User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Discuss GLB Issues With Catch22 > NOT A BUG - CLOSED > Defense AI occasionally not followed
Page:
 
oronis
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by islander1
I am having the same problem with a different set.

Shotgun, the QB occasionally throws to the HB in the flats - even though the QB's setting is never, and Bort or any admin can confirm this within the AI.

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=193766&pbp_id=3829189




Is that the play where the HB is the intended target? Its not a dump pass if he's the primary target for a play.
 
islander1
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by oronis
Originally posted by islander1

I am having the same problem with a different set.

Shotgun, the QB occasionally throws to the HB in the flats - even though the QB's setting is never, and Bort or any admin can confirm this within the AI.

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=193766&pbp_id=3829189




Is that the play where the HB is the intended target? Its not a dump pass if he's the primary target for a play.


Actually no, it's not

but I found out the cause of my problems. It's indeed a bug, here's the thread about it and my findings:
http://goallineblitz.com/game/forum_thread.pl?thread_id=1187330
 
islander1
offline
Link
 
don't know about Hazy's issue though
 
RAPB
offline
Link
 
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=146243&pbp_id=6071961

This is the single back big. We play one of our single back plays (3-3-5 and MLB + ROLB blitzing) - instead of the single back big plays (3-4 and 4-3 + no blitzers).

The single back big - input is above the single back inputs, so it should have triggered. But it has not!
 
Link
 
To the OP:

Like I said in the other thread Islander mentioned, this occasional "not following" of what you thought your AI is supposed to do is NOT a bug.

Everyone in our alliance knows why this happens.

While some players like Forbin choose to give away everything they know, most of the best teams keep some secrets on player builds or tactics that not everyone knows.

This is one of those secrets. Most teams just give up and figure it is just a small error that it doesn't matter. Details matter.

If anyone is interested in joining our alliance though, you need to be a successful owner of a Pro League team or USA AAA or at least have excellent knowledge of the game to ADD to our list of secrets.....not just "use" ours.


John
Adriana Lima Beans (6-3)
Canadian Pro League
**Member of The Secret Alliance**

 
RAPB
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by SteelersInsider
To the OP:

Like I said in the other thread Islander mentioned, this occasional "not following" of what you thought your AI is supposed to do is NOT a bug.

Everyone in our alliance knows why this happens.

While some players like Forbin choose to give away everything they know, most of the best teams keep some secrets on player builds or tactics that not everyone knows.

This is one of those secrets. Most teams just give up and figure it is just a small error that it doesn't matter. Details matter.

If anyone is interested in joining our alliance though, you need to be a successful owner of a Pro League team or USA AAA or at least have excellent knowledge of the game to ADD to our list of secrets.....not just "use" ours.


John
Adriana Lima Beans (6-3)
Canadian Pro League
**Member of The Secret Alliance**



You really think this is a fair "way to go"?

I sure can understand that you keep your player builds and tactics a secret. But this is a bug - just something that shouldn't happen.

If someone was too dumb to set a proper play vs. the weak I - no need to help there for he just didn't do his homework. But a proper setting just not followed is something different.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by RAPB
Originally posted by SteelersInsider

To the OP:

Like I said in the other thread Islander mentioned, this occasional "not following" of what you thought your AI is supposed to do is NOT a bug.

Everyone in our alliance knows why this happens.

While some players like Forbin choose to give away everything they know, most of the best teams keep some secrets on player builds or tactics that not everyone knows.

This is one of those secrets. Most teams just give up and figure it is just a small error that it doesn't matter. Details matter.

If anyone is interested in joining our alliance though, you need to be a successful owner of a Pro League team or USA AAA or at least have excellent knowledge of the game to ADD to our list of secrets.....not just "use" ours.


John
Adriana Lima Beans (6-3)
Canadian Pro League
**Member of The Secret Alliance**



You really think this is a fair "way to go"?

I sure can understand that you keep your player builds and tactics a secret. But this is a bug - just something that shouldn't happen.

