User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > South America AA Leagues > South America AA #1 > SEC is the Best Conference and Big East is the worst
Page:
 
marauder22
offline
Link
 
What would the Pac 10 teams be ranked. If they played Sacramento State, Idaho, Portland State, Eastern Washington, Montana State, Northern Arizona etc...In their non league games.
 
Jmac0585
offline
Link
 
My point is this: If the way the rankings are done won't be changed, play the patsies, and do your best to go unbeaten in conference. If you don't, you'll fall out of the rankings and rightly so. The only rankings that matter are the final BCS rankings. Everything up unto the week or so before don't really matter.
 
Jmac0585
offline
Link
 
There won't be a playoff for some reason. It's not a money issue, it's not a bowl issue. I sent the BCS commissioner a plan a few years ago that makes the BCS, other Bowls, and a national playoff all relevant and worthwhile. I believe it is simply a monopoly that they, the BCS, don't wanna give up.
 
marauder22
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Jmac0585
My point is this: If the way the rankings are done won't be changed, play the patsies, and do your best to go unbeaten in conference. If you don't, you'll fall out of the rankings and rightly so. The only rankings that matter are the final BCS rankings. Everything up unto the week or so before don't really matter.


Like I said though. How can you say your the best conference. When your only claim is we have a lot more teams ranked. Its easy to get ranked. Play D1 AA's or scrubby D1 A teams and win. Then when you start conference play. The conference has a lot of ranked teams. Making it look tougher. Than what it really is.
Last edited Oct 13, 2008 15:42:36
 
blazzinken
offline
Link
 
ok if you want to talk schedule lets compare USC and Texas and Alabama....

USC- 1 ranked team on there schedule (as of right now)
Virgina- Not good at all lost to duke 31-0
Ohio St- Good team, not great
Oregon St.- not very good and they lost
Oregon- not good either
Arizona St.- Not good at all
Wash St.- Horrible
Arizona- Decent team but not great
Washington- Bad
Cal- Not that great
Stanford- Bad
Notre Dame- good i guess
UCLA- not good

Texas 5 ranked teams on schedule
FAU- not good
UTEP- Not to good
Rice- Good offense, bad team
Arkansas- Not that good
Colorado- Decent
OU- Very good
Mizzou- Very good
OK state- Good
Tech- Good
Baylor- not that good but better then half the teams in the pac 10
Kansas- Decently good
A&M-Horrible

LSU 3 ranked teams
App St- D-2
North Texas- Bad
Auburn- not that great
Miss St.- not good
Florida- really good
South Carolina- Decent
Georgia- Really good
Tulane- bad
Alabama- Really good
Troy- Good for a mid major
Ole Miss- Decent better then half the teams in the Pac 10 probably would be number 2
Arkansas- Not good


The number of Quality oppents for LSU and Texas is far better then USC even tho there out of conference schedule is better.

You keep saying there are two teams in the Big 12, there is one team in the Pac-10 USC.

But i would say there are about 5 good teams in the Big 12, 1 in the Pac and 4 or 5 in the SEC
there is no question who is the better conference
Last edited Oct 13, 2008 16:31:18
 
marauder22
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by blazzinken
ok if you want to talk schedule lets compare USC and Texas and Alabama....

USC- 1 ranked team on there schedule (as of right now)
Virgina- Not good at all lost to duke 31-0
Ohio St- Good team, not great
Oregon St.- not very good and they lost
Oregon- not good either
Arizona St.- Not good at all
Wash St.- Horrible
Arizona- Decent team but not great
Washington- Bad
Cal- Not that great
Stanford- Bad
Notre Dame- good i guess
UCLA- not good

Texas 5 ranked teams on schedule
FAU- not good
UTEP- Not to good
Rice- Good offense, bad team
Arkansas- Not that good
Colorado- Decent
OU- Very good
Mizzou- Very good
OK state- Good
Tech- Good
Baylor- not that good but better then half the teams in the pac 10
Kansas- Decently good
A&M-Horrible

LSU 3 ranked teams
App St- D-2
North Texas- Bad
Auburn- not that great
Miss St.- not good
Florida- really good
South Carolina- Decent
Georgia- Really good
Tulane- bad
Alabama- Really good
Troy- Good for a mid major
Ole Miss- Decent better then half the teams in the Pac 10 probably would be number 2
Arkansas- Not good


The number of Quality oppents for LSU and Texas is far better then USC even tho there out of conference schedule is better.

