User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Page:
 
pestface
offline
Link
 
CBs are one of the hardest positions to rank, a true shutdown corner will hardly even get thrown at, can even lead to a decent #3 CB to get more PDs and INTs, just since QBs never see anyone open in the #1 spot.
 
mmuhr
offline
Link
 
word. I cant think of a single position that is harder to rank than a CB.
 
Link
 
The agent of both the OT's of the Mafia is honored by the selection to the all-star team....
 
BlackSamurai
offline
Link
 
Given your rating system, No Love of the Ougadogou Voodoo has 73 points. I do believe that would put him above Forde Skor . . . I've got a lot of tackles, though. And no, they're not from letting the receiver make the catch then tackling him (except there's been a LOT of that these last few games, which needs to be taken care of).

Edit: Oh, and I think TFL should be part of the equation for the d-line and LBs as well. 5 TFL in a game is a lot more notable than 5 regular tackles in a game.
Last edited Oct 12, 2008 09:01:40
 
Link
 
Hey BlackSamurai,

The all star list was done before the last game. Your counting the 11 tackles you had this last game. Also with TFL, TFL is only kept track of in your own personal stats when you go to the conference leaders page and click defense. No TFL. I don't have the time to look at each and every player's personal stats page. This isn't a perfect scoring system. I am using what is available.

With CB's it is very hard to get an accurate All Star. I am thinking about raising the points for pass deflections and interceptions. Thanks for all the feedback, this was just a rough draft and I am taking into consideration everyone's ideas on scoring individual positions. I have a basic defensive scoring system due to the fact that I can't view the stats by individual positions so I have to look at every single conference leader for each individual stat. It takes a lot of time so if I make a mistake or leave someone out, I apologize. Thanks for the feedback
 
BlackSamurai
offline
Link
 
I gotcha. I meant what I said about teams seeming to be picking on me these last few games. Don't know what's changed, but my guys have gotten a lot of receptions recently. I'm used to tackling OTHER people's guys . . .
 
mmuhr
offline
Link
 
Its hard for CBs to be shutdown right now. I think CBs matched against same level WRs wont really be effective until higher levels. My CB keeps getting more shutdown as he progresses levels. SAs baby!

Oh and I dunno if this would be a good idea or not...but when rating CBs maybe you should just leave out tackles all together. More often than not the CBs with lots of tackles are giving up lots of catches.
Last edited Oct 12, 2008 14:17:06
 
thisisbad
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by mmuhr
Its hard for CBs to be shutdown right now. I think CBs matched against same level WRs wont really be effective until higher levels. My CB keeps getting more shutdown as he progresses levels. SAs baby!

Oh and I dunno if this would be a good idea or not...but when rating CBs maybe you should just leave out tackles all together. More often than not the CBs with lots of tackles are giving up lots of catches.


LOL you want to make sure your guy up there one way or another. I don't think you voted for anyone else on your own team.
 
mmuhr
offline
Link
 
Ehh maybe? I do think I have a pretty sick CB, as you probably already know if you read our Anubis forums.
What does me not voting for any1 else on anubis have to do with anything though? If anything it shows im tryin to be unbiased.
 
thisisbad
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by mmuhr
Ehh maybe? I do think I have a pretty sick CB, as you probably already know if you read our Anubis forums.
What does me not voting for any1 else on anubis have to do with anything though? If anything it shows im tryin to be unbiased.


Voting for your guy and no one else on your team is unbiased? LOL

It's fine by me man. Do what you want it's all good. Congrats if you made the team.
 
A-Wad
offline
Link
 
WHEN was this voting supposed to be done??? I never received a pm?
 
mmuhr
offline
Link
 
there was no voting. I jus started a thread hella long ago where I named a few allstars at certain positions, mainly QB WR RB DE and CB. I voted for my own CB in that post. I guess thats what thisisbad is talking about...?

I dont see how me voting for Mattimus and not anyone else on Anubis is biased. As far as RB WR or QB no1 on anubis stands out that much because our offense is so balanced. We dont go heavy on one player because we have 2 qbs, and 3 rbs, and our WRs are no where near top of the league. My CB did stand out because he has the most interceptions, top 5 in PDs, and at the time didnt miss a single tackle. Unlike other CBs, I watch mine every single game and happen to know that he doesnt give up an insane amount of catches...Plus #1 CBs get extra points in my book because the team believes that he is the best of the ones they have.
 
thisisbad
offline
Link
 
Yeah thats all i meant was he came in here and pumped up his guy and that was it. Like i said in the long run it doesn't matter.
 
mmuhr
offline
Link
 
haha whatever who cares. If I want my CB to get voted onto the all star team I have to pump him up. Call it an election campaign. either way, we can both agree anubis is the best yah?
 
PLAYMAKERS
offline
Link
 
i have a feeling Lance King will make the updated all star list after he plays the Jags
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.