significant instances of the G actually pushing the D-Lineman that far back that by the end of the play he's been 10 yards downfield (with no exaggeration).


For examples of the G firing out, LG on this play, and the 3 plays after it.
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=149631&pbp_id=8521766

 
Koncorde
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by jdros13

Ken, you own a team that has given up 32 sacks on the season or 2 per game on average and is right in the middle of the league. There are many other teams in the same league that have given up less than 10 the entire year. The Orlando team you GM has given up 8 the entire year and there is a team in that league that has never been sacked on 384 attempts. There are at least some OLine builds that seem to be neutralizing most of the top pass rushers. Even the Alpine Golfers, with their poster child for the Speed DE build has been held to 2 or fewer sacks in 2 of their last 4 games.


As a GM on the Golfers - I have to say that a lot of the time there are infinitely more "hurries" than are recorded in the stats.

There's also the factor that a QB who releases quickly, often beats the pass rush. In the last game the QB had an exceedingly quick/agile WR's that meant they could get open, and make completions before the pressure got to them. In addition their QB has (I suspect) exceedingly high vision.

Not all sacks are down to purely the mistakes of the tackles in forming the pocket it does have to be said
 
Deathblade
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Koncorde

Not all sacks are down to purely the mistakes of the tackles in forming the pocket it does have to be said


True. On a very basic level, it is purely the OL's fault, but in reality, it is the entire teams fault.

WR couldn't get open
QB couldn't see an open WR
HB...ran around with his fingers up his ass
Last edited Oct 18, 2008 20:08:36
 
Mike Rogers
Lead Tester
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Koncorde

Not all sacks are down to purely the mistakes of the tackles in forming the pocket it does have to be said


Absolutely, I am not looking for perfect pass blocking here.

Just things that are going wrong due to the way a play is designed, which is being exploited and made worse.

 
Link
 
My guard picks up the CB blitzing and saves the sack. lol. Don't know if this was what you guys are talking about, but I don't feel like reading. lol. http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=153210&pbp_id=1853691
 
Koncorde
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Mike Rogers
Originally posted by Koncorde


Not all sacks are down to purely the mistakes of the tackles in forming the pocket it does have to be said


Absolutely, I am not looking for perfect pass blocking here.

Just things that are going wrong due to the way a play is designed, which is being exploited and made worse.



Indeedly. I just wanted anyone reading to understand we're not trying to stop sacks.

Just prevent cheese defence.
Last edited Oct 18, 2008 20:10:55
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.