You keep saying there are two teams in the Big 12, there is one team in the Pac-10 USC.

But i would say there are about 5 good teams in the Big 12, 1 in the Pac and 4 or 5 in the SEC
there is no question who is the better conference


Mizzou is not very good. Their Oregon good, and would be in dog fights against a lot of team across the country. Texas Tech is in the same boat. Texas Tech was in a dog fight against Nebraska. Kansas is average. These teams are ranked because of their shitty schedule. Saying Colorado is decent is funny. Their bad. Have you watched them?

LSU's schedule has Florida, UGA and Bama. The rest are average to shitty. Saying Ole Miss would be number 2 in the Pac 10 shows me how much you know about football. Ole Miss number 2 lmao.
Last edited Oct 13, 2008 17:02:47
 
tigerbait22
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by marauder22
Originally posted by Jmac0585

I don't get this. If I am making a schedule for ANYONE I am scheduling patsies ANYTIME I can. if you are in a BCS conference, and go undefeated, 90% of the time you are going to the Champ. game. The 10% you don't is when there are three. I got a hard enough time beating ALL the teams in my conference (and a conf. champ. game in what three of the BCS conferences), why not get easy W's when you can. Argue all you want about the S.O.S., undefeated is undefeated. Right, wrong or indifferent.

The thing is people prop up these teams, because their ranked right now. The reason their ranked, is because, their unbeaten, but have played a pathetic schedule. How good are those teams? We all hear how conferences claim how tough they are because, they have the 10,14,15 etc...Ranked teams in the country, but then when you look closely as to the reason why those teams are ranked so high. Its because, if you don't lose against powder puffs. you will get ranked. Then when those teams lose in conference play. People use it as their conference is so tough. Thats why they lost.


Name your ten top schools?

Someone has to be in the top ten If every team and conference is over-rated who is left? That's my whole point.. Some of these teams are very good.. they may not be great teams, but all solid clubs
 
marauder22
offline
Link
 
You also point to the rankings for a good opponent. Why don't you show who the teams Texas opponents are playing to get ranked? You should post the schedules for the following schools: Mizzou, Oklahoma State, Tech, and Kansas. Show how tough their schedules are. Thats how you get ranked.
 
marauder22
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by tigerbait22
Originally posted by marauder22

Originally posted by Jmac0585


I don't get this. If I am making a schedule for ANYONE I am scheduling patsies ANYTIME I can. if you are in a BCS conference, and go undefeated, 90% of the time you are going to the Champ. game. The 10% you don't is when there are three. I got a hard enough time beating ALL the teams in my conference (and a conf. champ. game in what three of the BCS conferences), why not get easy W's when you can. Argue all you want about the S.O.S., undefeated is undefeated. Right, wrong or indifferent.

The thing is people prop up these teams, because their ranked right now. The reason their ranked, is because, their unbeaten, but have played a pathetic schedule. How good are those teams? We all hear how conferences claim how tough they are because, they have the 10,14,15 etc...Ranked teams in the country, but then when you look closely as to the reason why those teams are ranked so high. Its because, if you don't lose against powder puffs. you will get ranked. Then when those teams lose in conference play. People use it as their conference is so tough. Thats why they lost.


Name your ten top schools?

Someone has to be in the top ten If every team and conference is over-rated who is left? That's my whole point.. Some of these teams are very good.. they may not be great teams, but all solid clubs


Top 10 Not in order.

Texas
USC
Florida
Bama
UGA
OU
Penn State
Ohio State
LSU
BYU

The SEC is the best conference just not as tough as some make it out to be. People say you never have a rest. Do they forget Ole Miss, Mississippi State, Kentucky, Vandy and every year a top program has a bad year. Tennessee and Auburn fit that role this season.
Last edited Oct 13, 2008 17:16:41
 
tigerbait22
offline
Link
 
I think you have it pretty close... LSU... not top ten this year I don't think.. Not because of how bad we lost to Florida...just too young.

Now take that list..

Texas and Oklahoma Big 12
Florida, Bama, UGA SEC
Penn St. Ohio St Big Ten
USC Pac 10

Now I'm not comparing how many of each.. This will change, TBH, very few conferences can be strong top to bottom. Pac 10, is surprisingly weak this season, but is known as a strong conference, Big 12 is definitely improving.. no one can argue that.. Big 10.. well they are what they are.. SEC is very strong...