If someone was too dumb to set a proper play vs. the weak I - no need to help there for he just didn't do his homework. But a proper setting just not followed is something different.



this is not a bug at all.

the CPU goes by the instruction you give it. that's all I can say.

If there truly was a "bug", then this would happen to all teams.

How many teams are there? Like 2,000? Why don't we have 2,000 owners in here saying something is wrong?

The problem is that people complaining about this "bug" don't have the "proper settings".
 
spionkopwa
offline
Link
 
D AI skips reading "Strong I" formation, period.
Last edited Oct 9, 2008 23:38:50
 
thehazyone
NFL Replacement Refs SUCK
offline
Link
 
No, it's a bug. The reason we don't have 2,000 owners saying something is wrong because probably only 50 of us actually go through each down and track what play was called to see it it matches up with our AI.

I'm a smart guy. I'm very thorough with the inputs and outputs I have and even more thorough in going through the game film. There is no reason for the correct play call to happen ten times in a game and then for it to randomly not call the play.

I wouldn't have posted it here if there was even the remotest chance it was user error. In fact, I didn't post it the first three times I ran across it because I wanted to make sure before I did post it here.

 
RAPB
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by SteelersInsider
...

this is not a bug at all.

the CPU goes by the instruction you give it. that's all I can say.

If there truly was a "bug", then this would happen to all teams.

How many teams are there? Like 2,000? Why don't we have 2,000 owners in here saying something is wrong?

The problem is that people complaining about this "bug" don't have the "proper settings".


Sorry, but the instruction is very clear to the AI.

- IF offense shows single back big formation (no further restrictions or conditions)
- THEN play following plays

No auto adjust to interfere, no input in front that could trigger (even the single back input is below), no quarter specific input that could trigger.

Unless Bort announces that there's some hidden "switch" - it should just play the plays entered for the single back big input.

It occasionally doesn't - but most of the time it does.

Now you claim to have discovered a workaround. Fine!

But you don't want to share, but force people into your "secret alliance" and have them share their secrets of player builds, tactics and gameplanning with you.

O.K. ... but don't expect any respect for this one. That's just a cheap move.

I personally wouldn't give away what works fine for the teams I'm on. But I'd always help to get rid of obvious bugs - or at least something to work around.

Fair play, you know?
 
Robbnva
offline
Link
 
I will agree with this, I have noticed it at times
 
Link
 
Originally posted by RAPB
Originally posted by SteelersInsider

...

this is not a bug at all.

the CPU goes by the instruction you give it. that's all I can say.

If there truly was a "bug", then this would happen to all teams.

How many teams are there? Like 2,000? Why don't we have 2,000 owners in here saying something is wrong?

The problem is that people complaining about this "bug" don't have the "proper settings".


Sorry, but the instruction is very clear to the AI.

- IF offense shows single back big formation (no further restrictions or conditions)
- THEN play following plays

No auto adjust to interfere, no input in front that could trigger (even the single back input is below), no quarter specific input that could trigger.

Unless Bort announces that there's some hidden "switch" - it should just play the plays entered for the single back big input.

It occasionally doesn't - but most of the time it does.

Now you claim to have discovered a workaround. Fine!

But you don't want to share, but force people into your "secret alliance" and have them share their secrets of player builds, tactics and gameplanning with you.

O.K. ... but don't expect any respect for this one. That's just a cheap move.

I personally wouldn't give away what works fine for the teams I'm on. But I'd always help to get rid of obvious bugs - or at least something to work around.

Fair play, you know?



1.) I don't know about your problem. I was talking about the others. You need to provide a link to the play you are talking about and the EXACT code you have (down, distance, field postition, etc, along with the defensive AI and we can go from there. Maybe you provided it before, but can you copy it again? Yours is probably a mistake you will realize just from posting it.

2.) They are talking about something completely different. They are talking about calling plays on offense (mostly), but also occasionally on defense that they didn't call and aren't in their playbook at all.


P.S. My solution is not a workaround. I just found the error is MY program. That is basically what we are doing, making a program. Many of US have made errors in our programs and come here looking for Bort to look through all our code and fix your mistakes. He has better things to do.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by thehazyone
No, it's a bug. The reason we don't have 2,000 owners saying something is wrong because probably only 50 of us actually go through each down and track what play was called to see it it matches up with our AI.

I'm a smart guy. I'm very thorough with the inputs and outputs I have and even more thorough in going through the game film. There is no reason for the correct play call to happen ten times in a game and then for it to randomly not call the play.

I wouldn't have posted it here if there was even the remotest chance it was user error. In fact, I didn't post it the first three times I ran across it because I wanted to make sure before I did post it here.




I just noticed your GM is Painmaker?!?!

He knows alot about this game, why don't you have him look at it?

Last edited Oct 10, 2008 11:27:08
 
RAPB
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by SteelersInsider
...

1.) I don't know about your problem. I was talking about the others. You need to provide a link to the play you are talking about and the EXACT code you have (down, distance, field postition, etc, along with the defensive AI and we can go from there. Maybe you provided it before, but can you copy it again? Yours is probably a mistake you will realize just from posting it.

2.) They are talking about something completely different. They are talking about calling plays on offense (mostly), but also occasionally on defense that they didn't call and aren't in their playbook at all.


P.S. My solution is not a workaround. I just found the error is MY program. That is basically what we are doing, making a program. Many of US have made errors in our programs and come here looking for Bort to look through all our code and fix your mistakes. He has better things to do.


Look... you kind of pretend to know that's an error in the AI. I've been helping people to fix those kind of self-made bugs for quite a while. I'm not dumb, but just reporting a BUG.

The BUG is that plays are called that are NOT supposed to be called while the defensive AI is PROPERLY set up. How hard is that to understand?



Originally posted by RAPB
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=146243&pbp_id=6071961

This is the single back big. We play one of our single back plays (3-3-5 and MLB + ROLB blitzing) - instead of the single back big plays (3-4 and 4-3 + no blitzers).

The single back big - input is above the single back inputs, so it should have triggered. But it has not!


Here's the play.

Here's the defense AI test:

Quarter: 4
Time Remaining: 673 seconds
Ball Spot: opp 20 yd line
Down: 1
Yards to go: 10 yards
Score: I'm leading by 1 points
Opponent Formation: Single Back Big
Number of Wide Receivers: 2


Matching Input
Input Named: Single Back Big

Possible Outputs
5% 3-4 - "(deleted by myself)" (3-4 Cover 1 man)
25% 3-4 - "(deleted by myself)" (3-4 Cover 2 man)
70% 4-3 - "(deleted by myself)" (4-3 Cover 2 man)

(ALL of these outputs don't have blitzers; we don't blitz on this shorter pass play - and the play in question is a 3-3-5.)


Got it?

Just a bug. Plain and simple.

Now - just for a second - assume that some of the guys posting here haven't done something wrong too. They just keep on reporting a BUG.

Got it?

Just a bug. Plain and simple.

No Painmaker, no SteelersInsider, no secret alliance will take that away - for the AI is set up properly.

Just a bug. Plain and simple.



(while I do agree that 99% of all "AI not followed" posts are just user errors, you should take some people serious once in a while)
Last edited Oct 10, 2008 11:03:18
 
Link
 
Originally posted by islander1
Originally posted by oronis

Originally posted by islander1


I am having the same problem with a different set.

Shotgun, the QB occasionally throws to the HB in the flats - even though the QB's setting is never, and Bort or any admin can confirm this within the AI.

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=193766&pbp_id=3829189




Is that the play where the HB is the intended target? Its not a dump pass if he's the primary target for a play.


Actually no, it's not

but I found out the cause of my problems. It's indeed a bug, here's the thread about it and my findings:
http://goallineblitz.com/game/forum_thread.pl?thread_id=1187330



Actually yes, it is:

http://goallineblitz.com/images/plays/75.gif

This guy GAVE the answer to Islander for his problem, yet he wants to go on believing it is a "bug".
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.