No one can argue strength of OOC it makes no sense... Add in the Championship game and its even harder...

Why doesn't the Pac 10 schedule one? Because they don't want to lose the chance at having a Pac 10 school in the BCS Championship Game...

So USC played Ohio St... Commendable.. you guys will play anyone, BUT you don't have to face the championship game... So say Florida, Alabama, or UGA, having to play AGAIN against one of those teams evens out the lack of a quality OOC opponent.. We have to play a TOP FIVE team in the Championship game just to get there...

The Big 12... They ALSO will have to play an extremely tough game to get there..

So you get a +1 for playing Ohio St. and a -1 for no championship game

It evens out.. Yall argue OOC every year but you guys NEVER mention not having to play a championship game to win the Pac 10

 
Link
 
Ok all... to end the Debate BYU and Utah should be ranked #1 & #2....


 
Link
 
My Solution....

Take 119 Schools

Make 3 Tiers - 40 or so Schools in each tier.

Every year the top 10 in the bottoms move up, the bottom 10 move down.

Out of 40 Schools you ONLY play those schools to make up your 12 games

The top 8 schools at the end of the year run a BCS type playoffs (Adding up to 3 games for 2 schools). Then you don't have teh 2 months before a damn New Years Bowl game.

 
marauder22
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by tigerbait22
I think you have it pretty close... LSU... not top ten this year I don't think.. Not because of how bad we lost to Florida...just too young.

Now take that list..

Texas and Oklahoma Big 12
Florida, Bama, UGA SEC
Penn St. Ohio St Big Ten
USC Pac 10

Now I'm not comparing how many of each.. This will change, TBH, very few conferences can be strong top to bottom. Pac 10, is surprisingly weak this season, but is known as a strong conference, Big 12 is definitely improving.. no one can argue that.. Big 10.. well they are what they are.. SEC is very strong...

No one can argue strength of OOC it makes no sense... Add in the Championship game and its even harder...

Why doesn't the Pac 10 schedule one? Because they don't want to lose the chance at having a Pac 10 school in the BCS Championship Game...

So USC played Ohio St... Commendable.. you guys will play anyone, BUT you don't have to face the championship game... So say Florida, Alabama, or UGA, having to play AGAIN against one of those teams evens out the lack of a quality OOC opponent.. We have to play a TOP FIVE team in the Championship game just to get there...

The Big 12... They ALSO will have to play an extremely tough game to get there..

So you get a +1 for playing Ohio St. and a -1 for no championship game

It evens out.. Yall argue OOC every year but you guys NEVER mention not having to play a championship game to win the Pac 10



The Pac 10 doesn't have a conference championship, because they don't have 12 teams. Teams from the Pac 10 don't want Fresno State in, or they will become a power IMO. Fresno State would get a ton of top recruits. If they were to join the Pac 10.

LSU is a top 10 team in the nation. Florida is a bad match up for them. I can show you where I had that posted prior to the game. Mizzou would get handled by LSU by 2TD's at least.
Last edited Oct 13, 2008 18:00:50
 
Link
 
Would some rival games go out the window... sure... but it sure would be fun to watch week after week.

To make it fair also if you are in the top tier then you get X amount per home game... drop it a bit for the 2nd tier... and lower for the 3rd.

There is your incentive to win


Now would it kill a Utah State? Sure for now but to say they can't move into the top 80 programs in the country isn't completely out of the question. They can't say now that they expect to be a top 25 team.

On the other hand the Arizona States, Purdue, Oregon State, Arkansas, Texas A&M would be on the bubble to be in the top 40.

 
marauder22
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Ronald McDonyell
Would some rival games go out the window... sure... but it sure would be fun to watch week after week.

To make it fair also if you are in the top tier then you get X amount per home game... drop it a bit for the 2nd tier... and lower for the 3rd.

There is your incentive to win


Now would it kill a Utah State? Sure for now but to say they can't move into the top 80 programs in the country isn't completely out of the question. They can't say now that they expect to be a top 25 team.

On the other hand the Arizona States, Purdue, Oregon State, Arkansas, Texas A&M would be on the bubble to be in the top 40.



Colorado, Tennessee, Auburn, and a couple of other teams as well this season.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.